6 ms·
Land is generally expensive because infrastructure is expensive. Building plumbing systems, subways, highways, schools, etc gets directly reflected in land pri
by Retric 6y ago
Land is generally expensive because infrastructure is expensive. Building plumbing systems, subways, highways, schools, etc gets directly reflected in land prices. That compounds when the cost to build even more transportation infrastructure skyrocket. Trying to build larger buildings without that infrastructure just results in pointless gridlock.
The Bay Area compounds that by capping property price increases which heavily distorts incentives and the overall market. But, don’t assume simply building more housing would actually make a significant difference long term without massive investments in infrastructure. At best it simply changes which land is valuable.
- thatfrenchguy 6y agoInfrastructure gets more expensive as density lowers. Most of the US (and France, for example) built after the 1960s decided to build stupid detached single family houses. There is no incentive to upzone there given that homeowners who bought for cheap want their property values to go up, with no downsides for them (thanks prop 13)
- mc32 6y agoDevelopers didn't build stupid detached homes because no one would want them, they built them because that's what most people prefer. People don't prefer dealing with noisy neighbors, etc. Almost anywhere where there is land available and it's affordable you'll have a large group of people who prefer single family homes --even favelas have single family homes. As societies become more affluent they want more independence --and your own house is part of that.
- lordCarbonFiber 6y agoCitation desperately needed. Having grown up in the suburbs and participated in the exodus along with everyone I knew that could, detached housing is an isolating personal hell (and a pain to clean and maintain on top of it). Places where single family homes exist rarely even have the option for high density housing and, in the US at least, never have the public infrastructure to support it. It's a learned excess not a requirement.
- zepto 6y agoHow is a detached house an ‘isolating hell’? I have lived in apartments and single family homes about 50/50 both as a kid, and as an adult, and I’d say bigger places have had an edge in terms of socializing just because it’s more comfortable to host people - but not by much.
- mc32 6y agoBBQs are a great getting together activity summers (good weather). Many apartment buildings don’t have balconies or communal space fir BBQs... detached houses (or ‘plexes) make that activity easier.
- davidgay 6y agoReplying to parent as the child is too deep(?): > Places where single family homes exist rarely even have the option for high density housing and, in the US at least, never have the public infrastructure to support it. Berkeley is on the list of US highest density cities (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...) and has a lot of single-family homes (definitely most by area by a large margin, and there are no high-rises in Berkeley...). The lots are small of course . And it has, for the US, reasonable public transportation.
- mc32 6y agoSF is dense but it also never the less has neighborhoods with single family detached homes too (glen park, cole valley and others built around approx time). of course it's mainly multi-family low-rise mid-rise buildings.
- NumberWangMan 6y agoI think the root problem with single family homes is not their existence, but several factors: 1) They are implicitly subsidised by cities in the form of having way more infrastructure and public services dedicated to them, per-capita, than denser forms of development. Even though taxes in suburbs may be expensive, the massive amount of infrastructure it takes to support thousands of single-family homes, most with at least two drivers, means that suburb dwellers are not paying their fair share of taxes. It's like someone at a restaurant ordering a $200 bottle of wine for themselves and only being asked to pay $50 more when it comes time to split the check. In fact, in many places, single family suburbs are actually a net loss for the city, depending on the tax rates and how sparse they are. That's also not to mention things like carbon emissions not being properly priced into the cost of gasoline. It would be much less attractive, relatively, to live far away from employment if this were fixed. 2) In many places, zoning makes it illegal to build anything BUT single-family homes. If we could eliminate these two issues -- have people living in suburbs pay the true cost, and make it legal to build pretty anything else, then I think most people wouldn't have a problem with suburbs. But then, I also suspect that suburbs would be much, much less attractive if that were the case.
- Retric 6y agoIt’s U shaped. NYC could build a new highway by knocking down skyscrapers or building massive tunnels like the big dig etc. At the other end, a new highway in Iowa needs to be extremely long to connect to anything useful. The sweet spot depends on a host of factors and the Bay Area ticks off several of them by having the ocean, bay, and parks, forcing a long narrow strip of development. Add in earthquakes and it’s really a terrible location for building infrastructure even ignoring NIMBY issues.
- kspacewalk2 6y agoYou have it almost completely backwards when it comes to the relationship between density and cost. For a fixed number of residents, nothing is more expensive per capita in terms of long-term infrastructure costs than low-density (especially single-family residential) housing[0]. The skyrocketing you speak of may occur when you look at the cost per area, but certainly not per capita, and definitely not per dollar of property tax revenue. Basically the staggering long-term costs of maintaining suburbia infrastructure are so much larger than the property tax revenue from suburbia residents that many cities are doomed to either abandon the efforts to fend off the slow infrastructure decay, or go bankrupt. [0] https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/9/the-real-reason-your-city-has-no-money https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/9/the-real-reason...
- Retric 6y agoThat’s overly simplified and missing the point. You can buy a 880 home for 90k in Gilroy CA just 52 miles from Stanford. In much of the country you could travel that distance daily, but because the roads are so overcrowded it’s still cheap. I am saying the exact same thing happens just a little bit closer whenever you build higher density without building new infrastructure to support it. Now sure like most things there is a density sweet spot. But nobody is building suburbs because their close to corn fields. It’s still the cities infrastructure that’s driving up land prices around it. Simply because that land happens to be near stuff people want.
- NumberWangMan 6y agoYou're touching on another important issue. Zoning that mandates homes be built away from jobs and businesses means that more density causes drastic increases in traffic. But allowing mixed use development gives people an option to cut their commutes to almost zero, if they choose, letting the density scale a lot better than if everyone has to drive. Since most modern work is not noisy, polluting industry, the major benefit of separating residences from work has mostly gone away. But we're still suffering the costs of this form of zoning. It would be non-trivial to intentionally come up with a more wasteful way to structure our cities and towns. Another thing to think about is that if we could allow denser, mixed used development in all the suburbs, there wouldn't be so much pressure on housing in the dense urban core of cities. If just 10% of houses in suburbs turned into duplexes, that would mean a 10% increase in housing, and it would be hard to even notice. But again, we also need more intermingling of commerce and residences, to cut down on traffic.
- mtnGoat 6y agoSub-division being built by my house right now. They paid $500k for the land a few years ago. Paid $1.1m this year to get the earthworks done ( underground power, water, sewage, irrigation,etc) plus they will pave the street and do curbing. The land was the last expensive part by far, prepping it cost double. There will be 19 lots, however he will not sell any, he will build every home on spec(ulation) and sell them himself. It's purely a profit driven decision and he will make million+, after spending years getting everything aligned and tying up capital. $80-100k in outfit per lot, plus another $100k per house. He will do quite well. However if he sold those lots and more builders were involved, we would have new housing faster. This is true for at least 4 sub divisions being built in my town. Greed/capitalism is creating/exacerbating a housing shortage, everyone wants to maximize profits in a slow moving business, instead of just facilitating the creating of housing as efficient as possible.
- jjeaff 6y agoThe only reason that spec sub-divisions like that are profitable is all the permitting and other bureaucratic work is too burdensome for individuals. It requires economy of scale to get over that hump. Of course, there is some economy of scale with building multiple homes, buying bulk, etc. (and most of all, cutting corners that an individual home owner would never cut if they were building for themselves) but overall, it's the bureaucracy that makes it difficult for your average person.