8 ms·
More often than not, when someone takes you off from hold they expect an answer right away, and will hang up on you if there's no response. I've had this happen
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
More often than not, when someone takes you off from hold they expect an answer right away, and will hang up on you if there's no response. I've had this happen in cases where I put myself on mute and couldn't hit the un-mute button fast enough.
So I'm not sure how well this would work in practice. At minimum, I would be anxious the whole time I was waiting, ready to hit the return to call button at a moment's notice...
- benmller313 6y agoCall centers are going to have to become more accommodating about this. If they make customers wait for hours but can't wait seconds for someone to get on the line, they should be considered effectively unreachable by phone.
- ugh123 6y ago>If they make customers wait for hours but can't wait seconds for someone to get on the line, they should be considered effectively unreachable by phone. I think thats part of the playbook for most support call centers.
- crpatino 6y agoUnlike the playbook, though, this is a observable behavior that can be documented. If I were writing an utopia, class action lawsuits would rain like fire and brimstone.
- a_bonobo 6y agoAustralia's Centrelink, the unemployment/student payment government body, is notorious for doing this. They have physical centres which usually tell you to call the hotline. In 2015, the hotline got the busy signal for 29 million callers (Australia has 25 million inhabitants). 7 million were hung up during the wait time. I myself have been in their queue for hours at a time. There are zero legal ramifications for this behaviour. Source: https://www.smh.com.au/public-service/centrelink-hangs-up-on-29-million-calls-senate-estimates-hears-20161021-gs7ecj.html https://www.smh.com.au/public-service/centrelink-hangs-up-on...
- throwaway2048 6y agoConsidering how little they already care about their customers, I find it extraordinarily unlikely they are going to suddenly become more accommodating for some random Google project.
- bleepblorp 6y agoFor the company that's operating the call center, that's a feature rather than a bug. Anything they can do to just make you go away, including making you wait for two hours in the first place, saves the company money.
- xmprt 6y agoThat doesn't make sense though, right? Barring regulatory reasons that force companies to have call centers, if the company wanted to provide customer support then they would want to be able to fix customer problems, right? And I've heard call center employees are paid based on minutes on the line so why wouldn't they want to wait a bit longer to solve someone's problem.
- EamonnMR 6y agoThey want to provide the outward appearance of providing customer support.
- KeepFlying 6y agoThe company wants problems to go away. Fixing them or making it so people don't bother the company about it are both ways to accomplish that goal. And as long as the lack of support doesn't impact sales, it doesn't hurt the company and saves them money in not having to pay for more/better call center staff. Also in more benevolent companies, providing support over the phone is the most expensive way to provide support. So as much of that that can be shifted to automated systems, better products, etc the better because it avoids the high cost of a call center. While a call center employee may be paid by minutes on the line (though I think that is rare), they would be penalized for taking too long on a single call or helping too few customers. There's little incentive to spend time on longer more difficult calls when you could just focus your effort on solving many of the simple calls instead.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> if the company wanted to provide customer support then they would want to be able to fix customer problems You've clearly never had to deal with a company in a monopolized industry like telecommunications. The call center needs to be there on paper, otherwise it will give people the option to cancel their contracts or even initiate lawsuits because something doesn't work and the company is unreachable. The call center doesn't need to provide quality support however; as long as it is there on paper it is all that matters. In reality the call center is costing the company money and they'd rather not have you on the phone as long as you keep paying your bill (and most people will keep paying even if they receive subpar or lack of service because of the lack of consumer protection laws in the US, forced arbitration, the fear of a hit on their credit report or the lack of competition).
- dx87 6y agoOr it will make the wait even longer, since the queue time is going to increase if a large amount of people use this feature and take 15-30 seconds to answer their phone when a representative is available, instead of being able to answer immediately.
- Nition 6y agoMaybe the feature should switch the phone to loudspeaker mode when the call is answered, so you'd immediately hear them speak and could also immediately reply before picking the phone up.
- ogre_codes 6y agoCall centers that give a shit about customer service usually have the option to just leave your number and they call you back. Call centers that don't want/ need to be accommodating will just hang up.
- cube00 6y agoSome of those never seem to call back in my experience.
- jojobas 6y ago*laughs in Comcast.
- aschatten 6y agoAren’t they effectively unreachable anyway, if they make customers wait for hours?
- VectorLock 6y agoI thought the exact same thing as well, I assume that the program will annunciate a message when it detects someone on hold, like to does with their Screen Call feature (which I love)
- nom 6y agoI hope this google assistant will start talking to them while it waits for you to notice the notification, essentially putting them on hold until you answer. Didn't look into it so no idea how it behaves, but sounds like a realistic solution to this problem and would have very interesting consequences!
- bleepblorp 6y agoThe most likely interesting consequence will be companies burying a line in the ToS saying they can deny you service if you use a tool to reduce your opportunity costs of sitting in a hold queue. The purpose of a hold queue is to reduce the number of customer service calls a company has to field. They will not take lightly to any service which defeats this. Alternatively, they'll hire staff to answer the phone, say a few words to break out of Google's hold music detection algorithm, then put you back on hold, this time with ads instead of music. Repeat every few minutes to make sure you're still stuck on the line. There's no limits to what's possible when you realize the purpose of anti-customer service is to harm customers rather than help them.
- nom 6y agoThey could, but google could pretend to be you and answer basic questions until you pick up. Or just pretend to be your secretary. We're at a point where it becomes impossible to tell if you are talking to a human or not, at least for the first 10-20 seconds. I don't think those companies/call centers can win here, they will have to adjust sooner or later.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- est31 6y ago> Once a representative is identified, Google Assistant will notify you that someone’s ready to talk and ask the representative to hold for a moment while you return to the call. We gathered feedback from a number of companies, including Dell and United, as well as from studies with customer support representatives, to help us design these interactions and make the feature as helpful as possible to the people on both sides of the call.
- tinus_hn 6y agoObviously companies like Dell couldn’t come up with a system where you enter your phone number and you get a call as soon as an agent is available.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThe lack of such a feature is not a technical problem; it's misaligned incentives. The company does not want you on the phone; the annoyance of being on hold is a feature for them and not a problem that should be fixed. In a healthy market this behavior would cause the company to lose marketshare to a competitor offering better support, which is why the only companies still using call centers as their primary (and often only contact) are those in monopolized industries like telecommunications. Every other industry has moved on to better solutions (async email, chat, etc) because consumers demanded them. The real problem here is monopolies and misplaced regulation (harmful regulation that prevents competition combined with the lack of regulation that would force the incumbent to actually provide good service).
- GekkePrutser 6y agoExactly. In fact some callcenter systems have a feature called something like 'expectation management'. It can make you wait even if there are people available, just so you don't get used to the quick response and be less happy at busier times. Or to dissuade people from calling for minor issues I guess. It's often used on cheaper support tiers also to make paid support more interesting. I'm not joking, this is an actual feature. I used to build callcenters and it surprised me when I saw it in the documentation. None of our customers ever implemented this but I can imagine some would otherwise it wouldn't have been in there.
- loco5niner 6y agoPresumably, your phone would say something like. "The person calling you is using a google service to listen to hold music for them... they should be with you momentarily."
- nraynaud 6y agoThey don’t play a hold music for them? I’ve had Brands interactions on Twitter where they ask me to go into private, then ask for my phone number, call me and send me directly to a holding queue, i guess it would fair to respond in kind.
- bigiain 6y agoOuch - that's _nasty_... Exactly the sort of behaviour I'd expect from a company that considers "brand interactions" to be a thing.
- floatingatoll 6y agoIt’s not going to identify itself as a robot.
- Shebanator 6y agoIt actually does
- loco5niner 6y agoWhen my phone screens calls, it does exactly that.
- mentos 6y agoWould be cool if they let you record a ‘yep I’m here just a second my headset came unplugged’ that it could play while you rejoin the call
- yefim 6y agoI prefer that to listening to the repetitive hold music.