9 ms·
Oh, this is really unlucky. I like Hacktoberfest and always get my T-shirt. Perhaps opt-in would be a great idea. I can see why this happens, though. I've noti
by renewiltord 6y ago
Oh, this is really unlucky. I like Hacktoberfest and always get my T-shirt. Perhaps opt-in would be a great idea.
I can see why this happens, though. I've noticed that a whole bunch of projects have `good-first-issue` being something like "Re-architect module loading system" while most commits are like "correct typo". Like, jeez, man.
The participants are probably just pattern-matching against the commits available.
EDIT: Decided to go look at the spam that OSM got (a project close to my heart) and what the hell, man, look at this diff
<removed>
* Tom Hughes [@tomhughes](https://github.com/tomhughes/)
* Andy Allan [@gravitystorm](https://github.com/gravitystorm/)
+
+
+ Made with Love
This is just awful! I really feel for the maintainers. This user is just adding nonsense to a bunch of places.'
EDIT again: Whoops, guys, I didn't mean to cause more spam to the project. Removed the diff link. Jesus Christ, I ended up becoming the villain I was complaining about by linking it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dmurray 6y agoYou may have missed it, but the article screenshots a similar example where the spammer added "### Great Work" to the front of the README.
- renewiltord 6y agoOh you're right! I was reading on my phone and bucketed that picture as a link to the other blog posts like the carousel at the bottom and mentally skipped it. My mistake!
- domenicd 6y agoSorry about that carousel. I want to get rid of Disqus entirely (when I started the blog in 2012 they were not so icky). But, then I think about related yak-shaving, like moving off of Jekyll...
- renewiltord 6y agoIt's all good. The error was mine. Disqus was, indeed, a great product back then. I didn't realize they added all this stuff now.
- dceddia 6y agoI’ve been down that rabbit hole myself. My blog is still running Jekyll but my comments are now on a self-hosted install of Commento. It works pretty well. For me the main feature is that it’s not Disqus, but another nice benefit is that comments support Markdown now!
- nefitty 6y agoI’ve heard of people spamming readme commits to get their github graph green... I guess if an employer is tricked by something like this they are kinda asking for what they get.
- pop44 6y agoThat’s a failure of imagination and evidence of having never read the Git manual pages, because the GitHub contribution graph respects commit time (which you absolutely can override), and it’s a trivial hour-long project to write messages on it. I had greenscale pixel rendering of images on the contribution graph working in about an hour, most of which was figuring out the heuristics for quantity in each cell (hint: it’s not as complex as you think). I can’t understate the simplicity of doing it, and I’d be nervous about someone taking the other approach as indicative of their technical depth. Then again, they’re already spamming READMEs so it’s not as if it was a strong signal to start with.
- renewiltord 6y agoIt's pretty easy, but if I'm looking at your Github to look at your work I can't find anything if you've clobbered your true history with a message. I don't ever see that as a negative signal, but I do see it as a positive signal if I can just read your code, so if you write good code in public and you hide it, I can't find it. Of course, whether you care is up to you, but if I find solid code there I'm going to recommend skipping technical evaluation if you're considering working with me.
- ric2b 6y agoAll you need is a throwaway repo where you create all those commits to control the commit chart. It doesn't hide your work at all (commit frequency is an awful metric of valuable work, some people do a lot of "fix typo" commits).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- alkonaut 6y agoWth is that? Bots? Trolls? Scammers wanting to start a t-shirt business?
- jacques_chester 6y agoPeople resell them on ebay.
- impropsters 6y agoSometimes it feels like software development has devolved into a sea of posturing and marketing oneself. It's faintly depressing to see reminders of that trend which are as stark as this. It's a fitting allegory, though. This contest has used free T-shirts to solicit open-source contributions in the same way that the industry has used high salaries to solicit creative and impactful contributions. Now imagine that you're trying to fill a position, and these pull requests are analogous to candidate interviews. You might start to have some sympathy for people who believe that we need some sort of professional certification for the trade. It's unfortunate considering the democratizing promise of low-cost computing, but how else can you effectively deal with this "market for lemons" caused by large swaths of people acting in blatant bad faith? When seeming is taken for being, being becomes seeming. \ When nothing is taken for something, something becomes nothing.
- addicted 6y agoI’d argue getting a shirt for some PRs is better than the status quo, where you get nothing for a PR. Which just goes to show how bad the status quo is.
- robocat 6y ago“But we obtain the puzzling result that, when rewarded, volunteers work less. These findings are in line with a large literature in social psychology emphasizing that external rewards can undermine the intrinsic motivation for an activity.” Be very careful assuming that a payment motivates open source developers. If you offered to help me do something for an hour for whatever internal motivation you might have, and afterwards I offer you $5 for your time, you would likely be demotivated.
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoIf you offered to help me do something for an hour for whatever internal motivation you might have, and afterwards I offer you $5 for your time, you would likely be demotivated. On the other hand if you offered to buy them a beer or a coffee it would probably be very motivating. I'm not sure why this is. Maybe cash just feels lazy and impersonal, so the amount being offered has to be big enough to counter that feeling.
- agbell 6y agoThis is strange, I wonder why they are targeting this repo? I have labeled some issues 'hacktoberfest' and have gotten very well meaning contributions. Here is an example https://github.com/earthly/earthly/issues/334 https://github.com/earthly/earthly/issues/334
- lordgrenville 6y agoHow did linking to the diff cause spam?
- renewiltord 6y agoWithin seconds of doing so, people started adding reactions to it and then someone 'suggested changes' that were essentially a commit revert. It's the community saying the changes were undesired, but those things nevertheless do notify maintainers. I only realized then that I was creating one of those situations where people pile on a few hundred comments onto a PR that are thin me-toos onto one side or the other.
- rob74 6y agoI think they should completely reverse their approach: instead of instigating people to create senseless PRs, DigitalOcean should use the GitHub API to find contributors who made meaningful first contributions to existing projects over the last year, and send them T-shirts... in October?
- codeduck 6y agobut this would take time and imagination and is so much harder.
- searchableguy 6y agoI think a major part of this is about pushing devs who haven't contributed before to contribute such as new cs students.
- mkl 6y agoThat may be the intention, but what's happening is basically vandalism: https://github.com/search?o=desc&q=is%3Apr+%22improve+docs%22&s=created&type=Issues https://github.com/search?o=desc&q=is%3Apr+%22improve+docs%2... ~1000 single line/word pull requests in the last 3 hours, almost all worthless rubbish. The scale of the problem is pretty severe. To pick a single example: https://github.com/Geng-WD/websiteTest https://github.com/Geng-WD/websiteTest A little personal Java project, unchanged in 3 years, where a new "contributor" has submitted a pull request where they add a comment with their own name in one commit, and then remove it and replace it with "Awesome coding website" in a second commit. 19 hours earlier another new "contributor" submitted a pull request to add a completely irrelevant mock gym web page (and they've done the same thing to a bunch of other randomly chosen repos). If these people had to demonstrate valuable contributions over a longer span of time, I don't think any of this nonsense would be happening. There's no reason new CS students can't be respectful and put a little effort into doing something worthwhile, and they'll learn a lot more than from this mindless spamming.
- cyphar 6y agoAfter looking at a few dozen accounts and their PR histories, the spammers seem to be just searching for repositories that have the word "website" in their description and picking a random set of 5 to send random requests to.
- t-vi 6y agoSo when you're throwing a party and suddenly have guests trashing the neighbor's front yard, do you stop the party or let the party go on for another month because it was so good last year "and we'll change something next year, in the mean time can you build a fence"? I'll not advocate calling DigitalOcean on the phone, but tagging the CEO on the complaints on twitter might be more effective than tagging the community manager who professes he is not listened to.