6 ms·
>All I want is to just focus on engineering and ship features/improvements. Yeah if there wasn't the pesky world around all the engineering and we could all ju
by Barrin92 6y ago
>All I want is to just focus on engineering and ship features/improvements.
Yeah if there wasn't the pesky world around all the engineering and we could all just stare at our stock options while we sit in our gentrified neighbourhoods and pretend the world doesn't exist.
You can ignore politics but politics doesn't ignore you. See no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil is an unworthy attitude for a democratic citizen. The etymology for the word 'idiot' comes from 'idios', meaning 'one's own', in ancient Greece signifying a person who is only concerned with their private interest, rather than living an active life and participating in civic affairs. To be an idiot was to be withdrawn, isolated and selfish, to not participate in the public, political life of the state.
Given how much people nowadays love to invoke the Greeks and our ancient Western traditions, maybe it's time to remind everyone of the meaning of that word again.
http://faculty.washington.edu/rsoder/EDUC305/305parkeridiocy.pdf http://faculty.washington.edu/rsoder/EDUC305/305parkeridiocy...
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoGP never said to ignore politics. You are the one that brought that up. They said to leave them out of the office. There is plenty of time for politics before and after work. Bringing your politics in to work just makes for an uncomfortable work environment for you co-workers.
- Barrin92 6y ago'the office' or the firm today, is for better or worse our primary means by which we can exercise influence. That is why tech workers are bringing politics into the firm in the first place, because they realise, rightly, that it is one of the most potent channels to actually exercise change, and that's why so many people want to keep politics out of it. The workplace is the one space where your political opponent can't simply escape from politics, and has to be confronted with your views, which is after all the actual point of political life. People realise that rather than the local town hall, the large internet platforms, their workplace, and their social media feed have become the public space of ideas. That's why the free speech debate focuses so much on internet platforms, and why 'it's privately owned' has long lost meaning to anyone in the debate. Keeping politics 'out of the workplace', at least in our environment today, is basically to say to keep politics out, period. It's not the apolitical position, it is the 'idiotic' position because it intents to keep politics out of the one place that actually matters the most in this day and age.
- claudeganon 6y agoIt’s always been this way in the west, post industrialization. People treating it as some novel development are just ignorant of history. Why do you think so many democracies have “labor” or “workers” parties? Myriad progressive movements and political parties were born out of and materially supported by workers organizing their workplaces.
- moneytalks 6y agoSome would call political activism on your employer's dime theft. Unless it's part of your job description. But no one likes to face what it means to sell their time to another person.
- tshaddox 6y ago> Some would call political activism on your employer's dime theft. That's probably true, but they would be wrong. The fact that some people would say incorrect things is not a strong argument.
- gambler 6y agoYou haven't really provided any arguments for why converting companies (entities providing goods and services) into mini political parties is a good idea. Anyone can yell about "status quo" and "change". In reality, "status quo" is frequently an ill defined concept and the benefits of change depend entirely on what kind of change it is. When I work for a company, I provide my labor in exchange for payment. I am then free to use my money to support an activist organization or a cause. So are all other employees. Corporate activism, on the other hand, is inherently degenerate. It means your employer withholds resources from improving the business or paying higher salaries. They instead apply those resources to some causes of their choosing. Any employee who doesn't agree with the cause is effectively coerced into supporting it unless they quit. So is every customer. The goods and services become inherently tangled with an ideology of some sort. Why should a model where everyone is free to pursue their personal activism be replaced with a model where people are coerced to pursue activism "approved" by corporate execs?
- uoaei 6y agoAnd what about when the business performed by the company you are working for has political consequences?
- x3n0ph3n3 6y agoBrian Armstrong pretty clearly stated that position: > Policy decisions: If there is a bill introduced around crypto, we may engage here, but we normally wouldn’t engage in policy decisions around healthcare or education for example. Are there other "political consequences" around crypto that you'd have Coinbase engage in?
- subsubzero 6y agoYour strawman argument is invalid to what I said. I spend an inordinate amount of time researching each candidates views and each propositions pros and cons. Before election day I usually set aside a day or two to deep dive into every choice I make. I take voting very seriously as people have died to give me the luxury to vote. These actions all occur outside of the office where they belong. That being said leave politics out of the office.
- toiletfuneral 6y agoThank god IBM had employees like you during the 1930's, otherwise they might not have made as much money.
- derkster 6y agoAbsolutely. And I better not hear anything about unionizing either, with all their liberal communist ideology! They're lucky I let them have jobs. /s
- claudeganon 6y agoLots of people also died to make sure that we have the right to organize our workplaces, a right that’s just as much enshrined in law as voting: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_worker_deaths_in_United_States_labor_disputes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_worker_deaths_in_Uni... Their sacrifice wasn’t any less important or necessary to the expansion of the democracy in the United States. In fact, it was this “bringing politics to the work” that provided the means for workers having real representation for them in government in the first place.
- md_ 6y agoThis may sound like a troll, but how do we delineate what politics belong in the office and what do not? As I noted elsewhere in this thread, I think it's more ambiguous these days, not less. As a few concrete examples: * Say I refuse to buy Chinese-made goods because I oppose the treatment of Uyghurs in Xinjiang. What do I do if my employer considers doing business in China? Should I not mention this, because it's "political"? * What if it's 1933, and my employer is IBM, and the customer is Nazi Germany? * Say I oppose H1B visas because they take jobs away from American citizens, and my employer considers expanding the H1B workforce. Should I speak out against it, or hold my tongue because my motives are "political"? * Say I believe in equal rights for gay couples, and my employer is considering expanding health coverage to same-sex partners. Should I speak out in favor of it? In each of these examples, it seems to me there's a spectrum of options, ranging from: A. No constraints on in-office behavior; I speak out about anything. B. In the office, I am purely a shareholder-profit-maximizing robot. I don't think either of those extremes is very satisfying—I expect many of us would say it is noble to oppose selling adding machines to Nazi Germany, but that we'd have many more questions when it comes to some of the other examples. Unfortunately, I think that means that there's no simple answer here. "No politics in the workplace" can result in ghastly, amoral outcomes (selling adding machines to the Nazis). But "every culture war, all the time" is a great way to be a dick. I think my personal code here is, "try not to be a dick." Past that point, I don't think there are easy answers.
- ptero 6y agoThe comment author does not advocate ignoring the world, he wants to separate his engineering work from politics and thus wants to look for employers who do not push a particular political program on him. Which seems a perfectly valid (and attractive to me) view. You cannot ignore your dreams, your health, your family, social ills, the air quality, politics and a myriad of other things in the world around you. But if you focus on all of those all the time you will achieve nothing. Imagine a great inventor, scientist, engineer or artist working on his next idea. Do you really want to make him jump and go demonstrate for/against your list of hot button topics?
- toiletfuneral 6y agoThis response is mis-characterization and is acting in bad faith, no one in this thread is asking for forced demonstrating. That's not actually a thing that's happening.
- Barrin92 6y ago>Do you really want to make him jump and go demonstrate for/against your list of hot button topics? Yes I do and countless of scientists and artists do exactly that, which is why a lot of them ended up being subject to McCarthyism paranoia at one point or the other. Brilliant scientists, more than anyone else maybe, need to engage the political world to understand what influence what they built has on it. Technologists being painfully unaware of the political ramifications of their work, if anything, got us to where we are right now. It's no coincidence that the politically detached scientist is the archetypical citizen of autocratic countries. The technologist who does not care for politics is today, the most sought after person in China.
- tshaddox 6y agoWanting to separate engineering work from reality is precisely what Barrin92 is saying should not and can not be done. Engineering work isn't just some insulated game that gives you tokens to buy things you need in the real world. The engineering work is itself part of the real world.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
- shams93 6y agoWell said!
- natalyarostova 6y agoGreat. Go work at a firm that reserves time for activism under a common cause. Plenty of us don’t want to do that at work, and will look for firms that let us focus on engineering for our time at work, so we can reserve our free time to do as we please.
- manigandham 6y agoIt's perfectly reasonable to separate the workplace and the rest of the world. No need to ignore everything to limit your discussion at work. You can also still take action - by leaving. That's exactly what this policy is encouraging with a generous exit package. Why is that not acceptable? Why does the corporation have to follow what you decide?
- Reedx 6y agoIf people don't want to bring the political battlefield into every venue, that's not only valid, but wise. You are not going to innovate or create anything if you're fighting all day, every day. Constantly distracted. The purpose of a company is to bring people together to CREATE something of value. To solve problems. Hopefully to improve lives on some vector. And you do that most effectively by rowing in the same direction, focused. People spending their day on Twitter or Slack or in the office halls arguing about the war is not productive. It's mostly just destructive. They're certainly not inventing anything, or curing a disease, or improving energy efficiency, or creating tools, or educating, or entertaining, or inspiring, or anything else additive.
- uoaei 6y agoYou've misrepresented the quote, and in the process invalidated your whole point. The original quote is diplomacy is war by other means. And it had very specific connotations to explicitly adversarial political relationships. Politics is much larger than diplomacy, and indeed as Aristotle concluded there is nothing in a society that is not politics.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Yeah if there wasn't the pesky world around all the engineering and we could all just stare at our stock options while we sit in our gentrified neighbourhoods and pretend the world doesn't exist. The issue with "activist" employees isn't so much that they want to bring politics to work (which I can see arguments for and against). It's that the new "activist" employees insist everyone's politics be the same, else you become a target. I think "no politics" offices will crush it in the future, if by nothing more than being able to focus on the product.
- kennywinker 6y agoYour logic is sound: politics are a distraction, so offices where politics are put aside will be more productive. But I know a lot of VERY smart people who wouldn’t sign up for that workplace. Especially if there are social and political ramifications to the product being built or the customers being served (there almost always are - hence the cliche “making the world a better place” goal of any startup).
- luckylion 6y agoAre there really that many? A lot of very smart people tend to end up at Google, FB or Amazon, their ethics don't seem to be the deciding factor in the choice of employer.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>But I know a lot of VERY smart people who wouldn’t sign up for that workplace. Sure, that's the trade-off. In a vacuum we all want to "make the world a better place". Does cancelling academics who appear on Joe Rogan's podcast "make the world a better place"? Does having a coworker cancelled or fired because of a stupid joke "make the world a better place"? I don't know; I don't think so. On the other hand, I think there should be internal political discussion regarding policy at a place like Facebook. What are the politics relevant to your job? It's not easy to answer.
- zackees 6y agoThe problem with activism is that most people engage in easy to grab fast food activism served to them by the oligarchical msm. The social justice actions by google was nothing less than a coup of the United States. Hence the reason I was forced to sacrifice my career to the blow the whistle. [www.zachvorhies.com](https://www.zachvorhies.com https://www.zachvorhies.com)
- f00zz 6y ago"Everything is political" "Being apolitical is a political stance" "If you don't take a stand you're part of the problem" Gosh, this is tiresome.
- sbmthakur 6y agoI also believe that every citizen has certain roles and responsibilities in a democracy(voting for instance). However, the workplace is not exactly a democracy. The only thing that I will definitely participate is in the work that I am getting paid for. All other endeavors of the company should be voluntary. If the company is directly or indirectly forcing these on me, then I will consider it as a breach of my agreement with the company.
- oh_sigh 6y agoDo you ignore politics while you're pooping? If so, why?
- ideal_stingray 6y agoAs a member of several different marginalized groups, I want to be able to go to work and do my job without having to hear my coworkers argue about whether I get to exist. I’m well aware that politics doesn’t ignore me, but for my own sanity I don’t want to think about it any more than necessary, either.