7 ms·
The argument they're making here is a little subtle, but it tracks. They're not claiming Google will hand out a user's biometrics to insurance companies or oth
by shadowgovt 6y ago
The argument they're making here is a little subtle, but it tracks.
They're not claiming Google will hand out a user's biometrics to insurance companies or other parties. They're claiming Google will offer biometrically-based signal as an ad discrimination channel.
At that point, they don't have to hand out the data to allow insurance companies to discriminate; insurance companies could set up targeted ads for Cadillac insurance programs on users having XYZ biometrics and those ads only run for users that are showing they're low health risks. So it's soft market discrimination; only the extra-healthy get explicitly told about new insurance plan A, and the self-select group signs up, possibly making A cheaper for the insurer to implement even if they don't do any additional screening.
I think the theory has holes, but it's not nonsense. And it's unclear to me that it demands government regulation (but my bias is American-style law; I don't know how European legal eyes see the story I just laid out).
- tehjoker 6y agoWhen the user clicks on specially targeted ads, they reveal themselves to be part of the group and are individually identifiable.
- shadowgovt 6y agoTo a first approximation, yes. There isn't any authentication around following an ad link, so technically anyone could click the ad. But practically, no; nobody's going to randomly click an ad link someone else handed them for funsies. In the common case, the ad company will be able to do conversions on the target demo (and make strong assumptions about the target demo, even if Google doesn't explicitly leak that data).
- eptcyka 6y agoI wonder if it'd make sense to have a plugin that'd share ad links in a p2p network just to screw with these people.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThat's click-fraud, and Google at least attempts to identify it (so they're not charging for false ad views). No idea if they share the "That click was fraud" signal with their clients for this kind of display ad.
- alienfilesystem 6y agoWhat about AdNauseum? Same basic premise.
- heimatau 6y agoClick fraud sounds like an ominous term. But let's be real here. We aren't truly opting into all this tracking. I'd rather call it anonymous clicks. As for Google trying to resist it, I strongly suspect there isn't a network actively trying to give privacy back to the people. On a related tangent, CloudFlare creating a Google Analytics tracker could help lessen Google's tracking. But this battle should've been waged about 10 years ago. It's a shame that Hydra has many formidable heads.
- frenchyatwork 6y agoI think that calling ad-sharing "click-fraud" is a little ridiculous. I can understand why someone would call an extension like AdNauseam click-fraud, but this would presumably be people legitimately clicking on the ad.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI'm using the industry technical term, in the sense that the algorithms that could protect an advertiser from screwing up their metrics already exist to protect Google from screwing up the payment model.
- luckylion 6y agoDon't forget that Google allows some ad buyers to run their own JS inside the app. They could embed additional tracking and would get the hit without the user even clicking.
- shadowgovt 6y agoNot in a way they reveals demographics; that JS is sandboxed and can't generally figure out why the ad was run. There's room for abuse, but Google will slap wrists of advertisers who try it.
- luckylion 6y agoYou don't need to figure out why the ad was run if you target the ad to people who match the demographic you want to identify. It runs because it fits the match. I don't know whether Google will slap any wrists. It went so far that their ads hijacked the browser and redirected to scam sites. I've been on the debugging end on a few such attacks over the years, and it just happened once every other year or so on sites with a healthy amount of traffic. The scammers do try to fly under the radar (only targeting specific sites, only targeting mobile and specific demographics to make it harder to track). If they simply didn't allow them the access, the problem wouldn't exist.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThey allow the access because "good behaving" advertisers can use it to do animation and such without having to load high-bandwidth media files. It is a feature of their display ads system that user privacy is protected and advertisers shouldn't be able to solve to a user when the ad is displayed (though they can, of course, begin a business arrangement with a user if the user clicks the ad; that's called a "conversion"). Scammers that abuse the JS layer fly under the radar because Google will ban their display ads account if they get caught abusing what the JS allows them to access (such as trying to data-scrape parameters off the user's machine to estimate whether they're seeing someone they've already seen). "3 Ad Serving. (a) Customer will not provide Ads containing malware, spyware or any other malicious code or knowingly breach or circumvent any Program security measure." [https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/54818?hl=en https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/54818?hl=en]
- tqi 6y agoThis is called risk selection, and is already a common practice [1] that doesn't require much in the way of "health data" [2]. I suspect that 80% of the effect can be achieved via "simple" methods like advertising on health and fitness related sites or keywords, partnering with gyms to advertise to members, etc. ACA has some provisions to help address these incentives [3], though it's unclear how effective they are. The Privacy / Big Tech angle is attention grabbing, but is grossly missing the point. In my opinion, the reality is we need to decide if this type of discrimination is something we as a society want to regulate or not. [1] https://www.nber.org/papers/w19198 https://www.nber.org/papers/w19198 [2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/feds/2015/files/2015101pap.pdf https://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/feds/2015/files/2... [3] https://www.kff.org/health-reform/issue-brief/explaining-health-care-reform-risk-adjustment-reinsurance-and-risk-corridors/ https://www.kff.org/health-reform/issue-brief/explaining-hea...
- rapind 6y agoI’m not sure it’s missing the point though. I think the specificity and scale that big tech brings can change the impact of these practices significantly. Some thing’s are not be a big risk to society until they get amplified.
- tqi 6y agoAgree that is possible, but from what I've seen for the most part big data and predictive ML has been incremental (at best) to more naive methods.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoYup, yup. The real efficiencies in insurance come from data, not models. This is mostly true because the models which can be used are massively regulated, and must be explained to regulators (which sounds like a fun job).
- Dirlewanger 6y ago>They're not claiming Google will hand out a user's biometrics to insurance companies or other parties. Make no mistake though: those days are coming. It's just a matter of how soon. And no government will give a shit to stop it.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThat's an odd prediction, given how unpopular the idea is.
- Dirlewanger 6y agoUnpopular to whom, the HN crowd? The crowd that no one pays attention to? I'll tell you who it's not unpopular to: HMO execs that would love another excuse to raise your premium.
- BurningFrog 6y agoLet me just point out that the root problem here is the broken US "health insurance" system. That targeted ads might cause these kinds of problems is a side effect of this.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI believe the article in question relates to a European Commission investigation. In the US, this kind of data aggregation doesn't even make waves regarding antitrust. Google just has to comply with HIPAA and it's basically good to go (they already had "Google Health" as an app for self-reported data ages ago, which nobody stopped). If Google started feeding this data to insurance companies, it'd be out of compliance with HIPAA.
- qppo 6y agoPersonally I'm more worried about companies outside the healthcare markets getting access to health data more than insurance companies. But it seems like everyone is in agreement on that. I'd bet money that with consistent access to sleep cycles, heart rate, blood pressure, ecg, and body temperature combined with device analytics (screen time, content watched/listened to) you could easily come up with a behavioral model that identifies users suffering from depression and anxiety. And while it could be useful and positive (for example, they already can identify and target smokers with smoking cessation ads), I'm more afraid of malicious actors targeting people already prone to destructive behavior with feedback loops that worsen their symptoms and profit off it. For example: User 123 is experiencing a panic attack. Send notification that Uber Eats now delivers alcohol.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- treis 6y agoThis argument rests on an undeseriable business practice. Essentially we don't want insurance companies to discriminate on the health of potential buyers so let's stop Google from acquiring that data. But if that's what we want it makes more sense to ban the thing we don't want to happen. Namely, don't allow insurance companies to discriminate on the health of buyers.
- kodah 6y agoThere's also the good old argument that your argument has been used in respect to Google for decades and it has yeilded the exact sort of outcomes this paper is warning against.
- shadowgovt 6y agoCan you give an example?
- jjoonathan 6y agoHealth insurance only risk-pools as a side effect of its ignorance. In a high-information world, it risk-smooths but does not risk-pool. It's completely bonkers that we insist on doing it this way.
- uoaei 6y agoThere are plenty of cases where plausible deniability allows bad actors to continue to exploit loopholes. In this case, the health insurance industry could use statistical tricks to counter the allegation that they are discriminating at a significant level.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoJokes on them, Fitbit hurts me[1] and being disabled insurance companies already discriminate against me[2]. On a serious note, Doesn't insurance companies already partner with fitness monitors? They claim to provide incentives for good health by offering discounts in premium but then again it could also mean higher premium if any health issues are detected by these fitness monitors irrespective of its accuracy. [1]https://abishekmuthian.com/my-experience-with-fitbit-charge-hr-numbness-tingling-and-pain-fec85d41d165/ https://abishekmuthian.com/my-experience-with-fitbit-charge-... [2]https://abishekmuthian.com/insurers-are-putting-the-lives-of-sick-and-disabled-at-risk-during-covid-19-pandemic/ https://abishekmuthian.com/insurers-are-putting-the-lives-of...
- rmtech 6y agoI had tingling pain with a fitbit and I have solved it. Loosen it fully at night and the tingling stops.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoSorry, that's not it for me or many others who face the same issue. As I've mentioned in the blog, I've loosened it to the max with multiple fitbits and I always end up with pain; unless I switch off the heart rate monitor. When the heart rate monitor is switched off, there is no pain/tingling even if I wear it tight and this has been corroborated by many others in fitbit/apple watch forums. But since, most of these cases are due to wearing it tight (or the manufacturers want to project it that way) the heart rate monitor issue is not getting enough attention.
- rmtech 6y agothat is interesting. I also switch from left to right. Maybe that makes a difference? The other thing is that the two explanations are not mutually exclusive. Once you loosen it fully it moves around on your arm, which might move the harmful parts away from whatever is vulnerable. Do we know what exactly causes the tingling? My left hand is still numb almost a week after I was first injured.
- mortenjorck 6y ago> They're not claiming Google will hand out a user's biometrics to insurance companies or other parties. They're claiming Google will offer biometrically-based signal as an ad discrimination channel. This cuts to the heart of the common, disingenuous, privacy bromide of "we don't sell your personal information." Of course you don't – you sell sophisticated insights about me derived from it.
- shadowgovt 6y agoSophisticated, anonymized insights.
- sulam 6y agoGoogle has specifically said it _won't_ do this sort of thing (health data will not be made available for advertising, either within Google or [obviously] externally).
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoWhat i dont get is this: the purpose of insurance is to average out risks in life. The more insurance is 'tailored' and personalised, the more it defeats itself. If an insurer could see the future, he would give me a policy that costs (cost of my future accidents + X% profit)/(my lifetime) Essentially turning insurance into like bad savings account with negative interest rate.
- hiddencost 6y agoThat's not quite true. A pool has less variability than an individual. My expected cost of future accidents might be N, with variance M >> N. The insurance pool can absorb it if I have a catastrophic outcome, but I can't. So it may be worth buying an insurance contract with a negative expected value to hedge risks.
- jdmichal 6y ago> If an insurer could see the future, he would give me a policy that costs (cost of my future accidents + X% profit)/(my lifetime) But what happens when (cost of my future accidents) is very high? Are you as an individual just uninsurable? Is that the best outcome? Distribution of cumulative healthcare costs maybe looks something like a lognormal distribution. Most people fall into a "normal" range but then there are outliers who can cost far, far more. But even though their individual costs are high, their absolute numbers are low compared to the total pool. So everyone can pay something like a normal expected cost, plus a small fraction, plus the profit overhead, and thereby cover those outliers. Large employers will negotiate pooled coverage like this for their employees. That's why the 21-year-old with zero health issues pays the same as the 60-year-old with dialysis. But, it's the fact that this is essentially a monopoly market on those employees that allows this. They can create a single pool because there's no alternative market. (At least functionally, because the costs of those external market players don't get the employer subsidizing the plan.) Without that monopoly and subsidy, market forces come into play. For those people who have a high likelihood of lower costs, if an insurer can create a pool targeting people with those same signals, then they can offer that pool lower rates and capture business. However, that necessitates that the remaining pools become more expensive. This is a classic race to the bottom, but with the added complexity of a zero-sum game. Your stated position is the logical end-game of this direction. But it's not the only functional solution. One could also switch instead to a single pool over the entire population -- aka, single payer.
- adrianmonk 6y ago> argument they're making here is a little subtle, but it tracks. [ ... ] They're claiming Google will offer biometrically-based signal as an ad discrimination channel It's not impossible that that would happen, but it would be a departure from current behavior. To some degree, Google is selective about what data does and doesn't feed into ad targeting. Examples: (1) Emails are sensitive, and Gmail messages are off limits: "Google does not use keywords or messages in your inbox to show you ads. Nobody reads your email in order to show you ads." (https://safety.google/privacy/ads-and-data/ https://safety.google/privacy/ads-and-data/) (2) Drive/Docs/Sheets/Slides (if I'm interpreting this right): "We will not use your content for marketing or promotional campaigns." (https://www.google.com/drive/terms-of-service/ https://www.google.com/drive/terms-of-service/) And they've already stated they don't use health data: "We do not show ads based on sensitive information or interests, such as those based on race, religion, sexual orientation, health, or sensitive financial categories." (https://support.google.com/admanager/answer/140378 https://support.google.com/admanager/answer/140378) It is very reasonable to ask how your data might be used or misused. But the scenario here supposes that Google will change its general pattern of behavior and go against what it publicly said.
- foobarian 6y agoHah. I got a home screen notification to use Google's travel product minutes after I got a hotel booking confirmation email. I'm sure you can come up with reasons this is not breaking T&C but it would have never happened if the two products were in separate companies. And I'm sure they will "not use" the health data in a similar fashion.
- bryan_w 6y agoI mean if you have Google travel installed then it's a feature that it's integrated with gmail. Additionally I wouldn't find it weird for calendar or maps to make suggestions based on gmail. That is the value proposition by adopting the Google ecosystem.
- 013a 6y ago(For the benefit of the doubt, I'm choosing my wording very carefully here): I'm not convinced that Google works in this way, which could be a signal that their systems are so vast even they aren't aware of how users' data moves through it and gets used. Of course, you could just as easily conclude that they're lying, but I find that harder to believe. Everyone has some stories about how Google drew a suspicious correlation between products not supposed to be connected. In my case, there was one day where I wanted to watch an MP4 copy of Harry Potter I had on my NAS while on a work trip. Obtained ages ago. I uploaded it to my G-Suite Business Google Drive (not shared, nothing was pirated here despite ripping blurays still being a legal ish-zone). Later that day, YouTube started suggesting clips from Harry Potter to me. Suspicious. Not damning. Are they scanning my Google Drive for filenames to feed to the YouTube recommendation engine? I don't know. Maybe it was just chance, or maybe a few days ago I clicked on a random article about JK Rowling's latest drama and that was enough to trigger three layers of indirection through the Google Brain and suddenly I love Harry Potter (I don't. Its fine. I'm sure after writing this out, though, Google's opinion on My opinion of it will be reinforced.) But lets say I never watched those videos recommended to me. Is the YouTube recommendation engine data fed to their ad engine? What if I never click on something, but the system knows it presented it, and maybe I like Harry Potter anyway? I don't know. But it seems feasible, doesn't it? And if that's the case, then the data traveled two steps, where each step on its own is weird, but reasonably ok, but the two steps together look less ok. We're really talking about the absolute cutting edge here; Google is building a brain processing exabytes of data. If you're in engineering; have you ever worked in a job where you felt like you knew how every part of the system worked? I work at a company with 10 people and I still don't feel that. Why would Google be any different? Teams talk to other teams. A middle manager two jumps up approves it. They get access to a database. Data travels around. An engineering lead at the top thinks they have a grasp on everything, a grasp spuriously assembled from reports written by people who themselves understand some non-100 percent of whats going on in their silo. Things fall through the cracks, it happens all the time, and in this case we're talking about buses of data so big that no one could even look at it all to verify what's in there is what they think is in there (and if they did actually have humans look at it, that'd have concerns on its own). This is my pet theory: That the desires and realities of Google are so different that even what they say is untrustworthy because no one there knows whats actually going on anymore.