4 ms·
> If you offer web-hosting to a group of white nationalists, this is a political action. no it's not - you're just offering a service for a fee. As long as the
by chii 6y ago
> If you offer web-hosting to a group of white nationalists, this is a political action.
no it's not - you're just offering a service for a fee. As long as the service is not illegal, and you're not under-charging (which can be considered a political donation), then it's apolitical.
Deliberately choosing not to conduct business with a certain group because of their political ideology, on the other hand, _is_ a political action.
- sammex 6y agoI don't agree. Selling a gun to a hunter is not the same as selling a gun to a known child murderer. Both is "just" selling a gun but they are very different in practice.
- hexis 6y agoYes, but this distinction doesn’t require a corporate policy to implement. One transaction is legal and the other is not.
- ozorOzora 6y agoWould you like to mandate background checks for every potential customer?
- stevehawk 6y agoya, one would be illegal
- chii 6y agoDoes your view change if the gun was sold to a republican vs a democrat? Or a communist?
- diegoholiveira 6y agoYou can't take responsibility for what someone will do with your product. This is insane. If someone buy your car, how can you make sure he will not use for kidnap someone?
- eli 6y agoOf course you can. We just sell cigarettes it’s not our fault problem of people smoke them and get sick?
- austhrow743 6y agoAbsolutely that yes. Cigarette salesmen are performing a valuable service.
- diegoholiveira 6y agoPeople make dumb things like smoking. We already know that prohibition doesn't work. Putting warnings in the cigarets doesn't work either. So, the next thing would be the seller give a speech about how bad cigarets its for each sale?
- solidasparagus 6y agoIf you take a look at the history of smoking, it's very clear that education and taxes DO work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- manigandham 6y agoSociety is much better when we have individual freedom and responsibility, which includes the ability of people to make bad decisions.
- eli 6y agoAnd here “freedom” means you are forbidden from discussing certain topics at work?
- manigandham 6y ago
- zajio1am 6y agoIf seller offers guns to general public (e.g. gun shop) and child murderer does not have restriction on gun ownership as a part of their sentence, then not selling gun is not a political action, it is an extra-judicial punishment.
- cribbles 6y agoDeliberately choosing to not not conduct business with certain groups on the basis of their political ideologies is a political action. It implies a disposition toward trade and exchange that is itself political. Consider the fact that you cannot legally offer a service or a fee to terrorist groups (however that may be defined), money launderers, industries from countries under sanctions... the list goes on. These limitations are political in nature and could be revised, expanded, or eschewed via political action. But even if they were all eliminated, this would not constitute a "depoliticization" of trade: such an action could be characterized variously as libertarian, free-market, laissez-faire, or something of that nature but it would nevertheless be explicitly political.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]