3 ms·
Is this trip really necessary? It's a good read, but mostly states the obvious. One real question - which plane makers will survive? Unless air travel rises t
by Animats 6y ago
Is this trip really necessary?
It's a good read, but mostly states the obvious.
One real question - which plane makers will survive? Unless air travel rises to higher levels than before the epidemic, there are enough spare aircraft around for a few years of no new purchases. COMAC will be supplying the China market soon, along with their client states. Airbus is subsidized. Boeing might not make it.
- kalleboo 6y ago> there are enough spare aircraft around for a few years of no new purchases Unless airlines decide they need to downsize their aircraft and demand shifts to smaller/regional jets
- KiranRao0 6y agoGiven the precedence set by the auto makers, I don't see how the US government will allow Boeing to go bankrupt. Edit - spelling
- sumedh 6y agoDidnt GM go bankrupt? Existing shareholders are left holding the bag when new shares are issued.
- 88840-8855 6y agoI disagree. COMAC will do China. Airbus will do Europe Boeing will do USA + is super strong on its military branch Airbus + Boeing will share the rest of the world
- PuddleOfSausage 6y agoRegions like Africa may see some COMAC activity too.
- paganel 6y agoAs a European I don't see Airbus being allowed to fall, after all it's mostly a military company which has also been busy building commercial aircraft in times of peace. The same discussion goes for Boeing, at most the US Government will nationalise it for a time.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoYeah I think this is the answer - it depends on which ones get bailed out by the government. Same with airlines.
- baq 6y agothey also build spacecraft and launch systems, so yeah. https://www.airbus.com/space/launchers-deterrence/ariane-6.html https://www.airbus.com/space/launchers-deterrence/ariane-6.h...
- benhurmarcel 6y agoThe military activities of Airbus are much smaller than their civil revenues. You got it reversed. See their financial statements [1], defense and space is 15~20% of the revenue in normal years (and not all of it is military). On the other hand, Boeing does make a lot more revenue than Airbus on military contracts [2]. It seems to be around 34%, and double the amount at ~$26bn for Boeing vs ~$12bn for Airbus. [1] https://www.airbus.com/investors/financial-results-and-annual-reports.html https://www.airbus.com/investors/financial-results-and-annua... [2] https://investors.boeing.com/investors/financial-reports/default.aspx https://investors.boeing.com/investors/financial-reports/def...
- paganel 6y agoI don't think those revenue percentages are representative of the true character of both Airbus and Boeing, which I personally see as military companies first, and if they happen to also be dominant in the civilian industry (hence extending their owners' economic power without the use of actual weapons) then it's all for the best, otherwise it will do. I'd say that Airbus is even more military-complex-based than Boeing, as its CEO is selected by the French and German governments combined, private shareholders be damned. There's also yesterday's speech by French president Macron, saying that Europe needs "to end military dependence on US" [1]. There's no other company in Europe than can better achieve that goal other than Airbus (especially today, when air superiority is paramount in almost any conflict, see the present war between Armenia and Azerbaijan) [1] https://www.nationalreview.com/news/macron-calls-on-europe-to-end-military-dependence-on-u-s/ https://www.nationalreview.com/news/macron-calls-on-europe-t...
- kenneth 6y agoIt'll be a long time before China can produce planes domestically. COMAC doesn't even yet have a 737-class plane ready, nevermind anything more advanced.
- DocTomoe 6y agoActually, COMAC has the C919, which will have it's first delivery as soon as 2021.
- Animats 6y agoRight. There are problems with the C919, but making airliners is a national priority for China. It's one of the areas in the China 2025 Plan. So money will be spent until it succeeds. COMAC is still learning. Probably the airliner after this one will be good. It took Airbus 21 years to get a good airliner out the door.