6 ms·
The robots were too efficient. They could bring items so quickly that the productivity expectations for workers more than doubled Here's an old Kiva Robotics v
by Animats 6y ago
The robots were too efficient. They could bring items so quickly that the productivity expectations for workers more than doubled
Here's an old Kiva Robotics video that shows how picking works.[1] It's an utterly mindless job. An automated laser pointer points to the bin from which to take an object. A lighted button shows which box to put it in. A new bin then moves into position, and this goes on. Training time required is about 30 seconds. Amazon liked the system and bought Kiva. The company, not just the system.
So anyone with basic eye-hand coordination can do picking, computers check that it's done right, there's no future in the job, and Amazon is trying to automate the picking process anyway. Classic assembly-line job.
[1] https://youtu.be/CWNuaPE4DTc https://youtu.be/CWNuaPE4DTc
- Klinky 6y agoWell, until it's fully automated, human safety is still important. I think the problem we have is that destroying a human body with mindless repetitive tasks is often still "cheaper" than engineering an automated solutions. It is simply cheaper to feed off desperation than to value human lives, and there is the engrained notion that humanity cannot be productive without putting humans into positions of desperation. This is a mindset issue that needs to eventually change.
- Aperocky 6y agoWhen I was a graduate student, the lab next door was working on robotic arms and picking challenges, their PhD grad was then hired by... Amazon. I don't think it's cheaper, it's just that a solution has yet to exist. Once it start working, it will go out at breakneck pace.
- Klinky 6y agoI'd imagine hiring PhDs to work on hard problems is not cheap, and I doubt Amazon would invest unless they believed that the long-term investment would result in a cheaper outcome than what they have now. The problem is that human labor has been so cheap that automation is often not even worth any R&D effort for most companies. If human labor cost more, this would cause more impetus upstream to find automated solutions. Also the burger-flipping robot and self-driving car have been just around the corner for the last two decades. Although the end solution to those issues may very well be that we need to stop eating so many burgers and stop designing cities around cars, rather than robots coming in to allow even more consumption.
- gowld 6y agoFull automation is always out of reach, but McDonald's is extremely automated.
- Klinky 6y agoIs that automation or scale? Doing things on a large scale can be more efficient and require less labor, but McDonald's is still hiring people to do effectively the same thing in the stores as they did 50 years ago. A lot of industrial food tech is not new or cutting edge, and has limits, like you can't freeze dry a fully-made hamburger for later consumption.
- Animats 6y agoThat problem was solved over 50 years ago, but it wasn't cost effective.[1] [1] https://youtu.be/FmXLqImT1wE https://youtu.be/FmXLqImT1wE
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoDoes it matter? There are refrigerated burgers of all sorts available in the supermarkets, you only have to microwave or bake them after unpacking. I think I've even seen some where you leave them in the packaging during microwaving. Never tried them, so far. I really mean fully 'assembled' and prepared burgers, not only the patties. In a box like the ones from the golden M, just printed different.
- Klinky 6y agoIt does, because large scale lends itself to automation more easily, but even still, you have manual labor with unloading and loading, maintaining and reconfiguring the line, quality control, packaging, and delivery. A lot of these processes are not new, and have been around for decades. The McDonald's store doesn't have a machine make your hamburger, there is still significant manual labor involved, which hasn't really changed in decades. Even your frozen burger likely had significant manual labor investment in it at the factory it was produced. Also by "fully prepared", try adding fresh ingredients like lettuce, tomato, onion, freezing it and then microwaving it. I am sure it will be enjoyable to the palate. Even without the fresh ingredients, most will find the microwave burger inferior to even the cheapest McDonald's burger.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I don't think it's cheaper, it's just that a solution has yet to exist. Once it start working, it will go out at breakneck pace. I don't think this is a single problem. There are several dimensions to it, and you can trivialize some at the expense of others. Stop storing things compactly in bins and you can make it a lot easier to grab those things with a robotic arm. Give everything very robust packaging and you no longer have to worry about appropriate grip strength.
- hinkley 6y agoThere still seems to be a degree of 2.5 dimensional thinking with the current robotics systems. If you occupy the entire volume of a warehouse, then the volume occupied per object becomes less of an issue than when you have huge air columns between the roof and robots, workers, or shelves. You could move most of the manual handling to the ingest side; having truck workers load product into what amounts to a fancy Pez dispenser customized to each high volume product. The humans spend more time dealing with oddball items and trying to arrange the order to fit within the box, instead of grabbing things out of bins.
- Animats 6y agoYou could move most of the manual handling to the ingest side; having truck workers load product into what amounts to a fancy Pez dispenser customized to each high volume product. Now available in Germany.[1] Except the manual handling on the input side is done by robots. General bin-picking is still hard. But bin-picking of roughly rectangular objects in a moderate size range works pretty well. [1] https://youtu.be/B_a2YcstoN0 https://youtu.be/B_a2YcstoN0
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoI've thought of something like this, but for the stores/supermarkets themselves. Because why not? edit: Looking at how things are packaged and presented in the lower end like Lidl/Aldi, they are often standing on a pallet, either in full carton boxes, or just with carton around the top and bottom and the sides, stacked to maybe a meter, or 1.20m high. And the boxes are perforated in such ways that you can pull on some marked corner to open them easily.
- gowld 6y agoIt's only cheaper because of the externalities. If employers were required to pay for the damage the work does, it's be a different story.
- bsanr2 6y ago>It is simply cheaper to feed off desperation than to value human lives When the inherent costs are externalized, of course. The public pays the bills of these people who can't afford medical care or end-of-life expenses. My last job was a late-night warehouse position, where the hazard pay of 50¢/hr in no way covered the health consequences of a disturbed and atypical sleep schedule (driving heavy machinery, in my colleagues' case).
- newen 6y ago> The public pays the bills of these people who can't afford medical care or end-of-life expenses. Just privatize it! The human meat grinder will be perfected.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoYummie! Can't wait for my first soylent green...
- shalmanese 6y ago> I think the problem we have is that destroying a human body with mindless repetitive tasks is often still "cheaper" than engineering an automated solutions. But this is the majority of jobs that humans have right now globally. There's a reason why it's called "backbreaking labor", it literally breaks down your back. Everything from agriculture to mining to construction to manufacturing to logistics. The world is full of intrinsically unergonomic jobs that slowly grind human bodies down. It's just that we've decided that one set of these jobs we arbitrarily care about and the rest, we give a collective shrug to. Like, if you look at the image at the top of this article: https://www.pri.org/stories/2014-12-29/what-it-s-be-rice-farmer https://www.pri.org/stories/2014-12-29/what-it-s-be-rice-far... this is the reality for hundreds of millions of rice farmers across the globe right now and our collective response ranges somewhere between cringey romanticism of the task to a shrug of "whaddayagonnado?"
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThis is why I see capitalism eventually failing. On one hand, I think it's great that these mind-numbingly boring jobs can be automated away. On the other hand, the end result is that more profits go to Amazon, while many more people have fewer opportunities to participate in the economy. For the old predictable arguments of "Well, these people can do something else, do you expect buggy whip makers to still be around?" - at some point if the rate of automation is faster than people are able to retrain, and faster than the economy is able to create new opportunities for these people, the outcome is still the same: all the benefits of capitalism go to very few people while huge swaths of people are made "redundant".
- throwawaysea 6y agoIs that a failure of capitalism or of our education systems or simply an oversupply of humans?
- TeaDrunk 6y agoAn oversupply of humans?
- ci5er 6y agoWell, we do replicate. Maybe not as much as rabbits. And, recently, we die less in childbirth and infant-hood. So - even with falling childbirth rates, we still tend to multiply a bit. But given that absolute and relative global poverty rates and starvation rates and disease mortality rates have plummeted and population grows dramatically - it becomes a resource allocation problem. Germany (for example) needs more laborers because of plummeting domestic birth rates. The retired community's social net requires young tax-payers to pick up the burden. Demographics are screwing with this math. Somalia or Syria (for example) have a lot of folks that need to escape. Problem: Once Turks or Arabs or Persians or Somalians or Syrians or Northern Africans get to Germany - they may or may not want to learn the language - but as refugees, they get full public benefit. And are not willing to learn or work to support retired Germans (this is an isolated example). Maybe we have an exploding population in all the wrong places? (I am not recommending genocide - just: It is a wicked problem)
- qppo 6y ago> It's an utterly mindless job I worked as a picker/packer one summer. This is an understatement, even before the robots did the walking for you. It's interesting that the only thing left is to make a robot that can handle the objects to be placed, currently they cost more than minimum wage human labor unless the thing being picked is designed to be handled by a machine. Ultimately that's what I think will happen, the packaging will be designed for picking by machine and the job can be fully automated.
- 8note 6y agoThat's essentially what's happened with shipping containers
- gowld 6y agoJeff Bezos has a speech he gives, a about how shipping containers are interfaces and Amazon's primary value proposition is to metaphorically apply the shipping container "interface" concept to the retail industry.
- amelius 6y agoThe question is whether the solution will be heavily patented, or that it will be a generic machine-learning application (like classifying images). So either Amazon will own it, or we all own it and distribution centers can become like public utilities.
- Animats 6y agoAlibaba already has warehouses using robots that work just like the Kiva robots.[1] [1] https://youtu.be/FBl4Y55V2Z4 https://youtu.be/FBl4Y55V2Z4
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 6y agoAmazon is getting big enough that it's only a matter of time before they start trying to dictate packaging on products, to make it easier for robots to pick them up. Walmart has been flirting in the same space to automate inventory management.
- programd 6y agoTHe Kiva video is not state-of-the-art I think. Check out this automated grocery warehouse, something right out of Factorio: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4DKrcpa8Z_E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4DKrcpa8Z_E Humans would just get in the way and get mangled.
- tpmx 6y agoThat's a rendered video of the Ocado warehouse system, which I think is a ripoff of the Swisslog Autostore system. There was a lawsuit. Then Ocado hired Swisslog... Btw: This Autostore system is becoming the standard automated warehouse system for Swedish e-retailers, as they prepare for Amazon entering the Swedish market in a month or two. I think there are at least like 10 very large Autostore installations in Sweden for various niche online e-retailers. And like 20 "large" installations.
- Animats 6y agoI'm amazed that Swisslog system works reliably. All that precision track and rack. All those moving parts. There have been big automated storage and retrieval systems for decades, but they're often a maintenance headache. The Kiva system just needs is a flat floor. The robots are mechanically simple and totally interchangeable. On-site maintenance is limited to replacing batteries and wheels; for anything else it goes back to a repair center.
- tpmx 6y agoI think the major design philosophy differences between the two systems are: - Kiva robots are designed to work along with cheap labor - Swisslog Autostore is designed to minimise labor, because labor is expensive in Europe (it does more of the work). Here's a four year old video of an Autostore at komplett.no/komplett.se: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZWK5xL_o3f4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZWK5xL_o3f4
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoAmazing. Now imagine that combined with something like [1] http://www.cargocap.com/ http://www.cargocap.com/ or [2] https://www.smartcityloop.de/ https://www.smartcityloop.de/ or [3] https://www.cst.ch/en/ https://www.cst.ch/en/ maybe even extended right into your condo via elevator! edit: Surprise, Surprise! [4] https://www.four-parx.com/en/four-parx-smart-city-loop-for-underground-city-logistics-hamburg/ https://www.four-parx.com/en/four-parx-smart-city-loop-for-u... in my hometown! Yay!