3 ms·
This supports the point. Incandescents were banned, and CFLs were heavily promoted and subsidized to replace them. Meanwhile, along came a superior technology
by samatman 6y ago
This supports the point.
Incandescents were banned, and CFLs were heavily promoted and subsidized to replace them.
Meanwhile, along came a superior technology, ten times as energy efficient, longer lasting, and with a broader range of light which is at least as good.
So all that heavy-handed regulation produced, was an era of inferior light, a mercury disposal problem, and the inability to acquire incandescents for applications such as heating, which they're excellent for. Sometimes a lot of heat and a bit of light is what you want, and most of those devices have an Edison socket.
To head off one objection: any technically competent person could have taken a look at the trajectory of LED technology and said "hold on, CFLs suck, how about we just hang back and wait five to ten years?". LED bulbs were hardly a black swan.
- CamperBob2 6y agoActually, good-quality LED replacement bulbs were around for several years prior to the ban. They just cost an arm and a leg. The ban didn't force the technology to magically appear -- something that hardly ever happens due to legislation alone -- but it did drive competition and force an economy of scale that would otherwise have been much slower to develop.
- samatman 6y agoSo the subsidy backed the wrong horse, and the ban eliminated a useful technology, but it also accidentally supported buildout of LED bulbs, which we could have just accomplished by subsidizing LED tech and not banning incandescents? Yeah, that seems about par for the course for this kind of regulation. Sometimes a blind cat catches a dead mouse.
- CamperBob2 6y agoNote that the ban didn't prescribe CFLs, it only proscribed incandescents. Yes, it was arguably premature, but it's going to be very hard to convince me that it was the wrong thing to do in retrospect. It didn't eliminate any technologies, either. I can still buy incandescents if I insist... but why would I?
- jandrese 6y agoThere are still a few places where I use incandescent bulbs. Inside of my oven for example. But I'm totally fine with them being relegated to specialist niches.
- marcosdumay 6y ago> I can still buy incandescents if I insist... but why would I? My father had a really hard time getting them for an egg incubator a while ago. A problem that was solved by replacing the incubator (more trash).
- samatman 6y agoYep, I've heard that story a few times, and haven't heard the contrasting "I needed a 125 watt incandescent for the EZ Bake oven I bought at a garage sale for my daughter, and purchased it, no problem" story, ever. But that's just anecdote. This being HN, I look forward to the reply which will shortly set me straight on the subject.
- marcosdumay 6y agoExactly how many anecdotes do you need? Notice that the anecdotes all point the same way, there's no opposite story to average. Differently from taxes and subsides, prohibiting products is a really impactful action for a government to make, it's not something to be done lightly. And we have had a fashion of really frivolous environment legislation lately doing exactly that kind of thing.
- shadowgovt 6y agoHow's the efficiency on the new incubator?
- marcosdumay 6y agoOh, it's better than the old one on nearly every way, but the energy consumption is about the same (both are electric heaters, just in different formats) and it's harder to see if it turned on.
- Gibbon1 6y agoIncandescent is a bad technology compared to fluorescent lamps with rare earth phosphors. Seriously come on, a 100 W Incandescent uses $25 worth of electricity over it's life. Where a fluorescent to LED unit uses $3 over 2000 hours. And lasts 5-10 times longer.
- tuatoru 6y ago> ten times as energy efficient As CFLs? Nowhere near. Early LED bulbs had a horrible color rendering index, too. They made things look weird. Cheap LED bulbs have the same reliability problem as cheap CFLs, too. They both skimp on the heat dissipation. The life of semiconductiors (in the control circuitry, for CFLs) halves with each ten degree Celsius rise in temperature. Cheap bulbs use cheap, low-spec components close to the edge of their ratings and treat them badly. Irrespective of the base light-producing technology. The mercury-in-CFLs problem is as overhyped as the asbestos problem (there are hundreds of thousands of miles of asbestos water pipes carrying drinking water) and the idea that plastics are bad for the environment. (In most cases, they're far better than equivalently priced alternatives.) Finally, I had CFLs in my house for over ten years before LED substitutes became available. Now that LEDs are cheap enough and good enough, I'm using them. But from the late '90s to about 2012, CFLs were it.