9 ms·
I Lived Through Collapse. America Is Already There
- UncleEntity 6y ago> In the last three months America has lost more people than Sri Lanka lost in 30 years of civil war. Umm...what?
- anonymouswacker 6y agoCan't take this article seriously after that ridiculous comparison. There haven't been many more deaths, year-over-year, than any other year in America with a deadly flu season. Perhaps it is collapsing, as the disease care, food, and pharmaceutical industries continue to kill people before their time, but not like a Civil War.
- uniqueid 6y ago“A U.N. panel probed the last phase of the war [and] has estimated that around 40,000 died while other independent reports estimated the number of civilians dead to exceed 100,000.” If it's 40,000+, the author can only be referring to Covid-19 deaths. I agree he should have dedicated more space there to convince the reader.
- spfzero 6y agoOr, at least put it into a per-capita number. Normal flu season in the US is 40K+. Heart disease is. Cancer is. Auto accidents. Opiate overdose deaths. The population of the us is 18 X that of Sri Lanka, so all sorts of unfortunate, but non-collapse-level processes, hit numbers like 40K.
- EdwardDiego 6y agoWhich is why "excess deaths" is a good metric to look at - heart disease, overdoses, cancer, and car crashes are all normal, routine causes of death. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm
- Schiendelman 6y agoAre they routine? If we built our infrastructure like Japan we wouldn’t have those car crashes. If we had healthcare for all we wouldn’t have those opioid deaths, or that heart disease. A lot of these would be a lot lower.
- icedchai 6y agoDeaths are only the most unfortunate part of it. Do you think life is going back to normal any time soon? I don't. What happens when this goes on for another couple years and people finally realize 2019 was probably the last "normal" year they'll experience for quite a while? Nothing good.
- Barrin92 6y agoyes and that, to prove the authors point, is also collapse. The opioid epidemic, the car deaths, the obesity, the cancer, and the heart disease they're avoidable, they're the result of desolation at a societal scale, they're cultural illnesses, which the public responds to with indifference and numbness and another drive through at McDonalds. Hundreds of thousands maybe more preventable deaths, every year, written off as "per capita" statistics, as if we're talking about a bad quarter at the office, and not human lifes. Every year maybe .5% more. That's what the author means when he's saying that you're already collapsing without even realising it.
- horns4lyfe 6y agoThe author says "collapse", but all they discuss is civil war. People dying from a pandemic that is effecting the entire globe is not remotely close the the circumstances of the Sri Lankan civil war. Deaths from violent acts are still very low.
- tonyarkles 6y agoIt is affecting the entire globe, yes, but unevenly. Canada and the US are similar countries, but the US is at 624 deaths/million and Canada is at 251 deaths/million. The countries doing worse than the US are countries generally considered to be on the “not very wealthy” end of the scale (except the UK...). For being probably the most wealthy nation in the world, something is going terribly wrong. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1104709/coronavirus-deaths-worldwide-per-million-inhabitants/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1104709/coronavirus-deat...
- haidut 6y ago>which the public responds to with indifference and numbness and another drive through at McDonalds. Look through the responses in this thread. At least 2-3 other people described that their approach to the impending collapse is...to ignore it...and to also make sure they enjoy the nice September weather and to ruminate on their impending richness from cashing in on stock options. I sincerely hope these comments were /s or a joke. If not...well, then maybe this is why we are in this situation now - a good portion of the public is severely lobotomized to care about anything else but frozen pizza.
- matthewdgreen 6y ago>Or, at least put it into a per-capita number Ok. For comparison, Sri Lanka has had 13 total COVID deaths (0.599/1M). The US has had ~206,000 deaths (627.67/1M). Alternatively: assuming Sri Lanka's death rate was applied to the US population, we would have 197 total deaths.
- dogweather 6y ago> per-capita Sad that every comment explaining how numbers work is strongly downvoted. Per-capita is the only way comparisons are made by the intellectually honest. And that's without even getting into the author's false equivalence of homicide (rebel fighting) and illness (Covid).
- EdwardDiego 6y agoCovid-19, presumably.
- techbio 6y agoSo collapse is...life goes on.
- kevin_b_er 6y agoIf you read the article, life went on for the rich. Others just suffered.
- tuatoru 6y agoYeah. Until it doesn't. One day the bridge you used every day is closed for repair, and after a few years you realize it isn't going to get fixed. Protection rackets appear, because the police can't get in to maintain order any more. Working around them takes a lot of thought and social connection, but life goes on. At some point, the water stops coming through the taps. Getting water is a hassle, but life goes on. Phones stopped working a while back too, you realize. So did the street lights. Potholes in the roads stay there and get bigger and bigger. But you can still use the road. Until one day you can't. A few years later you look around and say, "hey, where is everybody?"
- kspacewalk2 6y agoYou are describing my childhood in the mid-90s Ukraine. Difference is, I never knew any different because I was 6 when the USSR collapsed, and by then even its version of "normal life" has been slowly decaying for a while. This decay accelerated in the 90s, but it was all normal to me. Hyperinflation, no hot water or heating for weeks, no electricity for 2-3 hours every evening (better not be stuck in an elevator at 6 pm when the blackout is scheduled to start!) Every piece of physical infrastructure slowly decays and doesn't get replaced. It was so strange to go from that to Canada at 12 years old.
- legerdemain 6y agoSeriously, the best advice I've received as a Palantir employee is "stop reading the news." Suddenly all this stuff about the election, the Supreme Court, targeted drone strikes, reproductive rights, police brutality happening to people other than me, rampant disease, and riots in the streets goes away. All that's left is me enjoying a sunny September afternoon in cozy, charming Palo Alto, counting down the hours until my company IPOs!
- icedchai 6y agoNice. So how much will you be worth tomorrow?
- legerdemain 6y agoIf the price on the private market is anything to go by, $6 times several tens of thousands of stock units, minus the astronomical cost to exercise, minus confusing Trump taxes. Oops, I just said the T-word! Better stop thinking about the news again! Ha ha!
- icedchai 6y agoCongrats! You've won the options lottery. I'm going to watch the stock and maybe pick up a few shares later in the week.
- legerdemain 6y agoI mean, what's your reason for optimism? The private market price has been $1-$2 below the option strike price for a few years now. Most employees who received options as part of their comp for the last five years or so would have been underwater if they exercised them. The company even started compensating in RSUs, despite many years of opposition to them.
- icedchai 6y agoWell, I said "maybe." I have to watch it. I am not entirely optimistic, but am a bit of a gambler. The last direct listing I bought (Slack aka WORK) went badly.
- somewhereoutth 6y agoThe first thing I noticed when I moved to Portugal, after spending a few years in the US, was that nobody was afraid.
- theonemind 6y agoThe US hasn't collapsed. If it collapsed, something could rise from the ashes. The US has developed major weaknesses like fault lines, to to speak, and a collapse event, like an earthquake, has an elevated probability of happening, a prediction horizon, but the event still has to happen. The US has major weaknesses like high health care cost, aged infrastructure, no social safety nets to speak of, radically unequal wealth distribution, and erosion of democracy from lobbying and cash in politics, BUT it has not collapsed. However, all of these things raise the probability of collapse dramatically. Of course, it has changed from its height, a lot of it for the worse, but a change isn't a collapse. A collapse is a collapse.
- dogweather 6y ago> In the last three months America has lost more people than Sri Lanka lost in 30 years of civil war. If this isn’t collapse, then the word has no meaning. This is pretty weak reasoning, and the article's good points are unfortunately diluted by it. * Raw deaths mean nothing: How many people has America lost -per capita- compared to Sri Lanka? * The immediate, unexpected and shocking loss of a loved one from a bomb is vastly different from the typical Covid experience in the US. Outside of NYC, it is, typically, a nursing home illness. * Direct homicide from a rebel military cannot be compared to succumbing to a novel and little-understood virus.