2 ms·
Yes. In what you just said: Some = everyone who hasn’t already made it to the a higher tier. This removes the incentive for anyone to work out how to defeat
by zepto 6y ago
Yes.
In what you just said:
Some = everyone who hasn’t already made it to the a higher tier.
This removes the incentive for anyone to work out how to defeat an incumbent who is using the strategy, since they are forced to stop using it by law and not because a better alternative has emerged.
Indeed you might even expect it to become more virulent.
Imagine if Apple knew in advance that at some particular arbitrary revenue level, they would no longer be allowed to operate a store.
That would create an even stronger incentive to lock in their advantages through other means.
It might well have tilted the playing field in a direction where Apple chose to adopt Facebook style addiction dynamics as a strategy or risk being outcompeted by someone who did.
The way out of the Apple walled garden is for someone to build an alternative that is better.
There are many promising ways to do this.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> This removes the incentive for anyone to work out how to defeat an incumbent who is using the strategy, since they are forced to stop using it by law and not because a better alternative has emerged. If my goal is to win through innovation, I would rather fight against multiple smaller non-innovating incumbents than one big one that can crush me with money. > That would create an even stronger incentive to lock in their advantages through other means. > It might well have tilted the playing field in a direction where Apple chose to adopt Facebook style addiction dynamics as a strategy or risk being outcompeted by someone who did. > The way out of the Apple walled garden is for someone to build an alternative that is better. Or they make an alternative that's Facebook style addictive... It seems to me like one consequence of your argument is that encouraging innovation is dangerous because Apple might innovate in a bad way. That makes most of this irrelevant to deciding whether market caps are good or bad. You came up with a scenario where caps lead to something bad, but the same kind of scenario could apply to a world without them. And remember that if someone actually does start taking market share from Apple under the current laws, they still have the option to do the bad things you listed, and they'll be just as effective.
- zepto 6y agoIt seems to me like one consequence of your argument is that “encouraging innovation” is dangerous because Apple might innovate in a bad way. Is this meant to be a good faith steel-man of my argument?
- Dylan16807 6y agoYes. You're trying to encourage a lot of innovation, but your bad alternative scenario seems to be innovation gone wrong. I'm not sure how I could remove either part of that while keeping the spirit of your argument.