23 ms·
Epic’s decision to bypass Apple’s App Store policies was dishonest, says judge
- HenryBemis 6y agoThe judge is right in many many things.. but this one caught my eye > Microsoft has had a walled garden. No it doesn't. I have never purchased anything from Microsoft. 90% of the software I have purchased is straight to the vendors (e.g. InternetDownloadManager, ACDSee, etc.). The remaining 10%, even when it comes to Microsoft products (OS, Office), I purchased them back-in-the-day from stores, and I got the CDs/DVDs. Same with computer games. AoE, Diablo I-II-III and expansions, and many more. I know that M$ tried to pull everyone through their (imho) crappy Store, but still, I can get everything I want/need outside their marketplace and straight from the Devs, bypassing their store. Unless the Judge strictly means the mobile app store, in which case, I exited WM6 a 10+ years ago and have no knowledge of this.
- readams 6y agoXBox is the walled garden, not Windows.
- ericmay 6y agoNot to mention, the Epic store itself is a walled garden!
- mantap 6y agoThe epic store is not a walled garden. If you use Windows you have many choices of App Store, including just downloading from your web browser, and hell if you don't like what's on Windows you can install Linux. If you buy an iPhone you are forced to use the App Store and pay Apple 30% of every digital product you buy on it. It's intensely consumer hostile.
- ericmay 6y agoI'm a consumer, I find it to be liberating. But yea the Epic Store is a walled garden. They don't let me publish whatever I want.
- sem000 6y agoThe actual Epic store is a walled garden. You’re intermingling two separate things. Epic won’t let you out a game in their store without taking a cut.
- gruez 6y agoBy that logic is your local supermarket a walled garden? They won't let you sell stuff without taking a cut.
- sem000 6y ago... Not sure what point you’re making here. I guess so? They invested and developed their customer base, they deserve a cut of what my products I want them to sell like they take from every product they sell? This is how the supply chain has worked since the beginning of time.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> is your local supermarket a walled garden? Yes? Of course? That’s the whole point of a supermarket. To curate and distribute in exchange for a cut.
- jasonlotito 6y agoYou don't know what a walled garden is. A walled garden, or closed platform, is a platform that prevents you from going outside the ecosystem, or platform, in order to use it's features. To continue the supermarket comparison, it would be like a system where you buy pots and pans and a stove and what not from Whole Foods, but you can only use food you purchased from Whole Foods, and anyone wanting to sell you food would have to sell it through Whole Foods.
- samfisher83 6y agoYou could install whatever you wanted on wm6
- 542458 6y agoDue to the preceding Nintendo and Sony I had assumed she was talking about XBox there.
- falcolas 6y agoWhether you’ve used it or not, there is a Windows store. There was also a Windows phone store, and there is currently an Xbox store. The second two examples were and are walled gardens.
- Barrin92 6y agothen the judge should have been more precise because this is a night and day difference. If Windows, the operating system itself, would function as a walled garden, that is to say every developer for windows would have to shell over 30% of their revenue, we'd have started a revolution two decades ago. Apple's app store isn't comparable to the XBox store (revenue on the apple store was 50 billion last year, compared to three on the xbox), it's comparable in reach to the Windows ecosystem overall.
- swiley 6y agoThis is the way it's going to go if developers keep saying it's about the IAP premium and not the fact that apple is literally selling access to people's phones in bulk.
- ericmay 6y agoInteresting to see the judge bring up the same points that so many have here on HN, myself included. I've read a few articles about this topic, not just this one, but some good points I saw from another article [1]: > Judge Rogers questioned Epic on when, exactly Apple became a monopoly given that its App Store rules have remained unchanged since the App Store launched, which Epic had no solid answer for, responding only that it was a monopoly when Fortnite came to iOS in 2018. She also said that walled gardens have existed for four decades and that what Apple's doing isn't too different. "They created a platform," she said > She also reiterated that Epic Games made a "calculated decision" to defy Apple's App Store rules, and the court doesn't provide injunctions for contractual disputes. Epic was "not forthright," she said. "There are people in the public who consider you guys heroes for what you did, but it's not honest. > Epic Games continued to argue that Apple has an App Store monopoly and charges excessive fees, but the judge pointed out that the 30 percent rate that Apple collects is the "industry rate" collected by PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo, Amazon, Walmart, Best Buy, Google, and more. "It's all 30 percent and you just want to gloss over it," the judge said to Epic's lawyers. I don't remember where I read this but someone mentioned that the judge asked Apple why they charge 30%, which I found to be a bit of a strange thing to ask (and probably a bit of a softball). Why not 30%? Why not 40%? Why do companies have margins that they set that the market will bear at all? Etc. [1] https://www.macrumors.com/2020/09/28/epic-games-apple-dispute-possible-jury-trial/ https://www.macrumors.com/2020/09/28/epic-games-apple-disput...
- actuator 6y ago> > Epic Games continued to argue that Apple has an App Store monopoly and charges excessive fees, but the judge pointed out that the 30 percent rate that Apple collects is the "industry rate" collected by PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo, Amazon, Walmart, Best Buy, Google, and more. "It's all 30 percent and you just want to gloss over it," the judge said to Epic's lawyers. She also glossed over the fact that software can be distributed free with its own payment systems in laptop/desktop OSs like Windows, OS X, Ubuntu etc. When I paid for Sublime I didn't go into an App Store to pay for it. Smartphone/tablet OSs are logical successors to the laptop/desktop OSs we have not game consoles. They are general purpose computing platforms.
- logicOnly 6y agoApple gets to write the terms of service and you must do whatever is said. It's inherently anti-developer. Duh Epic broke the contract. I'm not sure what people are expecting the legal system will do in favor of Epic. At best Apple will be found to use Unethical cornering the market strategies, but that's unrelated to the TOS.
- baconandeggs 6y agoYou get to accept it, or not. That is 100% on you.
- luckylion 6y ago> “You did something, you lied about it by omission, by not being forthcoming. That’s the security issue. That’s the security issue!” Rogers told Epic Why does that sound like it's a reality tv show?
- appleflaxen 6y agoThat's what stood out to me, too: how is "not being forthcoming" a security issue? I don't have confidence that the judge understands the technical parts of the case. They might not matter, depending on the legal issues in play, but if they matter, this quote seems a bit clueless.
- drfuchs 6y agoThe lie-by-omission is leaving out the security aspect of having a walled garden. It’s not well expressed if you read this as an essay, but it is natural for on-the-fly spoken language.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoApple's argument is that they provide a guarantee to iPhone that all the apps in the App Store are safe and secure. They can't make that guarantee if developers add secret features the reviewers don't know about.
- eps 6y agoYet the developers can clearly add secret features and sneak them past the review as it's been trivially demonstrated by Epic.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoHow do you know it was a trivial demonstration? As far as I've seen the details of how Epic did it aren't known.
- 6y ago
- DeusExMachina 6y ago> “Walled gardens have existed for decades,” said the judge. “Nintendo has had a walled garden. Sony has had a walled garden. Microsoft has had a walled garden. What Apple’s doing is not much different... Shouldn't a judge look at what is allowed by the law, instead of being the devil's advocate and say "those guys have done it for years, so it's fine"? Something might be a long standing practice and still be against the law. Something might have not been against the law in the past and be against it now. I'm not saying that it is, but that's what the judge should base his argument on.
- nmfisher 6y ago> Shouldn't a judge look at what is allowed by the law, instead of being the devil's advocate and say "those guys have done it for years, so it's fine"? I haven't been able to find the actual details yet, but from what I can gather, this is not the actual hearing. Right now, the judge's job isn't to determine whether Apple's terms were illegal, or whether Epic breached those terms with Apple. The judge is deciding whether or not Apple should be injuncted from booting Fortnite from the App Store, and whether or not the matter should proceed to trial. It's less about black-letter law, and more about judicial discretion (albeit exercised very conservatively). So this type of looser language is to be expected.
- dlgeek 6y agoJSYK: "injuncted" -> "enjoined"
- nmfisher 6y ago'injuncted' is the preferred term in Australia. Source: http://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/sinosrch.cgi?method=auto&query=injuncted http://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/sinosrch.cgi?method=auto&q... I assume "enjoined" is preferred in the USA (and in all fairness, I guess it would be better to use the American term for an American case).
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Something might be a long standing practice and still be against the law The first step to finding legal precedent is exploring practical precedent. This being an injunction hearing, part of the judge’s job is determining whether Epic is likely to prevail in its argument. The fact that it seeks to challenge practical precedent makes the outcome less predictable and an injunction less reasonable.
- dxuh 6y ago> She also said that walled gardens have existed for four decades and that what Apple's doing isn't too different. In relation to this lawsuit it's mostly the same, but in general it's way different. The iOS is not a gaming platform. While gaming consoles are purely for entertainment and mostly optional in almost everyone's life, phones are not. The iOS walled garden is a lot more like a Windows or Mac walled garden would be, if it existed, which would be horrible. Phones are somehow not accepted as a general purpose personal computing platform, while they clearly are. I don't think Epic Games could reasonably sell that argument in their position, but it doesn't mean they are wrong.
- dariusj18 6y agoTBF, Apple is trying to make Mac a walled garden.
- richrichardsson 6y agoTrying? It virtually is already. Want to put out some software and not pay the $99/year Developer Fee and still have a simple install process for your users? Good luck with that.
- thelastdev 6y agoInstall Brew Brew install whatever you need. Apple is doing a decent job here. Art Student gets a very easy to use computer with a safe app store. Comp Science student can compile and install whatever they need.
- jpttsn 6y agoThey even ship brew now, don’t they?
- richrichardsson 6y ago> simple install process for your users Those are the pertinent words. Yes, folks like us have no issue going to Terminal.app and `brew install whatever`, but most "regular" users are going to baulk at that idea.
- Shared404 6y ago> “Walled gardens have existed for decades,” said the judge. “Nintendo has had a walled garden. Sony has had a walled garden. Microsoft has had a walled garden. What Apple’s doing is not much different... So is this case is going to determine if phones are general purpose computers or game consoles? Many people use a phone instead of a computer, often it's an individual/families only internet access. I don't think there are any examples of general purpose computers acting as walled gardens. Edit: Change first sentence to question.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> if phones are general purpose computers or game consoles There is zero law that makes this distinction.
- Shared404 6y agoTrue. I wonder if there needs to be. It worries me that game consoles, an appliance used for playing games, could be used to set a precedent for general purpose computing that could quite possibly lead in a direction non/very few of us want to go.
- falcolas 6y agoGaming consoles are no longer just gaming consoles. They’re also web browsers (albeit inferior ones) and media consumption machines (music and movies). One could even argue that they’re media creation machines, with the presence of RPG Maker (and a few other pieces of software I can’t recall the names of at the moment).
- Shared404 6y agoInteresting point. That being said, the only uses I've seen consoles used for are gaming and media consumption. I know there's web browsers on there, but I don't think I've ever actually seen one used. As for media creation, I don't know. There's certainly an argument to be made for it, but I don't know where playing a game stops and making a game begins.
- FullMetalBitch 6y agoPersonally I don't think it's fair to compare Apple to any of the names (Playstation, Xbox, Nintendo, Amazon, Walmart or Best Buy) since a videogame from Sony, Nintendo or Microsoft can be sold on Amazon, Walmart or any other store. And you can open your own store (F-Droid for example) in Android.
- bognition 6y agoWhy isn't it a fair comparison? Just because the big video game companies have multiple channels of sales it doesn't mean they don't collect their cut for each sale. It's very much the same thing just slightly obfuscated. Access to the platform is still restricted and those who want release content have to pay.
- ece 6y agoI think the relevant market here is phones. Anything that can substitute for a phone and reduce sales of phones. Within this market, devices have long been able to run whatever apps were compiled using relevant free SDKs and downloaded from any website. iPhone/iOS was the first phone to not allow side loading.
- jpttsn 6y agoOn the Nokia 3310? Or a rotary phone? What is a “phone”?
- guru4consulting 6y agoThere is a huge difference between having access to a single channel and 2+ channels. It promotes competition among the channels. What if Apple takes 30% of your phone bills, because it just can. What if Apple and Microsoft starts restricting the applications that you install in their OS and then start charging 30% of all programs that you install in their OS?
- rmrfrmrf 6y agoSo what you're saying is you want EA to be able to have its own store on iPhone where Apple collects 30% on the backend anyway? Because that's what Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft do now. I don't see "I should be able to purchase iPhone apps at Target" as a compelling argument, much less relevant to the case at hand.
- belltaco 6y agoSo I guess there will be no outcry when Microsoft starts charging the alleged "industry rate" to allow programs to run on Windows.
- sem000 6y agoApple has been charging since they allowed third party access to App Store. Quite different in this case. Epic and consumers know what they’re getting into with Apple.
- codegladiator 6y agoAnd now everyone should know what they are getting into with any of these stores that 30% is normal. Fight back is futile. Just makes microsoft look like stupid business guys not charging 30% yet.
- krzyk 6y agoFirst, they don't charge everyone 30% (have you seen the emails between Amazon and Apple?). Second, why break up AT&T in 70s/80s, you know what you are getting into when you sing up a contract with them.
- scarface74 6y agoThe difference was that AT&T had a monopoly because of the government. They had a real monopoly. They were the only game in town.
- krzyk 6y agoReally? Didn't US have a mail service at that time? I think that is an alternative "platform" for communication (just like Android to Apple), a bit of a stretch but not much.
- sem000 6y agoAre you really comparing using a phone vs mail, to using iOS vs Android, or any other phone out on the market?
- _qulr 6y agoScale and market power are what makes a monopolist, by definition. It doesn't matter if the terms have changed; what has changed since 2008 is the scale and power of Apple. Incidentally, the 30% came from the iTunes Music Store, on which the App Store was based 100%. The most popular game consoles have 2-3 thousands games total. They are truly "curated". The Apple App Store and Google Play store each have 2-3 million apps each. They're orders of magnitude larger than game consoles. This is the crucial difference in platforms.
- flohofwoe 6y agoApparently the 30% cut has it's origins in a deal between Nintendo and Hudsonsoft. 10% licensing fee, and 20% manufacturing costs for physical cartridges. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/the-30percent-fee-epic-is-fighting-apple-over-began-with-nintendo/ar-BB18lkPz https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/the-30percent-fee-...
- sova 6y agoIf Steam, Apple, Google, any of them made a physical cartridge of a developer's games for them, that would seem a lot more reasonable a fee.
- wil421 6y agoWhat about what the virtual platform Apple provides? The cartridge is the feature rich phone and virtual services Apple provides to get to the device.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoFor which a customer spends hundreds of dollars, comparable to purchasing a game console that took cartridges. Apple doesn't provide that, buyers provide that. Apple is trying use their leverage to dominate every angle of the action. Surprise, surprise, surpriiiiise.
- 6y ago
- einpoklum 6y agoThe intricacies of how Capitalism devolves into struggle over rent.
- yupyup54133 6y agoI mean, at the end of the day the one thing that Epic has convinced me of with all of this is that my next phone will not be an iPhone even though I am very happy with my current iPhone6s.
- shadowgovt 6y agoFor a lot of Apple users, the relative predictability that comes from the exclusive licensing on the App Store is a value-add. There are, obviously, exceptions, but Apple's agreements arm them with ample tools to address the exceptions when they're discovered, since they're basically the emperor of their fiefdom.
- mrtksn 6y agoI don't follow the reasoning here. Why would you march behind another company if you are happy with the one that you get your services from? I would understand if Apple had a dominant market share like Google with no real alternatives or if was close to become like Google. If that was the case, I would be very sceptical but obviously that's not the case.
- yupyup54133 6y agoHey, I don't have to be logical here. I am just saying that Apples actions here are what have made me emotionally decide to not buy an iPhone as my next phone.
- parasubvert 6y agoI’ve tried that, and throwing my Android across the room out of frustration emotionally led me back to iPhone ;)
- yupyup54133 6y agoWhy all the down-votes?
- monadic2 6y agoChrist even judges believe in "platforms" now.
- pmontra 6y agoPartially off topic but I like this feature of American law of asking people (and not judges) to decide the outcome of this kind of trials: > Judge Gonzalez Rogers did recommend, though, that the case be taken to a jury trial in July next year to settle these issues permanently. “It is important enough to understand what real people think,” said Rogers. “Do these security issues concern people or not?”
- bart_spoon 6y agoNot particularly impressed by this judge. Her biggest arguments boil down to every 6 year olds favorite "Well other people do it too!". That doesn't justify the practice so much as illustrate how pervasive the practice has been allowed to become. > She also reiterated that Epic Games made a "calculated decision" to defy Apple's App Store rules, and the court doesn't provide injunctions for contractual disputes. Epic was "not forthright," she said. "There are people in the public who consider you guys heroes for what you did, but it's not honest. I also fail to see how that is relevant. She comes off as overly interested in Apple succeeding here.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s very relevant. If other people do it, and it’s a problem, then this isn’t about Apple. It’s about the practice, and the scope of the case should be much larger and apply to everyone. I support that outcome. I don’t think Apple should be targeted. If walled gardens are bad, they should be banned everywhere, not just the one Epic happens to want to profit from.
- colejohnson66 6y agoNot to mention that in the legal system, other people doing something is called precedent, and it’s a very important thing in (US) law.
- 16bytes 6y agoAFAIK, this is a hearing for a preliminary injunction, not the actual trial itself. That means that saying, "Well, other people do it too" is exactly what a judge should be examining at this point. There was a T&C contract, the form of which is standard across the industry, and Epic broke the T&C on purpose. Which likely means no injuctive relief at this point. You could argue that the T&C are onerous and/or that there are anti-competitive behaviors, but neither of those can be addressed in this preliminary phase. I don't see any basis for claiming that the judge has an "over interest" in Apple succeeding. That claim implies impropriety, and such a claim should carry a high bar for evidence.
- camhart 6y agoEpics actions may have been dishonest, but what rebellion is? Regardless, Epics actions don't remove the case that Apple has a monopoly and uses anti-competitive practices to benefit itself at the cost of the consumer and creator.
- shadowgovt 6y agoSure, but you can understand why courts aren't in the business of allowing themselves to be a vector for rebellions. ;)
- camhart 6y agoFair enough :)
- hellisothers 6y agoAnti-competitive practice to benefit itself? Yes, Apple sure has done this, as has Epic and every business ever. A monopoly though? I mean I guess, as much as Epic has a monopoly on its App Store.
- DeusExMachina 6y agoI keep reading this analogy, but it does not make sense. Apple is controlling access to customers with iOS devices. There is no alternative. Epic is not. Any competitor can sell to the same people that buy from Epic's store.
- jimmydorry 6y agoNot GP, but this is not exactly correct. Epic has been buying up releases to sell exclusively (just like consoles do in their walled garden monopolies).
- nottorp 6y agoYeah, it's funny how people conveniently forget that and cry for the poor billionaire underdog. And they're warring about the commission on ... in app purchases ... on a predatory free game aimed at teenagers?
- jhawk28 6y agoEpic fail!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- newbie578 6y agoI mean honestly, is anyone surprised? Apple is America's golden child and you can be sure no one in the U.S. is going to touch it. Our biggest hope lies in the EU, at least they try to fight these giant corporations..
- mcphage 6y ago> you can be sure no one in the U.S. is going to touch it. That hasn't been true historically.
- DeusExMachina 6y agoI read a couple of comments here from people alleging that the judge is trying to protect Apple. According to Wikipedia, in the past, she "adjudicated various cases against Apple": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yvonne_Gonzalez_Rogers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yvonne_Gonzalez_Rogers
- Zarel 6y agoYou may be misreading that line. It says she adjudicated two cases against Apple (besides this one), and both were found in favor of Apple (one by her, one by a jury).
- sizt 6y agoso many things wrong here. platform. walled garden. precedent. dishonest. ... load of judicial bs everybody charging 30% is evidence of monopolistic behavior, not a defense argument judge is okay with walled gardens because she works in one
- joshuamorton 6y agoIf everyone is a monopoly then no one is.
- seanwilson 6y agoRegarding the 30% app store charge, if you were giving 100% of the sale, wouldn't you then be personally liable to collect VAT and country specific tax yourself to sell worldwide? I feel this is glossed over as the admin + complexity for this is a real burden if you have to deal with it yourself.
- ComputerGuru 6y agoApple collects > 100% to cover the VAT and sales tax (sticker price does not include them).
- seanwilson 6y agoWhen Apple has to pay transaction costs and country specific tax for you, deal with the tax admin, while also managing the app store, if 30% for this is unreasonable, what's a reasonable amount and why? Many countries have VAT at around 20% on each sale for example so wouldn't Apple be losing money if they went down close to even 20%?
- username90 6y agoVAT isn't included in the 30% fee so you have to pay that as well. Apple just handles the transaction and the paperwork, they still get their full 30% cut.
- giovannibajo1 6y agoIt’s true that 30% cut is AFTER VAT is paid. It’s also true that Apple handles VAT for the developer, and that’s a real mess. So in the list of things that the 30% pays for, VAT handling (and all invoicing in general) should be remembered.
- t0mmyb0y 6y agoWhy doesn't epic just show the hundreds or thousands of apps apple let remain? Maybe it will be their money laundering final push?
- jariel 6y ago"That’s the security issue. That’s the security issue" Its' not honest, but it's definitely not 'the security issue'.
- parasubvert 6y agoOf course Epic was being dishonest. This is about the court of public opinion - there’s very little chance of winning this lawsuit, but it draws attention of lawmakers and lobbyists to either change the laws or get the DOJ or EU to take another look at this. That said, I think most people are going to be disappointed regardless the outcome. Markets aren’t created by god, they’re created by customers. If you want to force the creation of an App Store market, one that customers aren’t actually asking for, it will need to be government-mandated. If you think the EU or US knows how to create a utility market of app stores without completely fucking up competition, security, consumer experience, and enshrining Android and IOS as the “government sanctioned platforms” for 50 years, you are placing far too much faith in the power of regulation. It takes years to decades to get this right - no one has the answers, and governments aren’t great with uncertainty (see how policy and science mix!). Laws move very slowly, especially with partisan gridlock. Do we really think these platforms have a 50 year lifespan? If not, it’s probably not worth regulating. Be careful what you wish for.
- nodamage 6y agoThis hearing went really, really poorly for Epic. The judge repeatedly told Epic's lawyers she wasn't particularly persuaded by their arguments with regards to several key aspects of their case. Epic's case hinges on being able to establish that Apple has a "monopoly" in the single-brand market of "iOS app distribution". However, the judge seemed rather unconvinced that a market definition consisting of only iOS devices was actually the correct market to analyze. If Epic can't establish that "iOS app distribution" is in fact a valid antitrust market, they're going to have a lot of problems with their case, as both their section 1 (tying) claim and section 2 (monopoly maintenance) claim rely on that market definition. As an aside, I've read a number of comments here lamenting that the judge doesn't understand tech, but I think the opposite is true as well: many of the commenters here don't understand the law. The judge needs to work within the framework of existing legal precedent when making her decisions, and unfortunately for Epic, it doesn't really seem like existing precedent is on their side. As a specific example, many of the comments here point out that smartphones are not like gaming consoles because smartphones are general-purpose computing devices whereas consoles are entertainment devices. Be that as it may, there's nothing in US law that says general-purpose computing devices are supposed to be treated differently than other products for the purposes of antitrust analysis.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stale2002 6y ago> The judge repeatedly told Epic's lawyers she wasn't particularly persuaded by their arguments with regards to several key aspects of their case. It is a bit more complicated than that. This was the preliminary injunction stage of the trial. It is more that Epic did not pass the very high bar that it is so very likely to win the case, such that they should be able to force an injuction to happen right now. That is a very high bar to pass, and it is more that the judge is not willing to effectively declare epic the winning, right now, all on her own. Instead, the judge has said that she wants this to go to a jury, and that this is no ordinary case. She said that it is an extrordinary case, that is on the bleeding edge of technology monopoly law, and basically, that such an important case should not be decided by a judgement from the bench. Or at least this was my impression of what she was trying to say, when I was listening to the trial live. Which I agree with. I expect this to be a landmark technology monopoly case that is going to make its way all the way to the supreme court. As such, it would be inappropriate for the judge to basically decide the winner so early by enforcing an preliminary injunction, even though I ultimately believe that epic will win.
- sharker8 6y agoPay to play app stores are a symptom not a cause of a broken internet. Sideswiping a pay to play distribution scheme does not a hero make.
- gjsman-1000 6y agoOne of the few benefits of the walled garden that often gets forgetten by developers is the anti-piracy features. On iOS, installing a pirated version of an app is exceedingly difficult for most people, and that (theoretically) improves sales. If Epic were to allow side-loading on iOS, developers may notice a financial hit from increased pirating of apps.
- viseztrance 6y agoThese hypothetical losses are easily offset by the apple tax.
- ponker 6y agoApple should provide a button to basically permanently liberate the hardware. You no longer get security updates from Apple, perhaps there's a permanent light that turns on on the front so that any buyers know that this device no longer belongs to the Apple ecosystem and could be compromised. The phone cannot talk to Apple services. You can install whatever you want and lose all warranty coverage. It would rebut many of these complaints but I honestly don't think it would be very popular.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoEpic can fight back all walled gardens are monopoly and he is fighting a dragon or dragons using his wooden weapon on his epic horse. Even sing the song “To dream the Impossible dream ...” is as delusion as the original novel or movie. It can fight the 30% but as long as Apple allow small business and people like us pay 99 get publish I am on that m... walled garden side.
- reticulated 6y agoI don't understand why Epic don't persue the argument of an unlevel playing field. Amazon don't have to pay 30% for every transaction I make through the Amazon app on my iPhone. Same with eBay. Yes, I know Apple class these as different categories, but when push comes to shove what's the real difference here? Epic are providing electronic assets that they have paid in-house artists to create and want to distribute in exchange for their in-game currency (V-Bucks). Why should Apple cream 30% off the top of that revenue? Other than the electronic distribution, Apple has no fixed or variable costs relating to these in-game assets. I fully agree Apple should take a cut of Fortnite being a reviewed, and therefore trusted, app on their store. I find it hard to justify the ongoing 30% cut of additional assets that bear no discernable cost.
- LexGray 6y agoTake your average high end mall, Apple negotiates with the mall owner to pay much less than other stores because having Apple around makes the mall more attractive. Equally unfair as the Amazon case? Every business owner, mall owner, or head office of a franchise takes a large cut of the profits with likely little in fixed or variable costs. Saying this should change is like arguing society is fundamentally flawed. With the market as it is now Apple can ask for the 30% just for being associated with the brand.
- anfilt 6y agoThe user owns the device. They should be able load software without apples blessing. The problem is simple. There is no way for a user to load their own signing keys for the boot ROM to load other OSes like linux, or even simpler disable signature checks. There is no way to give iOS your own signing keys or disable signing checks to run applications. As such there is no way for me to run Firefox rendering engine. This is because the app store policies. Then there are other open source applications that don't want to bother with having a developer account with apple. There also the fact proprietary software probably raises their prices. So the user eats the 30% instead unlike the case if that software were able to self distribute.
- gameshot911 6y agoThe user agreed to the inability to load whatever software they wanted when they purchased the Apple device.
- anfilt 6y agoA purchase is not a contract. The closest thing is the EULA for iOS and I am not sure it states such a restriction, but lets assume it does. Still then the user should be able to load an other operating system.
- gameshot911 6y agoThat's an interesting point that I'll have to reflect on more. Thanks.
- chrischen 6y agoToo bad Epic’s trial wasn’t held in the court of HN public opinion.
- PostThisTooFast 6y agoIlliterate headline, Verge: "Epic’s decision to bypass Apple’s App Store policies were dishonest" The decision were dishonest? Really?