5 ms·
I worked for a company with a UK department, the UK boss would routinely use similar software to check that people where actually working and doing things corre
by mrweasel 6y ago
I worked for a company with a UK department, the UK boss would routinely use similar software to check that people where actually working and doing things correctly.
The Scandinavian bosses opted to just trust everyone to do the right thing and people always would.
Interestingly enough if was always the British employees who would do things like steal customer contact lists when they left or do deals on the side, so I suppose they had a reason to not trust people.
While I don't think spying on your employees is acceptable, I was also extremely disappointed in the behavior of my British colleagues.
- lambdasquirrel 6y agoThere's also, to some degree, people acting according to the expectations that are set for them. Having run up against that myself, there is frequently no point fighting that expectation. It's better just to either play that game, or leave. Oftentimes in a low-trust environment, you just do things in order to survive. Need to run a critically important errand or pick up the kids? I'd see parents skirting around things all the time. No one gave them crap for it, because we all knew it was just life. I'd suspect your British employees are living in some part of society that is low-trust. I've usually chosen to leave situations where there was no use fighting expectations. We don't get to set that culture. To some degree, cultural context matters, and to some degree, it also comes from the top.
- nilsb 6y agoI'd argue that workplaces where people are micromanaged and monitored tend to attract people who are either willing to adapt to these circumstances or are OK with gaming the system for their own benefit ("clearly my employer doesn't value my privacy, so why should I value theirs?"). Meanwhile people who thrive on getting things done their way without interference find work elsewhere.
- raxxorrax 6y agoIf you are expected to misbehave while not under surveillance you have to cherish the time when you can let it all out.
- zem 6y agoyou took a different lesson away from that than I did - I was fully expecting you to say "and little wonder, seeing as how the company had set up an adversarial relationship with the British employees from the get go" rather than "I suppose they had a reason not to trust people"
- mrweasel 6y agoI actually had a similar conclusion originally, but then I also saw the level of fraud by our UK customers. They where maybe 5 - 10% of our total sales, but 90+% of fraud cases. My take away is simply that there's less trust in the British society as a whole and it's not necessarily a fault or problem isolated to a single company.
- t0mas88 6y agoIt may be a bit of both, but indeed from anecdotal evidence starting a company in the UK and in the Netherlands: A lot of things are set up with less thrust in the UK. As a simple example in the Netherlands if you reclaim VAT as a company tax services just gives you the money and checks later (obviously you need to give it back if it wasn't correct). In the UK you'll need to show invoices, proof etc before HMRC pays you. Similar for insurance, car insurance in many European countries is done in 1 minute online just an update to a database. In the UK you need a sticker on your car, people that check the stickers etc.
- tpmx 6y agoMatches the data shown here: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/self-reported-trust-attitudes?tab=map https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/self-reported-trust-attit...
- mrweasel 6y agoChina is kinda funny. Either the question was misunderstood, or they've answered what they know should be the right answer. Everyone I know who as been trained in dealing with Chinese suppliers or business partners is telling me that you can only trust the Chinese as long as their financial interests are aligned with yours.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- oneeyedpigeon 6y agoI have a follow-up question about chickens and eggs...
- kelnos 6y ago> ... so I suppose they had a reason to not trust people. When you teach people that they aren't trustworthy, they tend to end up not being trustworthy. Perhaps if the UK bosses had given their employees a bit of trust, they would have lived up to it. And, on the flip side, perhaps if your Scandinavian bosses had implemented the same draconian monitoring measures, there would have been more people from your office doing shady things.
- ksk 6y agoI think you're getting to the the crux of it. Exactly What actions make it seem like the other person has branded you as untrustworthy? Would a cashier counting the money you gave them be a sign that they don't trust you? Or an airport security making you pass through a metal detector? Or a Police officer running a speed gun on your car? With the old 'Trust, but verify' idea, the disagreement is always on the 'how' in verify.
- henru 6y agoI would argue that if someone trusts you, you have something to lose if you break their trust (you might feel ashamed, it will degrade your work conditions, etc...) While of someone doesnt trust you already, if they catch you red handed it just confirms an already exisiting situation, so its no big deal.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoHere in Norway I think that the kind of surveillance described would be of debatable legality. And would be regarded by pretty much everyone as a breach of trust and etiquette. In particular such arrangements must be discussed between the employer and the representatives of the employees and the employer must choose the least invasive alternative. Here is a document giving guidance on the subject, sorry it's only available in Norwegian: https://www.arbeidstilsynet.no/contentassets/04ec2eb566d44942bd6693e9e3a0c99e/veileder-om-kontroll-og-overvaking-2019.pdf https://www.arbeidstilsynet.no/contentassets/04ec2eb566d4494... Also this one on camera surveillance which is analogous to screenshots: https://www.datatilsynet.no/personvern-pa-ulike-omrader/overvaking-og-sporing/kameraovervaking/kameraovervaking-arbedsliv/ https://www.datatilsynet.no/personvern-pa-ulike-omrader/over... "For at en arbeidsgiver skal kunne kameraovervåke en arbeidsplass, krever loven at det må foreligge et særskilt behov dersom man skal overvåke områder der bare de ansatte ferdes." in English (my translation): "In order for an employer to use video surveillance of a workplace, the law requires that there be a specific need if one is to monitor areas where only the employees go." I imagine that the Datatilsyn (Data Protection Authority) would regard regular screenshotting as similar.
- hnick 6y ago> Interestingly enough if was always the British employees who would do things like steal customer contact lists when they left or do deals on the side, so I suppose they had a reason to not trust people. If you're already treating me like I've done you wrong, then trust is gone and it wasn't by my choice. That cuts both ways. If someone feels like they are being treated as though they've already broken a social contract, then they probably have fewer qualms going a step or two further.
- lostlogin 6y agoYou see this with children (and some adults if I’m being honest). Being told not to do something makes it more appealing.
- cutemonster 6y agoAnd/or do other things one was not told not to do?
- cortesoft 6y agoIf you have to lie to do reasonable things, most people will lie.... and then you get used to lying, and find it easier to justify.
- Nursie 6y agoHonestly, as a Brit, I think we have a pathological work culture. Employees are often treated like naughty children, and in return they behave that way.
- b0rsuk 6y agoYou might find our Polish workplaces a refreshing change. Employees are often treated like feudal peasants. Poland never really had bourgeoisie/townsfolk class. Jews were the closest, in part because they were forbidden by law to own land. It was almost entirely peasants and gentry(20% at most), with clergy also playing a big role but the last two would pretty often overlap. The time when social changes happened in Europe Poland spent partitioned, under foreign rule. Progressive changes, like freeing of peasant class, were often imposed, even by Russian tzars. They were rarely a result of internal consensus.
- tpxl 6y ago>Employees are often treated like feudal peasants. Could you elaborate on what you mean by this, please?
- b0rsuk 6y agoWhen you browse articles about Polish workplaces, the word "folwark" comes up pretty regularly. Typically in a phrase like "employer treats the company like his folwark". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folwark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folwark https://biznes.gazetaprawna.pl/artykuly/801950,kapitalizm-po-polsku-folwark-ma-sie-dobrze.html https://biznes.gazetaprawna.pl/artykuly/801950,kapitalizm-po... This article would be titled "Polish Capitalism: folwark is holding up well.". The opening paragraph: "His will, whim, mood determines what happens to the company and its workers. Pan (sir, master) says what to do and how to do it. If he's in good mood - he will praise you. If he's mad - will reprimand you, yell at you, fire you. Will put you into pillory." The article goes on to bring up the uniquely polish Pan/Cham* dichotomy (Sir vs rube/redneck/yahoo/hillbilly), books that describe the relationship, areas of society where it thrives (one person rules, the rest timidly obeys). It's poignant that many corporations operating in Poland have a toxic mix of Western corporate culture and Polish feudal relations. Some extra aspects that I personally encountered: recruitment is done by HR and/or boss. Potential future coworkers, their representatives are frequently left out. Bosses like to micromanage rather than delegate tasks, unless to push something unpleasant down and away. This is also visible in government. I vaguely remember an interview describing a foreign statesman minister. He arrived and had a lecture of sorts about (modern) management strategies. He got a question along the lines "how do you assure things are done the way you want", to which he replied that he mostly doesn't care, that's the responsibility of his subordinates. Which provoked some smirks and snickering. In Poland, such manager is often perceived as weak. Also, bosses rarely ask subordinates for advice. My comment: naturally, in Poland people love to insinuate they come from aristocratic lineage, and calling someone a villager is offensive, with varying degrees depending on the word used. Poland and Germany are the last 2 European countries where it's polite to address someone per "Pan" or "Sie" - a remnant of feudal relations. But in a society that was about 80% made of peasants it's just not possible that everyone has blue blood. Especially that the bulk of wars was fought by upper class, and this tradition lived on to WW1 and WW2. Peasants were reluctant to fight, it didn't matter to them who ruled because they would end up in forced labor anyway. Sure, there was mass mobilization / forced draft called https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pospolite_ruszenie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pospolite_ruszenie but does it make sense to kill your livestock like that? So anyway, on top of gentry forming up no more than 20% of the society, a large part of them died in the two World Wars, and plenty were even explicitly exterminated (for example mass graves in Katyń). Another article in an openly leftist portal: https://krytykapolityczna.pl/felietony/kaja-puto/praca-polski-folwark-zabija-nie-tylko-ukraincow/?fbclid=IwAR0DvlwCDUseJEMFjd2CBiHq14y6N5CezcQRGVqH_jFc5yq77La472iPOUU https://krytykapolityczna.pl/felietony/kaja-puto/praca-polsk... it touches on the unsurprising fact that immigrant workers are treated worse in every country, and Polish employers have a particular superiority complex in respect to migrants from the East. Historical reasons. There were numerous cases where illegal immigrants from the East had work accidents and employer would stop people from calling an ambulance, or in one case even she dropped him in a forest and he died. Poles are quite stingy when it comes to tipping waiters (because Poland was a poor country), and if you're a waiter with an Eastern accent you're playing Hard Mode. I read few right-winged portals or articles, but I think they don't care, for them hierarchy is natural and they blame everyone around (Liberals, leftists, Germans, Jews, France&Britain for not sending military help at start of WW2, Ukrainians for driving poorly/stealing/assaulting people/stealing jobs, the list goes on and on)
- Thlom 6y agoThe Scandinavian bosses didn't just opt to trust the employees. Spying on employees is illegal in (most of?) Scandinavia as far as I know. (By the way, I have the same experience re: British/Scandinavian labor culture)
- MrDresden 6y agoYes, this kind of invasive surveillance would not be allowed and could end up in the company being fined huged sums
- Silhouette 6y agoSpying so intrusively on employees need to be done very carefully to stay legal in the UK as well. The ICO (the national data protection regulator) provides extensive guidance for employers on workplace monitoring, and there are several laws that might be relevant depending on the circumstances. The rules are far more nuanced than just saying that an employee on work time can be subject to whatever monitoring an employer feels like doing.
- bb123 6y agoAre we just engaging in lazy cultural generalisations now? This feels in poor taste.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoThat’s because Scandinavian countries are still mostly white and the UK is filled with brown people now. Stop pretending not to understand this, you faggot.