6 ms·
A company has to pay workers for 49 - 59 weeks without getting any work? I'm all for parental leave, but that's a full year. Does the government subsidize this
by echelon 6y ago
A company has to pay workers for 49 - 59 weeks without getting any work? I'm all for parental leave, but that's a full year.
Does the government subsidize this? That expense could sink a small company.
What happens if the workers leave the company after getting the benefit?
I'm really curious how European firms compete with American ones when workers can take so much time off and saddle their companies with so much responsibility. If every company in the world had to do this and the governments and taxes supported it, I'd be all for it.
I'm not passing judgment, just really curious how this works. I certainly favor parents getting plenty of time to adjust and spend time with their newborns. But I wonder if this is too much for companies to bear when they have to compete with companies that don't do this.
- tialaramex 6y agoYes, the government will subsidise this, although exact details vary, for example government might choose to arrange that they pay the employee over this period instead. It's not magic, obviously overall the economy is still paying for this to happen, but then the US system isn't magic either, babies don't magically receive any benefits from parents who are actually working all the time and barely see them for a handful of hours per week. So the question is only: Is it a good idea? Because if it's a good idea then paying for it is just a question of mechanics. Same for universal healthcare, the provision of safe drinking water, literacy programmes, you name it.
- matsemann 6y agoIt's the government paying. Up to a fixed amount. But most high earners are in a position where the company will pay the difference as a perk. If it were companies having to pay, that would probably lead to some aversion about hiring people without children in the right age. But that's probably an aversion lots of companies in other countries have about women. "Will they have kids and leave the workforce soon?". I strongly believe giving dads a lot of paternity leave is good for equality. Of course dads should have the same opportunity as moms, but males taking paternity leave has an indirect good effect on woman in the work force as well. No longer is it assumed that they will be gone for X months in their 20s/30s, compared to men. Some argue the rules should be "X days, split as the parents see fit". But that is what historically has put the pressure on the man to work and the woman to stay at home.
- rags2riches 6y agoIf you want to force an even split or not depends on if you see the system as something that enables people to make choices that are good, or something that makes them do what you think is good (for the parents in question or for the society in general). I know a couple that had two children. He wanted a third child. She wanted a PhD. The current Swedish system enabled them to have a child and let him take virtually all the leave while she finished her PhD. But some social engineers would rather not let them have that choice, because the aim is a perfect 50/50 split for all couples in a column of a report somewhere. (Or even worse, they would be fine with this particular case, but would object if it was she that wanted the third kid and he that wanted a PhD, because a 50/50 split in aggregate also looks pretty good, and this would work towards that in the present situation...)
- Ericson2314 6y agoUgh, more myopic individualism. How about this: after we mandate even split and the culture changes, we give parents back the right to allocate it as they see fit. Hell, if we want to converge faster and get back to parental choice quicker, we might mandate 3:2 men's vs women's paid leave. Annecodes like your female PhD candidate story are no basis for determining policy.
- rags2riches 6y agoSure, call it individualism to view people like my friends as the ends of your policy. What shall we call it when the policy treats them as a means to some other greater end?
- Ericson2314 6y ago> What shall we call it when the policy treats them as a means to some other greater end? Sacrifices for the greater good.
- matsemann 6y agoNo, the aim isn't "to fill a column of a report somewhere". That's just unnecessary snark from you. It's a difficult thing to balance. Ideally one should be able to split as wanted, based on one's life situation. But when one is free to choose, one often can find that the freedom is only imaginary. There will be pressure from society/employers/etc to do it a certain way. Lots of countries where it's expected that the father forego all paternity leave, or his career at the company will be done.
- sokoloff 6y agoThe salaries for devs in Europe are quite a bit lower than the SF/NYC/Seattle/Boston/Austin markets. You can look at it as they’re “buying” these (and other) benefits via lower salaries across the entire market.
- jarek83 6y ago"Buying" perks is ok-ish - the difference with state-regulated perks is that the employer has no way to tell 'no' to say, paternity leave. In other case, you never get the certainty that you'll be allowed to use your perk when need it.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoTech salaries aren't lower in Europe because of free healthcare and education funded by our higher taxes, they're lower because we don't have a huge government funded defense tech sector, we don't have mammoth sized, trillion dollar SW companies with a global monopoly like FAANGs that create hundreds of thousands of highly paid jobs, we don't have massive VC funds throwing money at every founder that promises to create the next Instagram and we don't have the US treasury free-debt money printer. Combine all that with a shortage of skilled workers due to the high cost of higher education in the US and the very restrictive immigration policies, even for skilled labor (H1Bs are still way tougher to get than a work visa for Europe). So basically the US has huge demand for talent with low supply which results in high wages. Instead we have the opposite. We have very welcoming immigration laws(which waters down salaries) we have plenty of skilled grads as education is basically free(which waters down salaries again), so in my college town I can't pretty much throw a rock without hitting someone who's doing a PhD in DS/ML/AI but we have no massive local companies that can utilize all that talent and no big VC funding so all those bright minds end up working in lame webshops/consultancies or in some research institute that gets bought up by FAANGs the minute it comes up with a good idea. So basically, we have a huge supply of talent(local and imported) but a low demand(compared to the US) wich results in lower salaries. To summarize, this is why we can't compete with the US on the tech front, not because of our taxes but because the US can outspend us.
- sokoloff 6y ago
- jarek83 6y agoJust gut feeling - this might not be a hit towards competitivity because it might actually be worth to have well-balanced employee. I find a similarity to good quality code - hard to prove its usefulness with just numbers, but it does pay off. Americans seem to struggle with their economy, yet still seem to look in the wrong direction when they try to find the cause.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Does the government subsidize this? That expense could sink a small company. In Canada, your maternity/paternity wages come out of the Employment Insurance system, so everyone chips in. Mothers or fathers can split the leave, which is 52 weeks or more. Seems like a good system. But some of your concerns are valid; from the employer's standpoint, planning around your staff having children isn't easy. Sometimes new parents decide to never come back to work, and in this country aren't required to provide special notice.
- marcusverus 6y agoFolks love to talk about these marginal 'perks' in Social Democracies, and the benefits experienced by the least fortunate, but you never hear about the costs of these programs or their impact on the finances of the average household. All these great benefits are, of course, funded via massive taxation of the middle and upper classes. You can see the (relative) impact in the data, which reveal household incomes to be ~40% lower than in the US , household debts which are ~double than US household debts, and household savings which are half those in the US: Household Income in US dollars (2018) [3]: Denmark - $34,712 Norway - $39,555 Finland - $34,497 Sweden - $34,301 Iceland - Not reported USA - $50,292 Household Debt as % of disposable income (2015-2018) [1]: Denmark - 281% Norway - 239% Finland - 145% Sweden - 189% Iceland - Not reported USA - 105% Household Net worth as % of net income (2014) [2]: Denmark - 553% ($191,900) <-- The dollar amounts are my math, based on household income above. Norway - 318% ($125,700) Finland - 359% ($123,800) Sweden - 526% ($180,400) Iceland - Not reported USA - 601% ($301,700) [1]https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-debt.htm https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-debt.htm [2]https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-net-worth.htm#indicator-chart https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-net-worth.htm#indicator-... [3]https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-disposable-income.htm#indicator-chart https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-disposable-income.htm#in...
- nmfisher 6y agoAnd interestingly, no apparent difference in fertility rate compared with the USA.
- bwb 6y agoTaxes in the usa are not accurate above, you need to add in healthcare and social security type payments too. Our tax rate is as high with those things included.
- TMWNN 6y ago>Taxes in the usa are not accurate above, you need to add in healthcare and social security type payments too. The OECD definition of disposable income is after healthcare and social security costs (http://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=46 http://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=46).
- x87678r 6y ago> A company has to pay workers for 49 - 59 weeks without getting any work? That's for each child. I worked with a guy who had 5 kids and with sick leave and holidays he worked <6mo a year for 7 years straight and when he did turn up he was too tired and uninterested to do anything useful. Its a good reason why Europe is disappearing as a economic force. OTOH The other reason is not enough children so maybe my coworker ended up helping the economy.
- sveme 6y agoWhy the fuck does this become a dick measuring contest? What do you personally gain from being comparatively exploited in the US? Why do you fall for that propaganda when income disparity is only getting worse in the US?
- Swenrekcah 6y agoHaving more than 2 kids as a couple is actually pretty rare. Kids/woman ratio is way under 2 everywhere in Europe [0]. So this is just nonsense. 0: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Fertility_statistics https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
- Aeolun 6y agoHis coworker certainly did have 5 kids, regardless of what the average birth rate is.
- confidantlake 6y agoI interpreted the "this", in "this is nonsense", to refer to the claim that excess leave from having 5 kids is causing economic decline in Europe. I don't think he was claiming that someone in Europe having 5 kids was nonsense.
- dheera 6y ago> I'm really curious how European firms compete with American ones when workers can take so much time off On one hand I guess you could compare it to American manufacturing vs. manufacturing in e.g. Vietnam, India, China where companies often fly under local labor laws and workers are worked to unreasonable hours. On another hand I also do think there is something to be said for better mental health => better work output at least in skilled jobs. A fact that many American companies don't seem to get.