5 ms·
‘It's like an open prison’: the catastrophe of converting office blocks to homes
- Spooky23 6y agoIt’s a great example of why the “no zoning” crowd is as wrong as the NIMBY people.
- war1025 6y agoHonestly sounds like it's not an issue of "zoning" so much as people exploiting government funds to house the poor in cheap, isolated locations. I lived in a office-to-studio conversion for six years and it was great. But it was also within walking distance of basically everything I wanted to do.
- lopmotr 6y agoWhat's wrong with housing the poor in cheap isolated areas? If they're not working, they don't need to be occupying more valuable locations near town. Doesn't the government fund cheap houses on purpose to prevent homelessness? Where's the exploitation? If the poor are too deserving for cheap housing, then who does deserve it?
- war1025 6y ago> What's wrong with housing the poor in cheap isolated areas? The thrust of the article is that no one should really be living in those places. Living in an isolated area is fine if you have access to transportation. The implication of the article is that there isn't adequate public transportation and the people don't have cars. Basically, if you house someone in a place that sets them up for failure, how grateful can you really expect them to be? > If they're not working, they don't need to be occupying more valuable locations near town. The lady in the article said she couldn't work because she spent half her day getting her kids to / from school. That is different from being unwilling to work. Maybe the residents are unwilling to work, but maybe it's a matter of them being too far away from jobs to realistically get one. > Where's the exploitation? The implication of the article is that the exploitation is by the property developers who converted the office space into something that qualified for government housing money, but wasn't really suitable for people to live in.
- bilbo0s 6y agoIf they're not working, they don't need to be occupying more valuable locations near town Maybe that works in the UK, but in the US, at least where I live, we have rules about the poor. You can't be getting benefits and at the same time not be going to work. You used to be able to do that, like a few decades ago or whatever, but not nowadays. If you're poor, you can not work if you want, but you won't get benefits. As soon as you sign up for benefits where I live, they will assign you work, and your new employer has to keep them informed of your performance. Most states would call it something like "work-fare", or "w2", or something like that. There may still be states where you can get benefits without working? But I'd imagine there aren't too many of them, if any.
- Spooky23 6y agoIsolation makes the poor poorer. If you look at what happened in the slum clearance programs in the United States, we tried to fix people problems by bulldozing buildings. If you think about the needs of people without a prefix, the obviousness of some problems pop out. “Poor people” are “people”, and if you think that way, the issue of being a 50 minute bus ride from groceries should become apparent to you. The South Bronx is a great obvious example. 300k+ people were displaced directly by the construction of the Bruckner and other expressways, and probably twice that were indirectly displaced as their neighborhoods were shattered by the construction and impacts of running superhighways through. Landlords abandoned or torched thousands of buildings in the 70s. The answer to the housing issue was building big public housing projects in disconnected, cheap areas, which rapidly became magnets for crime and misery. Try feeding a family when no groceries exist — fast food and bodega food only. If you look at old neighborhoods and cities, the poor were present and integrated in broader society. They may have been marginalized, but they weren’t set aside like dirty dishes in the sink.
- irjustin 6y ago"No zoning" is has its merits, but the core problem here is no regulation. If each house took up one whole floor, there wouldn't be an article. These people are here, presumably, because it's the best thing they can afford. If you followed them from here to another location - the stories probably would different but equally difficult/terrible. It takes effort, for sure, but good public housing can work.
- coldcode 6y agoGood public housing only works if the government (and the people) want it to. In this case no one cared about who would live there, and stuck them in a place people should not live. Likely someone made a large fortune and gave zero concerns about the residents, and the government got poor people out of sight and out of mind.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe core problem here isn't no regulation. It's government regulating by subsidy and causing these otherwise non-viable office to apartment conversions to spring up where they shouldn't have. You get what you incentivize.
- jnwatson 6y agoI’ve lived in a no zoning area. No zoning isn’t the same as no building code. I seriously doubt these conversions would pass inspection in the states.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoCareful, that straw-man looks mighty flammable. This isn't a no-zoning issue. It's an issue with the government subsidizing something that it shouldn't have subsidized. So if you consider subsidies for particular uses to be under the umbrella of zoning it's a zoning issue that wouldn't be present with less zoning.
- Spooky23 6y agoShoving residential units into downmarket commercial office space sure sounds like a zoning issue to me. The article even states that this issue isn’t issue outside of England, as local control in Wales and Scotland (ie zoning among other things) prevents obviously stupid things like this from happening.
- vidanay 6y agoAs an aside...where does the UK practice of naming things "Shield House", "Terminus House", etc come from?
- chrisseaton 6y agoHow do you name buildings where you live? ‘House’ just means building in this case. And then it was probably built by a terminus of some kind, or there’s some notable shield from the area.
- vidanay 6y agoThe majority of buildings in the US simply do not have names.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBlair House in Washington DC for example? Seems the same naming convention doesn’t it? It’s not particular to the UK.
- rst 6y agoBlair House is... a house. A family named Blair used to live in it. So, not really parallel to the British usage of "House" for structures like the BBC headquarters, "Broadcasting House", which have never had residential usage, and are in no way suited for it.
- chrisseaton 6y agoAs I already explained, ‘house’ in this context means ‘building’ not ‘home’. It’s a little old fashioned that’s all.
- vidanay 6y agoSure, I can name lots of structures in the US that have names, but they are far from the majority, and I an unaware of any legal weight for the name (IDK if UK building names have legal weight either though...)
- luckylion 6y ago> There have been drug dealing and knife fights in her block. There is “always shouting and arguing”, she says. “The children are frightened.” The key point about the issue, in my opinion, is that it's not the type of building or the location that makes it a terrible place to live there, it's the neighbors. Don't get me wrong, the location and floor plan aren't helping, but they're not the issue why most large scale public housing projects fail.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoPeople are subjects of their environment, not the other way around. Architecture makes an enormous difference to crime/safety.
- luckylion 6y agoArchitecture doesn't create crime, but it may well look that way because we generally build the cheapest way possible when building public houses for socially-challenged people. But it's still the people that create the problems, not the building. The next generations that grows up in those buildings aren't being shaped by the building itself, they're shaped by the culture that the inhabitants create.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoA police state also makes an enormous difference to crime/safety. You know what a police state has in common with architecture optimized for reducing crime and increasing safety? Nobody actually wants to live there.
- lopmotr 6y agoThis article is really trying to put a negative spin on something that could easily have been spun in a positive way. There's nothing clearly wrong with them, just a long list of minor discomforts from the author's perspective. Poor people have to live in posh houses with a garden and not a "once-fashionable" style? They even mention the council missing out on planning fees as a downside! What?! Since when are planning fees supposed to fund the council's other activities besides planning the building the developer is paying for?
- chrisseaton 6y agoThe Guardian’s whole act is middle class people telling working class people that they should think and act more like them. But most of the working class people don’t read the Guardian so it’s just shouting into a bubble.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoWe are talking about things like fire safety and crime. A friend of mine is renovating his place in Scotland and the planning process demanded that a bedroom must have a window to be avaliable as a fire escape and the kitchen must be isolated with a fire door. Now there appear to be apartments without windows at all, with narrow corridors, clogged with bycycles. It sounds like Grenfell Tower N2 coming right up - half the people inside won't make it out alive.
- alistairSH 6y agoThese sound even worse than the housing estates built in the 20th century. The ones the UK has steadily been demolishing. Sigh.
- ykevinator 6y agoI never understand these stories. Why don't people just move?
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoBecause they can't afford to. Housing in and around London is very much Not Cheap.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIs this a joke? They’re very poor people. They don’t have choices like presumably you do.
- war1025 6y agoI believe from my reading that it's government housing. As in: You would are poor and qualify for housing assistance. Here is your housing. What most people might be envisioning is more of a stipend system, where you can live wherever you want, and the government just gives you money towards rent. I believe this is more of a prescribed housing situation.
- oakesm9 6y agoMoving costs money. These are council (government) provided houses for those on low incomes. Basically, they don't have a real choice to move.
- Bworkbwork 6y agoThis reminds me of that Ben Shapiro quote that goes something like "If sea levels rise, do you think people won't just sell their house and move?" How can people these people move? Especially if they own these places.
- ealexhudson 6y agoBefore lockdown, I would stay in cheap hotels relatively often - eg Travelodge, our form of motel. One bed, a TV, a teasmaid. There would generally be two types of common guests. Workmen in the area to build something, tradespeople, or those the council was housing. Typically it would be a mum and a couple of kids, up in the morning by 8am in their school uniform. These places don't serve food, and you'd see people leave with a couple of bags or boxes, as they get shunted elsewhere. I'm glad they were not out on the street, but it broke my heart every time I saw it. I could well understand a parent thinking that a stable location would be better than shifting from one B&B to another. The lack of social housing is a genuine disgrace, and these resi conversions are absolutely not the answer.
- loopz 6y agoWho pays the real price of deregulation, and why are government permitted to do it?
- ethagknight 6y agoReading the article, unless I’m missing something, it sounds like people just don’t like the government housing they were given, maybe it wasn’t as good as what they had before. They have to pay a lot to travel and visit their friends, but then again the housing is free? A boy got his head stuck under a truck? Is that the development’s fault? No local services like grocery is a challenge that takes some time for a market (or government) to respond to. I would hope schools and groceries and essentials begin to adapt to these new housing areas, but that’s a government control issue. Personally, (and maybe a bit of a hot take) I expect government housing to be nothing less than a backstop before homelessness, and as such it should carry sufficient motivation to get out, but not too much motivation that you’d rather be on the streets. Because at the end of the day, a resident seeking free or subsidized housing is just a problem for the government to deal with, and governments do not have sufficient funding to deal with the problems in front of them, so things will get short changed. I don’t expect my government to take care of me, because it couldn’t care less, and I’ve been totally screwed by broken government in the past.
- leppr 6y ago> I don’t expect my government to take care of me, because it couldn’t care less, and I’ve been totally screwed by broken government in the past. Depending on where you live and how well paid you are, 60% to 20% of your work's output goes into your government's pockets. Furthermore, the government is usually also in charge of zoning and building restrictions, thus directly responsible for homelessness (There are plenty of extremely poor countries where homelessness is virtually nonexistent. What makes people homeless is police tearing down illegal houses, not poverty). Those are the very simple reasons people rightfully expect their government to provide them with free housing.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago> "What makes people homeless is police tearing down illegal houses, not poverty" This is a very good point, and i never see it mentioned - people will generally create their own housing out of whatever they have avaliable. These take the forms of refugee camps and slums, but they can and sometimes do evolve to something respectable over time - after all thats how housing began at the dawn of civilisation. Now if the person's right to create his own shelter and solve his own problem has been taken away, then a substitute must be provided. Every now and then we get people who make a mudhut or a tree house www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7826923/amp/Man-fights-live-inside-self-built-tree-house-council-bans-bushfire-risk.html
- jacknews 6y agoEveryone deserves decent housing and community. But community can grow, even from indecent housing, and then turn around and make the housing decent. It seems to me this is a social issue, not an architectural, or even a directly economic one. I'll guess these are mostly immigrants, corralled far from the rest of society by short-sighted and rather mean government policy.