4 ms·
You will never do this easily. If I run a developing nation there is absolutely no way I accept that you, a developed nation with a century of pumping CO2 into
by renewiltord 6y ago
You will never do this easily. If I run a developing nation there is absolutely no way I accept that you, a developed nation with a century of pumping CO2 into the atmosphere, will merely accept a reduction of your annual emissions. I will pump as much CO2 as necessary to raise my population into prosperity and until you have taken out enough GHG to match my historic emissions you're going to have to either take me with guns and bombs or you're going to have to pay me.
You don't want to do the first because future millions of people are not worth the lives of present millions. And you're not going to do the latter because you can't afford it. You burnt too much to get here.
So guess what? You're fucked. I'm not going to help you for free.
It's like Europe giving Brazil shit over the Amazon. Buddy, you guys clear cut your forests. Your absolute forest cover doesn't matter. You've killed so many of your forests. Brazil has 60% forest cover. Germany has 30%. You cut your trees to build cities. And I can't? No, raze your cities or pay me for 400 years of treelessness.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt's absolutely true, but put this way, it lends an argument towards force-subjugating the entire planet under one government just to end the bickering about fairness. Global warming isn't fair. What I'd honestly want to see happening instead is developed nations doubling down on greentech, and donating all of that (+ expertise and IP) to developing nations, so that the latter can leapfrog the CO₂-intensive energy generation methods. After all, the developing nations aren't into greenhouse emissions for the sake of greenhouse emissions - they just want to have the same level of prosperity for their people as the West enjoys. So I say we should just give them the means to achieve that without burning fossil fuels, for free - and screw intellectual property and some perceived "fairness". This is a global problem, we're all in this together.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThere is no “greentech” that mitigates the environmental damage of the luxury everyone wants, which is space. And no one with kids is going to voluntarily accept living in cramped apartments while other countries have individual houses on lots. Increased space per person => increased fossil fuel usage => increased emissions. Maybe the greatest “greentech” would be dissuading having kids, either culturally or economically.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThat's a fair point I haven't considered. But I was under impression that the developing world has plenty of space?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoSpace means more miles driven, more ground paved with cement/concrete/asphalt, more distance water/electricity/gas/sewage/trash has to be pushed. The amount of (developed) land a person uses is a rough proxy for quality of life in the developed world, and it is afforded by ignoring the long term externalities of fossil fuels. Obviously everyone wants a detached single family house with a garage and a couple cars and a backyard for their kids and a few flights every year for the family, but if the environment is buckling with such a small portion of the population enjoying these benefits, there is no chance everyone can. Overall consumption needs to go down, which means lower consumption per person, and/or fewer persons.
- ookookookook 6y agoFewer persons with high luxury sounds a lot better than more persons with low QOL.
- asymmetric 6y agoI’m not sure everyone considers space the top luxury. Just look at most Asian/European metropolises: people are happy to sacrifice space for other luxuries.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWouldn't read that much from it. They're likely sacrificing space because they have little other choice (Japan, HK?), or because cities are where the good jobs are.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoI think it's like money, more makes you linearly happier but only up to a certain point, after which the curve flattens.
- renewiltord 6y agoThere are ways to do it. Sometimes you just need the tech to exist and you just need to drive down the price. Subsidies to build solar have done a great job in that respect. It's just not enough until it becomes crazy cheap, though. You have to be way better than fossil fuels to match up because of their advantages. And no one has the power for global subjugation. No single group of currently allied nations has that power. So that's a safe thing. It simply can't happen. I doubt America could even subjugate Mexico, which is next door.
- Joeri 6y agoThe thing is that brazil is mostly cutting forests down for slash and burn farming. If they modernized farming practices, the rate of deforestation would drop significantly. The solution there as with most of these questions of climate fairness is for first world countries to invest in technological development of poorer regions. If brazil’s farmers could practice farming in the same way as european farmers, they wouldn’t need to cut forests down.
- renewiltord 6y agoI'm all for that: the approach of paying them not to do it, either with tech or money (pure dollars or carbon-taxing imports and your local production or anything like that).
- marcosdumay 6y ago> If they modernized farming practices, the rate of deforestation would drop significantly. Ha, that's funny. Europeans have to subsidize their agriculture to compete with Brazil, but Brazilian practices aren't modern? If Brazilian farmers practiced farming in the same way as Europeans do, the country would ban bankrupt.
- rtkwe 6y agoThey have to subsidize because labor and land are more expensive the Europe than Brazil, it has very little to do with how efficient the farming techniques are.
- marcosdumay 6y ago> They have to subsidize because labor and land are more expensive the Europe than Brazil Yeah, mechanization is lower in Europe... (This is related to the subsides.) Anyway, those waves of temporary immigrants that every year go to Europe from poorer neighboring countries aren't much more expensive than Brazilian labor.
- COVardsStayHome 6y agoGuess what, maybe we should civilize these savages with a barrage of nuclear weapons? You want to cut 50% of the Amazon? We nuke you back to the stone age. So guess what? You are fucked.
- defterGoose 6y agoThat's why the countries with the most resources and technology have to graciously give those things to developing nations. Lead by example, but make sure that any nation can also have nuclear power, electric vehicles, etc. It's simple really, you stop letting any one person or family hoard massive pipes of resources. Yes this is something like socialism, but with everyone finally realizing that acting in their own self interest is identical to fixing the climate problem. No one can escape that. I assure you Elon doesn't want to go live on Mars by himself.
- ookookookook 6y agoGuns and bombs it is, then.
- renewiltord 6y agoYou can say this but no nation as a whole has the balls. That's the power of fighting off an invasion from a rich country. I can lose ten for each one of yours and you will lose hope first. To say nothing of the fact that the first American soldier who dies to stop climate change will cause, by his death, the crucifixion of your "liberal tree huggers". Your internal politics will fracture and break you. You are too weak for this. And if you're European, your populace doesn't have the appetite to use guns and bombs to stop climate change anyway.
- glogla 6y agoThere's no need for invasion or occupation, bombing is enough - look at per capita carbon footprint of Afghanistan or Somalia. And that can be done "cleanly" with drones, no risk for the attacking nation. Other than that, some parts of American / Western population would be gladly sold on "the overpopulated non-whites are destroying the world by over-consumption and need to be kept in check" - without realizing the irony of "over-consumption" and without seeing the parallels between "overpopulation" rhetoric and eugenics of old. Moreover eternal war is more money for the capitalists, while there's little profit in saving the world peacefully. And you know who truly rules the West. So hopefully we can all agree on stuff. I'm not sure it's all that likely. EDIT: also if you're a "leader of a developing nation", chances are you're going to see effects of climate change, like drought and famine, way sooner than the rich parts of the world. And if you get no aid because you refuse to cooperate ... you know. Maybe your replacement that got to power after you got hanged by an angry mob will do more solar panels or whatever.
- renewiltord 6y agoThe developed world can't afford it. Both those countries were fucked already. And the Afghanistan war barely has support - despite sheltering someone who performed the most significant terrorist attack on America in decades, perhaps centuries. If you want to stop Brazil or China or India from industrializing you're in for it. It's not going to work. It won't work there and it won't work in Pakistan or Indonesia. And it won't work in Nigeria. And it won't work in Argentina. You just can't do it. And the benefits of industrialization are huge. Especially now before we put carbon caps in because everyone knows you get grandfathered in. When the famines come, you'll be expected to buy food. And the West will be expected to sell it. Because what are you going to do, say "No aid because you didn't play along"? You'll get absolutely mulched in your Parliaments and your Congresses. To say nothing of what will happen, which is that China will sell them food because it is unlikely everyone gets a drought at the same time. And then you will have committed a geopolitical own goal. You can force a lot of things. A lot of things. But China put the cat among the pigeons. Everyone knows that burning hella fossil really fast is optimal, because sooner or later the West is gonna ask for some deals. And since we'll wipe the slate clean of emissions then, it is optimal to burn now. Burn everything because the jubilee will come.
- jeffnappi 6y agoThe hopeful side of this might be that the economies of scale in renewable energy such as wind and solar have been funded by the wealthy countries. Thus the developing nations are in a far better spot where it may even be cheaper to use renewable sources than GHG producing sources. If you consider that coal plants also come with negative health effects on a population (elevated cancer rates, etc) - it makes even more sense. Compare this to how the U.S. invested in developing fiber optic technology - it was INSANELY expensive to build out fiber networks in the 80s/90s, and now it's nearly free. The small countries who waited until ~2005 or after were able to build out their internet infrastructure for a fraction of the cost. Perhaps a similar effect is taking place with energy, but I may be overly optimistic.