4 ms·
Of all the things you need to be careful about on the net, predictions of climate doom are definitely one! Know that doom predictions, being very emotionally a
by BurningFrog 6y ago
Of all the things you need to be careful about on the net, predictions of climate doom are definitely one!
Know that doom predictions, being very emotionally appealing, travel around the world before science can get its shoes on.
- tsimionescu 6y agoIn principle you are right, but this is one case where you have it backwards. The reality that science shows is far worse than what has permeated mainstream culture, on the web or otherwise. The size of the climate disaster, and the urgent need for radical changes in the global economy, simply can't be overstated right now. Unfortunately, the amount of status quo propaganda, especially in the US, is also staggering. You can't open a media site and not read false information like 'we still have time', 'scientists aren't really sure', 'new technology will help address this', 'if people did this one easy thing, the problem would go away', 'track your personal carbon emissions and the world will be saved' - all dangerously misleading and outright false information. But cleverly disguised as of we can keep the status quo and things will just improve.
- Udik 6y ago> The reality that science shows is far worse than what has permeated mainstream culture I'm really curious where did you get this information from. I suppose it must not be popular or mainstream media, because of course msm telling you that science shows a worse reality than msm is a contradiction. So does which primary literature does it come from?
- revax 6y agoMainly from the IPCC reports.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoMaybe it's a different experience for you, but the IPCC reports are much better than what's permeated mainstream culture around me. I consistently see people saying that we've gotta stop having children, that the Earth can't support modern industrial civilization, that in 100 years we won't be able to grow enough food and half the planet will starve. The IPCC reports don't suggest anything nearly this bad.
- Udik 6y agoWhich parts exactly? Because usually it is claimed (in popular and mainstream media) that ipcc reports are toned down for consensus and political support.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 6y ago> The reality that science shows... Just saying that means nothing without a reference to this alleged science. Nothing!
- lucb1e 6y agoI see where you're coming from but one doesn't need references to say that water is wet. This is a similar case. "Science" (people like you and me that looked into the matter, did experiments, asked critical questions, and presented their work) finding that we are causing the climate to change into something that is less favorable to humans than our current climate is abundantly clear to anyone who will either read the evidence or verify the experiments (e.g. buy an accurate CO2 meter or whatever other part it is that you doubt).
- BurningFrog 6y agoThere is a huge difference between what I was responding to... > The size of the climate disaster, and the urgent need for radical changes in the global economy, simply can't be overstated right now. ...and your take, which I fully agree with: > "Science" (...) finding that we are causing the climate to change into something that is less favorable to humans than our current climate is abundantly clear to anyone
- lucb1e 6y agoAh okay, now I better understand what you meant. Personally I think it's true that the size of the climate disaster is absolutely enormous and we really do need radical changes throughout the global economy. But if you don't share that opinion then I see why you'd want to see a citation with such a statement, even if you don't deny that the CO2 in the air is man-made and causing the planet to become a lot less hospitable to us. So I'll oblige and go to Wikipedia's climate crisis page, which provides under the heading of "Scientific basis": > While powerful language had long been used in advocacy, politics and media, until the late 2010s the scientific community traditionally remained more constrained in its language.[13] However, in a November 2019 statement published in January 2020 issue of the scientific journal BioScience, a group of over 11,000 scientists argued that describing global warming as a climate emergency or climate crisis was appropriate.[14] [...] > Also in November 2019, an article published in Nature concluded that evidence from climate tipping points alone suggests that "we are in a state of planetary emergency", defining emergency as a product of risk and urgency, with both factors judged to be "acute".[15] The Nature article referenced recent IPCC Special Reports (2018, 2019) suggesting individual tipping points could be exceeded with as little as 1—2 °C of global average warming The page does warn for the backlash from the alarmist phrasing, but at least many scientists appear to find this phrasing accurate. They're not infallible but it does seem to be our best understanding of the situation.
- Joeri 6y agoWhile I agree that climate change is the dominant issue of our time, I disagree that media is underexposing it. There is quite a lot of unwarranted climate doomsaying. To give an example, in the coverage of natural disasters like wildfires and hurricanes they keep drawing a link to climate change and saying this will get worse and worse due to climate change. But what the IPCC actually says is this: Increasing exposure of people and economic assets has been the major cause of long-term increases in economic losses from weather- and climate-related disasters (high confidence). Long-term trends in economic disaster losses adjusted for wealth and population increases have not been attributed to climate change, but a role for climate change has not been excluded (high agreement, medium evidence). [1] The message that what is causing these major natural disasters is mostly people living and building in the wrong places, not climate change, is what the media should be saying, but they tend to link it almost entirely to climate change, which is an overstatement. [1] https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/03/SREX_FD_SPM_final-2.pdf https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/03/SREX_FD_SPM_...
- kingkawn 6y agothe climate doom predictions I’ve read so far seem to have underestimated the impact and speed with which it would arrive
- porb121 6y ago> Know that doom predictions, being very emotionally appealing, travel around the world before science can get its shoes on. Read the first few paragraphs of any paper in climate or environmental science; their outlook is usually much bleaker than anything you find in the general public.
- BurningFrog 6y agoIn the general public I routinely see claims that we have until 2030 to save the planet! Are there really science papers claiming worse? Meanwhile the IPCC worst-case scenario is that world GDP in 2100 will be 8.2% lower with a +3.7°C temperature increase, compared to the aspirational +1.5°C increase.