6 ms·
I admit I did not read the entire publication, but, at least at face value, this seems somewhat absurd to me. Within the past couple hundred years humans have b
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I admit I did not read the entire publication, but, at least at face value, this seems somewhat absurd to me. Within the past couple hundred years humans have built massive structures in cities that should last for many millions (hundreds of millions?) of years.
I mean, Manhattan may be under water in 100 million years (or, much sooner), but all those gigantic steel, concrete, plastic and glass structures aren't just going to dissolve.
- digitaltrees 6y agoWouldn’t glaciers grind them to dust?
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI would guess that glaciers would encapsulate the skyscrapers and dislodge them from their foundation, and when they receded leaving a huge pile of steel and concrete. Even if that was later encapsulated by magma, future geologists would have to wonder about metal 'veins' that were so structured and why part of the rock was basalt and another part was an exceptionally hard and dense form of limestone. Note to self. Don't speculate on HN. Got it. :-)
- mcguire 6y agoThe oldest known iron artifacts, ca 3200BCE: https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0305440313002057-gr3.jpg https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S03054403130020... https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305440313002057 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030544031...
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI wonder how it is that the iron in meteorites doesn't just dissolve away. Any thoughts on that?
- nraynaud 6y agoThe meteorites we find fell “recently”? The iron is in a stable oxide?
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI don't think so, meteoric iron (according to the wonderful blog series[1]) is early Egyptian. Iron (and steel) is stable outside the presence of oxygen and water. It doesn't just dissolve. And certainly if it were part of the steel reinforcement inside concrete in a building where special measures had been taken to insure that neither oxygen nor water would come in contact with it (as modern skyscrapers do) would persist for an exceptionally long time. But I'm just guessing ;-) [1] https://acoup.blog/2020/09/18/collections-iron-how-did-they-make-it-part-i-mining/ https://acoup.blog/2020/09/18/collections-iron-how-did-they-...
- analyte123 6y agoWhat about when the skyscraper’s pieces are submerged under saltwater for a million years? Or are covered up by a mile of river sediment and then plunged another 5 miles under the earth for several million years?
- mcguire 6y agoOr the concrete develops cracks, allowing water into the steel reinforcement, which expands, further cracking the concrete until it collapses. Like modern bridges.
- yxhuvud 6y agoIf there are two things the glaciers you mentioned a few posts back would accomplish it would be creating cracks that would expose things to water and oxygen, and also expose the resulting heaps to loads and loads of water. This is how stones found in glacial deposits look like: https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rullstens%C3%A5s#/media/Fil:Rullstens%C3%A5s_i_genomsk%C3%A4rning.JPG https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rullstens%C3%A5s#/media/Fil:Ru... Note how rounded all the stones are. And the stones that are there are generally speaking a LOT more resilient than any variant of limestone will ever be (including concrete).
- lmilcin 6y agoThere is better argument and it is surface natural resources. We know, that before industry took off we had huge amount of natural resources almost lying on the ground. Now many of crucial resources have to be dug from huge depths or recovered from dilute sources. I can't imagine a previous industrial civilization leaving huge amount of resources available on the surface. Almost by definition, industry is about scaling and efficiency and it always look to get to the results as quickly as possible.
- api 6y agoDepends on time frame. Plate tectonics will reset things quite a bit over truly vast time scales. Over shorter time scales this argument mostly holds, though one can imagine an intelligence with technology but with less expansionary drive and conspicuous consumption than humans. This intelligence may use resources more slowly.
- a1369209993 6y agoTo be fair, industrial-level civilization (engines, mass production, etc) doesn't actually require large, reinforced concrete structures[0]. That said, the answer to TFA's question is "almost certainly yes, unless they deliberately tried to conceal geological evidence of their existence, and probably even then". 0: nor vice versa, technically, though the logistics of using pre-industrial steel as building material would be prohibitive. see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24591216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24591216
- gus_massa 6y agoThe steel doesn't last too much, this link claims only 1200 years. https://www.quora.com/How-long-can-stainless-steel-last-for#:~:text=316%20stainless%20steel%20is%20estimated,to%20a%20mere%20260%20years https://www.quora.com/How-long-can-stainless-steel-last-for#.... I'm not sure about that number, but the ancient the bronze swords are better conserved than the steel ones. Plastic will get washed away, and glass may get crunched and be difficult to find. The rest of the concrete has a longer lifetime.
- matchagaucho 6y agoThe Authors seem to be saying a visit to a barren planet shouldn't be written off as "no life". Evidence of civilization could be just below the surface.
- divbzero 6y agoIt sounds like “gigantic steel, concrete, plastic and glass structures aren’t just going to dissolve” really depends on timescale, and geologic timescales are far beyond our typical experience. From the Atlantic article by one of the authors: [1] [2] When it comes to direct evidence of an industrial civilization—things like cities, factories, and roads—the geologic record doesn’t go back past what’s called the Quaternary period 2.6 million years ago. For example, the oldest large-scale stretch of ancient surface lies in the Negev Desert. It’s “just” 1.8 million years old—older surfaces are mostly visible in cross section via something like a cliff face or rock cuts. Go back much further than the Quaternary, and everything has been turned over and crushed to dust. [1]: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/04/are-we-earths-only-civilization/557180/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/04/are-we-e... [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24601382 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24601382
- nabla9 6y agoIn periods of 100s of millions of years whole continents disappear or move around, new layers of rocks are formed and old layers are buried. The Rocky Mountains formed just 55 - 80 million years ago. Cities disappear completely. Concrete and glass becomes rock (again), steel is oxidized and is just layer of iron ore. Plastics degradate and breaks into nanoparticles. As the article speculates, most evidence would be likely something like synthetic biomarkers in deep sea sediments. Traces of industrial chemicals not produced naturally. Wrong chirality in some organic chemicals. Transuranic elements.
- friendlybus 6y agoSome zircons have been dated back to the hadean era, when the earth was forming. Any information for building something that sticks around long term would be contained in them.
- analyte123 6y agoThere are plenty of places within a two hour drive or train ride from NYC where you can see gigantic steel concrete and brick structures that are less than 150 years old well into the process of dissolving. If you live in prosperous cities and don’t have to maintain property, it’s understandable how you can be unfamiliar with the relentless processes of rust, melt-freeze weathering, erosion, storm damage, how quickly vegetation grows, and so on.