7 ms·
The fresh smell of ransomed coffee
- tyingq 6y ago"ESP8266 with AT modem firmware, 2 – STM32F05106 ARM Cortex M0" Wow, it needs two 32bit CPUs to make my coffee.
- bilbo0s 6y agoNo. They sell you 32 bit CPUs to make your coffee. It's more profitable that way. You don't need any IoT nonsense to make coffee.
- taurath 6y agoSmells like someone is already brewing up a Doom install.
- meekrohprocess 6y agoWiFi is a difficult protocol, so it makes sense to use a radio coprocessor. The ESP8266 can also have trouble running non-trivial applications while reliably handling WiFi, and in 2020 a Cortex-M0 chip is probably at least as cost effective as an 8-bit micro. They don't need those chips to make your coffee, they need them to connect to the internet and to avoid hiring expensive experts. 5 years from now this might use a single ESP32-S2, but it doesn't seem outrageous, especially when the machine also has a display. Plus, as a bonus, you can use it to mine Monero! Small correction to the article, STM32F0s have a PLL so they aren't limited to the crystal's 8MHz frequency. They're rated for 48MHz, but you can also overclock them.
- sokoloff 6y agoIt seems to me that “controlling a coffee maker” is about as least resource-intensive application as it gets. Processing UART traffic is more resource-intensive.
- lostlogin 6y agoYes, but that when stock, before mining Monero.
- HeyLaughingBoy 6y ago> in 2020 a Cortex-M0 chip is probably at least as cost effective as an 8-bit micro In many cases, more so. Economies of scale are such that there are many 32-bit MCUs that are cheaper than 8-bit ones with fewer resources.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 6y agoI just see technology is to the point that processors of this nature are so common we can waste them in coffee makers. we have coffee makers more powerful than the first computer's I used in school!
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoIt's simply cheaper that way. A standard, more powerful part is usually much cheaper than having to do more customization, and these CPUs are so cheap that making it cheaper simply doesn't matter anymore. For projects made in small quantities, as soon as you need a touch display, throwing an Android phone at the problem is often the right solution, even if you just need something extremely trivial. Sure, I could do it with an 8-bit microcontroller and physical buttons, but by the time I've designed a custom board for it, the time I spent was worth more than the phone.
- tyingq 6y agoIt's still funny though. It's got more horsepower than an SMP RISC box from the early 90s that would have powered a top 100 website. And probably could have controlled a room full of coffee makers.
- falcolas 6y agoI once asked the author of “Magical Objects” - a book proselytizing about the future of IoT - about security. He blew it off, saying something along the lines of “Security isn’t really necessary for these devices, but I’m sure someone’s working on it.” And thus we are here. When the evangelists don’t care about security, the industry won’t care about security. Well, maybe it’s the other way around. In either case, nobody in the industry cares about security.
- save_ferris 6y agoJust curious, what year did that conversation take place?
- falcolas 6y agoAround 2015. Enchanted Objects by David Rose
- mcguire 6y agoFrequently presented arguments: Worrying about things like security would adversely impact your time-to-market. Security isn't a feature---it has to be baked in from the ground floor and isn't apparent to the end user except as a annoyance. Security is a difficult problem that requires at least some minimum of knowledge and experience---knowledge and experience that are unrelated to the device or the development of its new features. There is no financial or professional upside to paying for security, and no financial downside to not doing so. Security is always regarded as a magic-bullet topic; there must be some magic pixie dust to sprinkle on the device to make security problems disappear. Like firewalls, VPNs, and encryption. Security problems have two advantages. First, they are rather rare and something that happens to other people. Second, they are easy to push off onto the end user: "Well, har, har, you wouldn't have this problem if you had just..." The devices themselves are regarded in black-or-white terms: either a coffeemaker with multiple processors is the best thing since Attila the Hun invented the pillage, or the whole idea is more idiotic than selling a fish a bicycle. No one is interested in a middleground, cost-benefit analysis. Yes, many of these put the responsibility for the (lack of) security of devices on the engineers and developers. That's why we get paid the big bucks.
- aunty_helen 6y agohttps://decoded.avast.io/martinhron/the-fresh-smell-of-ransomed-coffee/ https://decoded.avast.io/martinhron/the-fresh-smell-of-ranso... Original link from the article, perhaps a better source?
- dang 6y agoChanged to that from https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/09/how-a-hacker-turned-a-250-coffee-maker-into-ransom-machine https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/09/how-a.... Thanks!
- raverbashing 6y agoSorry for the rant but I think it's several wonderful (/s) mentalities coming together in the design of those IoC things: - hw engineers that don't know much (almost nothing I'd say) about internet security. Or all the gotchas of sw developments - "nodejs/docker/systemd" mentality who thinks of uptimes (what's uptime?) in terms of hours instead of years and "just reboot" as a solution to any problem - "Monetize all the data", hey your coffee maker has a gdpr popup with only an OK button, that's fine and dandy right? Every device should be factory resettable with a button. Allow upgrades? Sure, but the upgrade runs after the base code ran. It does not override a fixed partition. Everything that doesn't need to be plugged in shouldn't, and conveniences quickly turn into inconveniences if they can't be maintained long-term.
- herodotus 6y agoToo bad you got down-voted. I think you have made some valid points.
- gpapilion 6y agoI really question more the risk reward trade off of these devices. What is having an internet connected coffee maker buying me? Is the minutes save per month worth the security risk it’s exposing me? This coupled with the knowledge these are mostly discount devices made with the least amount of on going support intended, you pretty much know you’re setup for a disaster. Additionally, I was finding most of these devices were actually increasing the time it took to do something rather than enabling some impossible interaction. I’m short on IoT except for industrial usage, where you are displacing an inspector or a manual data collection. That said those spaces are just as bad as the home devices.
- 29083011397778 6y ago> I really question more the risk reward trade off of these devices. What is having an internet connected coffee maker buying me? Presumably they're similar to smart TVs: some consumers may want them, but nearly all OEMs would rather sell a smart one than a dumb one
- 082349872349872 6y agoGresham's Law arrives in the kitchen?
- CyberDildonics 6y agoSmart TVs are different - people want netflix/hulu/disney+ built into their TV a long with a bunch of other interfaces to play video with their remote. TV for lots of non tech savy people comes over the internet now. A lot of powered appliances either heat something up or spin a fan or pump. They don't need information from the internet and any slight advantage is outweighed by their complexity and cost. I think you are right that manufacturers want to break free from being commodities. I think it is only a matter of time before people realize that they aren't gaining anything from complicating things that used to be simple.
- GordonS 6y agoThe value from smart TVs is very clear, even if the privacy concerns are only clear to a few. But a coffee machine, toaster or whatever... just... why?! Even as a life-long techie, and putting aside privacy concerns, there isn't a single compelling reason to want my coffee machine to be connected to the Internet, or even my local network.
- tetha 6y agoLets just hope the heating pad has a temperature cutoff independent from the software, otherwise this turns a lot more scary.
- pravda 6y agoI think UL requires two thermal cutoff switches for coffee makers. Even my $15 el-cheapo coffee maker has two thermal cutoff switches. https://www.electrical-forensics.com/Coffeemakers/CoffeeMakers.html https://www.electrical-forensics.com/Coffeemakers/CoffeeMake...
- mcguire 6y agoPerhaps something similar to Underwriter's Laboratories for IoT security?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- taurath 6y agoThere will be good and bad IoT devices. At the moment there’s little way for a consumer to tell which is which - that you me is the biggest glaring omission. I wish we had branded security and privacy standards like “we don’t open unencrypted wifi access points”.
- praptak 6y agoThen there is the scenario of a good manufacturer being bought out by greedy assholes.
- nogabebop23 6y agoDoesn't this ignore the broader question of IoT devices for things like coffee makers in the first place? It seems like internet-enabled for the sake of it, which is cool in the "We built a java-based coffee maker monitor for the break room back in 1991" way, but kind of sad today. Product progressions in my lifetime: 1. Put a clock in it 2. Put a radio in it 3. Put a camera in it 4. Hook everything up to the internet
- lostlogin 6y agoBetween 2 and 3 there needs to be “put a screen on it”.
- vmception 6y agoIf by “screwed” you mean you can keep selling worse home kitchen appliances while also inheriting a recurring revenue stream because you slapped an android device behind the LCD Then, “yes”
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoTbh it might be best if we saw something like the FDA for consumer electronics. I don't worry that much about the food I way because my tax dollars are spent to ensure that it meets a quality bar.. Relying on the market to do that would put really high cost or high risk on each individual consumer. Imo it's much better to just be able to trust that everything you can buy meets a bare minimum, unless specifically unregulated.
- mcguire 6y agoPerhaps something similar to UL, linked to insurance contracts?
- windthrown 6y agoIsn't the FTC already "the FDA for consumer electronics"? Or do you hoping for an agency who is solely focused electronic devices?
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoI know the FTC regulates stuff like what frequencies something is broadcasting on, and on some of the broadcast spectrums they also regulate what is said. What else do they regulate?
- windthrown 6y agoThey have the very broad mission of "preventing anticompetitive, deceptive, and unfair business practices" which includes electronics but not a strong focus. Upon looking into it further, the few big cases I was remembering were privacy related rather than consumer electronics [1][2]. They also set energy standards and vet environmental marketing claims but that doesn't really match the approve/deny role that the FDA does. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Sears_Holdings_Management_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Sears_Holdings_Managemen.... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Gateway_Learning_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Gateway_Learning_Corp.
- alistairSH 6y agoI still don't understand the value proposition of an IoT kitchen appliance. This thing vs a $10 French Press in particular, but even internet connected crock pots and things. Monitoring my cooking food from across town doesn't solve any problem - if something goes wrong, there's nothing I can do about it and I've just added stress to my life that wasn't there previously.
- nogabebop23 6y agoThis is how I feel about the security cameras we have at my house. Initially I got very anxious every time a (usually false-positive) alert arrived; now I'm so desensitized I basically ignore them. I know when my house or garage gets burglarized I'll have some nice, grainy over-exposed videos of the entire event but no real advantage over where I was before.
- SkyPuncher 6y agoI have 3 cameras that I find use. 1. A weird part of the exterior. I don't physically walk back there often, so the camera is handy. 2. One at the mailbox/package drop spot. Not for theft, just to know when my packages arrive. 3. One in the "mechanical" room so I can check in while I'm away (we have hydronic heat, so we can't fully turn the water off in the winter).
- CyberDildonics 6y agoIt will also hopefully be time stamped. Video cameras for porch pirates seems to pay off well, though making a big mail box for your porch is probably more effective.
- alistairSH 6y agoI have two. They serve mostly as a notification system for somebody in the house that I'm not expecting, but not a security problem (housekeeper, adult son drops by for some reason, neighborhood friend drops off a roll of fabric for my wife - but that's everybody with a key, so like I said, not a security thing).
- coliveira 6y ago
- URSpider94 6y agoAmazon released its Alexa Connect Kit to solve this problem: it’s an end to end IoT integration in a module. It’s a good way to focus on building an IoT device while someone else takes care of the security. https://developer.amazon.com/en-US/alexa/connected-devices/alexa-connect-kit https://developer.amazon.com/en-US/alexa/connected-devices/a...
- mcguire 6y agoTwo issues: 1. "...while someone else takes care of the security." That doesn't actually seem likely. 2. Congratulations! You have now invested $N in development costs and glued your business to the side of Amazon's Alexa Division's business decisions.
- wlesieutre 6y agoYup, all your usage data goes through Alexa and Amazon keeps an eye out to decide when it would be worthwhile to make a first-party Alexa coffee maker and eat your entire business
- nogabebop23 6y agoI'm skeptical that Amazon did this out of a genuine concern of IoT security. Seems more likely they wanted to be firmly at the center of all the data acquisition, and while they're no doubt more secure than the average IoT maker they can never be as secure as the act of not collecting the information in the first place. Their new interior security drones are next-level distopian. How long till we're avoiding the Half Life 2 drones inside our own homes?
- IncRnd 6y agowhile someone else takes care of the security It's a shame that isn't true, however. Expecting a magical toolkit to ensure security, just means the application will have vulnerabilities.
- URSpider94 6y agoIt’s not just a toolkit. If you use Amazon’s hardware module, then they manage all of the security of the on-device code as well as the cloud connection, plus traditional vulnerabilities like setup (as demonstrated in TFA). If there are vulnerabilities, then Amazon can patch them via over-the-air updates that they manage. Yes, you can still screw it up, but Amazon takes care of most of the hard bits that people get wrong.
- marcinzm 6y agoThis attack works for a single brand of device if it's either not been configured for wifi yet or you're on the same wifi (and within wifi range or control the router, just access to the wifi isn't enough). So the risk profile to an owner seems negligible. Probably more risk that your coffee maker will have a short circuit and catch on fire. If this is the doomsday scenario then I can see why no one cares.
- mcguire 6y agoThe same could be said for Stuxnet.
- marcinzm 6y agoI don't see how. Stuxnet was able to remotely infect windows machines over the internet and local network while this is a purely physically local attack.
- webmaven 6y ago> I don't see how. Stuxnet was able to remotely infect windows machines over the internet and local network while this is a purely physically local attack. I think the reference was to the payload, which was targeted at the Siemens S7-315-2 programmable logic controller in order to destabilize high frequency drives and thus ruin the centrifuges attached to them.
- marcinzm 6y agoAh. I mean, sure, but it took a state level actor to make use of that against a state level target. So I stand by my statement that for the average user of a coffee pot the risk is negligible.
- Theodores 6y agoYou can throw rocks at the windows of any car, put a banana in the exhaust and put superglue in the locks. You can then say that the designers of the car didn't take security seriously. However, we live in a world where anyone throwing rocks through the car's windows or vandalising the car can be caught to then be given a criminal record, possibly involving time in jail. We need a culture of prosecuting people who vandalise computer systems and a police force able to take these things seriously, working internationally as required. As it is we do victim blaming and cover ups instead. If a server or an IOT gadget gets hacked we restore from backups (and don't tell the client) rather than go after the evil wrong doer. I would prefer to see our efforts go into not just better security (encryption everywhere and best practices) but also into the law and order aspect. In that way we can foster a better environment for citizens and business. Any country that gets this together and goes after hackers will have an advantage when it comes to attracting companies that want to have their web services (and coffee machines) secure.
- axaxs 6y agoI'm perfectly happy with my French Press, and it won't ask for a ransom, I hope.
- mcguire 6y agoI personally prefer an AeroPress---it's easier to clean---but I can understand others having different requirements.
- axaxs 6y agoI guess my point was, our devices are simple because making coffee is simple. I mean, technically you can just make cowboy coffee with no tools at all, but our methods get the grinds out. I never understood the need for most people to have electric machines, but I definitely will never understand the need for them to be network connected!
- lostlogin 6y agoMy 25 year old La Cimbali takes about 30 minutes to warm up. It’s 30kgs or so of brass and steel. Putting a smart plug on it has been great. The relay clicking at 6am makes me happy.
- twodave 6y agoChemex here but similar mindset. I don’t like my coffee going anyplace that I can’t easily clean between brews.
- awinter-py 6y agoI'm unhappy when this happens to my laptop but I'm frankly grateful to live in a world where coffeemakers can become almost literally possessed by demons I'd much rather have the poltergeist coffeemaker than be back in the 80s when there were 10 identical buttons and no display to schedule my VCR to record a show
- rightbyte 6y agoLiterary possesed by daemons.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- goodside 6y agoI’m often a Luddite regarding smart versions of simple electronics, but at least part of the issue is how cumbersome “dumb” versions have become relative to modern software. The knobs on my gas stove are intuitive, yes, but the buttons on my dumb microwave are not. It takes trial-and-error every six months to adjust the clock for DST. I bought a $30 Casio watch recently, specifically for the hourly chime so I don’t miss Zoom meetings while away from my laptop. It works great, but when I wanted to disable the chime on vacation I had to download a large, unsearchable PDF manual on my iPhone because I couldn’t figure it out. And this is an interface that, presumably, has been honed by decades of use by billions of people. It wasn’t enough of an issue to make me consider an Apple Watch or the like, but it’s made me more sympathetic to people who gravitate to modern, frivolous-seeming electronics by default. To a security-naive buyer (i.e., everyone), “smart” often means “usable without a manual”. I imagine this is doubly true for someone younger who isn’t used to electronics with highly constrained UI’s.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoEven if it is usable without a manual, adjusting a timer switch hidden behind the couch using its LCD display and buttons is a lot less comfortable than using an app, if you do it frequently enough. There are things where IoT was added to make them appear more modern, and things where it actually makes sense. For the microwave, for example, I'd argue IoT would still be the wrong choice, because figuring out the magic buttons for setting the time twice a year is less work than dealing with the overhead of IoT (updating their app, managing the account when it breaks, etc.).
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI've operated a bunch of button-equipped microwaves in my life and while changing the clock is a nuisance (and arguably, neither the microwave nor the electric oven should have clocks in the first place!), it's a great interface for its day-to-day use, i.e. heating stuff up. The tactile and audio feedback, coupled with low modality and high reliability, means you can operate it without looking. On the microwaves I owned, I'd start keying in times with one hand while the other hand was still putting the food in, and closing the lid doors would coincide with me pressing <Start>. That's not an experience you can replicate with an app. Phones themselves aren't ergonomic enough, and even if they were, app creators generally don't know how to design ergonomic user interfaces.
- charles_f 6y agoOriginal post: https://decoded.avast.io/martinhron/the-fresh-smell-of-ransomed-coffee/ https://decoded.avast.io/martinhron/the-fresh-smell-of-ranso...
- dang 6y agoChanged to that from https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/09/how-a-hacker-turned-a-250-coffee-maker-into-ransom-machine https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/09/how-a.... Thanks!
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoThe (editorialized) current HN title ("Coffee makers are demanding ransom") implies that this is an in-the-wild attack. It's just another PoC showing that IoT devices tend to have bad security. In-the-wild ransomware would be interesting news because the same fragmentation that makes it unprofitable to secure devices (too few devices sold of each vendor/model for the vendor to invest serious money in security) makes it unprofitable to attack most devices. Ransomware is particularly pointless for non-critical devices like a coffee maker. I could see it working e.g. with something controlling heating that isn't easily bypassable (pay us now, or by the time you get a tech out your pipes will be frozen and your house ruined), or something that can otherwise cause harm before the user can disable it (which is likely rare). With a coffee maker, you can easily unplug the device (preventing it from doing further harm/threatening to burn your house down), put it in a box, and ship it to the vendor to fix it.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoYou understand the technology. The average person does not. The coffee maker can be programmed to tell the user they have to pay or XYZ will happen. Some will believe them and pay.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoThe set of people who have that specific coffee machine is pretty small. The set of people who have that specific machine, will be able to send you the money without calling someone more competent first, yet are not smart enough to unplug it, is simply not worth the criminal's time. What would you make "XYZ" to convince a reasonable number of users to pay you, instead of unplugging the machine and optionally removing it from their house through the nearest window?
- netsharc 6y agoI suppose this PoC shows how bad it can be, and you should ask, would a machine from a "major manufacturer" be any better, or how high do you think the chances are that the product manager from that major manufacturer would just look for the cheapest vendor offering IoT, and would be fooled by the sales people saying "Oh yeah, our software is very secure!" (they'll tell him this lie over the Zoom meeting that has "end to end encryption"...). And showing the face of the devil and saying "Gimme money" is an obvious PoC. In 5 years the error message will be "Problem 0xDF. Please contact support at [scammer's number]". And then? Sending a fake repairman with a hefty bill would take too much time, how about a remote "repair" and a repair bill? "We can send someone out to repair it, but that'll 2 weeks. Or we can do it over the Internet in 5 minutes, but it will cost $10, which would you prefer?".
- kwillets 6y agoI'm coming around to the idea of having a separate VLAN for this stuff.
- lostlogin 6y agoAnd forcing all dns traffic through a Pihole (with the firewall forcing all port 53 back to the Pihole). Google and Samsung to some sneaky stuff and I assume others do too.
- SubiculumCode 6y agoThe minute my French Press tells me I need to perform an update before pressing, I'm done. With everything.
- FpUser 6y agoI do not really understand this obsession that everything has to be connected to a home network and/or the Internet. Not happening in my household.
- bryan0 6y agoReminded me of AvE’s Juicero teardown: https://youtu.be/_Cp-BGQfpHQ https://youtu.be/_Cp-BGQfpHQ Possibly one of the most ridiculous teardowns I’ve ever seen
- nanomonkey 6y agoThe Decent Espresso machines [0] are the only smart coffee makers that seem to be doing something exceptional with their interfaces. Control over temperature, flow, and pressure in real time with pretty graphs seem almost worth the sticker price. Of course knobs and heater indicator lights are usually all you need. [0]https://decentespresso.com/overview https://decentespresso.com/overview
- hereme888 6y agoClickbait
- jliptzin 6y agoI've tried a ton of different electronic coffee makers to try to replace the manual labor of my Chemex but they never taste as good. I'm not willing to sacrifice taste for a little more convenience but I may be in the minority.