3 ms·
Printer dots raise privacy concerns
- akd 18y agoJust buy your printer while you're on a road trip, and pay cash. Wear a hat.
- kirubakaran 18y agoAnd place it in a Faraday cage.
- tstegart 18y agoand don't print the "Pelican Brief" on it
- brk 18y agoThis isn't really new, it's been around/known for several years now. I haven't kept up with the yellow-dots, but this quote in the article piqued my interest: "The Secret Service is the only U.S. body that has the ability to decode the information," Last time I read about this in depth, the yellow dots were basically a printed "braille", and decoding the information they represented was trivially simple.
- jcl 18y agoThe EFF managed to fully decode the code for Xerox DocuColor tracking dots, but there are many other printers whose code is unknown: http://w2.eff.org/Privacy/printers/docucolor/ http://w2.eff.org/Privacy/printers/docucolor/
- brk 18y agoThanks, that was one of the links I remembered reading before.
- tstegart 18y agoThere's an entrepreneurial venture for someone. Decode the dots, and sell your services to private investigators and document companies. I'm sure a lot of companies would be interested to know who printed something. Then that article would read, "The Secret Service and YOU are the only U.S. body that has the ability to decode the information..."
- akd 18y agoThe information is really only valuable if you have the power of law enforcement behind you. What can you do with a printer serial number? You'd need to subpoena Xerox records which would lead you to Staples, then Staples records to find out which credit card had bought the printer and at which store.
- tstegart 18y agoGood point, however, if you own the printer, the information is still valuable. If you have the printer serial number, and own the printer in question, you can find out who may have printed it. Or who in an opposing organization may have printed it, if you're in a legal environment and can request discovery. But you're right, if the printer in question is owned by an unknown third party, you would need the help of law enforcement or Xerox, etc. However, even this would lead to entrepreneurial gain. Without being able to decode the dots, a person in possession of the originals would still not know who printed them. Knowing what printer they were manufactured on and the serial number, a company can now initiate legal action on a manufacturer to get the required information, just like law enforcement does. Today, no one has the codes, but if you did, people would want what you have, no doubt about it.
- t0pj 18y agoProblem with the little yellow dots: I pay cash for a printer and fill out the warranty card with someone else's information that I don't like. I send the warranty info back to the printer company; they now have a record of my neighbor owning the printer in question. Next, start printing out all sorts of illegal stuffs, distribute, and let the good times roll! In summary: Using those little yellow dots to track things or people is just a horrible, horrible idea.
- tectonic 18y agoI'd like to see an open source project to do this. Might raise awareness.
- jcl 18y agoIt's not just printers. Scanners, copiers, and image manipulation software like Photoshop have all had anti-counterfeiting measures quietly added: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation