9 ms·
Let's talk about safety of Pinephone
- eurg 6y agoI've to admit I'm surprised that the battery management is not on a separate IC. While quite a few battery management decisions are better done by software, hard-limits on current/temp/discharge really are not. Am I misinterpreting this?
- willis936 6y agoI don’t know what battery pinephones source, but I am under the impression that all smartphone batteries have a battery management IC that handles safety hard limits internally. Lithium ion inherently needs a lot of care in charging and discharging. You can get lithium ion batteries without smarts attached for RC planes and cars, but those are known to catch fire often since they’re driven so hard :). These battery management ICs will permanently shut down the battery off above a dangerous temperature threshold. Better to kill a battery than to risk a fire.
- solarkraft 6y ago> Lithium ion inherently needs a lot of care in charging and discharging. For longevity this is true, but even the while overcharging the risk of a fire isn't that high nowadays (from what I've seen close to 0 with cylindrical cells). Some pouch cells are even fine when punctured. Of course I want these issues to be fixed to keep Pinephones working and AFAIK the batteries in the Pinephone are of an older model, so maybe they're a bit more dangerous. The author definitely has a point.
- Inhibit 6y agoThat's usually the case in the battery packs. Looks like I'll be ripping apart my battery when I get around to taking out the Pinephone.
- numpad0 6y agoThose chips on the packs are last resort safety, not something to be relied upon daily as charge controllers.
- willis936 6y agoCertainly not. That is what the PMIC is for. It’s up to the developers to responsibly configure the PMIC and that is a real hazard. However, the safety situation might not be as bad the author makes it out to be. I don’t know any better though, and it is always a good idea to know when it comes to safety. It’s an important topic to shine the light on.
- numpad0 6y agoThe author also mentions LCD damage from SoC heat. Could it lead to a runaway from that side? Last time I read about PinePhone, the topic was kill switches hardwired to chip enable pins that also make it impossible to sleep peripherals from main SoC. That was only “weird but okay”, but personally, with this discussions going, this phone and associated ROMs aren’t something I consider anymore.
- jpgvm 6y agoFor RC cars/aircraft etc those are usually incredibly high current LiPo chemistry and wired in series to deliver much higher voltage. The LiIon chemistry used in electronics on the other hand is quite pedestrian and packs are constructed with lower peak current and voltage output. Despite similarity in name they are very different beasts. I'm not all that afraid of a LiIon pack unless it's been sorely mistreated or is a huge EV pack or something. On the other hand I treat LiPos with the utmost respect and get them far away from anything at the first sign of bloating or accidental shorting.
- StavrosK 6y agoYeah, getting your wire cutter arc-welded to the cable because you accidentally touched it to both ends of a LiPo is... fun.
- qchris 6y agoI would love to see a write-up and pictures of that incident. I think a lot of people, probably myself included, don't always give them the respect they deserve, and that would be a really neat story/visual to drive the point home. Obviously, no pressure, but figured I'd express the interest
- StavrosK 6y agoIt's much less interesting than it sounds, I was cutting the connector off to solder on a new one, and the first wire accidentally touched for a moment while I was cutting the second one. There was a huge spark and a big mark on the cutter.
- squarefoot 6y ago> I don’t know what battery pinephones source From the Pinephone wiki: "Battery: Lithium-ion, rated capacity 2800mAh (10.64Wh), typical capacity 3000mAh (11.40Wh) (nominally replaceable with any Samsung J7 form-factor battery)" I guess they're sourcing unmarked Samsung compatible batteries which should be all protected, where should equals to 99.999%. If that's the case, then there's no way malicious software or even firmware could damage it. The protection in those batteries is implemented hardware level; the chip contained in the cell will cut off its connection if it detects either an excessive discharge current (to avoid potential explosion), excessive voltage discharge (to avoid chemical degradation and subsequent charging attempts related dangers), excessive temperature (again to avoid explosion), excessive charging current (... explosion). They are all detected outside of system control, so no need for panic.
- megous 6y agoDefine excessive discharge. In-battery circuit kicks in at 6-8A. Battery is specced for max 1.4A continuous charge/discharge current. With the safety margins in these things, it will probably take 2-3A continuously, too. But can it take 4A for 1 hour? Wanna try? Also, there's no protection against excessive temperature in the battery protection circuit's specification, so not sure where you're taking your information from. It would be nice if people actually used the datasheets that are freely available, since Pinephone is mostly open HW, instead of proclaiming random generalities.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoI for one, would like batteries without built-in IC as we can run the device with external power even after the battery has died, with the battery removed, older phones/tablets where capable of being used with external power with a trivial hack. With current generation devices, once the battery is dead, it requires replacement even to use the device for an application which has constant power supply(e.g. external monitor), especially if it has become a spicy pillow and constant power supply means it can again become a spicy pillow[1]. [1]https://twitter.com/heavyinfo/status/1302310594423345152?s=20 https://twitter.com/heavyinfo/status/1302310594423345152?s=2...
- numpad0 6y agoThere is virtually no batteries without ICs, and, that has nothing to do with whether the device runs without a battery. That’s just a design choice.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y ago>There is virtually no batteries without ICs There are after market batteries w/o battery management ICs like TI Gas Gauge, its up to device on whether it will accept a battery without such IC. >that has nothing to do with whether the device runs without a battery. That’s just a design choice I agree that just having a battery without IC doesn't guarantee that the device would function directly with an external voltage regulated power supply, but a device which accepts only the battery with specific IC makes it difficult or even impossible to run the device that way.
- nsb1 6y agoThese two things are not mutually exclusive. The decision to allow operating without a battery is a mainboard design decision and has very little to do with the protection circuitry on the battery pack. In a device like this, the decision to require the battery as the primary current source is usually due to the high current draw for activities like initial searching for a cell tower. Lithium batteries can source this current easily, but if you want to run without the battery, your charger needs to be able to source that max current as well. Sizing the charger to handle this brief load translates directly to additional product cost, so it is often not done that way. The protection circuitry on the battery pack is designed to protect the cell from charging and discharging situations that may damage the battery. You definitely want those protections in there.
- megous 6y agoIt is separate IC: AXP803
- nerdponx 6y agoIt sounds like Pine should at least issue guidance around these specs for distro devs, even if they don't participate in actually writing the software or configuring the kernel.
- swiley 6y agoI think most distros currently pull from the pine64 kernel repo. There's the end goal of merging things into mainline but lots of bugs are getting fixed quickly so it's a ways off.
- zajio1am 6y agoSeems to me that main difference is that with PinePhone and FLOSS we can see such issue. It is hard to say how many non-free phones have similar hacks. Considering the usual state of embedded software, i would guess that many.
- t0astbread 6y agoAre there safety regulations or certifications for this? If so do smartphones usually pass them and does PinePhone pass them?
- jolux 6y agoThere are an enormous number of regulations around this, if you look at all the regulatory markings on most electronics. UL and Intertek being the biggest ones for electrical safety. I really hope Pine64 has gotten those certifications.
- ColanR 6y agoI wonder, if pinephone were to sell a version that was an ikea-style assemble-it-yourself kit, would that still require those certifications?
- notatoad 6y agoAFAIK one of the reasons phones typically leave logic like this in a binary blob on an IC is because the certification bodies stipulate that not only does a device have to comply with safety standards, but it can't be trivially modifiable by an end-user to violate those standards. If you're marketing a phone where one of the advertised features is the ability to change the operating system, and the operating system is responsible for enforcing electrical safety, i don't really see how that's certifiable.
- SahAssar 6y agoThat's usually for radio emissions, not for stuff like thermals. Radios are much more regulated.
- unnouinceput 6y agoReally? The article's author pet peeve is that all software running on PinePhone start with "no guarantee" or "as is". Tell me, does Apple or Samsung or Microsoft take responsibilities for their shitty software? Because so far I've seen thousands of examples their software bricking / penetrated / ransom-ware etc, and not a single one of them was held accountable in court of law because of that. Apple is the most vertical company, heck they give their software for free and even that one doesn't come with guarantees.
- Shared404 6y ago> The article's author pet peeve is that all software running on PinePhone start with "no guarantee" or "as is". Not really. It's not even that it's a pet peeve, just them pointing out that projects need to keep safety in mind. The author even mentions that they have contributed to PinePhone software.
- unnouinceput 6y agoNot a single software ever written comes with guarantees. And the way he was phrasing sounded like PinePhone is a hot potato while everybody else is chill, while in reality everybody's the same in that regard.
- numpad0 6y agoConsumer protection laws nevertheless hold manufacturers liable. Small part of why doing hardware is hard.
- sangnoir 6y agoWould that be the manufacturer of the software or of the hardware? I don't think any court would blame manufacturers for incidents caused by user-modifications (installing 3rd-party firmware)
- Shared404 6y agoIt doesn't read to me that the author is stating it's a hot potato, I read it as them just saying "hey guys, look out for this."
- stjohnswarts 6y agoThis style of writing is responsible for 41% of the rage on the internet and I hate it. It's as if people forgot how to argue a valid point without becoming a troll. If this is the future of communication standards please someone just sneak up on me and insert an ice pick in my brain stem.
- 0-O-0 6y agoWhat was wrong with it, assuming it's factually correct?
- Causality1 6y agoSeconding this question. If it'd been me writing the article, and all the claims are true, it would've been a profanity-laced screed condemning the entire project as a pack of incompetent morons. It wouldn't charge so we turned off thermal regulation Jesus effing Christ.
- asou 6y agoMove fast and break things ! I recall once a co worker said they'd never use Android again since it froze when trying to call 911. Gives Apple more ammo in their fight against Epic, users expect their phones to work , which Apple can't guarantee if anyone can run whatever binary they find.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- choward 6y agoThe thing that about me the most is how much it's pushing fear without any evidence of something bad actually happening. Has there been a single pinephone that has caught on fire?
- linmob 6y agoI am not aware of any case of fire. So unless it caused such a bad fire, that everybody involved died, I think I would know about it having followed the PinePhone very closely, especially since June for my blog. That said, as the fix seems to be rather trivial, distributions should just check and ship a new kernel if necessary.
- sokoloff 6y ago> When you connect the phone to the dock with monitor connected over HDMI, power consumption jumps by 4W. [raising a battery draw concern which is only rated to 6W] Why would you be running on battery while connected to the dock and an external monitor?! That seems like doing some math without thinking about the practical mechanics of being docked.
- linmob 6y agoYes, I did not get my dock to work with my monitor without even plugging the dock into power.
- Filligree 6y agoIt doesn't matter. There should be nothing an end user can do without disassembling the phone that can make it catch fire. If there is, then someone will do it. And personally, I wouldn't think twice about connecting the HDMI without connecting the power, for five minutes, to get hold of some document. I don't own a Pinephone, and from the looks of this debacle I never will. It doesn't seem that OSS is safe to run in safety-critical contexts.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf the HDMI doesn’t work unless the dock is plugged in, then it absolutely does matter. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24599735 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24599735
- tlamponi 6y ago> I don't own a Pinephone, and from the looks of this debacle I never will. It doesn't seem that OSS is safe to run in safety-critical contexts. Sound rather limited, almost stupid. OSS runs in various safety critical software, FreeRTOS, also Linux and various other projects run in very critical environments, far more critical than a smartphone. https://scholar.google.at/scholar?q=open+source+software+in+safety-critical+systems https://scholar.google.at/scholar?q=open+source+software+in+... https://scholar.google.at/scholar?q=linux+in+safety-critical+systems https://scholar.google.at/scholar?q=linux+in+safety-critical... You know that something is OSS allows letting anybody check this out in the first place, do you really think a proprietary phone is safe from this? There are many reports about iPhones and other smart phones catching fire each year.
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoOh I managed to misread the title, and was wondering how the common fruit can be so dangerous
- Proven 6y agoLibrem's phone suddenly looks a little bit better value for money. I was thinking about buying a PP but I agree with OP, it's a non-trivial risk. Also it seems there are way too many bugs in PP, it's a mobile Raspberry Pi with 20 apps rather than 2, that you have to troubleshoot everywhere you go because it's your phone.