3 ms·
> unfairly strong armed their way into being middle-man for over 40% of Americans What about the actual selling of iPhones counts as "unfair strong-arming"? No
by bobthepanda 6y ago
> unfairly strong armed their way into being middle-man for over 40% of Americans
What about the actual selling of iPhones counts as "unfair strong-arming"? No one's getting their arms twisted to buy a phone they don't want.
- echelon 6y agoConsumers often aren't aware of the impact of their choices. Apple is disrupting our industry. Consumers shouldn't have to change their behavior or learn about a complicated issue in order to restore balance and fairness. The forces at play are so great that the DOJ needs to pull the levers to fix this broken and unfair system.
- savolai 6y agoWho is the ”us” Apple is disrupting? There are arguments why consumers should be able to not have to think about this, and to have what Apple is doing as the default choice. I.e. everything available verified by default as mostly secure. There’s no a priori reason to assume consumers should be aware / educated which places to download from are safe and which ones are not. What should imho perhaps be changed if is the size of the cut, which indeed seems a lot.
- kelnos 6y agoWhen the only mainstream choices are iPhone or Android, and both of those options have significant, non-overlapping pros and cons, it's not like there's much choice. The other option, "don't have a smartphone", is becoming less and less tenable for most people who want to interact in society in a common way. And sure, you could buy something that runs PostmarketOS or whatever, but then you lose access to banking apps and mobile payments and a whole host of other things that are becoming table stakes for a mobile platform.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThe reason there isn't a third OS is because building a good OS and app ecosystem is hard. MS flunked, Blackberry flunked, to name a few heavyweights. Companies winning with good consumer solutions to complex problems isn't arm-twisting in any sense of the word.
- echelon 6y agoThat doesn't give them a right to own 100% of the activities built atop their devices. Not when these platforms capture every conceivable human action or transaction. They should have lost that privilege when their reach grew so broad and deep. (It is a privilege that the US allows them to conduct business, and that can be altered.) If Apple put up a bubble around 40% of all Americans and you wanted to give these folks air to breathe, would you be content to pay Apple 30% or be forced to go through Apple's slow moderation and release control mechanisms? Keep in mind that they may shut off your ability to provide oxygen at any point in the future for any reason. The correct model was Microsoft Windows. You pay to license it, but then you can execute anything you want on top of it. If you want to pay Microsoft to help with distribution, you're free to do so. Microsoft is still making bank. What Apple has done is uniquely controlling and prohibitive. They've captured all computing-related economic activities for a large percentage of the population. You shouldn't be allowed to conduct business like that in the United States.
- pixl97 6y agoYes, but companies entrenching a monopoly position after winning with a good consumer solution is arm-twisting.
- Daishiman 6y agoNot really. Palm had an excellent product. There were a lot of startups that had ideas that are still innovative to this day in that space. They lost because there are very few entities with the capital and manpower that Apple or Google have. A modern successor to WebOS or FirefoxOS would be what I would want as a consumer nowadays. And yes, when more and more interactions with society depend on a smartphone, the basic rules of capitalism don't really satisfy.
- 6y ago
- mhh__ 6y agoShould we assume the purchasers have perfect information? I know what to expect with Apple products, but I don't know many who can really put apple's walled-garden policy into words. It seems like a fairly easy regulation to make it possible to not need to worry about this when buying a phone or computer. You should be able to repair it, you should be able to run what you want on it.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThe purchasers have more information than you give them credit for. Pre-iPhone all loads of garbage were preinstalled on phones by carriers, and phone software was mostly garbage. Part of why iPhone uptake was so large was because Apple specifically refused to let this happen. A lot of non-tech friends I have, have owned Androids before, and anecdotally many don't have good memories of the state of the Android ecosystem around apps. Right to repair I do believe people should have. But that's related on principle but not the same issue at hand.
- Daishiman 6y agoHaving the right to repair is just another aspect of _owning_ the device you have. Apple's app store policy restricts what you can do with your device in a similar manner.
- unethical_ban 6y agoThis is a pitifully naive or disingenuous argument. Even if a "free market" allowed Apple to get where they are, it doesn't mean a society can't say that the current way of things is harmful to the market. Government has a place in regulating network effects.
- bobthepanda 6y agoWell how do you define a "market"? We don't say that every market needs to be perfectly open to everyone; I can't just put my home-baked goods on a Walmart shelf and start selling stuff unilaterally, or even handing them out for free within the store.
- pixl97 6y agoWhen the market becomes a duopoly then they will start falling under antitrust regulations. Walmart is large, but they no where near represent a portion of the retail market that google/apple represents in the phone market.