6 ms·
It's an often repeated fact that steel swords and the like were quite valuable during the middle ages, but it is a revelation that the reason they are so expens
by jandrese 6y ago
It's an often repeated fact that steel swords and the like were quite valuable during the middle ages, but it is a revelation that the reason they are so expensive is that they required hundreds or thousands of man hours chopping trees, managing slow burning fires, carting ore and wood around, etc... Modern media always just focuses on the last step (and usually gets it completely wrong to boot) while ignoring the small army of peasants needed to produce the raw materials for that smith to work into the sword/axe/helmet/etc...
- 01100011 6y agoDoesn't history generally ignore the contributions of legions of lower class to any of man's great achievements?
- AlotOfReading 6y agoThe kind of history you see on television and in general textbooks usually does. The omission has been recognized for a long time though, hence "social histories".
- InitialLastName 6y agoThe goal of this whole series (and the last one, about bread) is to in some part rectify that demonstrating and explaining the economics of the process from a more labor-oriented perspective.
- libraryofbabel 6y agoTo expand on others’ comments, popular history may still do this, but professional academic history got over that a long time ago. The subfield that deals with the experiences of ordinary people and “bottom-to-top” complete pictures of a society is called Social History. Social History is now over 60 years old (one of the most brilliant and influential books in this tradition, E.P. Thompson’s Making of the English Working Class, is from 1963), and Social History has shaped the perspective of pretty much every professional historian writing in the last half century, whether they were for or against the key ideas. The intellectual debt is to (non-doctrinaire) Marxism, later supplemented with a health dose of anthropology (which led to the related field of cultural history). Basically the Social Historians more or less won, although the naive “great men great events” approach remained strong in popular history outside the academy. Social History was and is enormously influential among professional historians, probably the most influential intellectual shift in the history business in the last 100 years. (All people, everywhere, make history! A powerful message!) The author of this blog is a great practitioner of the social history tradition but it’s not a novel approach per se. That said, there should be more social history blogs! This blog regularly hits the front page of hacker news; people love this stuff!
- kbenson 6y agoSure, but in the same way, what about all the little things that go into making a pencil today? Usually, as long as there is a market, you can break down all those hours of gathering materials into the concept of "buy X at market price". It only starts looking unbelievably complex when you take control of every single stage and step, and are thus doing the equivalent of running multiple enterprises. That was probably more common in a feudal society, but not a given. I'm sure a lot of producers just bought the materials they needed.
- zeveb 6y ago> It only starts looking unbelievably complex when you take control of every single stage and step, and are this doing the equivalent of running multiple enterprises. Yup, and that's a good part of the problem with central planning and autarky. There is just too much going on for any one decision-maker to effectively handle. There is a lesson there for large companies, I think. OTOH, go too far with decentralisation and you have Google's 8 or 9 different messaging systems …
- Retric 6y agoThat’s not really the issue with planning. Tracking the inputs to a process is fairly simple, it’s the output that’s really the issue. Diminishing returns makes it really difficult to how when to stop. Large companies often waste increasing amounts of money on internal processes because there is no mechanism to moderate the behavior. Markets can be summed up as discovering the value of the Nth of each and every little thing. And strangely enough you can use them with central planning. NYC could set the number of Taxi medallions based on their market price.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Usually, as long as there is a market, you can break down all those hours of gathering materials into the concept of "buy X at market price". It only starts looking unbelievably complex when you take control of every single stage and step But that's not what we're talking about. A medieval sword is expensive because making one requires thousands of hours of labor. Making a modern pencil has a lot of steps, but requires probably less than ten seconds of labor. Pencils are cheap. The number of steps is not relevant to anything. The complexity isn't hugely relevant either, though more so than the number of steps.
- legitster 6y agoI remember an article on HN once about medieval clothes. The reason people only usually owned one or two complete sets was that a single shirt could be the equivalent of thousands of dollars worth of labor in today's money.
- howlgarnish 6y agoPerhaps this: https://www.sleuthsayers.org/2013/06/the-3500-shirt-history-lesson-in.html https://www.sleuthsayers.org/2013/06/the-3500-shirt-history-... And yup, it took around 600 hours of labor to spin the thread and weave the cloth needed for a single shirt.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI am loving the series and yeah this does kind of sum it up. Based on the numbers given in this installment it seems like it would take a couple of months for one person to cut enough wood, and collect enough ore, to create a sword. (assuming they had access to the natural resources, and they had the physicality to do the labor, and the skill in smithing to craft the sword. Big assumption that) Using comparative economics, you could ask what would you have to sell something for to cover all of your expenses for two months? (food, housing, everything) Noting that if you're doing that much manual labor you are probably eating like an athlete in training (i.e. a LOT). Pretty sobering.
- dboreham 6y agoEven beer required a large amount of energy to make, usually from trees or coal.