10 ms·
Belief in Conspiracy Theories Is a Barrier to Controlling Spread of Covid-19
- vixen99 6y agoThe thrust of this piece is exactly what you'd expect from an agenda-driven left-leaning organization like the Annenberg Public Policy Center. Of course people with limited analytical skills might ride to town on the basis of a conspiracy theory but that says nothing about its validity. Given the very detailed genetic analyses in at least two published papers that I've seen (plenty more), the theory that someone engineered Covid is far from being a ridiculous proposition. One of the papers states: "Judging from the evidence that we and others have gathered, we believe that finding the origin of SARS-CoV-2 should involve an independent audit of the WIV P4 laboratories and the laboratories of their close collaborators. Such an investigation should have taken place long ago and should not be delayed any further.". A reasonable suggestion I would have thought. The takeaway from the Annenberg piece is that only (nutty) conservatives take this kind of thing seriously. https://capitalresearch.org/article/dishonest-fact-checkers/ https://capitalresearch.org/article/dishonest-fact-checkers/
- blitz_skull 6y agoBut of course you’ll get down-voted into oblivion for having rationale thoughts that don’t align with mainstream ideologies today.
- bitdizzy 6y agoI don't think you're speaking in good faith if you don't think the grandparent is speaking from the point of view of an extremely mainstream belief in the dishonesty of "agenda-driven left-leaning organizations".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 6y agoEven if it were found to be artificially created, how would that change what's necessary to control the virus? Are you saying that if proof were found it was created in a lab that people would suddenly start wearing masks happily?
- ColanR 6y agoI think if there wasn't a media blackout on any unapproved theories about the virus, the media and the approved experts would be somewhat more trusted.
- adrianN 6y agoThere is no media blackout. The media is simply reporting what is the general consensus among professionals. Mainstream news is not a good avenue for discussing theories supported by a single paper or two.
- mistermann 6y ago> There is no media blackout. If there was an effective media blackout on something, how would you know? > The media is simply reporting what is the general consensus among professionals. It is true that the media reports "general consensus among professionals", but is it perfectly true that this is what they are "simply" (just, only) doing? Human cognition has several flaws like this - it seems to very much behave in real time (when reckoning at the object level) like it considers itself to be omniscient, so falls victim to many things like "Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence"[1]. This is just one example of many that can be regularly observed in media and forum conversations, even on HN (whose participants are human beings let's not forget). I think if we were to spend more time considering world events from a more abstract, "zoomed out" perspective, perhaps we could break out of this never ending loop. So, instead of arguing about whether <IssueX> or <PersonA> "is" right or wrong, try to understand why people are forming the beliefs they hold, which then introduces a whole bunch of complexity into what appears to be (because of the nature of human cognition) a very simple situation. If we were also to document these learnings and add to and refine the list over time, I propose that a much clearer picture of just what the fuck is going on here would emerge. But instead, we repeat this simplistic process of "News event --> shallow analysis from biased perspectives --> form hasty conclusion that reinforces preexisting beliefs --> End" over and over, and we don't seem to realize we are doing this, because we are always reckoning about things at the object level. If you look closely, it's not too hard to see that this is quite similar (but not identical) to the approach the media takes to presenting the news as well, intentionally or not. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance
- ColanR 6y agoI've seen similar research indicating artificial origins, and one of the foremost experts in the relevant field came out and said there was no way this wasn't man made.
- gameswithgo 6y agowhich expert?
- temptemptemp111 6y agoPropaganda hits the front page of HN immediately, as usual.
- readingnews 6y agoI may or may not agree with this document or this website (never heard of them), but honestly, I am genuinely shocked at the number of people I run into both on the street and at my workplace (a university of higher learning) that absolutely believe that COVID-19 is a conspiracy. They are hell bent on not wearing masks, think this is all a load, and that we should ignore everything anyone from CDC (or any medical doctor that does not agree with them for that matter) says about it. I'm still baffled every day at the depths of our own misguided thoughts and beliefs.
- habanany 6y agoI may or may not agree with this document or this website (never heard of them), but honestly, I am genuinely shocked at the number of people I run into both on the street and at my workplace (a university of higher learning) that does not believe that COVID-19 is conspiracy. They are hell bent on that everybody should wear masks, don’t think this is all a load, and that we should ignore everything anyone outside the CDC (or any medical doctor that does not agree with them for that matter) says about it. I'm still baffled every day at the depths of our own misguided thoughts and beliefs. ️
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wyldfire 6y agoIt's a direct result of membership in a cult of personality. :(
- gameswithgo 6y agoI think this trend started with the Internet becoming mainstream, not with Trump. Trump has certainly encouraged and leveraged it though. Not sure if on purpose or just because he happens to be one of them.
- adrianN 6y agoWhich personality would that be? These people exist in every country.
- x87678r 6y ago> Nearly 1 in 4 (24%) believed in March that some in the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or CDC, are exaggerating the danger posed by the virus in order to damage Donald Trump’s presidency, which increased to 32% in July; Even I believe that one. It really didn't help when public health officials banned outdoor gatherings, but BLM protests were OK.
- ReptileMan 6y agoI don't know whether this is true, but I think that the freak out and measures are grossly disproportionate compared to the danger of the virus.
- PestoDiRucola 6y agoWhile I agree with what BLM protests were protesting against, they did pick the worst possible time to do so. Especially because, numbers in hand, COVID has killed and will kill more people than police brutality would.
- xphilter 6y agoI don't really follow your comment. Here's a paper that concludes that BLM protests had (have) no effect on Covid case growth in the population: https://www.nber.org/papers/w27408 https://www.nber.org/papers/w27408 "Likewise, while it is possible that the protests caused an increase in the spread of COVID-19 among those who attended the protests, we demonstrate that the protests had little effect on the spread of COVID- 19 for the entire population of the counties with protests during the more than five weeks following protest onset."
- eej71 6y agoI think many people look at that logic (that those large BLM protests were safe) and wonder why it can't be applied to more mundane activities such as the US Open. It comes across as blatantly partisan and not the least bit driven by the science.
- motohagiography 6y agoThe plan for solving a society wide problem that doesn't work if some people believe stupid things is a stupid plan. Let's stop spending time on counterfactual complaining and focus on what a serious solution looks like.
- holidayacct 6y agoConspiracy theories are a way for people to create rationale when they experience cognitive dissonance. Almost all conspiracy theories can be disproved if you consider if they are: 1.) Reasonable given the circumstances. (i.e. is there a simpler way to achieve the same ends) 2.) Is the conspiracy theory possible when adjusted for behavioral biology, neuroscience, physics and mathematics. 3.) Is it possible that sufficiently advanced technology is involved but has not been made public. There are many conspiracy theories that can be simply explained by technology that is possible but has not been made public. For instance you can make people paranoid by repeatedly having people walk by them talking about what is going on in their home. The problem is the technology to view and listen into people's homes has been available since the 1970s and is available now for less than $5000. You can modify millimeter wave technology for this purpose today. If the above two conditions hold true, you need to seriously consider the idea that some of the things that sound like conspiracy theory might be factual. You can't label everything a conspiracy theory, some of it is just crazy people who need a reason for things they don't want to take the time out to find a rational explanation for.
- shireboy 6y agoI think an important flaw in this survey is that it assumes people's belief in each element is 100% true or false, or without nuance. I prefer to think in percentages when it comes to these theories, and think many do. A few Chinese scientists came forward recently suggesting the lab-grown theory again. This put my personal "likelihood meter" up a few % points that the thing came from a lab (but still well below 50% since there is no smoking gun), and according to this, it sounds like others may have done similar. That people are politicizing the virus on all sides is 100% certainty. All you have to do is read the news- that's not a conspiracy theory. The degree to which any given aspect (mask effectiveness, CFR, HCQ, etc.) is subject to those politics varies. At least in my circles, most people seem to understand there are legitimate risks and mitigations like masks, quarantine, etc. work to some degree. Again, they believe this on a spectrum. Most people are somewhere between "lick all doorknobs" and "sleep in full body respirator". The pharma industry creating the virus is the least likely scenario IMO (~0%), but again, it doesn't take much imagination to see pharma making money on all this. I don't even necessarily see anything wrong with that, as long as it's done honestly. All that to say, the premise of the article is flawed in that it doesn't account for the full range of belief in these "conspiracy theories". Also, what is the alternative? Unquestioning belief in whom?
- danoloan 6y agoif only they hadn't reasons to believe them
- insickness 6y ago> U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or CDC, are exaggerating the danger posed by the virus in order to damage Donald Trump’s presidency, which increased to 32% in July; It's not a conspiracy to suggest that people are exaggerating the danger posed by the virus. There are many factions, political and otherwise, that have a vested interest to do so, particularly in an election year. To file any exaggeration in the danger of covid as conspiracy is exactly what makes people disbelieve more legitimate science sources.
- Nbox9 6y agoI think the best way to stop belief in conspiracy theories is to decrease the number of real conspiracies. From Watergate to Epstein it’s shown that people in power commonly abuse their own power. From Enron to Purdue Pharma it’s shown that some Americans will indirectly kill other Americans for profit. I’m not sure how we reduce political corruption or individual greed pursed with morals abandoned. However, I think that’s where the conversation should be around. I can’t blame people for believing China manufactured and unleashed a bio weapon that causes a disease we call Covid-19, that’s on par for the type of evil things other people are doing in the world.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoOne way would be to have less institutional power and a society where power is more decentralised. But we're going in the opposite direction. Probably straight to 1984.
- boredumb 6y agoAnd to that I would say the lack of nuance in almost every media outlet, covid-19 coverage not being exclusive to this, gives conspiracy theories a lot more weight and consideration. With the recent protests and riots in the US spawned a thousand conspiracies by having news agencies attempting to downplay any criminal activity in the protests by standing in front of burning buildings and telling the audience this was the result of a peaceful protest, queue the theories of people pulling strings in the media to provide cover and drive a communist uprising.
- recursivedoubts 6y agoPerhaps if the elites expected the public to trust them on this particular issue, they should not have lied, obfuscated and concealed so many times in the past. Social trust has been completely wiped out, by the same elites complaining about it. “In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function. We make men without chests and expect of them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.” --CS Lewis
- jlokier 6y agoPart of the problem is it's not the "same elites" with the level of consistency that phrasing implies. A group of people with some vaguely common perceived status are lumped together as "elites". Some of them have lied, obfuscated, concealed so many times. Others are trying to do good things in the world, and are consistent about that to the best of their ability in a difficult world. But we reason about them all as if they are single unit. Same problem as any other kind of lumping people together into a named group - men, woman, white, black, etc. It leads to false conclusions. But we love doing it, because it's a simpler model of the world than reasoning about the complex interplay of individuals.
- recursivedoubts 6y agoTrue, but we can't expect the average person to keep track of all of this. This is why the elites in general need to act in the interest of the public frequently enough for trust in the system to remain. It's easy to blame "stupid people" and "the internet" but it seems perfectly rational to me for the average person to view anything coming from elite institutions with scepticism, at best.
- jlokier 6y agoGenerally I agree with you, but I think it's useful and important to keep highlighting there's no such single unit as "the elites", so that people might take that into account when applying their skeptical thinking. There is no need for people to keep track of "all this" in detail with individuals and so forth. It's already a big skeptical improvement just to take on board the idea that vaguely labelled groups are a misleading simplification, and to think in terms of the interplay of very different individuals as taking place. For a start, that results in applauding good works (for whatever you consider good) when you see them, rather than applauding which party a person is aligned with. The result would be more sensible politics, imho. Another thing which comes from that, is you then don't blame person A for person B's misdeeds just because A and B are both inside some labelled group you have defined by convenience. That way lies blaming all "X people" for some "X people"'s behaviour, and that's not as effective as focusing on the actual bad behaviour, as well as being arguably unjust. I personally don't blame "stupid people" or call people that often, mainly because I think a lot of people who are not stupid still commit the cardinal error of hashing things out in public with vague group labels. Sometimes people could never agree on which actual people are part of those vague groups, but gloss over that as though it's irrelevant, and still reason about the vague group itself as if it's an object in the world with a coordinated intention. Sometimes it is, often it isn't. I do slightly blame some aspects of "the internet" a bit these days, because, like a lot of people, I'm seeing indications that the social media process appears to be amplifying a polarisation feedback process that is independent of the actual issues, and might be becoming more powerful than our evolved human instincts for a healthy balance of group harmony vs conflict. As an internet idealist from the old days, though, I'd rather we study that and learn ways to improve on it.
- nomorenyt 6y agoThis is not covid news. It is hackernews. This article doesn't touch on anything startups or tech. It is purely partisan propaganda and is divisive. Please don't post this material
- jcbrand 6y agoAccording to the article, if you believe that "CDC, are exaggerating the danger posed by the virus in order to damage Donald Trump’s presidency" then you're believing in a conspiracy theory. As someone living in Europe, I don't care two hoots about Trumps presidency, but I do think that the danger of this virus, and the current responses have been exaggerated. In the beginning, when so many things were unknown, it was perfectly understandable and appropriate to overreact. But now that it's largely clear that this virus is not much more lethal than the flu, (and that with the recent surge in cases in Europe, the deaths have remained largely flat), I struggle to understand the fear-mongering and hand-wringing. My guess is, instead of a conspiracy, it's a case of a massive sunk cost fallacy, whereby politicians and high profile celebrity epidemiologists etc. can't admit that they were wrong in their original estimations.
- x87678r 6y ago> My guess is, instead of a conspiracy, it's a case of a massive sunk cost fallacy, whereby politicians and high profile celebrity epidemiologists etc. can't admit that they were wrong in their original estimations. Absolutely. Remember though the original push was to isolate to the bend the curve so that hospitals could cope. Now hospitals have spare capacity but we're still isolating. The story changed.
- gdubs 6y agoInteresting that only 76% of the non-conspiracy-believing group intend to take a vaccine. Curious how that compares to the same group’s intention to take, say, a flu vaccine. E.g., some may not be able to take one, others may not want to. [2] Vaccine is an interesting one because there’s the conspiracy side — vaccines will be microchipped, a way for Bill Gates to control the population, etc — and then there’s the general skepticism over the safety of something done quickly. The latter is why the drug makers came together recently with a statement saying they would not cut corners on safety. It stems in large part from the White House pushing a message that a vaccine will be available before the November elections, in contradiction with public health experts who have consistently said it will take longer. Personally, I think health agencies should be given some latitude in an emerging, novel pandemic. Mistakes are inevitable. Course corrections are inevitable. But in times of so much active disinformation, contradicting and tarnishing the agencies tasked with reigning in the pandemic is incredibly dangerous. 2: On closer re-reading, this number was over 80% in the spring.
- ilaksh 6y agoI will just say as a precursor that I believe the masks have been a prudent precaution. But I am not 100% convinced about the shutdown of the economy. I'll start at the beginning to try to explain how my worldview is different from many people here. The treatment of the topic in this article appears to assume that simply by labelling these beliefs as conspiracy theories, they are disproven. Why else would beliefs that are held by such a large portion of the public apparently be dismissed out of hand? There is no other explanation given. They are labelled as conspiracy theories and therefore are not true by default. In my very different worldview, describing these ideas as "conspiracy theories" makes me suspect even more that at least some of them may have an element of truth. Because historically that description has been used for many government actions that they wanted to cover up. So in my worldview, even the term "conspiracy theory" is potentially a manipulation, and a significant number of conspiracy theories are true instances of government malignment. Normally many of these are acknowledged to some degree up to a certain historical distance. So if you are interested then you can research further to understand my point of view better.
- throwmeaway_pls 6y agoNo need to tiptoe. It’s been six months. You can call it bullshit and demand a real plan instead of a political escape plan.
- jb775 6y agoThe term "conspiracy theory" has evolved over the last few years into a tool to criticize people who think too far outside the box. It plays on the dynamics of social group theory, and is being used by the left to ostracize any person who brings up topics they don't want to discuss. It's also an easy unconscious fallback when cognitive dissonance kicks in. Keep in mind Christopher Columbus was labeled the equivalent of a conspiracy theorist when he stated the Earth was actually round.
- diabeticApe 6y agoYou're not the only one and i can think of at least a few others who are both aware and well connected. Im just stepping into the ring myself after a long time on the sidelines. Any chance youd be willing to discuss this further in private?