4 ms·
It's more gray than that. Some governments and some agencies do enough evil that the decision to do business with them is a moral choice. ICE may be one of th
by alistairSH 6y ago
It's more gray than that.
Some governments and some agencies do enough evil that the decision to do business with them is a moral choice.
ICE may be one of those agencies. NSA likewise.
Arguably contacting with the US military falls in a similar bucket. I wouldn't call it evil, but it exists almost solely to enforce American interests abroad (vs a purely defensive force). I wouldn't fault somebody for seeing that business as immoral.
There's also a huge difference between selling a product to that agency, but is not specific to that agency (Word, Linux tech support) vs something that exists only to enable that organization to do bad (spying equipment, the cages used to imprison immigrants, etc).
- bluecalm 6y agoYou can always convince yourself something is evil enough. ICE has a lot of support which at least means it's not universally seen as evil. Making a decision to not work with someone who represents widely accepted views/policy is the definition of politicizing. Same goes for military. If it should be a purely defensive force it one ensuring global interests is a polarizing political issue. It's not simply evil or good.
- alistairSH 6y agoICE may have support. But I don’t support forced sterilization. Or splitting families. And I’m sad that a substantial portion of my fellow citizens are ok with either.
- bluecalm 6y agoThey are not ok with it. They just understand the blame is not on ICE or US policies but on immigrants and their countries. If your policy is: "if you come illegally we will jail you and send you back when possible but we are also human enough to not keep children in the same adult jail as you" and then you come anyway the blame is on you. I don't think anyone is ok with forced sterilization. I don't really know why you put it on ICE or the immigration policy. It has to be investigated and from the information we have that it doesn't seem to be either widespread nor as simple as you portray it. Sure, investigate it, punish the offenders. It doesn't mean you owe stuff to all comers and have to take care of them.