5 ms·
This! Which is why I absolutely reject Epic et al’s position. They want to be part of a small exclusive group of store owners who get to share in the benefits
by zepto 6y ago
This!
Which is why I absolutely reject Epic et al’s position.
They want to be part of a small exclusive group of store owners who get to share in the benefits of Apple’s investments.
Very different from the device freedom you are calling for.
It must also be said that device freedom cannot come at the cost of security and trust.
I and presumably you, have the capability to make good decisions about what software to trust.
Most people must delegate this to a trusted third party.
I would support a legal requirement for iOS devices to have a bootcamp equivalent.
That way Epic and whoever else wants to build their own platform would be free to do so.
- bogwog 6y ago> Which is why I absolutely reject Epic et al’s position. > They want to be part of a small exclusive group of store owners who get to share in the benefits of Apple’s investments. Can you clarify what you mean by this?
- judge2020 6y agohttps://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-epic-games/apple-says-fortnite-maker-wanted-side-letter-to-create-own-game-store-idUSKBN25H2JD https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-epic-games/apple-sa...
- bogwog 6y agoI don't see how that's relevant. Epic isn't suing Apple so that they can have exclusive rights to open a second app store, they're suing to allow third-party app stores in general. If Epic wins, they aren't going to be part of a small group of store owners; anyone would be able to open their own competing store.
- judge2020 6y agoSo if Apple had entertained the original pre-lawsuit request, would epic have fought until Apple allowed app stores other than Epic and Apple existing?
- lern_too_spel 6y agoWhat does it matter? They're fighting for something that benefits everybody (except Apple) now.
- zepto 6y agoThere is no evidence that what they are fighting for would benefit anyone other than a small group of already rich companies.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoThere is plenty of evidence from Android that it would benefit both users and developers.
- zepto 6y agoAndroid is not a model for this. Stores on Android simply don’t have equal footing with the play store. Epic is suing Google too over this.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoEpic is suing Google for pressuring OEMs against preinstalling its app store on devices, not for preventing users from installing its app store themselves. It's true that app stores not signed with the system key can't automatically update apps, and users would benefit even more if they could, but users already benefit from being able to install apps outside of the official app store at all.
- zepto 6y agoYou just confirmed my point. Android app stores other than google play aren’t remotely on a level playing field with the Play store.
- zepto 6y agoAlmost no stores will be able to compete with Facebook, Google, Amazon, etc, who already have giant reach and network effects, Consumers will have to deal with them all, as will developers. There will be a small group of store owners.
- bogwog 6y ago> Almost no stores will be able to compete with Facebook, Google, Amazon, etc, who already have giant reach and network effects, First of all, that is not true at all. And second, even if it were true, it'd be a far better situation for developers than the current status quo.
- zepto 6y agoHaving to deal with multiple stores would be strictly worse for developers than the current situation.
- matwood 6y agoAnd worse for consumers. No way I'm dealing with entering my CC again and again. The current situation is not perfect, but it does have advantages for both consumers and developers.
- donmcronald 6y agoReally? Microsoft, Amazon, Google, and Apple already have my CC number. If I could buy all my apps through (ex:) the Microsoft store that exists on PC, Android, and iOS I could delete my CC info from Google and Apple. That's a win in my book. Maybe the competition would force all of them to innovate a bit. Wouldn't it be nice if you could give your CC number, but set a hard limit on in-app purchases? Ex: Here's my CC, but you're not allowed to charge more than $50 / month to it. I bet there are a lot of people that have gotten multi thousand dollar IAP bills that wouldn't mind a better system for some of that stuff.
- giantrobot 6y ago
- kodablah 6y ago> They want to be part of a small exclusive group of store owners who get to share in the benefits of Apple’s investments. Exclusive? Why can't I write an app store?
- zepto 6y agoFor the same reason you can’t build a phone. You’ll be competing with multi-billion dollar corporations who have exclusive content and nobody will bother with your store.
- FreeFull 6y agoOn Android there is the F-Droid software repository, and there is no issue of competition with the Play Store. Would things be different on Apple phones?
- abc-xyz 6y agoAndroid also have a lot of malware issues. I’ve had to help factory reset Android phones quite a few times because friends and family ended up getting spammed with sex notifications and had their search engine hijacked. Windows and OSX suffers from the same problems. The reason these platforms suffer from malware, while iOS does not, is because they allow third-party installations.
- FreeFull 6y agoFrom what I've seen, the majority of Android malware either comes from Google's Play Store, or gets included on the phones by certain OEMs. F-droid in particular, due to its open source requirement, hasn't ended up hosting any malware so far.
- abc-xyz 6y agoF-Droid is even more locked down than the App Store, and even if they turned it into the default app store then Android would still be riddled with malware. As to how the Android users keep acquiring malware, I have no idea whether it’s from the Play Store, or if they download free apk files of paid apps, or if they download it through ads or from emails or whatever. I just know I have to help fix them regularly, and if iOS is forced to open up then iPhones will suffer from the same malware issues that you see with OSX/Windows/Android.
- headmelted 6y ago"They want to be part of a small exclusive group of store owners who get to share in the benefits of Apple’s investments" False. Epic made very clear, early on, IN THEIR COURT FILING that their case was an attempt to legally force Apple and Google to allow for third party app stores to exist equitably on iOS and Android. Does that benefit Epic substantially? Of course it does. They want a mobile Epic Games Store on both platforms. But it would also break the stranglehold duopoly that Google and Apple have over the mobile software marketplace. Example to prove the point: Nothing in Epic's proposals or court filing would prevent Steam Mobile or the Microsoft App Store from launching on iOS and Android on the same terms that Epic prevailed on in court. That's about as far away from anti-competitive behaviour as this court case could possibly hope to be.
- zepto 6y agoNothing I said is false. Third party stores will not exist equitably on iOS and Android because there don’t exist equitably anywhere else. I said a small group, not just Epic. That group would be made up of the usual suspects - Epic, Amazon, Google, Facebook, various other TenCent properties etc. Nothing about it would make it either developer friendly, nor consumer friendly.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoAndroid is already both more developer friendly and more consumer friendly than iOS despite not having full automatic update support for third party app stores. If that were in place, it would be even better.