11 ms·
If users didn’t want these things, users wouldn’t buy them. For the vast majority of people, and iPhone is way, way better than a computer that can run any app
by sneak 6y ago
If users didn’t want these things, users wouldn’t buy them.
For the vast majority of people, and iPhone is way, way better than a computer that can run any app, precisely because it can’t run any app they click on.
I’m a hacker, so I would love to be able to install any software I want on my iPhone, and introspect it in other ways.
Most users, however, would have a way worse experience using their phone if they were given this option, because a non-trivial percentage of them would follow the tutorials online provided to them by malware authors to install their malware.
This is precisely what happened to desktop computers. Has everyone forgotten about Bonsai Buddy?
People who want a general purpose, configurable device that can run any code they want on it have options. They’re big, clunky, out of date phones.
Apple is being punished for their success here. They happen to make the best phone hardware at the moment, and they bundle the best phone hardware with cryptographically-enforced editorial decisions about the best software that runs on it.
I think the real danger here is that of censorship: if the state commands Apple to delete (or actively remote-disable) certain apps, a huge problem exists. Today it’s WeChat or TikTok. What if tomorrow it’s Signal? iMessage’s encryption has already been backdoored for the feds in the default configuration via iCloud Backup (which is not end to end encrypted and backs up the entirety of chat history from the device to Apple each night). The state could literally command Apple to prohibit any type of secure communication from the device via this method and they’d have to comply, and iPhone-owners would have no recourse due to the DRM. That’s the real danger.
There’s a real argument to not allowing Apple to do this, but I don’t think “consumer choice” is it. Consumer choice chose the walled garden over the anarchy of Desktop Computer Malware.
- bad_good_guy 6y agoIts a lot simpler than users wanting a device that 'cant run any app they click on'. The vast vast majority of users don't consider anything except the marketing. And apple is good at marketing. So people want iOS devices.
- pb7 6y agoMarketing only works for the first generation of purchases. Apple has the highest consumer satisfaction ratings year after year so when a new product comes out, consumers know they will get a product they will be really happy with. That is not the case with many other companies.
- Razengan 6y ago> The vast vast majority of users don't consider anything except the marketing. If marketing was all that mattered, and Apple's products were actually disappointing, they would not have repeat customers or high satisfaction after the purchase: https://www.macrumors.com/2020/09/22/apple-tops-customer-satisfaction-charts/ https://www.macrumors.com/2020/09/22/apple-tops-customer-sat... and please, stop speaking for a "vast vast majority" of people, as if you're an authority on why other people do what they do.
- damnyou 6y agoYes, this is partly about Apple being "punished" for its success. That is a good thing. Entities that are too successful become too powerful and should be "punished" for it.
- flenserboy 6y agoApple's advertising is built on security and privacy — allowing other App Stores on their system would only open up users to invasive tracking & attacks. I want my desktop system to be open as can be; I'm perfectly happy with my phone being (somewhat) locked down. That said, Apple could allow users to choose to install other App Stores on their devices, but at the cost of their devices being considered hopelessly compromised and no longer eligible for support from Apple. Let the market decide: a wider variety of games/apps, or a (fairly) secure system with attached privacy promises.
- xlii 6y agoIsn't this what's the Jailbreak is about? You can jailbreak device, Apple still will have to respect the guarantee but they don't have to support you whatsoever. Sure, Apple patch it, but then those are true vulnerabilities that are used to jailbreak it. Maybe they should just have a switch somewhere that would go "enable unsupported mode" that'd show a lot of angry texts at you before allowing you to do that. That'd solve most of the coalition claims probably. Epic can always put their software on Cydia...
- freedomben 6y ago> Apple's advertising is built on security and privacy — allowing other App Stores on their system would only open up users to invasive tracking & attacks. But why? If sideloading requires explicit user action and acknowledgment of danger, why would this affect their brand of safety and privacy in any way? The users who want a safe controlled environment can easily choose to stay in that environment. I just do not understand this argument.
- edmundsauto 6y agoBecause these users, regardless of what they previously clicked, will expect Apple to support it. And end to end support is kind of one of the big deals about the iPhone.
- shagie 6y ago(supporting this point) You can see this sort of thing in an old post by Joel on https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/06/13/how-microsoft-lost-the-api-war/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/06/13/how-microsoft-lost... This references an even older blog post (that has been lost to time) which was quoted: > Look at the scenario from the customer’s standpoint. You bought programs X, Y and Z. You then upgraded to Windows XP. Your computer now crashes randomly, and program Z doesn’t work at all. You’re going to tell your friends, “Don’t upgrade to Windows XP. It crashes randomly, and it’s not compatible with program Z.” Are you going to debug your system to determine that program X is causing the crashes, and that program Z doesn’t work because it is using undocumented window messages? Of course not. You’re going to return the Windows XP box for a refund. (You bought programs X, Y, and Z some months ago. The 30-day return policy no longer applies to them. The only thing you can return is Windows XP.) This is the same sort of thing that Apple faces with iOS. If an application breaks when the system is upgraded, it is the system's fault - not the application (at least in the minds of many consumers) and it is also considered to be the responsibility of the operating system vendor to fix the problem. (This is part of why the Catalina upgrade was such a big deal because it was known that they'd break a lot of things in doing that) If someone gets an app from a hypothetical 3rd party vendor store, and it breaks on an update of the operating system (or allows you to download an app that doesn't run) - its seen as company that wrote the OS's fault even though there is nothing that the company that wrote the OS can do about it - they can't even refund the app.
- uryga 6y ago> If users didn’t want these things, users wouldn’t buy them. doesn't follow. people buying a thing despite flaw X just means don't consider X a dealbreaker, not that they actually want X
- Razengan 6y ago..What? If X isn't a dealbreaker, then obviously customers are fine with X. If they weren't, it would be a dealbreaker.
- teddyh 6y agoThere is a vast gulf of nuance between “fine” and “dealbreaker”.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoAnd that gulf is different for everyone. You can’t dictate it to others.
- Razengan 6y agoIf it’s a “””dealbreaker””” then you’re not okay with it. If it’s not a dealbreaker then you’re okay with it. How many different ways do you want to twist this? If any of this mattered to anyone outside this echo chamber then Apple wouldn’t constantly come at #1 in customer surveys.
- simion314 6y ago>Most users, however, would have a way worse experience using their phone if they were given this option, because a non-trivial percentage of them would follow the tutorials online provided to them by malware authors to install their malware. I think Apple fans exagerrate when they say that most users are so "inexperienced" to get taken advantage off. - this number of completly inexperienced user is not proven to be as large, if you look at Android or OSX you don't see 51% of users having malware on their machine - with the amount of money Apple has they could afford to improve the security by adding more sand boxing and making unlocking of the phone by "tricked incompetent users almost impossible" - I assume apps and websites can use your microphone and camera on your phone, it is under soem popup/permission prompt, why do you trust the "inexperienced users" with the camera permissions some bad person could trick them. - "protecting" an unknown small number of users by limiting the rest makes no sense, what makes more sense is MONEY, Apple makes more money by locking things down and getting 30% from apps, subscrip[tions and the much hated lootboxes
- yazaddaruvala 6y ago> this number of completly inexperienced user is not proven to be as large, if you look at Android or OSX you don't see 51% of users having malware on their machine > "protecting" an unknown small number of users by limiting the rest makes no sense, what makes more sense is MONEY For creating policies 51% is a bad measure. Its inherently biased to be regressive. Setting policies at 51% disproportionately hurts the bottom 1%, 10% and 25% of the populations that need our help the most. This is true of all policies and especially laws. Meanwhile, if you've ever helped your grandma or parents with their computers, you'll realize just how much malware they have already downloaded. I also remember what I was like on Limewire and Kazaa as a kid. There is/was an entire industry built around it for Anti-virus and Malware protection. iOS doesn't require anti-virus or malware protection because Apple builds protection and privacy into the product as a core feature. Sadly, built into Android is malware but even Android is less susceptible to malware from unknown entities.
- simion314 6y agoI understand your point but we don't even know if the number of this users that need protecting is even 10%. This imaginary group of people must have this properties: - they are gullible , so bad people can trick them to ignore OS security warnings,create some extra account or security key to unlock the device (Apple can do it hard enough it must not be just 1 click) - at the same time this users are not that gullible to paste their credit card in random websites or on Apple approved chat messages - at the same time this users can be trusted with the app permissions for files,contacts, camera, location For me if I intersect all this sets of users I get void and your argument should be that everything should be locked down, no permissions allowed for this users, there should only Apple approved websites, apple approved contacts, Apple should scan your messages not to send your card details or do stupid things. This people should use an iOS version made for children and adults could use the unlocked version.
- systemvoltage 6y agoYour style of thinking cannot be popular on HN, but we all know why this is good for the consumer - in this day and age, businesses will completely rip apart the consumer in every which way. They'll not miss a chance to fuck the consumer's privacy, financial state, psychology, innocence and addiction. HN crowd wants something they can run sudo on. But people here have not got a slighest idea of how to run a device for close to a billion+ people.
- sneak 6y ago> Your style of thinking cannot be popular on HN, but we all know why this is good for the consumer - in this day and age, businesses will completely rip apart the consumer in every which way. They'll not miss a chance to fuck the consumer's privacy, financial state, psychology, innocence and addiction. Apple is among the worst offenders here, too. They expressly permit all sorts of embedded spyware in almost every single app in their App Store, and their view is that you agreed and consented to it when you accepted the iOS/App Store Terms of Service. They could build platform security features like Little Snitch into the OS to allow users to prevent it, but they don't. They could make App Store rules to keep apps from spying on you when you use them, but they don't. They could end to end encrypt device backups, so the US military and FBI couldn't read all of your iMessage history whenever they want without a warrant or probable cause, but they don't. (In fact, they were going to, but then specifically stopped.[1]) The "Apple respects user privacy" story is just brand marketing, not reality. [1]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusive/exclusive-apple-dropped-plan-for-encrypting-backups-after-fbi-complained-sources-idUSKBN1ZK1CT https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusiv...
- systemvoltage 6y agoThanks for providing the source about encrypted backups, that's chilling. Can you provide sources for other claims in your comments? I want to read up more on what sorts things these apps do. Apple is by far the best when it comes to privacy relative to the others. Would you trust Microsoft, Google, or literally any other company (even Canonical Ubuntu) more than Apple?
- panragon 6y agoI have this discussion nearly daily when talking with Android users. The iPhone is not a modular unit that can be tampered with at all, but despite even being a software developer, I do not actually care about my phone being modular. I want it to work and I want it to work well across the entire platform. Not only does iOS severely limit your options for changing your phone's UX, something a lot of people lament about quite often, but they also have rigorous design-guides that push every developer in the eco-system to have it look the same way. Something as simple as the date/timepickers that Apple removed in iOS 14 can't be changed by the user, but Apple does their hardest to make sure everyone makes it look the way they've set it up, and for my purposes I legitimately prefer that over deciding it myself but having the apps on the platform ultimately use either or willy-nilly. There definitely are issues with Apple, but the user not having full access to changing their device isn't really one, and that's coming from someone who most definitely has the know how to do pretty much anything and still remain safe, I'd dread to see users be stuck having full root access to their phones without even knowing what the fuck that means. There absolutely needs to be options for those that want to be able to hack away at their phone to their hearts content, but it doesn't need to be every phone, and Apple aren't criminals just because they don't offer that possibility and users happen to want their phones anyway. Please don't give me root access to my iPhone, I do not care about it, I have no need for it, and I do not want it.
- stale2002 6y ago> Please don't give me root access to my iPhone, I do not care about it, I have no need for it, and I do not want it Then don't turn on root mode? Nobody will force you to do anything, if I am given the option of easilu turning on root mode, and you can simply choose to not turn that on.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoOnce root mode is an option it will be exploited. The weakest link in software systems is often a human.
- lern_too_spel 6y ago
- headmelted 6y agoWrong. Completely. The vast majority of people you're talking about don't realise they're having their prices jacked up with taxes or their options curtailed by Apple. They just assume the App Store is where you get the apps because it's been programmed into them over the last 12 years. Allowing third party app stores doesn't change the API or permissions system already baked into the OS. If Epic wants to start an App Store with lax policies then if you and Apple are right about the value of their policies then that'll become apparent quickly enough and will still be a selling point of the App Store. This is nothing like what happened with desktop computers, where the security model had to be welded on after the horse had already bolted. Windows (just as an example) wouldn't allow blanket admin permissions to software if there was a way to stuff the legacy software genie back in it's bottle. Unfortunately fixing permissions retrospectively would break a multitude of legacy software that hasn't been updated in years, in some cases decades. Apple is not being punished for success, and you don't understand the problem or the legal case, which is entirely not at all related to Apple protecting or not protecting their users from pop-up ads. Consumer choice didn't chose anything. Most phone users don't even understand that they are in a walled garden. tldr; This isn't The Beach, it's The Truman Show.
- sneak 6y ago> Allowing third party app stores doesn't change the API or permissions system already baked into the OS. It does precisely that. Apple invests huge amounts of money into people and infrastructure to ensure that exploit code (that can subvert platform security) never makes it into the store or gets signed by Apple. If it does, they can immediately revoke it. Third parties providing app downloads would not invest the anywhere near same level of care, for the most part. Platform security can only do so much if you can run any code you want to try to attack it.
- headmelted 6y agoBut you cant run any code you want. You’re still in a restrictive sandbox, and you still need to explicitly request the limited expansions to the permissions scope that the OS allows the user to grant you - neither of which is dependent on the App Store.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- matwood 6y agoEveryone should keep in mind your points when thinking about improving the situation. The current setup does have advantages for both consumers and developers. Did the majority of the app revenue end up flowing through the Apple by chance or did the rules that setup facilitate that system? As you said, consumers who spend money have largely chosen the Apple walled garden.