16 ms·
$1 hearing aid could treat millions with hearing loss
- netdur 6y agoOk I will bit, I want to build this and redistribute in Africa, I lack technical knowledge to do this, what is best approach?
- janekm 6y agoTalk to a Chinese factory on what’s the lowest price they’ll sell you the hearing aids for that they already make at near-cost prices. The article is literally a “my first soldering project” combining an OTS microphone amp module with an R-C high pass filter. https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Rechargeable-Digital-Hearing-Aid-Severe-Loss-BTE-ITE-Ear-Aids-Voice-Amplifier/202966707766 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Rechargeable-Digital-Hearing-Aid-...
- janekm 6y agoThe $1 figure in the headline is clickbait as it’s only the cost of components for the PCB. Add the PCB + mechanical components + battery + plastic enclosure + assembly + testing + factory margin + overhead and it would be a miracle to come under the cost of existing low-cost hearing aids.
- anamexis 6y agoThat's not true, the $1 figure for all of the parts. Here's the original, search for "Table 1" for the BOM https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0238922 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- jononor 6y agoGood luck sourcing 3d-printed casings at 0.06 USD, or PCB at 0.05 USD a piece, even in 10k or higher scale. And of course in addition to the BOM comes production costs.
- anamexis 6y agoThe casing is just a rectangular plastic box with some holes in it, I'm sure you could get some made at that price. Even if the PCB costs 5x the quoted price, you're still rounding down to $1. That said, I have no idea what production costs are for something like this.
- janekm 6y agoI can understand how it may seem that way when a plastic takeaway box costs $0.1, why should this cost any more... The article's cost assumption is just based on the cost of the raw plastic material, which is hilarious (3D printer time doesn't really come free). But in more realistic mass production you'd make a mold, and the cost of the mold is dependent on how many "shots" you want to get out of it. Making plastic parts at the cost of takeaway boxes requires expensive high-volume molds. At 10k volume you'd be happy to get the box for $1 including amortised mold cost (though in reality the box could be much smaller, reducing mold & material costs some).
- jononor 6y agoThe casing is about 2 hours 3d-printing a piece. That is 20'000 printer hours for 10k units, giving a machine-time cost of 0.025 USD (including plastic). That is off by a factor of 10-100, at least. For injection molding, one would need to make the molds. That would cost probably more than 1000 USD, excluding engineering costs (the design is not injection molding ready). Amortizing the mold costs over 10k units alone would be 0.1 USD per unit. Then comes actually making the parts. Maybe 0.5 USD is doable. I checked an off-the-shelf casing (no custom molds needed) it was quoted at 0.20 USD at 1K units - but this then needs to be CNC machined on 2 sides to add the necessary openings. Probably 1 USD a piece, at the least. The costs in the scientific article does make any sense. It is really sad to see that it gets through peer review so easily... I mean OK that the scientist does not really know what things cost to produce, but then they need to consult someone who does! Ask a manufacturing or even a design house for a cost estimate. Quality check your numbers at least a little bit.
- jononor 6y agoI would estimate the PCB costs, excluding Assembly time, to be 10x the quoted price.
- tyingq 6y agoThe BOM prices are just wrong. You can find the volume pricing for the MAX9814 and MAX98306. Those two alone add up to more than $1.
- person_of_color 6y agoReminds of the clock boy who designed CPUs
- grenoire 6y agoStep one is to come in contact with an electrical/industrial engineer who will be able to assist you in the manufacturing aspects.
- aaron695 6y agoSay you want a order of 10 million made up for a name brand company to a Chinese company. Send in the plans for them to check. Put on an expensive looking logo and paperwork. Done.
- pkphilip 6y agoTalk to someone in Africa who works with repairing mobile phones, laptops etc. They will have enough skills to assemble such a device. Recruit one of them or work with of them to make the devices in bulk.
- sokoloff 6y agoRepair and bulk assembly are substantially different expertise. Almost no matter how cheap the local labor is, doing automated assembly with manual finishing is probably going to be way cheaper in China (especially since the supply chain for components is well established there).
- rini17 6y agoHearing aids (nor cochlear implants, for that matter) do not "restore hearing", except for light hearing loss. They are only like crutches (not even wheelchair). For example, to follow conversations or phone/skype with multiple people is very exhausting even with fancy device, because in most cases the "bandwidth" to the brain just isn't available. That said, the hearing aids vendor lock-in is really atrocious and can use a disruption. They don't like users configuring the aids themselves, you are expected to make appointments with audiologist - in fact several of them because every hearing loss is different and it's hard to exactly measure, so usually the aids won't fit on first or second try. The algorithms are strictly proprietary - when there's 40dB difference between responses to different frequencies such as I have, usual equalizer won't do. To enable bluetooth the rule is to buy expensive add-on streamer.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoFor a few dollars more it is possible to put a FPGA with perhaps a neural accelerator on it. It may tremendously simplify some of the DSP stack. More importantly, there should be a full-proof app or UI to allow the user to tune the hearing aid appropriately (or coupled with a training course for audiologists in the targeted regions to do so).
- KSteffensen 6y agoHearing aids are tremendously constrained with regards to power and mechanics. There is no way you will be able to get an FPGA in a hearing aid. An FPGA runnning complex DSP algorithms will: 1. Get hot. I don't want a +60C FPGA in my ear. 2. Eat up the battery. The batteries are small and fiddly to replace for an 85 year old with bad eyes and arthritis in the fingers. They should last for at least a week before needing replacing. No they are generally not rechargeable in the device. That would require a connector, which takes up precious volume. Wireless recharging requires a coil with the same problem. 3. Take up way too much PCB real estate. They are just too big to fit in your ear. Sure, you can run a wire to a box outside the ear, but that messes with the fashion statement. Most hearing aid users want small and discrete, so the world isn't reminded they have a disability. Besides, why would you put an FPGA in there? Hearing aids already feature some of the most high-grade low-power DSP ASICs available, custom made for that companys DSP algorithms.
- artonge 6y agoThe blueprints are hosted on github: https://github.com/bhamla-lab/LoCHAid-2020-PLOS-ONE https://github.com/bhamla-lab/LoCHAid-2020-PLOS-ONE Edit: there is also a video showing the building process: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0gnbOJ3nDo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0gnbOJ3nDo
- anamexis 6y agoAnd the original scholarly article: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0238922 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- jononor 6y agoBased on the MAX9814 chip, which costs 0.75 USD in 2.5K volume, leaving 0.25 USD for everything else. The design is not integrated much (many connectors), so assembly costs will be high. It also requires 2xAA batteries as a consumable, which consumer has to pay as well. So this is not a 1 USD hearing aid in any way. And if current units are 500 USD, then going down to 50 or 10 USD would already be a huge improvement.
- tyingq 6y agoThe pdf shows a MAX98306. Curious where you saw the MAX9814.
- jononor 6y agoThe HearingAid.sch PDF says MAX9814 on the JP1 connector on the left side. So are they actually using both?
- anamexis 6y agoThe MAX9814 is the microphone. Here's the BOM which shows the full breakdown coming in under $1. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0238922 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... (Table 1)
- tyingq 6y agoJust the BOM image so it's easier to read: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/figure/image?size=large&id=10.1371/journal.pone.0238922.t001 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/figure/image?size=... Also, I'm not sure where he's getting the prices. Prices for the MAX98306 and MAX9814 seem higher, even in high quantities, than what he's showing.
- kube-system 6y agoInteresting that they list the cost of raw PLA pellets for the "mass production cost" of the 3d printed case. This is starting to smell like an exercise in making an incorrect BOM to justify the result they were looking for. Nobody will 3d print you a case for $0.06. If what they meant was that they'd 3d print the case themselves, then it should be the filament or resin listed on the BOM. You probably can get a plastic part pretty close to that price, but not 3d printed, it would be injection molded.
- ritchiea 6y agoToo bad we live in the kind of world where the biggest hearing aid manufacturer will read this, raise additional capital, buy the patent & rights to the $1 hearing aid and then sell hearing aids for $5,000 each they'll bill to medicare and big health insurance co.
- GuB-42 6y agoPatent this? This is just a microphone, an amplifier and a headphone jack. That's the most obvious thing. There is no real innovation here. The work being done here is closer to a market research: find the cheapest components that do the job. Cheap is also its only quality. $5000 hearing aids are better in every other aspect. It makes no sense for big hearing aid manufacturers to use anything about this design.
- pomatic 6y agoIt does seem like a bit of a missed opportunity - even slipping in the most basic ots equaliser or dsp would add a minimal amount to the BOM, whilst moving from a late 70s format aid to late 80s, albeit in a dated form factor. (Chest worn isn't too terrible IME, but expect to replace the "wiring harness" to the earphones on a regular basis.)
- pkaye 6y agoYou can already buy cheap amplifiers like this on Amazon.
- tyingq 6y agoAt first, it seemed like a laudable effort. I hate it, though, when someone makes a github repo and sticks a single zip file in it: https://github.com/bhamla-lab/LoCHAid-2020-PLOS-ONE https://github.com/bhamla-lab/LoCHAid-2020-PLOS-ONE So I found the pdf in the zip file where you can see what it is. It's a MAX 98306 amp. The only peripherals are the typical filter capacitors, resistors, volume pot, microphone, etc. So, it's basically this: https://www.adafruit.com/product/987 https://www.adafruit.com/product/987
- magicalhippo 6y agoActually it uses two IC's and the more interesting one, in relative terms, is the MAX9814[1] microphone amplifier with automatic gain control. I suspect there are cheaper class-D IC's that could be used than the MAX98306, but for a prototype why not. It also puts the volume control potentiometer on the amplifier output which seems wasteful for a battery operated device. [1]: https://www.maximintegrated.com/en/products/analog/audio/MAX9814.html https://www.maximintegrated.com/en/products/analog/audio/MAX...
- andai 6y agoLooks like that's it in the first photo in the article: he's holding it in his hands and using earbuds. Presumably it would go in a pocket or clip on to your belt.
- dcassett 6y agoI was surprised to see a git repo consisting of one zip file. And that zip file itself contains a zip file.
- jdubner 6y agoAnd not even a ReadMe file to accompany either ZIP file.
- jononor 6y agoLooks like Chinese manufactures already sell hearing aid devices in the 25-50 USD price range. https://www.banggood.com/search/hearing-aid.html https://www.banggood.com/search/hearing-aid.html Unlike the device from the article (which would cost more like 10 USD than 1), these are rechargeable and fully integrated over-the-ear units. Would love to see a low-cost open/hackable hearingaid/hearable though. For example BOM of 5-10 USD. But then it should use a reprogrammable chip for the signal processing, so that one can make improvements in software. Even the cheapest and simplest hardware is harder / more expensive to improve than software.
- sputr 6y agoDamn that link made me happy. Was wondering if anyone has done to hearing aids what they did for glasses. We just brought my father progressive glasses for 100usd (would be 400+usd here at a 'normal' store). Now he needs a hearing aid and we're dreading the multi-hundred payment on top of what is covered with insurance for a basic device. So.. What's the catch with these cheap hearing aids? Why would we not buy these?
- bagacrap 6y agoquality? doesn't this question apply to every cheap Chinese product? My mom has had poor hearing for decades and always spent thousands on her hearing aids for marginal improvements in quality (e.g. noise cancelling, size, noticeability). The only thing that really made a big improvement was when she finally got a cochlear implant.
- criddell 6y ago> doesn't this question apply to every cheap Chinese product? The question is always valid but the answer isn't always the same. I'm thinking specifically of cheap eyeglasses.I've had nothing but good experiences buying glasses that cost 10-20% of what I would pay from a local store.
- NonEUCitizen 6y ago
- brento 6y agoI was told I could benefit from hearing aids, but was told they would cost $5K to $8K depending on which ones I wanted. I've decided for now that I'll put up with the issues associated with not having them for now. I was also told they blue tooth doesn't work very well if you have an android phone, so I'm hoping that there can be some real innovation and competition in this space to drive the prices down and also improve the technology!
- gedy 6y agoIf you have access to Costco their in house brand is much less (~$1600 pair) and good. Also I really like Bose Hearphones which work better for me and were $500, assuming you don't mind looking like you are on a conference call all the time.
- mgerdts 6y agoIf you can find your way to Costco, make an appointment with their audiologist. The test is free and hearing aids are less than $900 each. Follow-up visits are free. You do not need a Costco membership unless you decide to make a purchase. If you are unhappy with your purchase you can get a refund on the hearing aids and the membership. I believe that most of their hearing aids support bluetooth, but only when you get a pair. I only need one, so no bluetooth for me. I've had fittings by two people at Costco. One is an audiologist and the other was less credentialed, but I forget the title. I could hear better when fitted by the audiologist.
- jki275 6y agoThis is so true! We were told 8k, Costco got us a top of the line set with all of the features the other set had for less than 2k for the set. Costco made a customer for life out of that deal. They do glasses as well, though I haven't used them for that and don't know if the discounts are as good or not.
- Hovertruck 6y agoI don't have any first-hand experience to share, but my wife used to work at https://www.audicus.com/ https://www.audicus.com/ which is a startup focused on exactly this problem, in case you're interested in further research.
- Jaruzel 6y ago> the scientists anticipate that LoCHAid’s parts will wear out after about a year and a half. Why would that be, I wonder. Anyone know?
- londons_explore 6y agoPerhaps the AA batteries need changing that frequently? Or thats the average time till they get crushed/wet/stood on by the user?
- ajnin 6y agoSo this is a very simple circuit. Basically a microphone amplifier directly connected to some earphones with a volume knob. No frequency control of any kind. I'm wondering why this sort of device is not already available like loupe type glasses that we can easily find. I'm thinking this has something to do with legislation and maximum allowed earphone sound levels? Or maybe it is too crude to be actually useful?
- janekm 6y agoIt is available, even as in-ear style "hearing aid", for <$10 from the usual factories. I gather it's a little problematic selling them in the US due to medical device regulations...
- pkaye 6y agoYou can choose among hundreds of cheap "hearing aids" on Amazon.
- coupdejarnac 6y agoThey can be sold here, but they can't be marketed as "hearing aids" afaik.
- subhashp 6y agoMy mother has been wearing Hearing Aids for over 20 years. These days she has trouble with hearing what is on TV even with a powerful hearing aid. Most times she just sits quietly in front of the TV watching moving pictures. I have always wondered why it is so difficult to make hearing aid which can be connected to a bluetooth enabled TV or Mobile phone, so senior citizens can watch TV or talk to their loved one. Whatever is available on the market is so expensive.
- jaclaz 6y agoWell, my mom has one of those. They are actually two pieces, one is a match-box sized thingy that can connect to Bluetooth devices and that she wears around her neck that transmits to the devices in her ears and also has a microphone, it is very handy as she can easily answer the phone by pressing a button on it (leaving the telephone in the bag, it works as hand-free) and it also has two buttons that can regulate the volume of the hearing aids (the volume of her hearing aids can be regulated also through a teeny-tiny button on the back of the hearing aid, right hand one up, left hand down, but she simply cannot find/push them properly). We got the above first to better adjust volume and for the telephone use, then she started getting issue with the TV and we bought the following. Then there is a small transmitter connected to the TV that can link to the matchbox-like device (that has a fourth button to connect/disconnect to the TV device), it has both RCA plug and an optical input. She is very, very happy of this setup for the TV, much more than what she had before (wireless headphones). Prices are steep, to give you an idea, if I recall correctly: hearing aids € 2,500 neck matchbox-like thingy € 250 TV transmitter € 300
- pomatic 6y agoThey do come up on ebay - I got the tv link for my cochlear implant for £30. Yes, I was lucky. I assume it was a deceased estate sale, and I'm grateful for their consideration. A charity shop specialising in recycling of this kind of tech would fill a definite gap in the market.
- subhashp 6y agoThank you for giving a detailed explanation. I have got a general idea. I wish you could share photos, so I can replicate it for my Mom.
- ggrothendieck 6y agoPersonal sound amplification devices already exist at significantly less cost than conventional hearing aids. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2635618 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2635618 https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-personal-sound-amplification-product/ https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-personal-sou...
- joerango 6y agoI wonder how different it is from something like this: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Pocket-Hearing-Aid-Sound-Voice-Amplifier-Volume-Control-For-The-Deaf-The-Elderly/264761857445 https://www.ebay.com/itm/Pocket-Hearing-Aid-Sound-Voice-Ampl...
- patorjk 6y agoAs an aside, there's a lot of exciting regenerative work going on related to hearing at the moment. Sometime soon we may no longer need hearing aids. There are some neat drugs either in clinical trials or about to begin clinical trials that will re-grow hair cells and broken synapses in the cochlea (ex: FX-322, OTO-413, OTO-6XX).
- xtracto 6y agoI am closely following FX-322, but mostly for tinnitus. I do have hearing loss, but it is that disrupting so far. But the tinnitus is something I could definitely live without.
- newyankee 6y agoAny other clinical trials that you can recommend ? Has the path from clinical trials to commercial launch shortened ?
- snegu 6y agoAre any of these supposed to work on congenital hearing loss, or only when hearing loss is caused by damage/age?
- ygjb 6y agoIt depends on the nature of the hearing loss, for example, FX-322 and OTO-6XX appear to work by triggering regeneration of hair cells, while OTO-413 appears to work by triggering regeneration of synaptic connections (both of which are probably egregious oversimplifications because I am a security nerd, not a medical researcher :P)
- newyankee 6y agoIn theory i believe if regeneration of cells is involved it should work with congenital but i guess there might be other complexities that might be involved (not a medical professional).
- newyankee 6y ago
- biggieshellz 6y agoA few notes here: * This is intended to treat presbycusis, or old-age hearing loss, where the highest frequencies are lost first. It would not be effective for noise-induced hearing loss, where the frequencies around 4 KHz are lost first (the "s" and "f" sounds in speech). This matters in the low-income countries it's targeted for, because occupational health is not as strict and PPE is not as widely utilized, so people are more often exposed to damaging levels of noise at work. * It does not handle loudness recruitment, a common effect of damage to the outer hairs in the cochlea which causes loudness perception to become non-linear. Someone with a moderate hearing loss would hear an 80 dB sound as just a few dB softer than someone with normal hearing, but a 40 dB sound as many dB softer than someone with normal hearing, and a 20 dB sound as not audible at all. So if you do what this hearing aid does and boost it all by 15 dB, the 20 dB sound becomes barely audible, the 40 dB sound is perceived as "about right", but the 80 dB sound is perceived as nearly 95 dB (really freaking loud). You have to have some non-linear compression in there to adjust for this, and not just overall -- it needs to be per frequency band (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bark_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bark_scale) to match the way the ear works. * Another commenter mentioned that the "bandwidth to the brain" is not available. That's only true in the case of damage to the inner hairs of the cochlea. What's more common is damage to the outer hairs, which amplify the sounds, and that can be compensated for with a hearing aid. What we really need is a common way to program a hearing aid, so we can have apples-to-apples competition. Right now, when you go to the audiologist, you get an audiogram, which tells you the minimum threshold of sound that you can perceive at each frequency band. But beyond that, there are proprietary adjustments for compression, noise reduction, profiles for different types of loss, and so forth. It's not like getting glasses, where your prescription fully defines the lens, and you can take it to any vendor and have them make it for you. Edit: If you're really into this stuff from a technical perspective, http://refined-audiometrics.com/wordpress1/ http://refined-audiometrics.com/wordpress1/ is worth a read -- it's a project by an engineer who experienced a hearing loss later in life who has built a software system to make music sound right for him again, basically building a "super hearing aid" running on a desktop CPU to do more fine-grained processing than what is possible within the power budget and form factor of a regular hearing aid.
- caymanjim 6y agoThis is not a $1 hearing aid and never will be. The material cost of almost any device is insignificant compared to the overall cost of manufacturing, testing, and distributing it. The barrier to low-cost hearing aids in most countries is medical regulation and liability coverage, not expensive parts. Maybe India's regulations are lax enough that someone could bulk-manufacture cheap, poorly-tested medical devices to get the price down to a few dollars, but there's no technological breakthrough in this "new device" that would enable that; if there were a viable market, it would already be manufactured. There's no profit to be made, so why would anyone bother?
- markc 6y ago>There's no profit to be made, so why would anyone bother? Really dude?
- jiofih 6y ago> if there were a viable market, it would already be manufactured Yup. https://m.aliexpress.com/wholesale/hearing+aid.html?channel=direct&keywords=hearing+aid https://m.aliexpress.com/wholesale/hearing+aid.html?channel=...
- paulcarroty 6y ago> if there were a viable market, it would already be manufactured. There's no profit to be made, so why would anyone bother? Big market, not super-complex tech, it's only matter of time when cheap solution comes.
- vpribish 6y agohere's a more detailed write-up including pictures of the device: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0238922 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... It's a crude, bulky, ugly, and fragile thing and the $1 price is not realistic - but it would be less than $10. It seems like a decent product for the poorest places - which is their goal. The hearing aid biz in the US is glaringly inefficient and obviously ripe for disruption - but this product will not do it here. There's definitely a demand for hearing aids in the couple-of-hundred dollar range that doesn't require audiologist visits and insurance hassle - but the entrenched interests will not help bring it about.
- jiofih 6y agoThis is basically using academic journals as a marketing channel. As someone else linked above, there are tons of similar devices available from China, probably even using the same chips, at equally low prices.
- pontus 6y agoWith all the advances in tech, why does it seem that hearing aids are still from the 80s? I guess ultimately you're limited by your interface to the brain (something maybe neuralink could address?), but even still shouldn't there be some "magic" machine learning stuff going on in this space? Not at all an expert in audio processing, but I would imagine that we could do a decent job distinguishing voices from background noise, automatically thresholding sound in different environments, and possibly modulating sounds into different frequency bands when there are e.g. multiple speakers. For all I know, stuff like this is already going on.
- red_hare 6y agoMy mother, who's fully deaf in one year and mostly deaf in the other, has heavily depended on strong and expensive hearing aids her whole life. Over the years her hearing aids have improved in battery life, gotten smaller, and improved in things like filtering background noise. Every new hearing aid would start by sounding distorted and weird but her brain adapts to the new sounds after a couple of weeks. The single largest life improvement I've seen for her was about 10 year ago when she could finally get a hearing aid with bluetooth. Suddenly she didn't have to decide between the "whistling" (feedback) or not hearing to talk on the phone. We got her an iPad and she stopped watching TV almost entirely and now watches YouTube and Netflix. And she can do her yoga over Skype. Her biggest challenge, at this point, isn't a hearing aid problem but a bluetooh one. Her iPhone inconstantly switches between her hearing aid and her Volkswagen (pre-CarPlay). I agree hearing aids are stuck in the past, but I'm also convinced most of the problems are lower hanging fruit than a neuralink :).
- jki275 6y agoIf she likes watching on a TV, the Apple TV can talk to bluetooth audio devices. Have never tried it, but it would probably be able to talk to the hearing aids directly.
- skybrian 6y agoThese days they are fairly sophisticated; my hearing aids will automatically switch between several different programs depending on the environment. (It doesn't work how I'd like it to, though, so I have a program that I manually set for music.) There is also a phone app for adjusting settings, though it's limited and buggy. It's difficult to evaluate hearing aids because they are proprietary. Reading about the features in a brochure for a hearing aid is like reading the features for a TV set or stereo. Who knows what those trademarked terms really mean when it comes to how the code works?
- Snitch-Thursday 6y agoTL;DR: someone could make bank selling < 150USD a pop receiver-in-canal wireless bluetooth headphones. This is semi OT. I use a hearing aid every day. the hearing aid features are turned off, i just use it for bluetooth streaming and phone conversations. it is a receiver in canal hearing aid, and I've put a non-occluding ear dome on it so I can hear normally with it in, but when I play music, the music just arrives in my ear. its also very discrete, people dont notice it unless i tell them its there. Why someone doesn't take a cheap android/iphone bluetooth-compatible receiver in canal hearing aid and sell it not as a certified hearing device (heck, disable the hearing aid part in sw) but as a discrete wireless headphone set is a mystery to me. Wireless headphones give me earaches with pressure on my ear canal, over the ear headphones give me headaches with pressure on my ears, then glasses, then skull. Custom in-ear monitors conform to my ears just fine but block out most other sound and have wires to deal with. These? I put them in, forget about them for a long time, and have sound just floating into my ears when I turn on music. It's my go-to startup idea.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mothsonasloth 6y agoHearing aids are useless for people with tinnitus like my grandmother. The most expensive or cheapest are all the same when you have a medium high pitched buzz in your ear all day
- dpweb 6y agoUnfortunately that $1 aid will cost $1000 when it hits the public market. It would be nice to see open source hardware in medical devices. And a health/safety approval of the DESIGN. At least devices that won't kill you if they fail. So I can build my own like I build my own desktop computer. Buying any Chinese electronics off Aliexpress doesn't excite me too much. Generally, they suck.
- HashingtheCode 6y ago$1 hearing aid costs about $20...... what?? Clickbait.
- DenisM 6y agoRelated to hearing problems there is also a thing called"Auditory processing disorder": Individuals with APD usually have normal structure and function of the outer, middle, and inner ear (peripheral hearing). However, they cannot process the information they hear in the same way as others do, which leads to difficulties in recognizing and interpreting sounds, especially the sounds composing speech. It is thought that these difficulties arise from dysfunction in the central nervous system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auditory_processing_disorder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auditory_processing_disorder
- danjc 6y agoI get that this product is about super low cost but seems to me that with a custom firmware, the AirPods Pro could do a brilliant job of noise cancellation and amplification of specific frequency bands. Ostensibly, you could even employ some ML to enhance clarity of spoken words, etc - like Krisp
- AMC11 6y agoYou might be interested in this other comment chain: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24580446 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24580446
- jerome-jh 6y ago15dB amplification is very little. A 15dB hearing loss can really go unnoticed. It may help a few people, however this will never be a medical device mainly because it has no medical use.
- emcq 6y agoThe most accurate description is probably the authors built a hearing aid from the 1960s with only $1 today [0]. Its worn around the neck, doesn't have any fitting, doesn't appear to have beamforming or feedback management, and low amplification. It turns out these things are all important in clinical outcomes for listening comfort and intelligibility. I've built a modern hearing aid and done extensive patient testing - the details matter and it's not just electrical or algorithm problems but tough mechanical and UX challenges to get something more state of the art. While I haven't worn many neck mounted devices, the Bose Headphones can get crazy feedback and the feedback path is similar. This would cause squealing discomfort for patients and everyone around them. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_hearing_aids https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_hearing_aids
- rexelhoff 6y agoThis. The other issue to contend with in his grandparents demographic is the perception of being deaf and being seen wearing such a big bulky item. Image consciousness is a large hurdle to overcome these Great ingenuity but commercially it's hard to see it take traction
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoThis is nice, I was looking at this problem a while back and was wondering whether implementing sound amplification features on cheap TWS earphones can solve that[1], of course it wouldn't be $1 and I wonder whether the latency of BLE would defeat its purpose. [1] https://needgap.com/problems/22-enabling-hearing-aid-features-on-tws-earphones-audio-hearingaid https://needgap.com/problems/22-enabling-hearing-aid-feature...
- shae 6y agoI never wrote part 2 of this blog post, but there's a $300 open source hearing aid that can do way more than most hearing aids: https://shapr.github.io/posts/2019-08-03-tympan.html https://shapr.github.io/posts/2019-08-03-tympan.html Here's the organization building this thing: https://shop.tympan.org/ https://shop.tympan.org/ I'm kinda excited about the four microphone board, where you can subtract the ambient noise behind the listener from the noise in the direction they're facing.
- newyankee 6y agoCan i mail you ? Where are you based in ?
- KTallguy 6y agoI've been using over-the-ear hearing aids for about 8 years and they have become a part of my life, like contact lenses. The technology has improved dramatically but it's simply not fun having something riding on your ear. They need adjustment throughout the day, and now that facemasks are a thing they're always getting snagged. And there are just some situations where they aren't ideal: many people talking at once in different parts of a room, or when there is any kind of heavy background noise (fire alarms, sirens, etc.). That's why the neural implant that Musk recently demonstrated excites me to no end. Everything is inside the body, no need to amplify or filter anything, just interface directly with the nerves and compensate for the damage. I hope I don't have to wait more than ten years to get one.
- aurizon 6y agoAh yes, the hearing aid 'racket', and it is indeed a racket hidden under medical device laws. One hopes this will change once that law passes. The hearing aid racket people are hard at work lobbying to block it.
- RickJWagner 6y agoThis is awesome news. Public Service Announcement: If you're operating power equipment, wear your ear protection! I didn't, and now have permanent hearing loss. Be smarter!