6 ms·
Although a follow up would be the comforting level of maturity in Facebook's leadership, acknowledging that it isn't their role to bring politics into the workp
by roenxi 6y ago
Although a follow up would be the comforting level of maturity in Facebook's leadership, acknowledging that it isn't their role to bring politics into the workplace.
It is distressingly refreshing to see a company in the news for taking a stance like "In my work with Joel, I’ve found him to be ... very rigorous and principled in his thinking [and therefore I'm happy to work with him despite being a Republican]". It really is remarkable that Zuckerberg is in a position to have to defend that. From company employees of all people.
- agloeregrets 6y agoYes and no. There are lines that can be crossed and defending a line-crosser is political. This isn’t really a new line of thinking for Zuck, he has had to defend boards stacked with far more right members than typical in the valley for a long time. Peter Theil comes to mind along with their news chief from Bribart.
- coldcode 6y agoNothing remarkable in a company that makes lawnmowers. Facebook is a company that uses its power to change what people think because so many view it as a source of truth. Doing it for money, or doing it for power, is essentially the same thing. If you are in position to manipulate the truth for benefits to you or your friends in high places you will, and he is. If I worked at Facebook and felt the CEO was twisting truth for money, I'd leave, but the bribe to work there is so high. If Zuckerberg truly was not a dictator wannabe, he'd give up voting control of the company, but of course he won't.
- notacoward 6y ago> Facebook is a company that uses its power to change what people think I don't think that's a helpful way to look at it. Facebook is a platform that other people use to change what people think, and that's dangerous enough. Without any ill intent whatsoever from Facebook itself, that still creates serious issues with unintentional bias (e.g. via algorithms trained with poor data sets) and manipulation. Those are the problems we most need to address, because the number and power of people trying to manipulate Facebook from outside totally dwarfs the ability of anyone inside - including Mark - to do so even if they all wanted to. Framing it as "Facebook and all of its employees are evil" doesn't solve anything, and wouldn't even if it was true.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoDoesn't Mark Zuckerberg have the final say on what Facebook algorithms show people?
- notacoward 6y agoNot really. Even the people who train the models and code the algorithms don't have a lot of control over how they respond to ever-changing inputs - and that's kind of the real problem IMO. There was a recent thing on Twitter, where someone discovered that it would consistently generate thumbnails focused on white faces when both white and black faces were present. At a gross level this is clearly because of inadequacies in how that algorithm worked, but literally nobody could say exactly what was wrong or how to fix it (especially without introducing new kinds of bias). Facebook has the same kind of problem, at approximately 10x Twitter's scale. It's a machine that nobody knows how it works now, and therefore nobody knows how to fix it. Mark can influence it in very vague and general kind of ways, I suppose, but there is no fine control and often these gross adjustments bring their own unintended consequences.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoIf we don't understand how something works and it seems to be causing negative effects perhaps we shouldn't be using said algorithms in the largest social network.
- dboreham 6y agoIt causes positive effects in the form of higher profits for the company.
- notacoward 6y agoI'm not actually going to disagree with that. It's a perfectly valid point of view. However, I will also add this thought, which I also expressed internally. Neutrality doesn't just happen. No matter how neutral a system it is at one point in time, people will continue gaming it and it will cease to be neutral. There must be continuous active response to maintain that neutrality. This is a lesson Google learned with SEO long ago. Passivity is not the same as neutrality, and insisting on one often makes the other impossible. That's not meant as a refutation of your point, but perhaps it's worth some time to think about how a "no algorithm" version of Facebook would actually play out. Here's your starting point: Twitter but 10x as large.
- JamesBarney 6y agoI've seen a fair bit of criticism of Zuckerberg, but all of the criticisms would probably be more true if there was a CEO appointed by a profit maximizing board instead.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoWell that's due to the entryist take over of the republican party by far right - this is no long the party of Lincoln Esinhower or even Nixon. What sensible business leaders should have down was to put a stop to this - and freeze out the ultra hard line rightist's as they are poisoning the well for them. A bit like how in the 50's when the communists wanted to take over some large UK unions moderate Unions work with MI5
- supernintendo 6y agoThis wouldn't be a problem if the modern Republican party wasn't a genocidal hate group that wants to kill most of the people working for Facebook. I half-jokingly said in a group chat the other day, I wouldn't be a radical leftist if I didn't have Republicans in trucks waving Trump flags calling me a faggot in broad daylight. Half-joking because this is a real experience I faced as a trans person just trying to live my life and go about my day. Meanwhile, I have Facebook recruiters messaging me on LinkedIn with promises that the company is "turning things around" and trying to make a "positive change". It's sad and telling that they even feel the need to incorporate that sort of language into their recruitment strategy. If any LGBTQ people, people of color, immigrants or really anyone subjected to conservative hate is reading this, please know that you owe it to no one to check your politics in at the door when entering any space. You owe it to no one to use your creative energy and talents to build platforms for people who want you dead. And if you're a member of one of these communities who actually works at Facebook, understand that you will never turn that ship around. Go take a look at some of the social media platforms that have cropped up in response to what conservatives perceive as "censorship" and "deplatforming" - sites like Gab or Parler. This is what Republicans want Facebook to become.
- sagichmal 6y agoI don't view this as laudable. The debate that's occurring is a principled one and remaining stoically indifferent isn't virtuous, it's contemptible.
- nemothekid 6y ago>acknowledging that it isn't their role to bring politics into the workplace. This is very hard for me to square with Facebook. It's like working at the NY Times and saying "no politics in the work place." Almost any decision FB makes is by definition political. The top 10 most interacted pages on Facebook are political. COVID-19, in the US, is political. It doesn't strike me as mature, it's deceitful. It's very easy to claim things are non-political when the outcomes do not affect you at all.
- jjice 6y ago> Almost any decision FB makes is by definition political. The top 10 most interacted pages on Facebook are political. COVID-19, in the US, is political. While this makes sense and I agree with you, I still think that some dev ops employee shouldn't be forced to engage in political debate because their company is politically involved. While the company may be, there are many positions that can be politically agnostic to the company. Provisioning servers or working on internal work flows shouldn't require my political engagement.
- zbentley 6y ago> Provisioning servers or working on internal work flows shouldn't require my political engagement I think GP's point, which I agree with, is that your proverbial devops person already is acting politically by racking those servers in service (ha) to a political entity (a corporation which affects the lives and tendencies of the body politic). There's no way for most folks to opt out of actions having political consequences, due to the interconnected nature of the world we live in.
- mrguyorama 6y agoNobody is forcing Joe Blow devops to work at Facebook and get very well compensated. Sometimes you need to face the morals of what you are doing
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe notion that a medium can be above politics is, itself, a political opinion. The antithesis is "The medium is the message."
- mattacular 6y agoWhenever someone says "don't bring politics into X" it's a cop-out. Doubly so for anything related to Facebook. Politics is how we solve all problems between competing interests as a society. You can't operate a business in this country (or any) which is divorced from politics. It's absurd for Zuck to suggest that his business should be immune to political forces.
- dandersh 6y agoYep. Also it can be (not saying that's the case here) used as a way to exclude undesirable politics while keeping desirable politics in place. For example the "don't bring politics into sports" that was bandied about during the kneeling controversy in the NFL a few years ago. The National Anthem is political. All of the "support the troops" events during games (paid for by the taxpayers!) is political.
- ikiris 6y agoThe fact that this is downvoted says a lot about the bias emerging on hn.
- dvtrn 6y agoRather self-fulfilling - in a way, isn't it?
- mattacular 6y agoNot sure why you've been downvoted. NFL may not be in as good of a position to distort the political environment as Facebook just due to the obvious differences between what they do, so maybe not seen as as much of a "threat" to the political order. But the NFL absolutely hides behind the same "no politics here!" curtain that Zuck is attempting to pull down. Nobody is really buying it from either company. Anyone who has watched an NFL game has seen the stuff you mentioned and more. It's absurd to say sports are not political .. of course they are! It's one of the few common grounds Americans have to stand together on, it is broadly politicized as a result. Edit: grammar fixes
- 6y ago