3 ms·
I don't know, this is an interesting read, but I got to the end and I'm still not sure what the author's trying to say here. He acknowledges that humoral theori
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
I don't know, this is an interesting read, but I got to the end and I'm still not sure what the author's trying to say here. He acknowledges that humoral theories were wrong, that the modern understanding of medicine is correct, and that embracing it has allowed us to greatly improve medical outcomes. So... what's the issue?
- eru 6y ago> Today we can point to the benefits of these changes in medical thinking, but we must acknowledge their history and their limitations, as well. These new ideas of universality might have obliterated bodily difference, but instead they became a framework used to justify it and inscribe hierarchies on people, most notably around nascent categories of race. From that historical moment when understandings of bodies shifted, we can see a logic emerge that has shaped our relationship to health care and, conversely, health care’s goals for us. It might be one of those 'critical overviews'? (As in 'critical theory'?) Or at least it uses some of that language.
- frenchy 6y agoI think the author is suggesting that necessities of empire building in the 17-1800's were a significant driver in the adoption of modern medicine. It reads very much like a just-so story though, so I'm not sure how valuable it is.