4 ms·
> A bookstore refusing to carry books by certain authors is in no way censorship so i have to make my own bookstore just to sell that book? I'd say that's pret
by chii 6y ago
> A bookstore refusing to carry books by certain authors is in no way censorship
so i have to make my own bookstore just to sell that book? I'd say that's pretty close to censorship. Even tho the constitution doesn't stop private censorship (only gov't censorship), it isn't a good outcome imo.
- ilikehurdles 6y agoIf you own a bookstore, you should be able to curate its content at your leisure, which includes but is not limited to removing content that you find objectionable. I don't see how this is a bad outcome, because the alternative -- being forced to carry books on your shelves that you have no power to remove sounds like a much worse outcome. I, a terrible author, am not entitled to your bookstore's audience.
- FridgeSeal 6y agoIs this not "the market" simply deciding not to support something? Is that not one of tenets of free-market capitalism? In the market of video providers, none of them are interested in hosting a particular viewpoint, then the creators of the video either have to put up with that or go make their own.
- kelnos 6y agoIf you can't find even one existing bookstore to carry your book, perhaps your views or ideas are so toxic that you should rethink them. Either way: still not censorship.
- BurningFrog 6y agoOr perhaps the society I live in is so toxic that my sane ideas can't reach out. To spell it out, your reasoning assumes that the prevailing consensus in any society is good.
- kortilla 6y agoDo you know what censorship means? It’s quite literally the textbook definition (explicitly blocking books because of the ideas in them) so I’m curious what you think censorship is. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/censorship https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/censorship
- criddell 6y agoWould you also say if I were to ask you to leave my house because I got tired of listening to you, I'd be infringing on your free speech rights? Is that different than me removing your book from my store?
- chii 6y agoThe difference is that you would be forced to hear the speech in the house, but you are not forced to read/buy the book from the bookstore. Removing it from the bookstore prevents those who wants the book from getting it. Having it in the bookstore doesn't force those who don't want it from reading it!
- andrewzah 6y agoIt does, however, force bookstore owners to carry any and every book. Which is a ridiculous proposition. Instead, you can choose to not support that bookstore owner by shopping somewhere else and rewarding the bookstore owner that -does- carry it. Bookstore owners are not the government, they're free to do all sorts of things and you're free to be a patron or not.
- chii 6y ago> force bookstore owners to carry any and every book. Which is a ridiculous proposition it is ridiculous when there's physical constraints, but for digital goods, such as youtube, there's almost no physical constraints. Noone is saying the bookstore must promote or give prominence to all books equally. But preventing the books from existing by virtue of their platform size is wrong.
- strken 6y agoThere's a difference between the legal American right to free speech, and the global ethical principle of free speech. One can only have their right breached by the government, but one can be censored by anyone who has the power to read their incoming/outgoing communications and modify or remove parts. There's a difference between your home, which is a privately owned private space, and a mall, which is a privately owned public space. Youtube is more like a mall or a newspaper conglomerate than your house. For it to have a bias when censoring content can be objectionable in the same way that a big media conglomerate with a bias can be objectionable.
- Psychlist 6y agoYes, if that's what it takes. Flip it around: Imagine you have a tattoo. You're publishing the one tattoo therefore "free speech" means you have to publish all the tattoos? Should you be obliged to allow a big "Kick whites out of America" tattoo next to whatever tattoo you have chosen to wear?
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoPromoting a specific kind of speech is not equivalent to not acting on speech. Leaving a piece of speech alone and simply doing nothing to it doesn't count as promoting it. That's exactly what section 230 in the USC means.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]