4 ms·
"Otherwise you are using the metaphor to deceive rather than enlighten." That's an exaggeration. The point is to show where your tax payment is spent, and tha
by timr 16y ago
"Otherwise you are using the metaphor to deceive rather than enlighten."
That's an exaggeration. The point is to show where your tax payment is spent, and that's what it does. Emphasizing borrowing does nothing to further clarify the question.
More importantly, there's no way to know what proportion of the debt is attributable to any individual. It's a political question, because it deals in the hypothetical of how much someone would have paid, if we lived in an alternate universe where we ran a balanced budget. Nobody knows what that universe looks like.
In other words: let's stick to the facts. If you want to talk about deceptive metaphors, well...I'm sure that certain politicians would love to have the ability to send every taxpayer a "receipt" that told them that some large percentage of their tax bill was borrowed and used to pay for social welfare programs or pensions or bombs. That would really clarify the debate.
- ericd 16y agoWhat's the problem with dividing the credit proportionally by the amount paid? If you represent 1% of the tax base, you also represent 1% of the borrowing, regardless of who that money ended up being spent on. I agree with the parent that it is deceptive to not include that figure. EDIT: Then again, it doesn't give a very accurate picture to those who are being subsidized heavily, so there are some downsides to that. If one could track the amount spent on each person from federal programs, that would be very interesting - how much your fellow citizens are subsidizing you might be pretty motivating or depressing, depending on how you look at it.
- kevin_morrill 16y agoKudos to @DanielBMarkham for a very good point. @Ericd the most likely outcome--the one currently happening--is that most of this will be finances through inflation. So those who save the most will give up the most in lost buying power. And yes, closely behind that is the people who are taxes the most. For the most part these two go together, but I think this will catch a lot of the middle class off guard as they watch their 401ks become worth less. That will be a bitter pill.