14 ms·
The problem is that we have the person who arguably most understands the domain of web browsers, online privacy, and all the legal and ethical aspect thereof, w
by dotancohen 6y ago
The problem is that we have the person who arguably most understands the domain of web browsers, online privacy, and all the legal and ethical aspect thereof, working on another Chromium-based browser.
I do not need to elaborate on why a diverse browser ecosystem is important, there are enough threads on that already.
Mozilla had this jewel, exactly what it needed to succeed and make the web a better place. He was attacked for his personal beliefs regarding gay marriage, which went against the current popular liberal attitudes, who attack anything they perceive as against them with a fury on the scale of lynch mobs. The web, for better or for worse, gives huge leverage to whoever is willing to make the most noise and be the most unruly.
So Eich was attacked, Firefox market share plummeted, the new CEOs take home four times what Eich was taking home yet add "Pocket" and other misfeatures while funding for Rust and MDN is being cut. Instead of a 95% monoculture of a Microsoft product we now have a 95% monoculture of a Google product. But hey, the guy who doesn't support gay marriage is out of the picture, right? That's a win, right?
- jacquesm 6y agoSorry, but you're not going to paint Eich as a victim over what is a totally self inflicted wound. And there is no argument from utility to be made here either along the lines of 'oh Eich may be a bigot, but look at that nice browser he gave us'. He has to work with the people around him and that scenario would have likely not panned out. Instead, a large chunk of Mozilla/FireFox' employees may have walked if he had tried to hang on, or maybe he could have come around on the subject in a halfway believable way. But he chose to walk instead, his loss, and ultimately, possibly our loss too.
- amadeuspagel 6y agoIt's obscene to paint Eich as the perpetrator of a self inflicted wound for not "coming around on the subject in a halfway believable way", for not trying to appease the mob. "Stop hitting yourself."
- jacquesm 6y ago> for not trying to appease the mob. No, I meant as in genuinely doing that. People are typically capable of learning. I'm pretty sure Eich is smart enough to do so.
- panny 6y ago>Eich may be a bigot Eich was perfectly capable of working with others. He had a demonstrated track record of doing so since he co-founded Mozilla. >a large chunk of Mozilla/FireFox' employees may have walked if he had tried to hang on A group of people intolerant of a political difference would have left rather than continue working with him. That's the definition of bigot. Bigot: One who is strongly partial to one's own group, religion, race, or politics and is intolerant of those who differ. https://www.wordnik.com/words/bigot https://www.wordnik.com/words/bigot
- ahelwer 6y agoOut of curiosity, do you know of any companies in your field where the CEO believes you personally don't deserve rights? Would you work for that company? Why or why not? If there is no such company, why do you feel qualified to level this opinion here?
- nec4b 6y agoMy CEO believes only the people who have a baby should receive a bonus (a stimulus of a kind) for having a baby. Those who don't have a baby a specific year have no rights to that kind of a bonus. No group of childless people formed with the intention to cancel him.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoAll of the poly people I know work for companies that don't support their right to marry. I think it's worth pointing out that the ballot prop that Eich supported actually won. It wasn't a niche belief, certainly not at the time. I don't think Eich was the only CEO in America that didn't support gay marriage. What set him apart was that he didn't do a better job hiding his beliefs.
- smsm42 6y agoI have no idea what's most CEO's opinions are on political subjects, and prefer to keep it that way. I would certainly work with CEO that has different opinions than I do - in fact, for all I know, I may already be.
- late2part 6y agoI've often been troubled at the level of commensurate activism on polygamist rights. What is Mitchell Baker doing to help them?
- 1123581321 6y agoMy understanding is that Mozilla employees protesting his politics were not actually planning to walk and were disappointed and a little embarrassed that he left. They just wanted some sort of apology.
- pseudalopex 6y agoHow did you arrive at that understanding? The Mozilla employees I've heard from said the opposite.
- 1123581321 6y agoMostly based on comments from Rarebit, as well as a few others.
- pseudalopex 6y agoRarebit was 2 people who didn't work for Mozilla.
- 1123581321 6y agoThey worked with Mozilla and were prominent critics during that time. At any rate, now you know why I know how developers felt.
- pseudalopex 6y agoIt looks like the closest they came to working with Mozilla was porting a simple game to Firefox OS. Getting attention at the time doesn't mean they spoke for anyone else. It sounds like you don't know how Mozilla employees felt.
- 1123581321 6y agoPerhaps so. Thanks for guiding me through this!
- smsm42 6y ago> He has to work with the people around him and that scenario would have likely not panned out. Or it would, since he worked with the same people before the wokefest with absolutely zero complaints from anybody. If people didn't decide having ideological purity and expelling wrongthink is more important than having a good independent browser. Well, they have their purity now. Hope they are happy. Their usage may be in the drain and their perspectives bleak, but at least nobody dares to form an unapproved opinion! > Instead, a large chunk of Mozilla/FireFox' employees may have walked if he had tried to hang on Or, somebody adult would explain to them it's actually ok to disagree on some subject, and that't the thing adults do sometimes. Unfortunately, looks like there's no adults in the industry anymore. Or at least not at those quarters.
- tomp 6y agoFavourited! This is a good description of a Pyrrhic victory that is often the result of mode du jour social causes. I expect similar outcomes from #metoo and BLM.
- jacquesm 6y agoIn the context of this thread this is either very funny or very stupid, hard to make out which it is.
- newyorker2 6y agoSome comments are worth glancing over from time to time. This is one of them. Thanks for the reality check.
- cultus 6y agoEich voted to deny gay people rights that straight people have. That's not a personal belief, that's a concrete damaging action borne of bigotry. If he had shown actual remorse for doing this, he would have been fine. But he didn't.
- tracker1 6y ago"My gut reaction, is that they [homosexuals] are security risks, but I must admit I haven't given this much thought…I’ll be darned!’” -- Joe Biden, 1973 How many of those that "cancelled" Eich are still going to vote for Biden?
- cultus 6y agoI'm not a Biden fan, but Biden has since been a decent supporter of LGBT rights and pushed Obama on the issue. Eich never showed any kind of contrition like that. People can change. I am friends with a number of formerly homophobic people. However, Eich, at least in 2014, displayed no evidence that he had.
- tracker1 6y agoI'm not going to dig into this, but from other comments on this post, it seems he did make statements that walked back the position specifically regarding lgbtqqiaap+
- pseudalopex 6y agoHe wouldn't even say he wouldn't do it again.[1] [1] https://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-ceo-gay-marriage-firestorm-could-hurt-firefox-cause-q-a/ https://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-ceo-gay-marriage-firestorm...
- djsumdog 6y agoDid Eich make any statements at all? I recall he was cancelled out because someone found a donation of his to a political cause. He literally just gave money to a cause. Imagine if who you supported on Patreon or Ko-fi caused you to be harassed until you quit your job? Imagine if someone says you're a hateful bigot because you openly donated to a podcast. Imagine if a donation to the Trump or Biden campaign caused all your employees to turn against you? If he was firing homosexuals for being gay, that would be one thing and unacceptable. I grew up around Christians who would say they find x or y morally wrong, but that wouldn't prevent them from working with people who supported x or y, or believing they were human beings who are entitled to their own opinions. Real tolerance is accepting people who have different beliefs about core issues, and working with them despite those differences.
- djsumdog 6y agoI wonder why Eich went with Chromium/Blink and didn't decide to continue to use Firefox/Gecko as the basis for Brave?
- pseudalopex 6y agoEmbedding Gecko is harder.
- BrendanEich 6y agoSee https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/1297577391129128960 https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/1297577391129128960 among others.
- rasz 6y ago>Linus explained, "It's the fairness. Fairness is good, but fairness is usually bad for performance