9 ms·
Software engineers are not meteorologist nor doctors. Why not? People can be more than one thing. Heck, you're posting on HN. Are you really saying people can'
by onion2k 6y ago
Software engineers are not meteorologist nor doctors.
Why not? People can be more than one thing. Heck, you're posting on HN. Are you really saying people can't be a software engineer and a salesperson? Or a software engineer and a CEO? Or a software engineer and a business analyst? You have to be those things to launch a tech startup.
Lots of people wear more than one hat.
- a_square_peg 6y agoI'm not sure if this is a serious comment. On one hand you have professions and roles where failures are measured in lost revenue versus another where failures are measured in lost lives.
- onion2k 6y agoSoftware failures can, and do, cost lives. If you believe the worst thing that can happen as a software engineer is that you might lose a company some money then you are very, very wrong.
- Aeolun 6y agoI very much doubt that most of us are in a position to do more than make a customer sad.
- a_square_peg 6y agoI mostly worked with safety-critical software on avionics and lately with software on medical device so I hope I do understand. Rather than downplaying the role of software, my point was on pointing out that meteorologists and medical doctors are specialist roles requiring years of focused training. These aren't one of many hats that can be worn by a generalist.
- onion2k 6y agomy point was on pointing out that meteorologists and medical doctors are specialist roles requiring years of focused training Yes, and my point is that there are plenty of doctors and probably most meterologists who write code as part of their jobs. Meterology is statistical modelling at heart, and that requires lots of code. Don't forget that we get soemthing like 40 years of our careers; there's plenty of time to become an expert in a field and then to learn how to write code to build tools to do it better.
- true_religion 6y agoThose are indeed specialist roles, but nothing is stopping a potential doctor from taking software engineering in undergrad, or from keeping up with the field while working through med school. I had a teammate who did the later.
- renewiltord 6y agoAnyone can be anything. But as a rule, most software developers are masters of strictly one profession, if any.
- juancn 6y agoA bit of hyperbole hasn't hurt anyone (hopefully). I work with very good software engineers that were originally mathematicians, physicists, linguists, electronic engineers among others. But once they become software engineers, they kind of are just that. It tends to dominate all thought processes. It's not that they don't leverage their background, but software tends to eat the world.
- Viliam1234 6y agoA "dev-ops full-stack developer" is a master of what used to be multiple specializations a few years ago. Apparently, these days it is not enough to be a database expert, software developer, web designer, and system administrator... you should also be a doctor and a meteorologist. And don't forget to keep updating your Github open-source portfolio in your free time, because you are going to need it at your next interview.