7 ms·
My problem with Rogan isn't political in nature but with his uncritical attitude towards his guests, and his mixture of inviting respectable scientists (say, Ro
by Barrin92 6y ago
My problem with Rogan isn't political in nature but with his uncritical attitude towards his guests, and his mixture of inviting respectable scientists (say, Roger Penrose, Robert Sapolsky) and then two episodes later inviting someone like Alex Jones, some complete quack or conspiracy theorists.
Together with his lack of keeping the guests straight it creates a pretty toxic sludge that makes it impossible for casual audiences to determine who actually knows what they're talking about and who doesn't.
The article frames this as 'elitist' and implies it's bad, but I think this 'here's a real guy who broadcasts from his garage and tells you the truth the mainstream won't tell you' attitude is harmful, it feeds into a particularly American culture of anti-intellectualism, it's the modern extension of talk radio.
- koonsolo 6y ago> is uncritical attitude towards his guests This is actually the part I like the most, and I think contributed the most to his success. I don't like conflict and arguing, that is also why I stay away from the news. His podcast feels like you meet some interesting person at the bar, and keep talking to them until the late hours. Nobody needs to convince anyone about something. And at the end of the night, you go home and think what you want to think.
- dilyevsky 6y agoYmmv but for myself I prefer not to have my hand held entire life and explained “the one true way” I’m supposed to think. There’s a ton of programming out there that already does this (for your personal definition of “the one true way”)
- vannevar 6y agoThis is a straw man argument. There's a big difference between simply vetting your guests to weed out quacks, and pushing some single-minded idea of orthodoxy.
- dilyevsky 6y agoNo it isn’t. As I said if you want your microwaved lasagna go watch 60 minutes. I want to see Dorsey, Jones etc for the lunatics that they are and be thoroughly entertained by it
- BTCOG 6y agoI really just want to say that your comments have been hopeful and refreshing. Thank you.
- vannevar 6y agoSo you'll trade the lasagna for a bag of Doritos and some Slim Jims? If you think there is something "authentic" about people like Alex Jones, you're delusional. They are media creations, just as surely as Dan Rather. Just less coherent.
- dilyevsky 6y agoThat’s actually one of the reasons I watched that episode - to see how much of it is an act and what drove him to these levels of insanity where it’s not. This is what good interview supposed to show imo and jre is certainly not best at this but better than most interviewers out there (at least american ones)
- Scalestein 6y agoWho decides what counts as a quack? One of the things I find compelling about the format of the show is that the long format really exposes people, for better or worse. If you want to find out whether Alex Jones is a quack there is probably no better evidence than watching his appearance on Rogan's podcast. Same is true for Milo Yiannopoulos (often deemed an alt-right troll) who basically had his career wrecked from his appearance on the podcast. I think having guests from all over the political and 'quack' spectrum is a great example of sunlight being the best disinfectant. It is also a powerful bubble popping feature - very few media outlets entertain serious conversations with such a wide variety of guests.
- happytoexplain 6y agoI'm not sure declining to invite Alex Jones onto one's platform would qualify as forcing one's definition of "the one true way" on others. That's kind of an over-deep reading of that person's character.
- seibelj 6y agoI was interested in that episode. I thought Jones was batshit crazy before and still thought so after. It wasn’t hurting me to hear Jones speak.
- dilyevsky 6y agoI haven’t watched anything he did since the Waking Life time so it was interesting to see the downward trajectory there. I hate twitter and other “social” networks with a passion so jre and couple other independent voices are my only window into these sort of cultural phenomenons
- raxxorrax 6y agoBut it also doesn't hurt to have him, you don't need to buy his man pills. To declare him dangerous is rather counter-productive. Especially since there are alternatives for that where you never need to see him. So what exactly is the problem?
- koolba 6y agoThey've been friends for over 20 years. The format of his show is a group of friends having an extended discussion. And love him or hate him, Alex Jones is one of the most interesting people on this planet. It'd be a disservice to his listeners to not invite him on the show.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> The format of his show is a group of friends having an extended discussion. Sure. And that doesn't mean it is free from criticism. Rogan's format freely mixes experts, non-experts, and faux-experts in ways that contribute to an overall undervaluing of expertise in our culture. That's worth criticism even if he is friends with a conspiracy nut and wants to shoot the shit.
- freshhawk 6y agoMe too, that's why when someone tries to feed me bullshit, like Joe Rogan has many times, I decide to ignore them, because they are untrustworthy and misinforming me. And I happily share that information with others, because that's the nice thing to do. That's what people who don't need their hand held do. And if you didn't write Joe Rogan off a long time ago then, I hate to tell you, you do still need some hand holding apparently.
- manigandham 6y agoPeople watch for the guests, not just Rogan. Your morally superior attitude of telling others what's correct is exactly what people dislike about other shows. People who "don't need their hand held" can separate the information from the host and think for themselves.
- dilyevsky 6y ago> because that's the nice thing to do. I can already tell from your comment what a nice wholesome person you are
- aeternum 6y agoI find that there is still something to learn from the guests that are batshit crazy. You learn what aspects of their message resonates with their audience, even if their reasoning is clearly flawed. Rogan is unique in that he frequently let's guests speak freely enough that they divulge the reasons they believe the things they do. And that insight can be incredibly enlightening. As Aristotle said "It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it."
- obscoth 6y agoOf course, you prefer the “alternative” which tells you actually the truth is just the opposite of what “they want you to believe” and you figured it out because you’re so smart and not afraid to offend people and go against the grain.
- refurb 6y agoSo you’re saying Joe should just not talk to people who don’t hold the right views? Or spend his entire show trying to prove them wrong? I can go on CNN or Foxnews to see that.
- happytoexplain 6y agoThe answer to both questions is pretty clearly no, having read the parent.
- alexashka 6y agoWhat are you comparing Joe Rogan's 'toxic sludge' to? Let's have a list of programming that's excellent by your standards that also has millions of listeners for each episode for comparison.
- Barrin92 6y agoI don't listen to that many podcasts. Tyler Cowen has an excellent podcast called Conversations with Tyler, Russ Roberts is a long time podcaster/blogger with a focus on economics, Lex Fridman has a good science/compsci focused podcast and Sean Carroll's Mindscape as well as Ezra Klein's podcast I think have almost always high quality, fairly diverse guests. I'm well aware none of these have the audience that Joe Rogan has, but I find that a weird metric for comparing quality or how informative something is.
- pm90 6y agoAgreed that those are excellent podcasts! Ezra Klein is one of my favorites and I am always delighted by how he seems to productively engage with people on his show. His guest list is also pretty diverse although it is mostly intellectuals. I don’t think much is lost to the world by not engaging with Trolls or Quacks. There seems to be a weird kind of “both sides” going on where people seem to think that they should be heard from whereas there are so many interesting folks I would rather choose to listen to instead.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 6y agoLex and Sean started because of Rogan telling them they should, in fact they pretty much owe most of their audience to him.
- moltar 6y agoTo me that’s the main feature, and not a bug. I want raw and unfiltered content.
- manigandham 6y agoDo you instantly know the truth in every conversation? Do you argue every point or do you let the topics flow naturally? Joe Rogan is no different. He's not an interviewer but just a guy who has long conversations. That's why many guests are his close friends, and also why people are eager to be guests in the first place and talk for hours. The long-form uncritical nature is what made the show popular and gives you a chance to really see how someone thinks and speaks. It's a rare thing in the world of quick soundbites and prepared presentations. What you do with the information is up to you. Judge it, ignore it, research it, refute it - but that's for you to do. Also for all the claims of anti-intellectualism, the show has introduced me to more interesting guests of all kinds than anything else.
- Reedx 6y agoWell said. People are so used to shows and popular voices pushing agendas that it seems they're flummoxed when one isn't doing that. Apparently under the impression that Rogan is endorsing everything his guests say and that his listeners just blindly absorb/repeat. But he isn't pushing an agenda, isn't telling you what to think, doesn't filter by ideology. He's just having conversations with people that he thinks are interesting and treats them respectfully, like a friend would in real life. That's why it resonates, is refreshing, and will continue to mystify those that expect everything to fit neatly in a pre-defined, pre-approved box.
- tarsinge 6y agoThis is a false dichotomy of filtering vs non-filtering. It’s sad that we are at that point in polarization where we can’t have a discussion or debate anymore and everything has to be either labeled or unfiltered. A knowledgeable host or other guest challenging a guest about a scientific fact is not having an agenda, it’s critical thinking than can lead to a healthy discussion and it used to be interesting for listeners to make their own opinion, it’s not hand guiding. There is a large spectrum between being completely passive/complacent and confrontational/insulting/canceling.
- manigandham 6y ago
- Scalestein 6y agoI don't really get the 'truth from the garage' vibe from Rogan's podcast. To me the space he creates by not strongly challenging his guests and by keeping the guests list so varied is that of a sort of neutral ground that people can sample other viewpoints from. Almost all other podcasts are easily filtered into the left/right buckets, end up with their respective entrenched audience and help build that audiences bubble. If someone listens to Rogan's podcast they might hear some quackery along the way but they certainly won't end up in a bubble. I prefer sifting through the sludge to find what resonates with me rather than having hosts do it for me.
- mcgt 6y agoThose scientists must've felt some appeal going on Rogan's show, despite guests like Jones. That's probably why they agreed to it. How does that feed into a culture of anti-intellectualism?
- Antoninus 6y agoThis type of ethical dualism can be dangerous to your critical thinking long term. Implying that he needs to keep his guests straight suggests an agenda to be pushed. Having either Jones or Penrose on the show does not give it credibility or take it away.
- threatofrain 6y ago> Together with his lack of keeping the guests straight it creates a pretty toxic sludge that makes it impossible for casual audiences to determine who actually knows what they're talking about and who doesn't. I don't think it makes sense to criticize Joe Rogan for casual run your mouth conversation when we all know Joe rebranding to be more scientific and educational would destroy him and anyone else who tries. Trying to be sciency while winning isn't really a thing in US broadcasting. The late Mr Rogers suggests that those in broadcasting have elevated responsibilities as per their elevated stature in society, but maybe those who follow such advice have all but disappeared, undernourished by the market.
- hlieberman 6y agoAs I’ve said before, I’m terribly sad that Mister Rogers is no longer with us, but I’m so happy he didn’t live to see what television and the internet have become.
- m463 6y agoI think Mr Rogers would have carved out a niche in the internet just as surely as you and I are having a reasonable discussion involving hackers from all over the world.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- amw-zero 6y agoHe’s a comedian. The fact that people assume he has any kind of moral responsibility to do anything at all is pretty surprising. I also don’t view him as anti-intellectual at all. He also calls his guests out constantly.
- bassman9000 6y agoHim not being Yet Another Gatekeeper of the Anointed Opinions is actually pretty nice. Having a blank slate, laying out all options, even fringe ones, and letting people form their own opinions, it's a huge advancement in a media world where everything is ultraprocessed and spoonfed to the audience. You shine light on conspiracists and fools, for everyone to see, not just hide them in the shadows. That feeds them.
- greenduck 6y agoI mentioned this elsewhere, but people on HN eat up the argument of "do your own research, make up your own mind" as an excuse for not challenging even obvious the most obvious BS. I don't know about you, but I don't have the time to do quality research of every guest he has on. Even if I did, I can't match the manpower or experience of a professional media outlet to do even basic fact checking. For stuff that isn't decided fact, I also don't necessarily have the breadth of knowledge to even know where to look for the competing opinions on a subject. If I, a student, don't have the time to do that research, then what percent of a percent actually does? Like I was describing, what small fraction of that can even do that research effectively? My guess is that it goes to zero pretty quickly with the complexity of the subject. That might not be a problem for the most controversial guests where I already have my defenses up. But, what about the more subtle guest who is pushing extreme views based on literal misinformation, but sounds plausible enough that I buy into it?
- LifeIsThermal 6y agoIt´s your problem that you don´t evaluate the information, not Joe´s or anybody else.
- BTCOG 6y agoThat is solely your problem that you don't understand it's on you to verify information. You as a student don't have time to quickly look up basic information on topics? Then I suggest that you also don't have time to listen to 3-4 hour podcasts for enjoyment. I work 60 hours a week and I never understand that frail argument. If you buy into information spoken freely, it is solely on you. I understand that by you mentioning you are a student, you are likely quite young. 10 or even 20 years from now you many not even hold these opinions you are forming currently. You may wish to actually preserve free speech. Who is fact checking your teachers if you don't have the time to do these things? Do you just accept that whatever your teachers are now telling you within a school setting are true, fact, or something you should follow? I can think back 15-20 years ago to multiple things teachers told me to accept as true or fact that were really just a teacher pushing their own agenda/ideology or belief on an entire classroom of impressionable youths.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI enjoy this very much. I believe in giving the audience the choice to determine that for themselves, you seem to prefer the paternalistic approach we had in the past. > attitude is harmful I disagree completely.
- Balgair 6y ago> Together with his lack of keeping the guests straight it creates a pretty toxic sludge that makes it impossible for casual audiences to determine who actually knows what they're talking about and who doesn't. If anything, that is wonderful. Having multiple opinions put forward without context is a great way to engage critical thinking skills. The audience then has to decide what they 'feel' is correct. If the people with the facts can't sway the audience with said fact, then they should go back and figure out why that is. That will help them in the future and make the facts all the stronger.
- mam2 6y ago> makes it impossible for casual audiences to determine who actually knows what they're talking about and who doesn't. This is quite condescending.. Also people fail to understand that the appeak of extreme right has never been a matter of facts.