7 ms·
I’m not sure I parse things the way you do. Assange is accused of going beyond leaking into assisting Chelsea Manning get pass security systems. If he was not o
by rayiner 6y ago
I’m not sure I parse things the way you do. Assange is accused of going beyond leaking into assisting Chelsea Manning get pass security systems. If he was not only the distributor of classified material, but actively participated in expropriating it, he’s on the wrong side of the law.
Folks had been willing to overlook that, because they viewed him as sympathetic. But he’s undermined that with his connections to Russia. Moreover, Russian attempts to manipulate the 2016 election showed a lot of people that radical transparency isn’t cost free—hostile governments can use this information to jeopardize American national security, including by manipulating otherwise well meaning leakers.
If you’re neither sympathetic nor on the right side of the law, you’ve got a problem.
- agd 6y agoI believe that is incorrect. Assange is accused of helping Manning cover her tracks rather than extract the information in the first place. I.e. he was trying to protect his source. In addition, multiple journalists have spoken out to the effect that encouraging sources to leak is standard journalistic practice.
- rayiner 6y ago“Protecting your source” means that you don’t disclose your source. It doesn’t mean you help your source cover up a crime. This is not a difficult line drawing exercise. Lawyers do it all the time: you’re protected from disclosing client confidences. But it’s highly illegal to actually assist your client in obstructing an investigation!
- agd 6y agoJournalists have already testified in this case to the contrary of what you said. I.e. They do help sources stay undetected, providing advice and sometimes help where appropriate.
- rayiner 6y agoJournalistic practice doesn’t define what is and isn’t illegal in connection with collaborating with a source.
- contingencies 6y agoSimilarly, military and political practice don't define what is and isn't illegal in connection to launching and justifying wars, frequently and repeatedly killing innocents and journalists, setting up a highly illegal system of secret sites and covert armies explicitly for the purpose of abducting people globally (including random innocent members of the general public) and torturing and killing them, conspiring to lie about it all to the general public, then phoning up your cronies and launching a transparent international extra-legal persecution of someone who has embarrassed you.
- kazagistar 6y agoBut it should. The law should follow morality, ethics, and common practice. If the US law is beyond that, then it is overreaching and tyrannical. But of course, especially with these leaks, we already knew that.
- rayiner 6y ago> The law should follow morality, ethics, and common practice Whose morality, ethics, and common practice? The fact that this leaked and almost nobody cares means that people have made a decision. They want the government to have wide latitude to protect them from terrorism, and they care more about that than prosecuting this purported wrongdoing.
- torified 6y ago>The fact that this leaked and almost nobody cares means that people have made a decision. Most people have made the decision that the government is corrupt, Assange is an asshole, and there's nothing they can do about any of it because their elected officials are also corrupt. That is hardly an endorsement of all the horrible things that the US government has been secretly doing in their name.
- thefucnjosh 6y agoThe only crime being committed that matters is what he uncovered. If a Journalist walked on to private property to find an officer peeing on evidence or torturing an innocent person and then took that to the press, you wouldn't charge the journalist for trespassing.
- ncmncm 6y agoEven, torturing a guilty person. The US executed people for torture after WWII. (None of its own people, though. That is acknowledged as an unfortunate failing.)
- ineedasername 6y agoAssange is accused of more than that. Manning gave him something they thought was a hashed password. Assange tried to crack it so that Manning could use it to steal more data. A journalist can receive information from a thief, but if the journalist starts helping the thief cracks safes to steal more stuff, that is a whole other story.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>Assange tried to crack it so that Manning could use it to steal more data. *so Manning could steal the same amount of data with a bit more secrecy. The account in question was a generic Windows account that only had access to thing Manning had clearance for.
- ineedasername 6y agoIt doesn't need to have been successful or useful or practical. Assange stepped over the line of receiving leaked data into providing assistance for the person leaking that data break into more things. Please note that I'm not saying Assange deserves to be prosecuted for any of this by the US government. Saying he stepped over the line (or may have stepped, since he's not proven guilty) is only step 1. The next step to ask is "is that a crime?" Yes, in the US it is. But then comes the next question: "Was Assange subject to US law when he did this?" That is much less clear. I don't know where he was physically located when he was involved with this, or international law to know where jurisdictional issues land on this. Personally, I don't think he should be subject to US when he's not a US citizen and wasn't located in the US when he did this. I don't like the idea that countries could prosecute someone for doing something illegal when what they did was legal in their location. To take a simple example, within, within the US that would be like saying that Utah could charge & extradite someone who smoked weed in Colorado, where it's legal, to Utah, where it is not legal. And more questions after this too, like "Did crossing the line actually provide significant material aid?" In this, I don't think it did.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>Assange stepped over the line of receiving leaked data into providing assistance for the person leaking that data break into more things I can understand your point, but Assange never provided assistance that allowed Manning to break into more things. The assistance provided, if successful, would only let Manning access the data she already had access to, just not leave a log saying she was the one who accessed it. To use a physical analogy, Manning already had access to a file cabinet and was committed to leaking every document inside, and Assange gave her a pair of gloves to hide her fingerprints. His actions in no way enabled her act, but was an attempt to prevent retaliation.
- sneak 6y agoThis posits that it should be illegal to expose classified war crimes. Sometimes, the law is wrong, and should be broken. Nonviolent disobedience of the law is a moral obligation in many instances. There is a long and glorious history of this happening throughout modern history. This is why we have juries: to make that instance not illegal.
- rayiner 6y agoNo it doesn’t. It posits that the purpose of “exposing classified war crimes” shouldn’t immunize conduct that’s otherwise illegal. According to the indictment, Assange was running a whole operation where he was recruiting hackers to get sensitive data from protected computer systems. You’re positing that we should basically have vigilante hackers that expropriate and publish confidential data so long as they purport to be acting in the public interest. That’s an intriguing idea. Maybe that should be the law. But that definitely isn’t the law now. (And when it comes to a jury—we are still in the extradition stage, so the jury will come later—I suspect they won’t agree either.)
- sneak 6y ago> According to the indictment, Assange was running a whole operation where he was recruiting hackers to get sensitive data from protected computer systems. This is an accusation, and is not fact. You'd be wise not to treat it as such until it's proven. The main issue with the course that you seem to suggest is that by the time he might obtain a jury trial in the US, he will already be subject to US imprisonment, and thus, torture (which is precisely what happened to Manning). Countries that purport to be free (such as the UK) should prevent extradition to countries that torture suspects prior to trial, such as the US.
- rayiner 6y ago> This is an accusation, and is not fact. You'd be wise not to treat it as such until it's proven. Sure. But extradition hearings necessarily operate on allegations because they come before a jury trial that will determine the facts.
- cmiles74 6y agoThe US Department of Justice issued a press release in June that tries to summarize the charges in the superseding indictment.[0] For most of the document it's hard to tell what is part of the idictment and what may be simply a recap of other things the US DOJ believes he may have done. In regards to Chelsea Manning, that bit is quite short: "In addition, the broadened hacking conspiracy continues to allege that Assange conspired with Army Intelligence Analyst Chelsea Manning to crack a password hash to a classified U.S. Department of Defense computer. " Forbes spent some time on this[1] and they believe that this really is the important part, this is the act that elevates Assange's actions to conspiracy. According to Forbes no password was ever derived from the hash and it never led to the collection of any documents. [0]: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/wikileaks-founder-charged-superseding-indictment https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/wikileaks-founder-charged-sup... [1]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2019/04/16/unpacking-the-alleged-assange-manning-password-hacking-conspiracy/#530cfd4c6ee8 https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2019/04/16/unpac...
- rayiner 6y agoHere is the superseding indictment itself: https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1289641/download https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1289641/downl... Assange is alleged to have actively recruited hackers and directed them to find particular information from particular sources. Among other things, agreed to assist Manning in deriving a password from a hash file. (It is irrelevant whether he succeeded or not—the crime of conspiracy is complete upon taking the first substantial step toward achieving the goal of the conspiracy, such as passing the hash to someone else for cracking.) According to the indictment, he was closer to running an operation to expropriate sensitive data from all over the world than being a journalist neutrally publishing documents that people sent him.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoThis logic would render all national security reporting illegal. The job of national security reporters is to convince people in government to divulge information they're legally barred from divulging.
- ribs 6y agoAnd if your trial won’t be subject to the oversight that other trials gets. In fact, just that one fact means you’ve got a problem.
- barnesto 6y agoThere it is. Muh Russia. What attempts were those by the Russians in 2016? Buying $100k in Facebook ads? Unless you are referring to the Podesta emails, which weren't "hacked" by Russia. Just ask Bill Binney -- a source that is more credible than any other on this subject. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qg8iEnDmcpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qg8iEnDmcpE
- michaelmrose 6y agoAre we going to ignore the obviously extralegal illegalities required to even put him in the position to be subject to our laws as a foreigner including collaborating with a foreign jurisdiction to bring false rape charges? Our misdeeds are far more troubling than his.
- himinlomax 6y ago> but actively participated in expropriating The difference here we're talking about is minuscule, and this is clearly just some technicality BS the highly paid US lawyers have come up with.
- ArchD 6y agoIf you have war criminal suspects not being prosecuted but only Assange, your 'democracy' has a bigger (fairness) problem. If your citizens are so easily swayed by Russian manipulation that you have to make it such a big deal, your 'democracy' has a bigger (fragility) problem. If you are OK with MNCs swaying votes with money but not with nations doing the same, your 'democracy' has double-standards and has a bigger (integrity) problem. You can 'law' all you want. Laws are written by people, who are sometimes just and sometimes not just. Laws are not all universal; they get changed all the time; different countries have different laws. Some laws are right and some are wrong.
- ineedasername 6y ago"so easily swayed" You say that as though propaganda was not a real thing with a proven track record. Blaming the victim.
- akira2501 6y ago> Assange is accused of going beyond leaking into assisting Chelsea Manning get pass security systems. 1 out of the 18+ charges brought against him are for that. It's also a minor crime that would carry a 5 year penalty, which is hardly worth all this effort. The other 170 years of charges related to violations of the espionage act, and it's not at all clear that they would even apply to Assange who is not a U.S. citizen or military contractor. > because they viewed him as sympathetic. I've never viewed him as sympathetic. It takes a completely unrestrained ego to try to be the "public front-man" for Wikileaks. On the other hand, what's happening to him now is a clear abuse of the law and extradition process. Add to that the years of mistreatment he's been through, and I find it very easy to see him in a sympathetic light. > But he’s undermined that with his connections to Russia. How so? Did he actively seek out Russian documents so he could release them? > hostile governments can use this information to jeopardize American national security This misses the obvious. Hostile foreign governments _already_ had this information. How or why they were using it before is beyond us. Releasing it does serve their interests, but it's no longer possible for them to monopolize it either. The only difference is, after it was released, we all had it. > If you’re neither sympathetic nor on the right side of the law, you’ve got a problem. Yes, but that's _precisely_ the reason we invented courts in the first place, to ensure that even in these ambiguous circumstances that justice can be seen to. It's troubling that you see this as the exact reason he won't receive justice at all... and again, it's what makes it so easy for me to view him sympathetically again.
- hilbertseries 6y ago> How so? Did he actively seek out Russian documents so he could release them? Julian Assange hosted a show on RT, he was literally on the payroll of the Russian government. Also suspicious is that Wikileaks basically has only leaked documents that look bad for western democracy. There’s one leak of critical of Russia, but it has basically nothing of substance in it. When you claim to be for radical transparency and work for the country that regularly has reporters murdered, it strains belief.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>Julian Assange hosted a show on RT, he was literally on the payroll of the Russian governmen Assange made a show and sold broadcast rights to RT. Small but distinct difference in that he was never under pressure to follow what Russia wanted, they just wanted to broadcast his point of biew. >There’s one leak of critical of Russia, but it has basically nothing of substance in it. Why would anyone with information damaging to Russia choose to leak data to a primarily English organization, with no Russian speaking employees, and mainly Western readers?
- mlthoughts2018 6y ago> “ Assange is accused of going beyond leaking into assisting Chelsea Manning get pass security systems. If he was not only the distributor of classified material, but actively participated in expropriating it, he’s on the wrong side of the law.” This is not actually true for whistleblowing. Manning’s conviction was an illegal conviction given that the exfiltrated evidence unequivocally shows criminal murder, among other crimes, on behalf of the United States. It is not theft or illegal access or possession if it is indeed whistleblowing. You’d have to prove that the criminal murder was not in fact criminal before any action taken to exfiltrate it can be considered a crime. On top of all this, there is no evidence that Assange illegally exfiltrated it. It is illegal for charges to be brought based on the available evidence. Of course, the fact the charges are illegal or that the conviction was illegal in Manning’s case unfortunately doesn’t matter in the United States where political actors will go unpunished for perpetrating such crimes.
- takeda 6y agoYep, that was the case with me. I supported Assange and I stopped being sympathetic when these connections came out.
- grawprog 6y ago>Moreover, Russian attempts to manipulate the 2016 election As a non American, I always found this Russian manipulation stuff funny. America has no problem manipulating elections in other countries, overthrowing elected leaders with political coups and even assassinating foreign politicians within the borders of other nations, but Russia posting facebook ads to sway the people dumb enough to be swayed by them is oh so terrible.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> America has no problem manipulating elections in other countries Yeah, but the targets always have a problem with it, except for the entities in the target nation that are in league with the Americans. So it's not so surprising that Americans have a problem when the roles are reversed, except the ones in league with the attacker.
- grawprog 6y agoWell sure, I just mean, I dunno, I guess what i'm trying to say is, 'he who casts the first stone, 'pots calling the kettle black'...'don't dish it if you can't take it'...etc.
- telchar 6y agoIn this case, those in the US most alarmed by Russian interference in the US election are mostly the same people who oppose US interference in foreign elections too. The people who supported the invasion of Iraq, for example, are mostly happy to turn a blind eye to Russian interference now. Remember in every country which does things you don't like, there are people who feel as you do. In this case those people are getting the shit end of the stick.
- trevelyan 6y agoAh yes, the insinuation that Assange was hacking stuff because he supposedly sent a message saying, "no luck with that." If there was evidence they wouldn't have fabricated it. You should be ashamed of being an apologist for tyranny.