12 ms·
Boeing gearing up for 787 move to South Carolina
- dhruvrrp 6y agoIsn't the North Charleston plant the one riddled with serious QC issues, and the one Qatar airways refused to take deliveries from? https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/20/business/boeing-dreamliner-production-problems.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/20/business/boeing-dreamline...
- Tagbert 6y agoYes, but Boeing (aka McDonald-Douglas) really wants to get rid of the unions in the Seattle area plants. Prior to the 1997 purchase of MD by Boeing, Boeing’s culture was very engineering focused. When MD came on, a large chunk of MD management were retained and soon after Boeing moved it’s official headquarters from Seattle to Chicago (where the MD headquarters were). Since then, a lot of the business decisions seem to have been more driven by management than engineering.
- nickff 6y ago>"...Boeing (aka McDonald-Douglas)..." Boeing subsumed McDonnell Douglas, not a McDonald's franchise, and did so under pressure from members of the Clinton administration.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI think the mistake qualifies as an insult of McDonald's.
- nickff 6y agoMcDonnell Aircraft was a company with a proud history, responsible for remarkable engineering, including the F-4 Phantom II and Gemini spacecraft. Douglas also has a stellar history including the World Cruisers, DC-3, and A-4 Skyhawk. I see it as tragic that they merged and slowly failed.
- virtue3 6y agoI donno, you're leaving out the DC-10, which was a pretty n notoriously bad airplane.
- justin66 6y agoIf you're judging the quality of the companies and their iterations solely by the airplanes they produced for some reason, leaving out McDonnell Douglas's F-15 is a strange omission.
- nickff 6y agoI have mixed feelings on the F-15, and think it might have turned out better if it'd been a lighter fighter, as per Col. John Boyd's specification. I think the F-4 Phantom II was a more impressive engineering achievement.
- everybodyknows 6y agoStory as I recall had SecDef William Perry call both CEOs to Washington and tell them their companies "needed" to merge.
- wahern 6y agoAccording to a 1997 Washington Post article it happened in 1993, he didn't speak with just those two CEOs but executives from across the industry, and no company was singled out, rather he suggested for the industry generally to pursue mergers to survive large cuts to defense spending: > The frenzy of defense industry mergers can be traced to 1993, when then-Deputy Defense Secretary William Perry invited executives to dinner. At an event now referred to as "the last supper," Perry urged them to combine into a few, larger companies because Pentagon budget cuts would endanger at least half the combat jet firms, missile makers, satellite builders and other contractors represented at the dinner that night. > Perry's warnings helped set off one of the fastest transformations of any modern U.S. industry, as about a dozen leading American military contractors folded into only four. And soon it's likely only three will remain, with Lockheed Martin Corp.'s announcement yesterday that it plans to buy Northrop Grumman Corp. for $11.6 billion. Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/business/1997/07/04/how-a-dinner-led-to-a-feeding-frenzy/13961ba2-5908-4992-8335-c3c087cdebc6/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/business/1997/07/04/h... In context I don't see anything untoward here. 1993 was also the fourth round of closures under the Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) process: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_Realignment_and_Closure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_Realignment_and_Closure BRAC was the systematic demilitarization of the U.S. after the Cold War, and apparently Perry was giving the industry fair warning that the process was finally and irreversibly going to bear down on their long-term sales prospects. I think it's fair to say that the Defense Department had a legitimate interest in the orderly realignment of the defense industry. It doesn't seem like he told them anything that wasn't already publicly known; rather more letting them know that there weren't going to be any 11th hour miracles. If there's an issue here it's acting on the belief that defense contractors can only survive with enormous economies of scale given the long-term capital expenditures. But everybody believed that; and most still do. Most people still think Elon Musk and SpaceX are aberrations, and maybe they are. And nobody could have guessed 9/11 and subsequent wars, which inflated defense expenditures to well beyond Reagan's highs. (For that matter, nobody could have predicted the huge amount of assets and incredible liquidity of the modern investment world that make SpaceX possible.) If spending had remained at Clinton-era levels the reduced number of competitors may have worked out perfectly well, notwithstanding the demise of Boeing culture.
- js2 6y agoIs that true or did the Clinton administration just look the other way? Regardless, it should have been blocked on anti-trust grounds, and subject to approval from Congress. At least, Ralph Nader thought so: https://nader.org/1997/01/02/boeing-mcdonnell-douglas-merger/ https://nader.org/1997/01/02/boeing-mcdonnell-douglas-merger...
- WalterBright 6y agoNader is a lawyer and activist, and has no experience running any sort of organization or company, and has no engineering training. His opinion is of little to no value here.
- CPLX 6y agoDeciding if two companies should be allowed to merge is a matter of law and public policy, not engineering.
- dotancohen 6y agoAnd yet, those are two companies steeped in engineering. One cannot decide, or even understand, the consequences of merging two engineering firms if they know nothing of engineering. Should the Ministery of Agriculture know nothing of agriculture?
- CPLX 6y agoOf course you can understand the consequences. I don’t need to know how to drill for oil to know that Standard Oil was a monopolistic trust.
- wahern 6y agoFrom the [archived] contemporaneous articles I've read it was Boeing's CEO and Chairman, Condit, who pushed heavily for the merger. Condit engineered the exit of Boeing's CFO, a skeptic, as part of an unfolding strategy to replace much of Boeing's original executive staff with those from McDonnell Douglas.[1] And he had the board's support as the Boeing board was enamored of McDonnell Douglas executives' financial engineering strategies. So while it may have nominally been McDonnell Douglas' culture that ruined Boeing, it was also very much an inside job. Boeing's leadership had already been fatally infected years prior and invited McDonnell Douglas in with the intention and purpose of adopting their culture.[2] The demise of Boeing culture was a fait accompli before the merger. This notion that Boeing was a victim is revisionist. To the extent it was a victim, it was a victim of the wider business and finance culture. There's no need to spin conspiracy theories about how it happened; it happened in the normal course of things, unfortunately. While Condit was clearly the immediate driver, the choice of Condit as CEO years earlier wasn't accidental. [1] "The exit by Givan, 62, who has held the post of Boeing finance chief and senior vice president since 1990, stems in part from disagreements with other executives over the conservative accounting methods used by Givan, say people close to the matter. For example, some officials believe he was too stringent in assessing how Boeing would accumulate charges for problems incurred in the course of its commercial-airplane order boom." https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=19980715&slug=2761320 https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=19980715&slug... [2] "'When people say I [Condit] changed the culture of Boeing, that was the intent, so that it's run like a business rather than a great engineering firm.'" https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/11/how-boeing-lost-its-bearings/602188/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/11/how-boeing...
- numpad0 6y agoFrom that simplified model, it sounds like the focus on functions than value, and constant negotiation with unions, helped Boeing survive. I wonder what makes it possible for said management to continue union busting if literally the opposite is proven to work...
- salawat 6y agoInvestors speak financials. Not nuts n' bolts. As it turns out, there are many ways to make a company with a culture going down in flames look fantastic on the books apparently.
- coredog64 6y agoPre-merger, MDD HQ was St. Louis, Missouri. The public theory behind the move was that the overall org needed a more central HQ (BCAG was primarily in Seattle, but there was still a significant presence in Texas and Wichita plus the legacy Rockwell sites). The cynical explanations are/were that Boeing had to call Washington states’s bluff for negotiating leverage (The MDD commercial stuff in California was a dead end). My pet theory is that more states == more Congressional representation.
- palefirewax 6y agoWhen I was working at Boeing, my boss who was around during those times gave this anecdote. Apparently in return for being allowed to build the 777, the city of Everett (maybe it was Renton or the state of Washington) demanded large amounts of public works/benefits. Boeing was not pleased with this but in order to make the 777 happen they did all the stuff required. However, they vowed to never have to deal with such nonsense again. To make that happen, they moved their HQ (it was eventually decided to be Chicago) and began to consider relocating their plants to another state. Eventually, that became South Carolina. Or so the anecdote goes. I don't think my boss was very high up back then, so I can't speak to how factual it is, but it sounds plausible.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThe move to Chicago was more about Condit escaping his wife.
- V_Terranova_Jr 6y agoYes. That's on the civil side. On the defense & space side, BDS is working hard to shut down the storied ex-McDonnell Douglas Huntington Beach, CA facility and move to FL, Huntsville AL, and other LCOL sites. It's now as if certain iconic HB buildings never existed - they've already been razed.
- rectang 6y agoAcronym expansions for those not-in-the-know: ∙ BDS = "Boeing Defense Systems" ∙ LCOL = "low cost of living" (I'd hate to have to maintain your code, V_Terranova_Jr.)
- dopylitty 6y agoLCOL could also mean Low Cuality of Labor
- jgwil2 6y agoThe salient aspect of the destination sites isn't low cost of living, it's "right to work" laws and other anti-union policies.
- peteretep 6y agoThat sound you hear is corks popping in Airbus’s A350 sales office
- FeistyOtter 6y agoWhich is too bad since arguably 787 is a more advanced aircraft, while A350 is more conservative. Too bad Boeing management is bent on screwing Boeing engineers and their achievements.
- peteretep 6y agoI'm not disagreeing with this, but can you give some examples? As a passenger -- other than the windows -- there's very little difference I've noticed over the course of ~40 flights on each.
- FeistyOtter 6y agoFrom the top of my head, Boeing 787 fuselage sections are formed as a single tube (more advanced, more expensive) while a350 sections are formed from 4 separate parts (older, cheaper technology, easier to repair though). 787 Cockpit is made from carbon fiber reinforced with titanium, while A350 cockpit is a traditional aluminium one. So yes, these things are invisible to a passenger the same way as a software architecture is invisible to a user, but to airlines and to industry as a whole these things are important.
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoWhat advantages does the single tube fuselage give?
- FeistyOtter 6y agoI would imagine that without skin splices it weights less, has less drag in flight and generally one less thing to worry about for mechanics.
- bilbo0s 6y agoNot only Qatar, the US Navy was not accepting those either since a while back. Don't know if that ever changed.
- throw0101a 6y ago> Not only Qatar, the US Navy was not accepting those either since a while back. The whole KC-46 tanker program is quite the mess as well: * https://www.defensenews.com/air/2020/03/31/the-air-forces-kc-46-tanker-has-another-serious-technical-deficiency-and-boeing-is-stuck-paying-for-it/ https://www.defensenews.com/air/2020/03/31/the-air-forces-kc... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_KC-46_Pegasus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_KC-46_Pegasus
- bilbo0s 6y agoAt what point do you start to wonder if this level of mismanagement is purposeful? The number of flaws across multiple different programs. (Serious flaws no less.) The number of management missteps. It just feels almost like either a purposeful tanking, or the sort of slow motion, but accelerating, collapse that happens when you've filled every level of an organization with less than able people.
- jen729w 6y agoTo what end?
- mschuster91 6y agoUpper management whose KPI are solely on base of profit make a couple of big fat paychecks over the year as ever more and more is gutted. Now that the dung pile has grown so big that it touches the ceiling fan, that guard of beancounter managers has long moved on to other companies to raze...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- holler 6y agorelated article from local Seattle newspaper: https://www.thestranger.com/slog/2020/09/09/44441906/the-death-of-industrial-seattle https://www.thestranger.com/slog/2020/09/09/44441906/the-dea... "So, Seattle finds itself where Pittsburgh was in the 1970s and Detroit in the 1960s. The city is about to lose a central part of its industrial base. Today, Pittsburgh, the "Steel City," has no steel plants at all." ... "Seattle will finally become fully post-industrial in the third decade of the third millennium."
- dralley 6y agoSeattle is still in a better position than those cities due to Microsoft and Amazon, which will soften the blow, but it will still be quite painful.
- rtkwe 6y agoYeah the Everett plant only employees 30k according to the Boeing site which is 1% of Seattle's population even if the whole plant went away. It'd hurt to lose for sure but I doubt it will be disastrous the same way it was when steel and cars left other cities.
- akira2501 6y ago30k Boeing employees, but I'd like to know how many local contractors, shops and restaurants ultimately depend on this workforce.
- rtkwe 6y agoLocal shops can ship parts to Boeing's other plants and there are other aircraft that will still be made there. For things more tangentially related like restaurants the most threat would be to the ones right there that depend on work lunches, outside of that very local area are at much lower risk because as big as the factory is (and again it's not leaving just losing one plane) it's a small percentage of the local population.
- 6y ago
- aaronbrethorst 6y agoIf it ain't Airbus, Bombardier, or Embraer, I ain't going.
- jsjohnst 6y agoTo each their own, but the 737 NG (aka the models before the Max), the 747-400 / 747-8, and the 787 all have a lower number of fatal crashes per million flights than the Airbus A320 family and the A330.
- Spartan-S63 6y agoThese are all true statistics. I’d be curious to see an academic analysis on QC, flight hours, maintenance routines/quality of maintenance, and other factors that might play into why those aircraft have better safety ratings than competitors. It might be interesting to see if Boeing QC issues off the assembly line lead to better maintenance routines, which in turn results in safer overall operation. A result like that doesn’t imply that the manufacturer, Boeing, is the most influential component to safety.
- coredog64 6y agoThat’s not correct. For a long time, Boeing and Airbus had wildly different philosophies about how aircraft should be flown. I’m not going to pick a side as there are trade offs to both approaches, but there were a LOT of teething problems with the Airbus approach. I think we’ve settled down now and have a better handle on how to train for either approach. Of course, Boeing has also picked up (or been forced to adopt) pieces of the strategy used by Airbus.
- ponker 6y agoCould you explain these differences to someone with no experience in flying?
- 666lumberjack 6y ago
- jorblumesea 6y agoIt's hard to believe that the current Boeing leadership will turn things around with even less focus on quality and talented workers. Feels like they should be moving back towards engineering driven approaches.
- anonu 6y agoAre you implying South Carolina workers are less talented than those in Seattle?
- benzible 6y agoLess qualified and less trained. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/20/business/boeing-dreamliner-production-problems.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/20/business/boeing-dreamline... > While Boeing has nurtured generations of aerospace professionals in the Seattle area, there was no comparable work force in South Carolina. Instead, managers had to recruit from technical colleges in Tulsa, Okla., and Atlanta. > Managers were also urged to not hire unionized employees from the Boeing factory in Everett, where the Dreamliner is also made, according to two former employees. > “They didn’t want us bringing union employees out to a nonunion area,” said David Kitson, a former quality manager, who oversaw a team responsible for ensuring that planes are safe to fly. > “We struggled with that,” said Mr. Kitson, who retired in 2015. “There wasn’t the qualified labor pool locally.” Another former manager, Michael Storey, confirmed his account.
- isbjorn16 6y agoTo be clear, this doesn't mean there aren't intelligent people in South Carolina. What this does mean is there is a presence in this PNW area, specifically centralized in Puget Sound, where talented aerospace engineers tend to congregate. No matter where you move that is new, you are not going to have that _local_ talent pool necessarily available to you. This isn't to slight South Carolina at all, but it is reality.
- throw0101a 6y ago
- throw0101a 6y agoSo 787s are assembled at both Seattle, WA, and North Charleston, SC, plants, but it is the South Carolina-produced planes that seem to be drawing complaints: > Some of the airlines buying 787 Dreamliners built at Boeing Co.’s North Charleston campus are complaining about “unacceptable” production mistakes and poor quality, and analysts say the criticism points to issues deep within the aerospace giant’s culture. * https://www.postandcourier.com/business/airline-surveys-point-to-ongoing-production-problems-at-boeing-s/article_0e75f53a-b2d6-11e9-9606-0ffafccd055e.html https://www.postandcourier.com/business/airline-surveys-poin... Supposedly some airlines refuse to take delivery of airplanes assembled in SC: > Safety lapses at the North Charleston plant have drawn the scrutiny of airlines and regulators. Qatar Airways stopped accepting planes from the factory after manufacturing mishaps damaged jets and delayed deliveries. * https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/20/business/boeing-dreamliner-production-problems.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/20/business/boeing-dreamline... * https://leehamnews.com/2020/09/14/pontifications-boeing-sc-makes-its-case-for-787-production-consolidation-and-it-favors-everett/ https://leehamnews.com/2020/09/14/pontifications-boeing-sc-m... At this point, given how much Boeing seems to have turned its own reputation to ash, why would one buy an aircraft from them?
- chillfox 6y agoPresumably because you can buy a Boeing today where you would have to wait 5+ years for an Airbus. Of course if they keep sliding then you might as well buy a Chinese or Russian aircraft instead of Boeing if you want something now and don't care about quality.
- FeistyOtter 6y agoIs it really true that you can buy a Boeing instantly? I have read that both manufacturers have order queues for years ahead, but I can be mistaken.
- Twixes 6y agoBrb, buying a 787
- 6y ago
- MattGaiser 6y agoStrikes are expensive. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_machinists_strike_of_2008 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_machinists_strike_of_... The fact that this is even a maybe says that they expect billions in quality control issues from South Carolina a decade.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 6y agoThe 737 has succumbed to the same disease as software. What originally was a successful well engineered product gets loaded with extra bells and whistles until it collapses under its own weight. This process is accelerated with MBA manager. Mother Nature is judge, jury and executioner when it comes to abuse of aerodynamics. MBAs don't get the message until there's smoking wrecks. Passengers may decide to refuse flights on 737s. There's lots of parked aircraft at the moment and will be until the pandemic is well past. It might be a couple years. Passengers may vote with their feet for Airbus.
- Zigurd 6y agoThat's a broad brush you get there. There have been detailed investigations that show that specific actions by specific people in Boeing and the FAA led to a single point of failure, from which it is nearly impossible to recover, being permitted to get into production, in a passenger aircraft. On top of that, after one of those planes crashed in a way that is attributable to this gross defect, the pilots were blamed by Boeing, to deflect from having to fix this defect. So, while it may come down to that you can't run an airplane maker like a soft drink company, there is a lot of detailed information about why. No need to generalize. In fact there are confounding details that suggest that "MBA manager" is the wrong generalization. Dennis Mullenberg, who was the CEO fired due to the 737 fiasco, came up through Boeing engineering, after joining as an intern in the 1980s. He was replaced by David Calhoun, a director at Boeing, who came up through GE and Blackstone and was the co-author of a generic seeming self-congratulatory business book called "How Companies Win: Profiting from Demand-Driven Business Models No Matter What Business You're In" That sure makes it seem like he could sell Coke on Tuesday and airliners on Thursday. Maybe the real answer is that the FAA was lulled into complacency, and an engineer who should have been minding the shop wasn't.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- clamprecht 6y agoAs a pilot, I saw "gear up" and thought a 787 had landed gear up. What a terrible headline.
- redis_mlc 6y agoNo, I saw "South Carolina" and instantly knew this article was about union busting.
- Proven 6y agoManufacturers of cars, airplanes and high-value taxpayers moving out of socialist-dominated states... It’s going to get even worse if Sleepy Joe wins.
- LatteLazy 6y agoOn one hand, it must be a nightmare right now for anyone in the airline industry (from suppliers to operators etc). On the other hand, it's the perfect time to relocate factories and make changes to processes and try new technologies.
- lmilcin 6y agoI am not so sure. What about funding? Any move like that is going to cost a huge amount and this is risky proposition at a time when it is not exactly known what the future of the industry is going to be.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThere is definately that. I wonder if it helps though: if you're raising/borrowing/getting given 10bn to stay open, how hard is it to get another 1bn for plant re-arrangement or new software? It's all part of your efficiency savings, return to profitability plan right?
- draw_down 6y agoLabor costs.
- anjel 6y agoThis could also be seen as Boeing pursuing union and gov't concessions so I wouldn't rule out a last minute change-of-heart.