4 ms·
I don't know if that strictly goes to what the article was talking about, but nevertheless: Blockchains can prove that two parties once agreed on something, ch
by roenxi 6y ago
I don't know if that strictly goes to what the article was talking about, but nevertheless:
Blockchains can prove that two parties once agreed on something, cheaply. That is remarkably valuable information (of such bricks economies are built). And it is truly remarkable that there is nothing in the blockchain that a government can do about it. Ditto anyone else.
I believe it is financial information and preference data that is difficult to share at the moment and that the article alludes to liberating. For example, donating to Wikileaks was extremely challenging via Paypal and other traditional money handlers. That obviously has both up and downsides.
This is new. I live in an age where my cooperation might be strictly necessary for somebody else to tax me. The practicalities haven't changed much, but the theoretical change is quite profound.
- chii 6y ago> Blockchains can prove that two parties once agreed on something, cheaply. it's not as cheap as trusting a third party. The evidence for this is that block chain as a form of financial payment system is still way outstripped by commercial credit card providers. And it's not just existing/legacy momentum either, because if you look at china, the advent of digital payment systems on the mobile _could've_ been using the block chain, but it hasn't. > nothing in the blockchain that a government can do about it. And unless the entire transaction _only_ occurs on the blockchain, a gov't can always do something about it using the rubber-hose law of security.
- skitout 6y agoBlockchain (sometime) can replace third party by some open source code. For example on decentralized Exchange platform you directly exchange your assets ; no trust, no third party needed. And it is cheaper than third party based exchange. Of course, blockchain does not make sense in all the cases. But third party does represent a cost, and can sometime represent a risk (eg becoming dominant thanks to network effect, then extracting rent), or slow innovation (are you are dependent of this third party). Please keep in mind that blockchain is not only about cryptomoney.
- ay 6y ago1. Click != agreement. Cf: phishing. 2. https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/ - applies for any sufficiently large entities and certainly governments.
- ay 6y agoSorry can’t edit, but a perfect exhibit for (2) is on HN right now: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24545236 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24545236
- zozbot234 6y ago> ... cheaply ... For some values of "cheaply", of course. Reliance on a mutually-trusted third party, where feasible, is a lot cheaper than any blockchain.
- skitout 6y ago- often you need to rely on multiple mutually-trusted third party (eg transferring money from your bank account, to a a bank account in another continent) and that have a cost - Blockchain sometime bring a higher level of automation, reducing cost - And more importantly, there are many cases where the "mutually-trusted third party" becomes a "dominant power" in its area and extract rent from it. App stores come to mind, but that the case of most "platforms"... Decentralization + open source + token to incentivize the system seems to be able to have cheaper, better and more transparent stuff.
- zby 6y ago"Blockchains can prove that two parties once agreed on something, cheaply." - well actually you can do that with electronic signatures, much cheaper than with blockchains. The problem that blockchain solves is a very specific timestamping of messages between many participants. For two participants just signing a date is enough - the problem is if A singes two checks to B and C and you want to know which one was first.