5 ms·
It is very hard to open your first bank account in the UK as an immigrant due to AML regulations(They require proof of address, it creates a catch 22 situation)
by mrtksn 6y ago
It is very hard to open your first bank account in the UK as an immigrant due to AML regulations(They require proof of address, it creates a catch 22 situation). The joke goes that you need to be a drug dealer or a warlord to easily open a bank account in the UK. Maybe it was not all jokes after all.
- javajosh 6y agoThis is also true in Germany (to rent a place you need a bank account, but to get a bank account you need a registered address). You almost always will need a 3rd party to help you. In my case my employer rented an apartment, and then had someone register me there, which required me assigning limited power of attorney. Then I opened a bank account with that address, and the cycle was broken. Note that this also requires a work and residence permit, which is usually going to be a blue card, which is a whole other ball of wax. So, yeah, its hard, but not impossible.
- Scoundreller 6y agoSame for exchange students in France. Usually they get buddied up with someone to register at their address to get a bank account if they'll be there longer term and need their own lease.
- luckylion 6y agoI'm pretty sure you can use cash deposits at a bank to pay rent. My land lords in Germany have never asked for proof of bank account, they just provided their account details and asked me to set up recurrent payments. Not every bank offers it, and it's costly (5-20€ afaik), but it works. If you have a bank account in another country, that'll work as well, you just need a way to transfer money to accounts, as few land lords will accept cash payments.
- kxyvr 6y agoSame in Norway. The purpose is to put the deposit into an interest bearing account in both the name of tenant and the landlord to prevent the deposit from being stolen. Unfortunately, this catch-22 presents an undue hardship for new immigrants looking for either a place to live or a bank account. Reasonable landlords will hold the deposit in cash and give a receipt until the bank account can be obtained, but this is not strictly legal.
- valuearb 6y agoThe authors of this article haven’t considered how these ridiculous regulations affect the poor, or the innocent who have had accounts seized with little recourse.
- admissionsguy 6y agoA few years ago I was able to: 1) submit an online application for a bank account, 2) receive, to the address put in the online form, a rejection letter (due to, I think, lack of proof of address and/or credit history), 3) use that letter as a proof of address to open an account in another bank.
- mrtksn 6y agoI met someone who was riding the busses and the tube for free until he got caught so he can use the fine letter as proof of address. I don't know if he succeeded but I think the country you are from also matters, there was a French girl who managed to get her account using an Amazon shipment. Rent contracts don't work unless the renter is a some giant institution. GSM package shipment would't work(people tried GiffGaff envelopes). A letter from the employer works only if the employer is a large institution(Virgin would work, McDonalds would work, a small company with 5-10 employees may work if the banker had good sex last night, smaller companies unlikely to work). The first company I worked for was a small one and got like 10 letters from them and went around branches and one branch finally accepted the letter. I think it was around Christmas and the employee was in a festive mood that day. That said, I think the situation is easier these days thanks to Monzo or Revolut.
- jariel 6y agoThese kinds of rules are insane. It implies the government/bank cannot legitimately determine your status. It's a mind-boggling level of bureaucratic incompetency. You should get some kind of 'citizen number' from the government, then, the government allows certain 'highly regulated organizations' to 'check on status for specific reasons. You go to the bank/wireless carrier, show your ID with citizen number and 'prove it's you' - the bank has permission to request your 'status' from the government at that time (i.e. 'landed immigrant' 'citizen' 'diplomat') and makes their own business decisions. Easy peasy. Same thing for insurance, healthcare, social benefits etc..
- mrtksn 6y agoIn the UK there's no concept if national ID and national ID card(There's an NI number for social security stuff but that's different). There's no central registry of citizens addresses and such, at least officially. It certainly makes some things harder but I respect the spirit of the way British approach these things. Once you are in, it feels like the government minds its own business and doesn't have to know everything you do. I also think that this fosters the free thinking and innovation that UK is a leader of.
- jariel 6y agoEven though I get what you are saying, I think this might be a post-romanticization of it all. Same with 'no constitution'. It just so happens that Napoleon never made it across the channel, and you never really had 'your own Napoleon' and so all of the 'ancient systems' remained - sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse. Aside from the Biblically dystopian echoes of the 'each shall bear a mark which will be required to do commerce' of Revelations, which in all seriousness is a pretty insightful hint at what very well would provide the means for a totalitarian apparatus to control us all ... ... the benefits of some kind of 'national id' are just tremendous and we all need to think about this. 'Lack of ID' is a 'root cause' in everything from gun registry, to healthcare, to immigration, to financial fraud, to benefits fraud etc.. At least the gov. should provide a 'Google-like Single Sign' on for official use. The Canadian government is now defaulting to banks, god forbid billions of dollars in IT can't produce 'a login'.