10 ms·
Precursor – A mobile, open source electronics platform
- Etheryte 6y agoThis scratches a fairly specific itch I've had for quite a while now — portable DIY electronics. At the moment, even if you use something as Lego-like as Adafruit's boards [1], you still need your primary logic board, a separate module to handling charging, a battery pack, a case that holds all of the above in place neatly, and more. Personally I don't find the keyboard to be a very attractive feature of Precursor, but all the rest of this project is super exciting and I can't wait to see them deliver on it. [1] https://www.adafruit.com/ https://www.adafruit.com/
- josalhor 6y ago> This scratches a fairly specific itch I've had for quite a while now — portable DIY electronics Just the other day I found out about WiPhone: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2103809433/wiphone-a-phone-for-hackers-and-makers/description https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2103809433/wiphone-a-ph... The project appears to be in a "limbo" state.
- squarefoot 6y agoIt's sad to see that. The project is interesting, but making it WiFi only restricted immensely its use. Although it seems obsolete tech, many countries still use 2G GSM phones (my phone is only GSM in fact). Adding a cheap SIM800 chip on a small removable board would turn this into a real phone, and the sales from people who needed GSM would help to cover for further development for the 4/5G version.
- gabrielsroka 6y agoFrom TFA > if your application does not require a large display and a keyboard, you can simply remove them and replace the bezel with a full-sized circuit board
- semi-extrinsic 6y agoPersonally I just use ESP32 (specifically Lolin D32) in an altoids-type box with a run-of-the-mill small USB power bank taped to the back. Usually with some level shifters and stuff to run the Blinkenlights (FastLED + ws2813). If that's too ghetto for you, have a look at the M5Stack series. A main unit (ESP32, screen, speaker, TF card reader, in a case with some buttons) costs $35, and the battery module you can stack on is $10. There is even a keyboard and a gameboy-like attachment. I like the look of the Precursor, but personally the FPGA is a bit off-putting, just because I've never gone down that road.
- ncmncm 6y agoStep up to FPGA. There has to be a first time.
- 20after4 6y agoYou might also like Wio Terminal[1] if you are looking for something with a bit less powerful hardware and no keyboard. Also it's available now and supported by a fairly mature software stack (micropython for esp32) [1] https://www.seeedstudio.com/Wio-Terminal-p-4509.html https://www.seeedstudio.com/Wio-Terminal-p-4509.html
- R0b0t1 6y agoThe FPGAs could still be backdoored, and the WiFi chipset should receive a fair bit of suspicion. But I guess it is a good first step.
- beagle3 6y agoThat could be true even if you sourced and programmed them yourself, no? We already know that AMD/PSP and Intel/ME are back footed, for example. How deep do you want to go down the rabbit hole? Are you capable of fabbing your own silicon?
- adgshqr3h432 6y agointerestingly, bunnie's previous take has been that fabbing your own silicon is likely less secure than using an fpga due to supply chain security if your asic if compromised in tranist, it's a total game over. if your fpga is compromised in transit, the attacker has to have some knowledge of target bitstream it has been argued that by making it easy for end users to rearrange the bitstream, an fpga can be more secure than an asic https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=5706 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=5706
- R0b0t1 6y agoI looked through the link and that does not seem to be what he says. He is just talking about how much verification you need to do, like I am trying to do. It is shortsighted to view making your own ASIC as less secure. The supply chain weaknesses exist whether or not you make your own hardware. Making your own hardware can potentially limit your exposure to systemic baked in vulnerabilities. Additionally, after-manufacture exploits (as in the NSA interdiction of Cisco router shipments) are easier for mass produced goods. There are likely edge cases involving small, easier to bribe manufacturers, but I'm not sure you can make broad generalizations on that possibility alone.
- fragmede 6y agoCalling it an "edge case" dismisses the fact that Facebook/Apple/Google are never going to make the kind of openly verifiably secure device without a colossal shift in the market. We're not going to see mass produced goods that target the same market as Precursor, so all there is in this space is "small, easier to bribe manufacturers". It's great that Facebook/Apple/Google can securely manufacture devices, with a supply chain thats verifiable by them, but externally, TouchID's security amounts to "we're Apple, trust us". That's not good enough for the target market for Precursor.
- oehtXRwMkIs 6y agoI found a typo where the "are" is duplicated: > enclosure’s length and thickness are are parameterized.
- bunnie 6y agothanks, fixed.
- cocktailpeanuts 6y agoI remember there was a similar attempt years ago (probably between 5 to 10 years ago). I forgot the name of the startup but they were trying to build a non-phone mobile device that's programmable. I actually applied for beta testing and got one for free, but they ended up going out of business. I remember the color was ruby-ish. Can't remember the name. Anyone know what this was?
- cxr 6y agoAre you thinking of the long-delayed DragonBox Pyra from the Pandora community? https://pyra-handheld.com/boards/pages/pyra/ https://pyra-handheld.com/boards/pages/pyra/
- cocktailpeanuts 6y agono the project I'm talking about looked similar to this one but a bit shorter vertically, and the one I owned had a dark pink (or ruby) color. Had the same blackberry type keyboard too. It was a startup, and they shut down eventually.
- amelius 6y agoDoes that FPGA come with software tools that are backed by the FPGA vendor?
- PAPPPmAc 6y agoThe XC7S50 is a Spartan7, which is supported by Vivado's WebPack edition (free but with many non-FOSS parts) as well as the FOSS SymbiFlow toolchain (I can't figure out which Place-and-Route tool that targets Xilinx 7-series parts they're using from the docs, but they imply one is at least vaguely usable) too. The iCE40UP5K will work with any IceStorm-based FOSS toolchain (including SymbiFlow) as well as Lattice's free first party Radiant tool (and I think also the older IceCube2 toolchain). It's a little odd that they're different vendor parts / on different 1st party toolchains, but it does look like you could program everything through the FOSS tools, albeit probably missing a few features (Last I looked a couple of the special purpose blocks in both the Xilinx 7-series and the UltraPlus were not fully understood by the FOSS stuff; that may have changed). I've been meaning to try Radiant, I teach some classes on top fo Vivado + Artix7 FPGA dev boards, and it's so much less awful than ISE (Xilinx's old toolchain) I'm still pleased with, but there are some nice, affordable iCE40-UltraPlus boards coming on the market, and if Radiant is less of a hassle (Vivado is a 25GB install and not _entirely_ beginner-friendly) I'd consider retooling.
- intricatedetail 6y agoIsn't Spartan a legacy platform?
- PAPPPmAc 6y agoThe Spartan 3/3E/6 lines are legacy parts (and hence stuck on ISE for programming, so you don't want them). The Spartan 7 parts were a late addition (not shipping until 2017) to the 7th gen line for the low end; they use the 7th gen blocks and tooling, but are "cost optimized" and lack the fancy transceivers and such - though irritatingly the cost and resources of the Artix and Spartan parts have a lot of overlap; Spartan7 parts run from about $15-140 in single, Artix7 parts from about $25-430.
- radec 6y agosuper interesting. I know things cost money, but I really hope they can hit a price point similar to pinephone or wiphone.
- agumonkey 6y agomodern pocket calcs
- charsi 6y agoI love this. I like the form factor. I like the versatility of it that is being thought of from the start.
- motohagiography 6y agoBest name.
- ysleepy 6y agoWow, this looks awesome. This formfactor, combined with a LoRa transceiver would be epic as an off-grid or fallback comms device. I get fuzzy cyberpunk feelings imagining it. Bunnie's projects are always intriguing. I'm still amazed by the investigation into sd card controller chips.
- nullc 6y agoMaybe they'll later do a version where the corner of the PCB that has the wifi radio is notched out and there is a set of horizontal pins to slide in a replacement pcb... so you could replace the wifi radio with LoRa. Sticking LoRa in this would be awesome, (e.g. https://www.meshtastic.org/ https://www.meshtastic.org/), but I can understand why it has wifi.
- jedimastert 6y ago> I get fuzzy cyberpunk feelings imagining it. Definite cyberdeck potential
- gautamcgoel 6y agoWhat is LoRa?
- anon73044 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LoRa https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LoRa
- alexisread 6y agoSomething like the EZR32WG supports the Dash7 open source stack, so you can even verify the radio :)
- thawkins 6y agoI must admit while this cool, what I really want is a standard dirtcheap 8 to 10 inch Android tablet with a hackable OS and a row of gpio pins on it like the raspberry pi. $50 will get you a lot of power and convience today as these things are two a penny due to economies of Scale. Throw a usb-c video input and output onto it too, so it can use it as a touch screen monitor for my phone too. and I'm sold
- evilos 6y agoThis guy is working on a modular hardware linux tablet: https://hackaday.io/project/164845-dlt-one-a-damn-linux-tablet https://hackaday.io/project/164845-dlt-one-a-damn-linux-tabl...
- unnouinceput 6y agoWasn't not long ago right here on HN an article of somebody who did a phone from hacking together stuff around Raspberry Pi? Heck, you can even install Android or Windows IoT on a Raspberry Pi, if you don't like Raspberry Pi OS (former Raspbian)
- crispyambulance 6y agoOne of them was this guy... https://kevinlynagh.com/phonetron/ https://kevinlynagh.com/phonetron/
- buzzert 6y agoIt sounds like what you're looking for is the Pocket C.H.I.P. The company went out of business, but I bought one back in the day and it was so fun to hack around with. While writing this comment, I discovered that there's a website selling new old stock? Can't vouch for its authenticity, but you should go for it! https://shop.pocketchip.co/collections/frontpage/products/pocket-c-h-i-p-new https://shop.pocketchip.co/collections/frontpage/products/po...
- Fnoord 6y agoI don't think that is akin to an 8 to 10" Android tablet/screen. Then again, I don't see how all the other products are related to the one mentioned here. Except they're all hackable? If you want a small device to play old games on via an emulator, I can recommend Pocketsprite [1]. You can even assemble one yourself. FWIW, I'm looking for a small portable screen (1080p, IPS) to combine with my MBP 2015 (via TB2 or HDMI but I also want it to have USB-C for future compatibility). [1] https://pocketsprite.com https://pocketsprite.com
- analognoise 6y agoI just want a modern EEEPC in a 7" format with an FPGA for a brain rather than any processor, so you can build whatever you want.
- MayeulC 6y agoThis looks very nice, and actually pretty rugged. A few thoughts: * Would it increase the complexity a lot to provide a linux-capable SoC as an additional chip? (OK, this could be a daughter board) * "iCE40UP5K SG48, 98% utilized" <- isn't it a bit restrictive to start with such a low room for growth?
- bunnie 6y agoThe iCE40UP5K is not the main processor. It's the embedded controller. Think of it as a power management coprocessor that takes care of things like managing the battery while the main CPU is asleep. It is packed to the gills, but the iCE40UP5K is low enough power to remain on and not drain the battery for several days. The main CPU is a Spartan7 XC7S50, which has plenty of space for things like crypto accelerator cores beyond the primary RISC-V CPU.
- analognoise 6y agoWhat kind of crypto accelerator would be most interesting to people?
- wazzaps 6y agoProbably whatever TLS or GPG needs
- nullc 6y agoWhat I think would be most interesting is whatever primitives are needed to build fancy cryptosystems which are resistant to EMI/DPA sidechannels. Plain TLS stuff as the sibling comment suggests is entirely uninteresting to me-- a boring software implementation is more than fast enough even on a 100MHz device to accomplish whatever that 100MHz device is going to accomplish. (I assume bunnie's Betrusted soc will be faster than 100MHz too). But what you can't do from general software is get something which is extremely robust against EMI and power sidechannels. Similarly, while plain ECDH/etc. will be more than fast enough even in software for 99% of applications you'd want to run on a small device like this, various zero knoweldge proofs and other fancy constructions may still be painfully slow (as they're often noticably slow on desktops). Unfortunately the ed25519 curve is probably not really the best choice there for a primitive to optimize due to the cofactor being an extraordinary nuisance for other applications outside of plain signatures and key agreement. ... but group choices for ZKPs are by-far not a settled question.
- gautamcgoel 6y agoI really dig the slim and professional form factor, a lot of "portable" open-source hardware projects look like a bunch of PCBs stapled together, with wires and connectors hanging out everywhere.
- twarge 6y agoFor me the attraction is a reasonable screen and keyboard - that sort of interface is by far the most difficult part of hardware projects.
- gregsadetsky 6y agoBunnie (as you seem to be around here) — can the accel/gyro values be read/sampled? They’re listed under the “anti-tamper” category on crowdsupply so I wasn’t sure. Are there some specs on max Gs, sample rate, etc.? — I find this device extraordinarily appealing (will definitely be backing). Bunnie is a hardware hacker’s hacker, the project has at least 2 years of development behind it. It will most definitely ship, and work. Ha. But — I’m specifically excited because this seems like an ideal platform to build whimsical mobile hardware projects. My dream of a 2000-era electronic organizer with a “retro” (non touch) display, with physical keyboard, and battery, and programmable/hackable and fully open... this is truly a dream come true. Why couldn’t this become the democratizing mobile Arduino-like hobbyist “base”? I’m extra, extra excited about it! (And dream of adding LTE and making a retro minimal... phone OS/“app”? Fast email + wikipedia clients??)
- bunnie 6y agoThanks for the enthusiasm! I happen to be up really late tonight, but I'm going to bed soon. Thank you for the support and kind words. The accelerometer is the LSM6DS3, I'll refer you directly to the manufacturer's website: https://www.st.com/en/mems-and-sensors/lsm6ds3.html https://www.st.com/en/mems-and-sensors/lsm6ds3.html You can find out more about how it's integrated at https://github.com/betrusted-io/betrusted-hardware/blob/master/mainboard-dvt1/trusted_io_dvt1.pdf https://github.com/betrusted-io/betrusted-hardware/blob/mast... (note: this is a "DVT" schematic, bugs were found, they are currently being fixed, but they aren't related to the accelerometer). The TL;DR is that the accelerometer is integrated so that it's in the "always on" untrusted domain, so to access it from the main FPGA "SoC" you have to go through the system controller FPGA ("EC" as we call it). The idea is for it to be available in power down states for anti-tamper, hence the extra layer of complication. Talking to it requires a call to the EC via the "COM" bus (https://github.com/betrusted-io/betrusted-soc/blob/master/fw/src/main.rs#L849 https://github.com/betrusted-io/betrusted-soc/blob/master/fw...). The EC driver itself is based on the C-native library provided by STM and translated into Rust bindings. It's a little gross: https://github.com/betrusted-io/betrusted-ec/blob/master/sw/gyro_bindings/src/lib.rs https://github.com/betrusted-io/betrusted-ec/blob/master/sw/... Hope that helps.
- dvdkon 6y agoThis looks lovely. I've long been looking for a hackable device in this form factor, albeit more with the intent of running Linux. One thing I can't find any detail on is the keyboard. Making a keyboard from scratch is well outside of usual low-volume productions and there aren't any readily available parts in this form factor as far as I know. How is the Precursor's one made/sourced?
- bunnie 6y agoI'll be writing an article on this in the future, and you're right, the keyboard was a serious pain to build. It's one of the big reasons it took two years to bring the product to this state.
- dvdkon 6y agoThanks, I'm excited already! I'm using a Blackberry keyboard for my project, but that's obviously not scalable.
- ObsoleteNerd 6y agoSeriously cool. Love the attention to detail. I’ll definitely back whatever funding campaign is launched for this, I’ve got the perfect project in mind for a portable secure controller.
- bibabaloo 6y agoAt the risk of wanting this to be something that it's not - what's the reasoning behind not targeting Precursor towards running (embedded) Linux? With a little more RAM it seems like the specs would make it a great fit for Linux, which might allow for a broader ecosystem of use cases? Is there something I'm missing that means developing a new OS (https://github.com/betrusted-io/xous-core/ https://github.com/betrusted-io/xous-core/) works better for Precursor? Keen to understand the rationale, cause I think I'm probably missing something here! edit: There's a good explanation on the CrowdSupply page - seems like it's in order to make it a more secure platform: > Simplicity addresses the reality of only having 24 hours in a day. Even though the full source code for the Linux kernel and Firefox is published, nobody has the time to personally review every release for potential security problems; we simply trust that others have done a good job, because we have no other choice. Precursor rolls the clock back to the early 2000’s, when mobile computers were powerful enough to be useful for single tasks, while simple enough that individuals or small teams could build them from scratch. But don’t worry, despite its simplicity, Precursor’s computational capability exceeds that of the Palm Pilot series. It’s more on par with a Nintendo DS: sufficient for core security tasks such as authentication, instant messaging, crypto wallets, and even end-to-end encrypted voice calls.
- arc-in-space 6y agoThis is something that worries me about this project. Is the focus more on hackability, or security/inspectability? The messaging is unclear, and this decision looks like a big sacrifice of the former for the latter. I'd maybe be interested in this device but only for the purposes of DIY messing around, I'm nowhere near so worried about security I wouldn't trust the linux kernel.
- intricatedetail 6y agoInteresting project but it seems like the schematics require proprietary and extremely expensive software to look at. Certainly beyond hobbyist reach. Why not develop with open source tools like Kicad? Kicad these days is mature enough to handle a project of this scale easily.
- ncmncm 6y agoI just learned of "dynamic reconfiguration", where a running device configures and commits additional logic units to a temporary task. Is that possible, in principle, in a Spartan 7? It is easy to believe that you would need to pre-generate bitstreams for each configuation, and could only swap them in verbatim, not generate them on-the-fly, but downloading from a library, perhaps with parameterized choices, could increase flexibility.
- jecel 6y agoMost current FPGAs offer the option to have one configuration select a different bitstream in the configuration memory and have that replace itself. That allows a simple menu configuration to let the user select between several actual configurations. Or it allows over the air updates. In the specific case of Xilinx FPGAs there was a feature introduced in the original Virtex called "partial configuration". This has been present in all its products for the last 20 years. It allows a design to be broken into parts such that one part may be replaced even while the rest of the FPGA continues to work normally. This is pretty hard to use and the interface between the part being swapped and the rest of the circuit is rather tricky, so it has been use more for cool demos than actual products. It is possible to have the equivalent to this with non Xilinx FPGAs by having several smaller ones connected to each other on a board. Then dynamic reconfiguration of one can happen while the others continue to work normally.
- ncmncm 6y agoThank you. I guess it would be a bit much to hope for more auxiliary FPGAs on such a portable device.