7 ms·
Creativity Changes as We Age
- jl2718 6y agoThis made me think about what I want to be doing on my deathbed versus what I’m doing now.
- chrisweekly 6y agoThe linked article is beautifully-written and thought-provoking, excerpted from "The Age of Creativity: Art, Memory, My Father, and Me" by Emily Urquhart.
- katsume3 6y agoMy creativity has certainly changed and I'm middle-aged. I find myself constantly trying to make everything as ergonomic as possible. Years of sitting in an office chair has warped my spine, which now means I have to take regular breaks every 15 minutes or so to straighten out my back. In my early 20s I could go for long stretches in a chair, happily coding away doing 'sprints'. Now I've turned everything into a marathon, stretching out my work thinly over longer periods of time, paying attention to and mulling over details instead of glossing over them (something my younger self would do all day: gloss over everything and ignore nuance, yet still get things done)
- agumonkey 6y agocould I rephrase it by instead of short term you can project long term and see how tiny papercuts would add up in the future ?
- mellosouls 6y agoIt's a very optimistic view, and may be true in some limited domains and individuals but generally speaking groundbreaking creativity (as opposed to the natural creativity within us all which declines gradually but doesn't necessarily completely disappear as we age) is a property of the young, though it may vary from field to field. e.g. pop music, maths, poetry, physics, etc; you're done by 30. Writers/composers maybe another 10 years or so. I say that not to be negative, but to urge any young readers who feel they have a talent to not be complacent and assume they will be an exception, or that its related to family/financial/work commitments when you see the decline in your heroes and you will just avoid all that. Use it before you lose it!
- inglor_cz 6y agoAs a mathematician-turned-programmer-later-turned-writer, writing after 40 seems to be fairly productive. The quality decline seems to start at about 60-65 years of age, and might be avoidable if you can keep your brain healthy. Every single writer or journalist I know whose output started to decline exhibited signs of creeping dementia. Mathematics is a young people game, though. Very rare to push out significant results after forty.
- lnsru 6y agoHere you go: https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/lists/nobel-laureates-by-age/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/lists/nobel-laureates-by-a...
- alextheparrot 6y agoThis isn’t particularly interesting as a counterpoint, as there’s a known lag between creativity and recognition. To take the easiest example, Einstein published his awarded idea at 26, but he wasn’t awarded until 42.
- auggierose 6y agoThat's when they got the prize, not when they did what they won it for.
- mellosouls 6y agoIs that supposed to back or counter my claim? I haven't dug in, just noticed it's age at the time of award, not time of achievement. Eg Einstein early 20s for most of his stuff, early 30s for GR. Awarded in his 40s.
- lnsru 6y agoAs you can see, people get award in rather old age. Not many geniuses in their thirties, that made great achievement in their twenties.
- pier25 6y ago
- jedimind 6y agoOn a related notion, I can only recommend "The Courage to Create" by Rollo May. It's a fantastic work on the nature of creativity.
- CharlesW 6y agoThank you for the recommendation! I can also recommend "The War of Art" by Steven Pressfield. https://www.amazon.com/War-Art-Steven-Pressfield-ebook/dp/B007A4SDCG/ https://www.amazon.com/War-Art-Steven-Pressfield-ebook/dp/B0...
- DanielBMarkham 6y agoI'm 55 and I just finished writing a couple of books. I felt that I had done so much and seen so many cool things that before I check out I owed the world a "book report", whether anybody wanted to read it or not. So I wrote a couple. I don't think I could have done that even ten years ago. There's a perspective you get, kind of a postmodernism, where you both understand the topics and the common ways of addressing them, then are able to move past that. I guess geniuses reach that point in their teens. It might take a bit longer for the rest of us :) There's a thing I see with younger tech authors where they don't want to admit it, but they're for the most part chasing fame. That's a different kind of creativity. I never was good at that and it hasn't gotten much better, either. Perhaps you need a good foundation in order to "bloom" eventually?
- alchemism 6y agoI've seen discussion from time to time about there being two different types of genius which manifest at different ages. Especially as it applies to writers. https://qz.com/1606423/the-two-types-of-creativity-peak-at-very-different-ages/ https://qz.com/1606423/the-two-types-of-creativity-peak-at-v...
- tenaciousDaniel 6y agoI don't have as many years as you, I'm 36, but I can already start to see what you're talking about. I started out life as an artist, getting a bachelors in fine arts and imagining that I'd be a famous painter. In reality, I just didn't have a good enough foundation in order to build something truly creative. You just have to have a lot of varied experiences to draw from.
- moron4hire 6y agoI'm pretty sure becoming a famous painter has a lot more to do with who you know than what you know or do. I'm sorry, I didn't go to art school myself. I was alergic to art school culture, so I transferred to computer science. But I've been in and around lots of artist groups over the years. Even made a small business out of making installations for artists, for a short while. (That's a while other thing. Big Art artists often don't make their own things. They're more like producers or project managers than technicians). The one thing that struck as the big difference between the artists who were making it and the ones who were struggling was really just their social group. The ones who were making it came from rich families, knew art dealers, and were getting invited to the "popular" artist parties. At least, that was the case for "fine" art, artists selling a small number of high-value pieces. The other way to make it was to make a large number of populist pieces, for mass production, and then hustle hard on the craft fair circuit. If they could build a following that way and refine their process to cut costs to the bar minimum, then they could maybe explode selling online. But just going to art school, being really creative and a master of craft, and hoping someone will discover you... Never seen it happen. It's interesting, because I think it actually has a lot of parallels to open source software. You don't really get big in OSS by making a cool program. You have to market the shit out of it. And about the only way to do that in a way that OSS users aren't allergic to is networking on the public speaking circuit, knowing lots of other popular developers, getting them to use your software.
- feoren 6y agoAm I the only one who reads some homoerotic fan-fiction about Michaelangelo passed off as insight, and an unskeptical recounting of a medium "revealing" something about a late artist passed off as fact, and decides that this writer clearly has absolutely nothing useful to say? Who would take such drivel seriously?
- chrisweekly 6y agoPlease consider that the OP represents an artist's personal, semi-poetic reflections. Whence the vitriol?
- feoren 6y agoPersonal, semi-poetic reflections based on wild over-speculation and an erroneous understanding of the world is fine for a diary, but this is on Hacker News with the title "Creativity Changes as We Age", alongside actual scientific studies and sound, fact-based reasoning. This person knows nothing about the science behind creativity, or really anything about science at all.
- chrisweekly 6y agoContext matters; the linked article was excerpted from a memoir, and published under "Arts and Culture". The author made no claims to scientific rigor.
- incanus77 6y agoI have never felt as creative in my life as I do now in my early 40s. I think the best way I can describe it is that it changed for me from my 20s, where I was driven by what I wanted to do — the end result — and along the way, would pick up the knowledge needed. It’s similar now, but it’s more driven by what I can learn along the way and how I can connect it to everything else. Experience has shown me that more things are related than you think. And I feel like drawing these connections has made me think across disciplines and to try to connect things in multiple ways during the process, which has the side effect of creative solutions or accidental findings along the way. I have dozens of pages of notes and snippets and am constantly adding — things I could make, topics I want to learn about. The amount can be overwhelming, but it’s also liberating to write them down so that I can move on, and I feel like even doing that sort of validates that I’m “being creative” and keeping juices flowing. Don’t get me wrong — these are not world-changing ideas. But I’ve found that letting those flow has let little solutions or ideas here and there flow easily in the midst of bigger problems. It also helps to have internalized the idea that the value is in the execution, not the idea. This is typified by a client who wants you to sign an NDA to hear about what their idea even is. That’s a red flag that they think the golden egg is the idea itself and not the months or years, as well as discipline in saying no to a million little things, that will bring a good version of that idea to life.
- pier25 6y ago> my 20s, where I was driven by what I wanted to do — the end result — I totally understand what you mean here. In my early 20s I was into electronic music and I wanted to make music like my idols. I was really more in love with the idea of doing it, or the end result, than the actual act of doing it. Because of that, I didn't really know anything about synths, synthesis, playing an instrument, etc. Which, ironically, are the fundamental skills needed to be able to actually do the damn thing. Maybe if I had had someone to guide me it would have been different. Most of my friends were in rock bands, and those who were into electronic music production were just as lost as me. These days with Youtube it's a lot easier, everyone sharing their tricks and techniques.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoWell it would be astonishing if creativity didn’t change with age, considering that the brain can dramatically ‘rewire’ itself over time.
- pseudolus 6y agoThe reference to William Utermohlen and his ongoing deterioration after his diagnosis with Alzheimer's is particularly poignant. He painted numerous self-portraits up to the point where apparently he could barely recognize his own face. His work is a vivid testament to the depredations that Alzheimer's inflicts upon creativity. [0] A bullet we should all hope we can dodge until an effective treatment is found. [0] https://www.boredpanda.com/alzheimers-disease-self-portrait-paintings-william-utermohlen/ https://www.boredpanda.com/alzheimers-disease-self-portrait-...
- moseandre 6y agoCreativity isn't painting a photographic self-portrait. Creativity is, like, painting your own self over the course of your disease and so painting the disease.
- ducttapecrown 6y agoThe author is has a famous painter as a parent, has studied art history, and this article is an excerpt from their book on creativity of artists.
- travisgriggs 6y agoPossibly a bit off topic, but I read this submission last night (and gave it the first upvote) because today is my 50th birthday. I am a software engineer that has followed a somewhat unconventional path, but have enjoyed my career passionately. I have told myself that turning 50 is no big deal because it's just another arbitrary day, and 99+% odds I'm well past half dead already. But, because others around me keeping making a big deal out of it, it's hard to not get caught up in some transcendental introspection. If you're well past 50 (approaching 60 or beyond), what would you tell your 50 year old self and peers?
- WalterBright 6y ago> If you're well past 50 (approaching 60 or beyond), what would you tell your 50 year old self and peers? Buy AMZN.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI'm 58, and find I don't have the creative fluidity I had when I was younger (I was an artist[0], and a musician[1] -with bad hair), but I find that I have a much more efficient and effective creative process. Basically, my younger creativity was Jackson Pollock; splashing around a lot, with few boundaries, and my current creativity is a bit more like a scrimshaw artist; carefully making each line count, in a restricted and prescribed manner and medium. A lot of the stuff I'm working on now, is stuff that just plain wouldn't have been possible -at all, when I was younger. Basically, I have a great baseline for getting stuff done. I may not have the wild forest of creativity I once had, but what I imagine does actually end up existing, and at a pretty good quality level, and, sometimes, at a pretty sizable scope. [0] https://littlegreenviper.com/cruft/ArtistWithBadHair.jpg https://littlegreenviper.com/cruft/ArtistWithBadHair.jpg [1] https://littlegreenviper.com/cruft/MusicianWithBadHair.jpg https://littlegreenviper.com/cruft/MusicianWithBadHair.jpg
- patrec 6y agoStrange that the author does not mention Japan's greatest visual artist, who by his own (and others') reckoning only became truly great in his old age. Although there are many examples of great artists who do great, and novel, work late in life, I cannot think of another major artist who peaked that late. From the age of 6 I had a mania for drawing the shapes of things. When I was 50 I had published a universe of designs. But all I have done before the the age of 70 is not worth bothering with. At 75 I'll have learned something of the pattern of nature, of animals, of plants, of trees, birds, fish and insects. When I am 80 you will see real progress. At 90 I shall have cut my way deeply into the mystery of life itself. At 100, I shall be a marvelous artist. At 110, everything I create; a dot, a line, will jump to life as never before. Unfortunately he only made it to 90.
- mkl 6y agoWell, you didn't mention them either... The quote is from Hokusai Katsushika, the artist behind the famous Great Wave print: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hokusai https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hokusai https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/314154-from-the-age-of-6-i-had-a-mania-for https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/314154-from-the-age-of-6-i-...
- lostgame 6y agoGreat article, but in no way surprising. Look at a band like the Beatles; and watch their creative progression over time.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoOf course creativity changes: The older one gets, the more one learns about a variety of topics and the more life experience one has. This is precisely the reason I tell folks to make sure to learn about different things, meet different sorts of people, and step out of one's comfort zone from time to time. I think this is why drugs - especially hallucinogens - are popular among some artists (and scientists that need some creativity). Drugs give experiences of different ways of thinking.
- disown 6y agoSometimes HN seems like just a bunch of old people lying to themselves about how great getting old is. "Ask HN: What is it like to be old? What advice would you give to younger people?" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24527978 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24527978 You know that a young person didn't post that. If it was a young person, it's a rather sad one. Also, I'm beginning to think that social media is getting worse or more toxic, not because of ads/privacy/etc, but because the demographics is getting older. Not only that, I bet the demands for more censorship online correlates to the aging demographics online.