4 ms·
I don't know, if I'm running a business at 1/7th the size of Facebook I will still be trying to grow it as much as possible and triumph over my competitors, eve
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
I don't know, if I'm running a business at 1/7th the size of Facebook I will still be trying to grow it as much as possible and triumph over my competitors, even if that means I end up running a monopoly. Probably a failing of my personality there.
- rmrfstar 6y agoThere are like 15 stock exchanges in the US alone. For a long time there was a single network monopoly: NYSE. The reason there are now 15 exchanges and not 1 is because the SEC structures the market to incentivize "on the merits" competition and discourage "destroy mode" competition. In sports we don't tolerate players intentionally injuring the other side, so I'm not sure why we tolerate it in business.
- paranoidrobot 6y agoEven playing by the rules and not sabotaging/destroying the competition can be harmful to consumers. Mergers and Acquisitions have been responsible for the loss of countless services & products. Services & Products that were even profitable, and had a loyal and growing customer base, and a long road ahead of them.
- dalbasal 6y agoThis is both the example and counterexample of regulatory trustbusting. You decrease monopoly problems in one sense, but now the "SEC" and it's quasi-subsidiary entities (NASDAQ, NYSE) have become their own sort of trust. You can even include LSX and other major worldwide markets. International trade deals have brought regulatory regimes close to each other in order to maintain liquidity between markets. If you did this to the car industry, it would probably make cars worse. It's not obvious what a "worse car" means in the context of a stock exchange or ad marketplace, and dubious that "worse" means worse for us, so a regulator is not out of the question. That said, I'd rather have fewer or no multi-trillion dollar trusts than a regulated trust. Anyway, a social media regulator is problematic for other reasons. IMO the EU & US should just find some courage and act on the findings of their own courts. The marketplaces in particular have already been found (in court) to be operating monopolistically. Split them off. Make adwords separate from Google. Amazon marketplace is trickier, because it is a "real stuff" business... but the same logic applies.
- rmrfstar 6y agoWhy is social media problematic? Banks are networked and all speak SWIFT. Stock exchanges are networked and all speak FIX. Tier-1 ISPs are networked and all speak IP. Why can't we make that happen for information infrastructure of a certain size and importance?
- ghaff 6y agoWhat's probably most problematic is that some sort of federated/interoperable/regulated set of social media sites probably means that one governmental or quasi-governmental entity still needs to make calls about the thing that's actually the real flash point on Facebook. Namely, what sort of posts should be allowed and disallowed.
- rmrfstar 6y agoWhy? The question of America's apparent desire for official censorship is orthogonal to the question of monopoly. And even if it wasn't, people would be a lot more likely to get their preferred brand of censorship from whichever 1/7th Facebook they chose to use.
- dwiel 6y agoI like the approach Cory Doctorow has been advocating. Make it not illegal to scrape facebook/google/etc. Facebook got its start by being interoperable with Myspace. Now they wont let anyone do the same to them.
- aikinai 6y agoThey also had an “import all your friends from Gmail” feature since Google had data portability principles. But of course there’s no porting back out of Facebook.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoFacebook does have a data export feature, although I don't remember whether it existed before GDPR.
- dylan604 6y agoThere's a difference between intentionally injuring opponents and running up the score. A monopoly is someone running up the score. A company hiring someone to take out a competitor's employee is intentionally injuring the opponent.