5 ms·
That is, in fact, the actual practice. The constitution splits the appointment between the presidency and the senate. When the same party controls both, vacanci
by rayiner 6y ago
That is, in fact, the actual practice. The constitution splits the appointment between the presidency and the senate. When the same party controls both, vacancies are filled immediately. Otherwise, the party controlling the senate can exercise its heckler’s veto: https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/08/history-is-on-the-side-of-republicans-filling-a-supreme-court-vacancy-in-2020/ https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/08/history-is-on-the-sid...
What happened with Garland had happened numerous times before:
> In short: There have been ten vacancies resulting in a presidential election-year or post-election nomination when the president and Senate were from opposite parties. In six of the ten cases, a nomination was made before Election Day. Only one of those, Chief Justice Melville Fuller’s nomination by Grover Cleveland in 1888, was confirmed before the election.
By contrast, if Trump doesn’t put up a nominee, it will be literally unprecedented.
- rectang 6y agoThe proper response to this cynical argument is to pack the court.
- rayiner 6y agoHow is it “cynical” to point out that where a split senate/presidency exists in an election year, the senate has historically used its confirmation authority to postpone filling the vacancy? And the response is to demand something that actually would be unprecedented: packing the senate? Which only Democrats have done before, under circumstances where it was obviously to coerce the Supreme Court into deciding cases differently. Acting like Democrats hold the moral high ground here is utterly absurd.
- Robotbeat 6y agoSo if norms don't matter (as you, McConnel, and Trump seem to argue), the Democrats ought to pack the court, no?
- nwienert 6y agoSo would you be ok if Republicans won this election and then packed the Supreme Court?
- Hnrobert42 6y agoNo. I would not be happy about it. But I fully expect them to do it. There are no longer norms. Screw the country. It is every man for himself.
- jki275 6y agoThe republicans had the opportunity to do it, and haven’t...
- platyp 6y agoWhy would they need to pack the court? They already have a political majority, do they not? No need to break a norm when it confers no additional benefits (as the breaking of the previous norms did).
- nwienert 6y agoThey didn’t have majority until recently, and according to Vox and many left leaning sites, they’ve voted quite liberally since. Further, there’s this: https://thehill.com/regulation/454463-ginsburg-dismisses-court-packing-and-term-limits-for-supreme-court-justices https://thehill.com/regulation/454463-ginsburg-dismisses-cou...
- jki275 6y agoThe Republicans don't generally vote as a bloc on most things. And many of them hate the President as much as the Democrats do.
- 6y ago
- sukilot 6y agoIf the Democrats don't hold the moral high ground, why is McConnell lying about his rationale? He didn't say "The majority can do what ever it wants, and that's moral", he made up rationales that change to as the facts do. The idea that a Supreme Court opening should never be filled when the President and Senate are opposing parties is utterly absurd. It's true that the Constitution wasn't written like Ethereum to preclude all attempts to undermine it with bullshittery like refusing to even put matters up to a vote. That doesn't mean it's at all moral to ignore it. Also, was "Packing the Senate" a typo? FDR threatened but did not pack the Court. "Packing the Senate" is a Republican tradition (not that the parties mean much consistently, going back centuries), which even a blatant partisan couldn't avoid admitting: https://www.newsmax.com/michaeldorstewitz/democracy-republic-constitution-washington-dc/2020/01/15/id/949878/ https://www.newsmax.com/michaeldorstewitz/democracy-republic... And slaveholders (the spiritual inspiration of modern Republicans) had manipulated the Court to themselves since the beginning: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_Circuits_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_Circuits_Act
- rayiner 6y agoThe slave holders and segregationists were Democrats. You can tell that because modern Democrats claim the FDR and the New Deal as their own, but the New Deal coalition included the segregationist “solid south.” (Which at the time had anti-big business agrarian leanings.) Republicans, by contrast, were a fusion of religious fundamentalists and big business capitalists form the outset.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoYes, segregationists were Democrats during the New Deal, but so what? The parent described slaveholders as "the spiritual inspiration of modern Republicans," and we both know what they meant: the "Southern Strategy" Republicans used to flip the South toward them by consciously appealing to racism.
- rayiner 6y agoThe point is that the parent takes an extremely tenuous connection between Republicans and slaveholders, while denying the much more overt connection between Democrats and slaveholders and segregationists. There is this notion that the parties "flipped" sometime in the mid 1960s that's simply false. Republicans were from the inception the party of religious wackadoodles and capitalists. Democrats, at least since right before the civil war, were the party opposed to big business, banks, etc. The segregationists weren't just Democrats. They were New Dealers. They were New Dealers because the south was agrarian and at odds with big business (over tariffs) and banks (over monetary policy and debt). When Wallace broke off in 1968 to run on a segregationist ticket, he touted his pro-labor background. And as a result of that coalition, the New Deal and related programs were inextricably tied up with segregation: excluding most Black people from social security, creating redlining through the FHA, etc. See: https://jacobinmag.com/2019/06/rothstein-segregation-color-of-law-new-deal https://jacobinmag.com/2019/06/rothstein-segregation-color-o... ("Walker’s second point overlooks that the New Deal did not merely concede to private bigotry but pursued independent racial policies that did much to create a segregated landscape that persists today.") The South didn't really flip until Clinton. (Reagan won it, but he won everything.) Carter decisively won a bunch of southern counties that were 95% white. And ultimately it did so not because of the "southern strategy" but because southern states industrialized, and Republican ideas of low regulation and low taxes were great for attracting jobs and industries from northern states.
- rectang 6y agoAny Democrat who accepts a lecture about the "moral high ground" on the subject of the Supreme Court is the Republicans' useful idiot. The Roberts Court disenfranchised millions of Democratic voters by gutting the Civil Rights Act. The fight over the Supreme Court's composition is a fight over pure electoral power. It shouldn't be this way, but it is.
- sagichmal 6y agoI totally concur. Double the seats on the bench.
- _qulr 6y agoCan we please stop talking about "precedent" when the last time was over 150 years ago? For some perspective, there were only 31 states at the time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- filoeleven 6y agoWhat happened with Garland was new in that the Republicans refused to hold any hearing or vote on the matter. They did not violate any laws with their refusal, only norms. I don’t know why no nominations were made before Election Day in 4/10 cases; that may have been another lesser norm, or the vacancies may have been closer to the elections, or both. In any case, the refusal was a further erosion of any semblance of working towards the good of the country with people of opposing ideologies. The same goes for the increased frequency of government shutdown threats and occurrences. Really, if those practices had stood for so long on norms, they should have been codified into law already. But the Congress, regardless of party, doesn’t like to cede any power. It’s equally unlikely that if the Democrats take control they’ll do anything about it either. I’m vague on what it would entail—it’s been a while since I read up on it—but another hurdle might be that it would take an amendment rather than a law. Regulating what the Congress does is explicitly harder than making laws for the rest of us.
- zerocrates 6y agoCongress can't meaningfully restrict its own actions by passing laws: any law passed can be repealed by a future Congress by the same procedure as long as there are majorities. Which isn't to say that there's no point in purporting to do so: you may hope to require a politically costly public vote (avoidance of which was a significant feature of the Garland no-hearing: with nobody else "on the record," outrage focused solely on the politically-safe McConnell). How effective this is isn't really clear though: voters seem to usually want "their side" to take full, uncompromising advantage when they are on top, and increased polarization means that the fear of alienating independents/moderates isn't as much of an issue, because there aren't any of them left. Rules and procedures such as the filibuster are weaker still, as they require only a majority of a single house, and no cooperation from the President. We've seen that borne out as the parties out of power became more likely to use the Senate's procedures to stall the party in power, and the fairly quick recent dismantling of those procedures in a bipartisan fashion. Constitutional amendments can do all sorts of things and their high barriers to passage make them solidly entrenched, but it's very difficult to imagine any issue commanding the necessary supermajorities to pass an amendment on any subject in today's America. As for Democrats or Republicans in power after the election curbing this kind of partisanship, I wouldn't bet on it. There may be some pushes to try to codify
- jakelazaroff 6y agoThe link does not support your claim (or its own). The Senate did not consider and reject Merrick Garland, it refused to consider any Supreme Court nominee by Obama. Of course, I'm splitting hairs between "refused to consider" and "voted against". But it's similarly splitting hairs to say that the party of the president makes meaningful difference as well. Frankly, there's no good faith interpretation of McConnell's stance here as anything other than (ab)using his power to shape the judiciary.
- rayiner 6y ago> But it's similarly splitting hairs to say that the party of the president makes meaningful difference as well. Of course it does! The Constitution splits the nomination/confirmation process between two political branches. The process is supposed to be political!
- _qulr 6y ago> The Constitution splits the nomination/confirmation process between two political branches. The process is supposed to be political! The founders explicitly said that they didn't intend the system to be partisan, and indeed warned against the dangers of partisanship. Of course they themselves formed parties a few years later. They weren't as wise as everyone seems to think.
- Izkata 6y agoBranch, not party. Executive and Legislative.
- _qulr 6y ago> Branch, not party. I can read. I was referring to "The process is supposed to be political!" And by political, the implication is partisan, because otherwise it would be true by definition, and thus an uninteresting claim not worthy of ending in an exclamation point.
- dbingham 6y agoThe National Review became dishonest propaganda some time ago. They are going back 150 years to find a precedent and ignoring many more recent precedents. https://www.scotusblog.com/2016/02/supreme-court-vacancies-in-presidential-election-years/ https://www.scotusblog.com/2016/02/supreme-court-vacancies-i...
- rayiner 6y agoExplain to me what’s “dishonest propaganda” about the National Review article? 1) Going back to the 1800s is routine in the legal world to understand what is accepted practice in our system. After all, the relevant rules haven’t changed since 1789. Aren’t examples from people who created this system particularly relevant to understanding how it’s supposed to work? 2) The SCOTUSblog article goes through the exact same examples as the National Review article for the 20th century. The only difference is that the National Review article looks at whether different parties control the Presidency/Senate. What is “propaganda” about that? The Senate and Presidency are political branches that are supposed to be at odds, potentially. Is there any reason to assert that this political rivalry shouldn’t extend to Supreme Court appointments? Is it “propaganda” to even posit the idea?
- dbingham 6y agoThe article I posted also looked at what parties controlled the Senate and Presidency and quoted more recent precedents where the parties were split, and the president got to appoint. Moreover, stopping a vote entirely? That's unprecedented. Had there been a vote on Garland, he almost certainly would have been appointed. Many of the moderate Republicans in the senate, facing elections, would not have been able to justify voting him down to their constituents. For the National Review to leave those pieces out is dishonest. I'm also not just referring to that article. The National Review has been dishonest propaganda for a while, making dishonest arguments that manipulate the facts (usually by omission or careful selections as here, but occasionally outright lying) to justify the actions of what has become a fascist party.
- claudeganon 6y agoThe National Review has been nothing short of reactionary propaganda from its outset. They vehemently opposed the Civil Rights Movement in its era, including running unsigned editorials with such lovely sentiments as “In the Deep South the Negroes are, by comparison with the Whites, retarded” https://www.mediamatters.org/national-review/national-reviews-ugly-civil-rights-history https://www.mediamatters.org/national-review/national-review...
- dctoedt 6y ago> the party controlling the senate can exercise its heckler’s veto I'm trying to think of a plausible vehicle for arguing that if the Senate refuses to vote on a nomination within a reasonable time, then that refusal (i) constitutes a waiver of the right to withhold consent and therefore (ii) is deemed consent.