4 ms·
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion but not their own facts. Rogan is mostly an opinion guy but he has spread covid disinformation and hosted guests like
by tootie 6y ago
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion but not their own facts.
Rogan is mostly an opinion guy but he has spread covid disinformation and hosted guests like Alex Jones who say things like Sandy Hook was staged. That's not harmless self-expression. Spotify is under no obligation to host anyone's content and certainly not required to pay $100M for content that is detrimental to society.
- asquabventured 6y agoHe has guests from all spectrums, I believe it's healthy to listen to all sides and debate them on their merits. Regarding your point about "harmful to society" I would argue that there are plenty of individuals (not myself) who would claim vulgar lyrics or promotion of drug use is "harmful to society" but I don't see those individuals having a voice and trying to cancel and deplatform those ideas.
- gadabout 6y ago> He has guests from all spectrums, I believe it's healthy to listen to all sides and debate them on their merits. One could easily argue that Joe does in fact not debate many of his guest and instead allow them to use his show as a platform if they so desire. > Regarding your point about "harmful to society" I would argue that there are plenty of individuals (not myself) who would claim vulgar lyrics or promotion of drug use is "harmful to society" but I don't see those individuals having a voice and trying to cancel and deplatform those ideas. Those individuals are still alive and loud depending on where you live.
- cipher_system 6y ago> One could easily argue that Joe does in fact not debate many of his guest and instead allow them to use his show as a platform if they so desire. I haven't watched a lot of JRE but in general I see nothing wrong with people having the time to layout their thoughts and opinions more or less uninterrupted for an extended period of time and then listen to rebuttals and debate in comments or separate blog posts, videos etc. The other end is political debates or interviews with opinionated journalists where they barely have time to say a sentence at a time. This doesn't have to be bad but a lot of time its just bickering and platitudes. It doesn't provide much depth.
- nl 6y agoThe FCC tried to cancel Eminem, and before that NWA were cancelled by radio stations all over the country.
- dogma1138 6y agoJoe Rogan isn’t detrimental to society. Spotify isn’t obligated it chosen too, those employees can either do their job or find another one.
- emmelaich 6y agoHe's also interviewed Bernie Sanders and I believe JR said he would vote for him. Many people would consider[0] (not without zero justification) that Sanders is the most prominent USA representative of an ideology that has killed more people in the last century than any other ideology. Do you really want to go down the path of mutual assured cancellation? [0] no, I am not saying Sanders is a homicidal maniac, just in case people want to take that inference.
- lopmotr 6y agoWho has the authority to identify which facts are not somebody's own? Can a fact be converted to an opinion by prefacing it with "I believe..."? Is an opinion forbidden if, like your own opinion here, it's stated in the form of a fact? What happens to people who published facts that later turn out to be wrong? Are the retrospectively punished? Are the people who denied those "facts" before they were disproven somehow compensated for having had their rights wrongly restricted? I don't think you've thought your idea through at all and are just grasping at an excuse to make your political belief sound authoritative. Remember when people used to say America invaded Iraq so it could control the oil? That was counter to the official reason for the invasion so, according to your idea, they were not entitled to publish that. It was also not harmless self-expression because it could have altered public opinion about a war, which can have serious consequences.
- aww_dang 6y agoThe "truthiness" of debate has become toxic. It isn't possible or healthy for everyone to have the same interpretation. The demand for this impossible standard is disturbing.
- jordan801 6y agoWho gets to decide what is a detriment to society? Going out on a limb here, but at one point everyone thought the world was flat. Preaching that the earth is actually round, was seen as a detriment to society. So much so that people got horrifically executed for it. We don't know anything. So sensoring ideas because we don't like them, or they seem farfetched, is probably, a real detriment to society.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Going out on a limb here, but at one point everyone thought the world was flat. Maybe. More likely, at one point most people weren't concerned with more than the local topography. > Preaching that the earth is actually round, was seen as a detriment to society. So much so that people got horrifically executed for it. I won't say definitively that that never happened, but it certainly isn't something that there is any historical evidence I've ever heard of, and it sounds a lot like flat-earth mythology, possibly conflated with (exaggeration of) the actual heliocentrism controversy. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_flat_Earth https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_flat_Earth
- jordan801 6y agoAfter reading a bit, I realized I have misrecalled it. Woops. Thanks for pointing it out! :) The referrence was to the Sun being the center of the solar system, and not the Earth. Apologies. Failure on my part. Memory is a fickle thing.
- 4ggr0 6y agoWell, that's a REALLY long time ago. 1300 years ago the vast majority of people believed that the world was round. The flat-earth theory is strangely enough a relatively modern theory. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_flat_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_flat_Earth EDIT: Sorry, only just now saw that another commenter already posted the same link.
- ufmace 6y ago> hosted guests like Alex Jones who say things like Sandy Hook was staged Did you actually listen to that episode? I did, and he explicitly said that he no longer believes that. It's rather ironic that you are arguing that we should respect facts in the same post.
- latch 6y agoAlex Jones was on JRE on Feb 27, 2019, which appears to have been at the height of the litigation against him (1). I'll take your word that's what he said (so in that sense, you're right, it's a "fact"), but if you're giving him the benefit of the doubt...well, what could anyone say? He's been held in contempt of court, de-platformed, has a DWI and, more damning, has made similar inflammatory claims since. (1) - I just googled, apologies if I got the dates wrong.
- ufmace 6y agoWhat bothers me here is this pattern of personal destruction. It seems that certain people have somehow been declared "unpersons". The tactic is to develop a list of the 6 or so worst-sounding things they've ever done, always phrased in the shortest and most inflammatory way and devoid of any context or later explanations that might mitigate how bad they are. Then, any time that person's name comes up, a crowd of people appears to repeat those same sound bites in various combinations over and over again. The goal is not understanding, but to discredit and destroy people. Anybody who tries to provide context or mitigating factors for the selected sound bites may become a target of the destruction too. Alex Jones is not an angel. But then a great many people in public life have done things that can appear damming when packaged into sound bites like this. What matters is not whether Alex Jones is good or bad, but who decides what persons this tactic will be deployed against. What also matters is what kind of world we are building with this tactic. If somebody has done something bad, do they not deserve a chance to explain themselves, give their side of the story? Maybe roll back some ideas that turned out to be a mistake. If somebody has been declared to be an unperson somehow, and the goal is to do our best to prevent them from speaking at all in any forum by shouting them and any supporters down like this, well exactly what is it that we want them to do?
- raincom 6y agoEvery fact is theory-laden. There are no theory-neutral facts. What usually happens in natural sciences is that one theory wins over others; therefore, there is no dispute about facts such as "2 + 2 = 4" or "the speed of sound is ...".