8 ms·
I'd give that about 10 minutes before someone started claiming that their baby was immune to covid, and then you're right back where you started.
by rsynnott 6y ago
I'd give that about 10 minutes before someone started claiming that their baby was immune to covid, and then you're right back where you started.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoBut isn't that only happening because of FB allowing disinformation to spread so easily?
- dmpk2k 6y agoHow would you achieve that?
- dntrkv 6y agoCurious how you think it's possible for FB to prevent the spread of disinformation? Everyone likes to pretend like Facebook has the ability to just stop disinformation, when in reality, even defining "disinformation" is basically impossible. Sure, you can bring up examples of blatant lies, but most of the effective disinformation is a lot more subtle and depends on what side of the issues you are on.
- nindalf 6y agoI have seen this question asked many times on such threads but have never seen a workable solution. Usually the response is something like "I'd shut the whole website down" or "I'd employ millions of moderators" or "I'd allow people to only post once a month" or "I would remove sharing links, only baby pictures allowed". Nothing practical. If you respond to any of these with examples of positive speech that would be harmed, there is no response. For example, if you curb political speech, people wouldn't be able to organise political protests. People wouldn't even agree on what should be considered 'political'. For example, is organising a BLM event political? Should it be allowed under the proposed rules? I'm happy to be proven wrong though. Maybe this is the thread where people will make practical suggestions.
- munificent 6y agoWhat is "impractical" about "shut the whole website down"? When it was discovered that tetraethyl lead was widespread in the environment and caused neurological damage, it was banned. Yes, that materially harmed several chemical companies whose livelihood was based on producing tetraethyl lead. So what? If your business model harms people, I don't care if stopping harming people eliminates your business. People matter. Businesses do not. Are we supposed to just go, "Yeah, we know Facebook is harmful to millions, but won't someone think of the poor shareholders?" Then shrug and accept it?
- dntrkv 6y agoBanning a harmful substance, and banning a platform for communication are not comparable. There is no shortage of sites that will take Facebook's place. What is the legislation you propose to prevent Facebook, or the millions of other existing or soon-to-be existing apps, from doing harm to people?
- munificent 6y ago> Banning a harmful substance, and banning a platform for communication are not comparable. OK, consider gambling. That is simply a kind of software that enables people to engage in behavior that turns out to be harmful for a large number of them. And, because of that fact, it is heavily regulated. > What is the legislation you propose to prevent Facebook, or the millions of other existing or soon-to-be existing apps, from doing harm to people? I don't know if we know what sort of regulations would help yet. But I do know that if we assume a priori that corporations cannot be forced to change their behavior because it might hurt the poor corporation, then we will never figure out the answer.
- nindalf 6y agoWell that's all I'm asking for here. A practical proposal. Removing tetraethyl lead was certainly doable. Removing every car from the road was not. One was a targeted change that improved the industry, while the latter was so impractical that they never considered it. Here's a thought - you assume a priori that shutting down social media would be a net win. How did you come to that conclusion? Did you spare a thought for the people who's social lives revolve around spending time with friends online? You'd advocate for taking away these people's social networks because you're certain you know what's best for them?
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoFacebook's algorithms exploit the brain's attractiveness to decisiveness. They've know this and have chosen not to take action, except for small amounts so Mark can tell congress they are improving things. Source https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-knows-it-encourages-division-top-executives-nixed-solutions-11590507499 https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-knows-it-encourages-di... So besides straight up changing the algorithms to promote non-decisive content, these are a couple things I think could help: - Limit the spread of information in general in favor of content created by the people you follow - Un-personalize advertising
- dntrkv 6y agoFacebook doesn't profit from divisiveness, they profit from engagement. The fact that divisive posts encourage more engagement tells me more about people in general, rather than Facebook's business model. > Limit the spread of information in general in favor of content created by the people you follow I don't think that's what people want from their social networks nowadays. FB, Twitter, YouTube, TikTok, Snapchat, etc all do not work this way anymore. Suggesting that Facebook revert their app to what it was 10 years ago is not a serious suggestion because there are many other apps that will fill that void. If it's not FB, another app will take its place and give people the outrage they're looking for. > Un-personalize advertising Advertising plays a very small part in this. Most of what you would call "disinformation" is spread through reposts, which are not affected by advertising. Sure, there might be some hostile actors out their spending money on pushing propaganda to the masses. But from my experience, people actively seek this nonsense out, the algorithms just make it easier for them to find it. In my eyes, the real problem is that most people aren't equipped with the right tools to identify bullshit. Simple things like an inability to gauge scale. e.g. "9,000,000 gallons of oil has been spilled from pipelines in the last 10 years" Is that a lot? I have no idea, but what I can do is compare that against other forms of oil transportation. Most people won't do that work though, they will go straight to outrage.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y ago> I don't think that's what people want from their social networks nowadays. FB, Twitter, YouTube, TikTok, Snapchat, etc all do not work this way anymore. They don't work this way because it makes shareholder's the most money, not because it is the best experience for the user. > Advertising plays a very small part in this. Most of what you would call "disinformation" is spread through reposts, which are not affected by advertising. A completely false ad about a candidate of a different political party is much less likely to be called out or reported because it is only shown to a highly targeted group of people. This lack of accountability creates disinformation. These ads could not be ran as a billboard advertisement or in a non-personalized ad space. All of the counter arguments always come down to this: Facebook would make less money. And, yes, of course that is going to be the case because if any of these changes would make them more money they would have implemented them themselves. It requires a public corporation to accept that they are making the world a worse place, and to choose to make less money to stop doing that.
- elliekelly 6y agoDoesn't HN have some sort of "flame war" prevention feature where people are automatically prevented from commenting/replying in rapid succession? Rate-limiting posts/sharing and comments on Facebook seems like a good place to start. Maybe it isn't necessary (and probably not possible) that we stop disinformation entirely so much as we slow it down.
- CaptainZapp 6y ago> Curious how you think it's possible for FB to prevent the spread of disinformation? For example by doing something when they are warned for years by multiple entities that FB is used as a tool to support genocide, like in Myanmar. It seems that only when such things blow up publicly and the stench of bad publicity gets too bad they send out Zuckerbot announcing his usual platitudes to then get back to business as usual. And that's far from the only example were their product was used for oppression by authoritarian regimes. This company could do a hell of a lot more to counter this. But they just don't give a shit, unless publicity gets too bad. edit : word change
- beamatronic 6y agoDon’t be friends with those people
- dylan604 6y agoTo me, this is a valid response. If you can remember back when we as humans used to gather together in public places, we had lots of options on who we talked to at that gathering. If someone always talked about something you just didn't care about, you could walk away and talk to other people. People that you found yourself regularly talking to about things that everyone found pleasant were called friends. People you talked to occasionally were called acquaintances, and people you preferred not to talk to were called many things, but friend was not one of them. If some of your friends like the people you did not, they were called a friend of a friend but you would not refer to them as your friend. In Facebook, there are only "friends". So, if you don't like what they are always carrying on about, don't have them as a friend. Just like in real life.
- paganel 6y ago> claiming that their baby was immune to covid Some people are indeed immune to covid, babies too, most probably. I've personally heard of numerous cases of persons not getting the virus at all while their spouse was in intensive therapy or worse.
- driverdan 6y agoNot getting it is not the same thing as immune.
- paganel 6y agoWhat is it, then? Later edit: To add to my comment, what do you call sleeping in the same bed, eating from the same plate and having direct physical contact with a person who gets the virus and ends up in IC or dead while the other person tests negative for the virus? Let's not forget that ever since February we've all known that this virus is particularly easy to transmit/get, so you cannot say "that person got really lucky, that's why he/she hasn't got it".
- ideals 6y agoYou have no scientific evidence to support your claims. Take your L and stop spreading misinformation.
- acrobatsunfish 6y agoIf you're going to ask him to share sources, please show some of your own with the level of rigor you would like to see to the contrary. I'm tired of this trend of people shouting Sauce! Sauce! At each other. Collaboration is key.
- driverdan 6y agoImmune means you won't get sick. Not getting sick just means you didn't catch it.
- seattle_spring 6y ago