8 ms·
DNA sequencing of Viking skeletons reveals they weren’t all Scandinavian
- throrthaway 6y agoNo shit. Do the people who believe immigration was invented in the 60s also believe the Vikings used to wear horned helmets?
- Nasrudith 6y agoConcepts taken as the basis of a world view not existing at all tends to throw people off as they cannot shake the later ideas of fixed hard boarders and citizenship by blood. To their worldview there should be a fundamental traceable line to back before these distinct entities existed. It is the us vs them line to many. Their ideas of ethnicity are fundamentally lies which while old aren't as old as they claim to be. People tend to freak out when foundational beliefs are revealed to be lies regardless of how innocous - see the reaction to imaginary numbers, non-Euclidian geometry not only being proposed but proven to be real and the legendary Pythagorean freak out over pi proving that not all numbers are rational.
- throrthaway 6y agoIf people freak out that the Vikings weren't pure-bred Scandinavians, wait until they learn about the identical ancestor point [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_ancestors_point https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_ancestors_point
- menybuvico 6y agoPeople from the Nordics had trade relations with Southern Europe and Asia all the way back in the bronze age. Alas, records are vague at best, but there's definitely reason to believe there was an influx of people and ideas from the Black Sea area before and during the migration period, just a few hundred years before the viking raids and Norse settlements all over Europe. And as if that wasn't enough, the Norse were quite infamous for taking captured women as wives and they also took slaves from the peoples they raided. Those people didn't just dissapear from the gene record.
- rbecker 6y ago> Their ideas of ethnicity are fundamentally lies Looks real to me: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Principal_component_analysis_of_human_genetic_diversity https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Principal_compon... Or are you thinking of some ridiculous weakman* version of ethnicity where no ancestors can be shared ever? * https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/12/weak-men-are-superweapons/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/12/weak-men-are-superweap...
- throrthaway 6y agoUsing a PCA to prove an intrinsic point about ethnicity is as laughable as it gets. You're aware the vectors in a PCA are just linear combinations of the observed features, right? You're just staring at the same data a different way. But of course I didn't expect any less from someone who quotes Slate Star Codex of all sources to prove a point.
- rbecker 6y ago> Using a PCA to prove an intrinsic point A what point? > You're aware the vectors in a PCA are just linear combinations of the observed features, right? Yes, I am. Do you have a reason to think that means PCA is bad at representing similarity and kinship because of this? As for the Slate Star Codex source - that wasn't to prove anything, just to define the "weak man" term. I would have used "straw man", but then you'd dig up some idiot that genuinely believes whatever it is you're debunking as proof that it's not a straw man.
- throrthaway 6y ago>A what point? https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/intrinsic https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/intrinsic >Do you have a reason to think that means PCA is bad at representing similarity and kinship because of this? I suggest you read up on the definition of "distance" and "similarity" before drinking the PCA kool-aid. You don't get to define an ad hoc distance just because it fits your ideas about ethnicity. But then, I only have the popgen community to back me up on this. What do you have? >As for the Slate Star Codex source - that wasn't to prove anything, just to define the "weak man" term. SSC, providing ammunition to online HBD proponents since 2013.
- carabiner 6y agoYes. I believe that.
- boredumb 6y agoAnd here I would have thought the folks known in pop culture for raping and pillaging would have kept a much purer bloodline.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoWTF, srsly? If there's a successful warband coming through there'll be people joining them. Only thing that counts is: can new guy fight? The people that fought in the Kosovo were most certainly not all ethnic Albanians.
- pstrateman 6y agoThat's a whoosh
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoI was really hoping for new information on a statistically significant difference in the amount of Neanderthal DNA in old Viking skeletons versus modern time Scandinavians.
- bpodgursky 6y agoThe Viking era was only about a thousand years ago (vs Neanderthals who died about 35,000 years ago). It's highly unlikely they weren't completely modern humans in every sense of the word. If there were populations with significant relict Neanderthal DNA, you'd be looking at more like the Celt/Gaul populations, and talking at least a thousand years before that -- think the British isles, before the Angles/Saxons moved in. And even that is very... speculative history.
- udp 6y ago> If there were populations with significant relict Neanderthal DNA, you'd be looking at more like the Celt/Gaul populations, and talking at least a thousand years before that -- think the British isles, before the Angles/Saxons moved in. And even that is very... speculative history. Very speculative indeed, considering there was plenty of movement of people between the British Isles and the continent before the Anglo-Saxons arrived (who themselves had surprisingly little impact on the genetic makeup of the British people [0]). And if there was significant Neanderthal DNA in the British Isles 1500 years ago, it would still be detectable among living generations (it isn't). [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature14230 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature14230
- drocer88 6y agoThere is significant amounts of Neanderthal genes in British (and all European ) genomes. "Neanderthal-derived DNA was found in the genome of all contemporary populations". [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interbreeding_between_archaic_and_modern_humans#Neanderthals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interbreeding_between_archaic_... See also: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/01/genetic-data-half-million-brits-reveal-ongoing-evolution-and-neanderthal-legacy https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/01/genetic-data-half-mi... ( Genetic data on half a million Brits reveal ongoing evolution and Neanderthal legacy ) https://science.sciencemag.org/content/358/6363/655 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/358/6363/655 : "We find that non-African populations outside Oceania carry between 1.8 and 2.6% Neandertal DNA"
- tpmx 6y agoThe brought back a lot of DNA diversity from their tours abroad. That result is to be expected.
- ummonk 6y agoYeah, that would be totally expected but the paper isn't even saying that. It's specifically about someone buried as a viking in a settlement in Scotland being non-Scandinavian.
- fetbaffe 6y agoThis article does not explain the difference between Viking burials inside Scandinavia and outside of Scandinavia. And the headline is pure clickbait.
- hrafn 6y agoAs usual, the university's public relations summary of the paper does not match the claims the paper makes. It makes grandiose claims of debunkings and is written from the point of view of whatever societal issue is popular today (identity and population movement). Link to preprint: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334525855_Population_genomics_of_the_Viking_world https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334525855_Populatio... I'm not seeing any claims there that are new. It is cool to have more data on spread of culture and genes, but we've already had most of that for decades.
- interfixus 6y agoProject leader professor Eske Willerslev is - as far as I can ascertain - a highly competent and accomplished scientist, but with pattern of political leanings informing his scientific output and media appearances, of which there have been not a few over the years, at least in his native Denmark. From reports of this paper I have so far read, it doesn't really - despite claims - challenge what we know of the vikings, their comings and goings, and their genetic makeup. Their iron age ancestors were a mixed bunch a thousand years earlier, and those we call vikings had been out and about for centuries all over Europe. Educated common knowledge is well aware that they probably har a variety of looks much like modern Scandinavians.
- FranzFerdiNaN 6y agoEverything is politics, so saying ''politics informs his scientific output'' like it is some kind of gotcha makes absolutely no sense. And it is necessary to continue to reiterate the same basic facts when new evidence continues to support it. For a variety of reasons all kinds of ideas that have been debunked decades ago about the past are still mainstream. And some people get really angry when current historians tell them that those views are wrong because it clashes with their current political ideas and views. Just look at the pure evil shit Mary Beard, a well-respected classicist, got when she dared say that during Roman times there were black people in England (a well-established fact by now). Unfortunately the alt-right has also taken hold of the past, and they continue to spread all kinds of lies so they can continue to spread their idea of the past, namely that of a white past where non-white people did not exist (just look at the outrage you see when a medieval fantasy tv show casts non-white actors). So more evidence that Scandinavia was also populated by people from southern Europe and Asia is always welcome (even though it wont do a thing to convince people who hold racist views and ideals).
- bregma 6y agoShould have built a wall across Schleswig-Holstein.
- 082349872349872 6y agoAcross which end? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schleswig-Holstein#Duchies_in_the_Danish_realm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schleswig-Holstein#Duchies_in_... Edit: in the viking age, the Hamburg end. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Sea_Empire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Sea_Empire TIL thassalocracy is a possible description for 1984's Oceania. Bonus clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XebaXQjp4OQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XebaXQjp4OQ
- cambalache 6y agoI already lost my faith in the cultural "western" elites. I hate to sound like a hardcore conservative (I am pretty leftist) but I dont see there is coming back from the current environment. 2+2 = 5, original English people were actually black, more diversity has been proved to generate better stock performance of the company.From the flimsiest of evidence a whole new narrative is created, one that match the social issues in vogue today.
- wavefunction 6y agoWhat's so hard to believe about a largely "black" (with blue eyes) population being displaced/integrated with by subsequent migrations? That scenario is supported by the myths of those islands and human migrations are the story of humanity and human cultural developments. If you want to argue with the science or point out deficiencies you're encouraged to. That's the beauty of science.
- ummonk 6y agoDark-skinned people in non-fishing populations in the British Isles would have had seriously weakened immune systems from vitamin D deficiency. The theory is implausible on its face. Edit: apparently the theory is about paleolithic people (who did a lot of fishing) in Britain being dark-skinned, which is certainly believable.
- jdminhbg 6y agoFish has lots of Vitamin D in it.
- ummonk 6y agoAnd has not been a major component of British food since the neolithic. Edit: I guess that's what the whole argument upthread is about - apparently researchers said that paleolithic british settlers were dark skinned, and became light skinned with the switch to agriculture. Which is very plausible.
- 6y ago
- Angeo34 6y agoI thought this was obvious because of the Kiyv Rus
- etc-hosts 6y agoIf you're thinking of the Ukraine/Russian Origin story of Kyivan Rus, do you think Scandinavians settled in the Russia/Ukraine area? There's evidence there was trade between the various empires. I don't think that's addressing the "DNA of the Vikings" (whoever the Vikings may have been)
- vbezhenar 6y agoThe most likely version is that Rus was founded by Scandinavians who conquered local slavic tribes and were assimilated later.
- int_19h 6y agoThe ruling elite of Kievan Rus was originally all Scandinavian, speaking Old Norse, and holding to their customs. This was still the case when they conquered Kiev. But then they gradually intermingled with the local Slavic nobility, switched to Eastern Slavic as the native language, and adopted the local names. It's the bit about the names that's most telling, IMO. If you follow the Primary Chronicle (the earliest source on this), the first rulers of Rus were Rurik, Oleg, Igor, Olga, Svyatoslav, and Vladimir. The first four names are unambiguously Slavic adaptations of Scandinavian names: Hrorekr, Helgi, and Ingvar. Svyatoslav is an unambiguously Slavic name, but if you deconstruct it, its constituent parts are "holy" and "glory", which correspond to the earlier names Helgi and Hrorekr, respectively - so it's quite possible that it was deliberately constructed as a subtle translated reference. And then Vladimir is a purely Slavic name (Waldemar is a Norse / High German cognate, but it was derived from Vladimir, not the other way around).
- ummonk 6y agoThe introduction makes it sound super controversial but the mentioned results sound like exactly what you’d expect. Obviously ancient Scandinavia would have had gene flows from Eurasia, and obviously Viking settlements in the British isles would have non-Scandinavians amongst them...
- kome 6y agoI am surprised that they are surprised... it's cool to have more data tho.
- leroy_masochist 6y agoThere's a great documentary on this topic called "The Thirteenth Warrior"
- photonemitter 6y agoSo... this isn’t news at all, but rather can be seen as supporting what our (norwegian here) own older tales and historians wrote down around the time: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heimskringla https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heimskringla It’s well known we went around, even likely as far as asia (buddha statuettes were found in viking graves) and one of our kings (Harald Hårråde) was commander of the Byzantine royal Guard (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harald_Hardrada https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harald_Hardrada) So... far as I see there’s no one who knows Norse history that would find this the least surprising. Not really sure what the fuzz in the comments is about either. (Oh, and 13’th warrior was "based on" a, most likely, true event, with a, most likely, embellished narrative due to the fantastical language used back then to regale.)
- trhway 6y agoThe Russian Vikings (i.e. the Vikings who in the 9th century founded the original Russian state - Kievan Rus and accompanying dukedoms around - and ruled it for several centuries after that) were raiding as far as Caspian Sea and Iran and bringing the trophies - goods and slaves - for sale back as far as Scandinavia. So there were a lot of cross-continental blood/DNA mixing during those centuries (9th-12th) until Mongols came and that started another chapter.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoSome years ago I watched an interesting documentary on how a bunch of viking swords that all bear the same distinctive engraving were very likely made of steel from Persia. The doc claimed that they were likely using a route along the Volga to get down to the Caspian routinely.
- trhway 6y agoRelated https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahmad_ibn_Fadlan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahmad_ibn_Fadlan "Ibn Fadlan was a 10th-century Arab[1][2][a] Muslim traveler, famous for his account of his travels as a member of an embassy of the Abbasid Caliph of Baghdad to the king of the Volga Bulgars, known as his Risala ("account" or "journal").[b] His account is most notable for providing a detailed description of the Volga Vikings, including eyewitness accounts of life as part of a trade caravan and witnessing a ship burial.[4][5]" and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caspian_expeditions_of_the_Rus%27 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caspian_expeditions_of_the_Rus... "Initially, the Rus' appeared in Serkland in the 9th century traveling as merchants along the Volga trade route, selling furs, honey, and slaves. The first small-scale raids took place in the late 9th and early 10th century. The Rus' undertook the first large-scale expedition in 913; having arrived on 500 ships, they pillaged in the Gorgan region, in the territory of present-day Iran, and more to the west, in Gilan and Mazandaran, taking slaves and goods. On their return, the northern raiders were attacked and defeated by the Khazars in the Volga Delta, and those who escaped were killed by the local tribes on the middle Volga. During their next expedition in 943, the Rus' captured Bardha'a, the capital of Arran, in the modern-day Republic of Azerbaijan. The Rus' stayed there for several months, killing many inhabitants of the city and amassing substantial plunder. It was only an outbreak of dysentery among the Rus' that forced them to depart with their spoils. Sviatoslav, prince of Kiev, commanded the next attack, which destroyed the Khazar state in 965. Sviatoslav's campaign established the Rus's hold on the north-south trade routes, helping to alter the demographics of the region. Raids continued through the time period with the last Scandinavian attempt to reestablish the route to the Caspian Sea taking place in 1041 by Ingvar the Far-Travelled. "
- davidw 6y agoIt goes both ways: years ago in Italy, I had a housemate from Sicily. She had blond eyes and blue hair.
- tyingq 6y agoThat is unusual :)
- tomcooks 6y agoNo, that's Normans.
- alberto_ol 6y agoblue eyes, blond hair might be from a Norman ancestor, but blond eyes and blue hair is unusual
- goto11 6y agoI think blue hair is a culturally rather then genetically transmitted trait.
- davidw 6y agoHah, sorry, reversed the order in my comment :-)
- goto11 6y agoThe results are interesting but the article muddles the issue by confusing terminology. At the time, "Viking" did not denote certain people or ethnic groups, it denoted an activity - traveling (and raiding) by boat. So a person might be described as "in viking" for the summer. Only later have the people who did this activity been called "vikings". So nobody "self identified" as viking at the time. The article muddles this by talking about "ethnic vikings" whatever that means, and "viking ancestry". Probably "Scandinavian" is meant. But the article at one hand talks about "Viking DNA" and at the same time claims vikings are not an ethnic group. Edit: This criticism applies to the article, not the underlying paper which seem to be much more careful with terminology. It defines a "viking culture" existing outside of Scandinavia (e.g. in Scotland) with Scandinavian cultural links but where members of this culture were not necessarily of Scandinavian descent. It also examines remains of an ill-fated raiding party in Estonia which were Swedish vikings in the traditional definition. And then it examines DNA from viking-age burial sites inside Scandinavia.
- interfixus 6y ago>> The word Viking comes from the Scandinavian term ‘vikingr’ meaning ‘pirate’ There are a number of theories concerning the origin of the name. This one is by no means top of the list.
- mikeymz 6y agoit's an adjective. I go Viking I am not a Viking