5 ms·
Reverse Engineering the Logitech Harmony
- t0mbstone 6y agoThis is some proper hacking. It seems like the majority of stuff on Hacker News these days is just political crap, but this... this is good stuff.
- Grazester 6y agoZeitgeist? It also seems like IT was viewed as more fringe. Now that it's more mainstream and part of our day to day lives it would cross over more and more into the political; whether it be surveillance using tech or the regulating of domestic or foreign tech companies.
- sethammons 6y agoThat's pretty amazing. We used to have a Harmony remote like 15+ years ago. Best remote we ever owned. Great at controlling everything, including the original xbox for dvd viewing. Then they went and updated. They artificially limited the number of devices a class of remote could control. They moved more "features" into the display of the remote which made them harder to use and reduced buttons. The quality went down, and the the newer remotes stopped being able to accurately control all my devices. I now sit with 5 remotes on my couch's armrest instead of one harmony. They had the best universal remote and they ruined it. If I were more of a hardware guy, I'd start a competing product that added the required sensors as a dongle to your phone.
- ALurchyBeast 6y agoDid Harmony ruin it, or did Logitech ruin Harmony?
- sethammons 6y agoIt was a logitech device when I had the couple I did
- dublin 6y agoThe Harmony remote without the display works better, lasts longer, and is more durable and resistant to obsolescence than the ones with the display and touchscreen. Buttons last a long time. I bought one for the living room 15 years ago when Amazon had a special on it with the Harmony hub, and it's been working flawlessly ever since. The battery life on the thing is incredible: The CR2032 has only been replaced once in that time!
- jaywalk 6y agoThe shortcuts they took when developing this remote are just mind boggling! I never would have imagined it was running a full networking stack, servers, and Flash for the UI. Just incredible.
- HissingMachine 6y agoIt's hard to see, but I think he could have cut the plastic in the charger to let the rf blaster to function while it was connected to the charger. But it's always nice to hack old hardware instead of looking for a shortcut.
- saagarjha 6y ago(they)
- JoshuaRedmond 6y agoThey actually did[0], although admittedly it's quite a long way down the thread. [0] - https://twitter.com/Foone/status/1251483589914423296?s=19 https://twitter.com/Foone/status/1251483589914423296?s=19
- glenharris 6y agoHey y'all. I wrote the client/server/embedded software for the Harmony (technically the 'EasyZapper'(!) at first). It was the original 'two guys and a laptop' project. My mate Justin was the electrical/industrial/hardware/UI designer (although he will blame all the shitty software UI on me...). Happy to answer any questions. Glen.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jaywalk 6y agoWhy Flash?
- glenharris 6y agoOK, look, it was a long time ago, but I don't actually think we used Flash. Maybe one of the later versions where we tried to make it look sexier and/or more integrated? The original client side architecture was basically: 1) Some wrapper that let us embed a web browser that wasn't too buggy 2) Some crazy bridge that got us down to native (ish) code 3) Some crazy native code that abused the HID protocol to talk to the remote itself We had this working for: Windows - pretty sure it was VB embedding Internet Explorer that bridged down to a C++ COM component for communication Mac - Safari talking to java HID bridge Linux - Firefox talking to java HID bridge It was a long time ago, but that sounds 80% correct. Originally we wanted to use full java on all 3 platforms, but back then (2000), it was too slow and buggy. Ironically, we ended up using VB for the server stuff (for a consistent dev environment), and then had to rewrite back to java in 2003 ish. Fun times.
- jaywalk 6y agoI was talking about on the remote itself. In the Twitter thread, it was clearly discovered that the UI on the remote is written in Flash.
- glenharris 6y ago
- Lammy 6y agoFoone is into such fun things, but I absolutely can’t stand how everything is “stupid”, “the dumbest thing ever”, “what were they thinking?”, etc. It must be exhausting to hate everything so much. It sure is exhausting to read about it.
- mdaniel 6y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1251395931351609347.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1251395931351609347.html is the URL I came to the comments looking for
- CawCawCaw 6y agoSomehow it looks like the bot was not responding on twitter, but the unrolled thread was created.
- epda 6y agoReally amazing deep dive. When mine did this I just bought a new battery. This does seems more fun though.
- kelchm 6y agoI’ve been using the Harmony devices for years, even back before Logitech purchased them. The software is awful and has always been awful, but the hardware has been pretty consistently solid. I really wish there was a way to run a custom firmware on these devices, particularly the Harmony Hub + Simple Remote.
- glenharris 6y agoJustin could not agree with you more!