3 ms·
> the only meaningful failure here is repeated lack of maintenance The proximate cause of the fire was a broken hook. The other failures were: * Hook was not
by michaelt 6y ago
> the only meaningful failure here is repeated lack of maintenance
The proximate cause of the fire was a broken hook.
The other failures were:
* Hook was not maintained
* Tower was not adequately inspected
* Record keeping was insufficient to recognise the need for maintenance
* Power lines were built in hard-to-maintain, fire-prone places
* Nobody within PG&E sounding the alarm about this the hook problem specifically, or the lack of maintenance more broadly (or not sounding it loud enough)
* Lack of controlled burns (or equivalent forestry management) that would have reduced the spread of fire
* Homes built in fire-prone areas
* Low population density, with higher per-capita costs of infrastructure maintenance
* Dry conditions, due to climate change, due to energy policy(?)
* PG&E's bizarre blend of the worst parts of public and private business, and their perpetual bankrupt-but-still-operating status.
* Lack of political leadership able/willing to come up with and enact a master plan to stop wildfires
- Dylan16807 6y ago1,2,3 are maintenance 4 is unavoidable 5 is maintenance 6,7,8,9 are not PG&E 10 is "bad management"? Sure, that's a root cause, though a massively vague one. 11 is not PG&E So yes if you're concerned about external problems then there are things you can mention. I'd never argue that housing location and fire management and climate aren't factors! But in a discussion of what PG&E did wrong it's basically all maintenance.
- michaelt 6y ago> But in a discussion of what PG&E did wrong it's basically all maintenance. What I mean is: the first poster in this thread mentioned a broken hook causing $16 billion in damage, but the difference between a broken hook causing $1 million in damage and a broken hook causing $16 billion in damage was largely out of PG&E's hands. > 10 is "bad management"? Sure, that's a root cause, though a massively vague one. To be more specific: PG&E is a 'private company' but it has no competitors, regulations set the prices it can charge, regulations set the shareholder returns, regulations stop them refusing customers, regulations dictate what they can build and where, and regulations allow them to keep bouncing in and out of bankruptcy with minimal consequences. If a company's already bankrupt and has been for decades, any new CEO is going to insist on a bankruptcy-proof pay package. And what's the difference between liabilities of a million dollars and a trillion dollars when the electricity's going to keep flowing, the prices are going to stay the same, and the CEO's going to take home the same pay?
- Dylan16807 6y ago> What I mean is: the first poster in this thread mentioned a broken hook causing $16 billion in damage, but the difference between a broken hook causing $1 million in damage and a broken hook causing $16 billion in damage was largely out of PG&E's hands. That's true but they knew that and it was their responsibility and it was easy to prevent if they hadn't failed at maintenance in ten different ways.