7 ms·
It's definitely anticonsumer. I've no doubt that from a technical point of view, both DRM and the efforts to crack it are fascinating and interesting. What I
by the_af 6y ago
It's definitely anticonsumer.
I've no doubt that from a technical point of view, both DRM and the efforts to crack it are fascinating and interesting.
What I don't understand is this: consumers don't crack DRM; crackers and warez groups do. Once cracked, DRM is as good as nothing and it's low effort for an everyday gamer to get and play pirated games.
So this antipiracy "buffer" is only for crackers. For gamers it's just as if the game had a delayed release date.
For legit customers, the DRM is often intrusive and, because it's so complex and fiddly, often breaks in bizarre ways, giving rise to the paradoxical situation that the legit game is harder to use than the pirated game!
Only legitimate buyers lose.
- fxtentacle 6y agoI believe the cracked games are on sufficiently obscure websites to be a deterrent to regular users. So maybe 10% of those people that would otherwise not have paid will just buy a DRM game instead of cracking it. One could even argue that it is pro consumer by making sure the revenue will go back to paying consumers in the form of additional content, instead of paying for players who didn't buy it.
- the_af 6y agoCracked games websites are as obscure as The Pirate Bay, i.e. not very. Plus everyone who downloads a pirated game points his/her friends to the site, or directly shares the downloaded files. Even if you weren't aware of where to get warez, your friends will be. > One could even argue that it is pro consumer One really couldn't. It punishes buyers with encumbered software while merely delaying pirates a short while. Pirates end up with the better experience, so...
- Camas 6y ago>as obscure as The Pirate Bay, i.e. not very Blocked in Europe, China, Australia, ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countries_blocking_access_to_The_Pirate_Bay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countries_blocking_access_to_T...
- the_af 6y ago... and I'm sure there are no ways around that, right? Wink, wink.
- Camas 6y agoopening a pdf is a difficult task for most people exaggerating slightly but you know what I mean
- the_af 6y agoAll it takes is one of your friends who knows how to. Then they'll share with you. And much like opening PDFs, this isn't rocket science. The base knowledge here is people who know how to install and play pretty complex games. These people go to impossible lengths to install video drivers and troubleshoot problems with their computers; I'm sure they won't find this particular task very difficult.
- wtf_is_up 6y agoJust as recent as yesterday I accessed TPB while connected to a VPN server located in Sweden.
- russelg 6y agoAll of these blockades are simple ISP-level DNS redirections. Simply changing your DNS to google or cloudflare or similar resolves this quite nicely, no VPN needed.
- leetcrew 6y ago> Cracked games websites are as obscure as The Pirate Bay, i.e. not very. Plus everyone who downloads a pirated game points his/her friends to the site, or directly shares the downloaded files. Even if you weren't aware of where to get warez, your friends will be. you might be surprised at how obscure torrents have become outside of tech circles. when I graduated college (2017), basically no one outside of the comp sci department understood how to use torrents (or even knew what they were). this would have been unthinkable when I was in high school. everyone and their mother seemed to be torrenting music and movies. I even tried explaining how to use them to people, but they would object that the school would catch them anyway. when I explained how VPNs work, they complained that $6/month was too expensive for a poor college student. nevermind that they're already paying for prime, netflix, and hulu subscriptions every month. I think there are two main reasons for this. a lot of people have laptops with the base storage option, often a 256GB or even 128GB ssd. phones have even less storage. this makes it unappealing to keep a local library of music and especially movies (plus now that everyone has a phone and a laptop, syncing your collection becomes annoying). second, I think video and especially music streaming services have actually succeeded in making their products just convenient enough that people don't feel like figuring out how to use torrent trackers and clients.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI don't think it's the obscurity of the website that is doing it these days. I have plenty of money so I haven't downloaded warez for a long time. But if I were even tempted the possibility of getting hit with embedded ransomware would completely deter me, my multiple offsite backups notwithstanding.
- p1necone 6y agoThis is just one piece of anecdata, but I'm perfectly capable of pirating games yet haven't in years. I buy everything on steam or gog because it's so convenient. The last time I pirated any video games was suprise surprise when I wasn't making enough income to buy them. TV series on the other hand I still pirate to this day (if they aren't on the couple of streaming services I sub to), because buying them is way too complicated (even impossible with a large portion of shows that aren't current, and a fair number of current shows too). Movies are a mixed bag - grabbing cheap dvds or blu rays of pretty much anything is easy online so I usually do that, but I imagine if I preferred digital media or watched enough movies for my physical collection to be unwieldy I'd resort to piracy because buying digital copies of movies is just as complicated as TV. Give me "Steam for Movies and TV" or a streaming service that aggregates licenses from everyone, and doesn't only host the content that they think will be most popular and I'll probably stop pirating those too.
- Causality1 6y agoIt's the unreliability I can't tolerate. I don't pirate pc games because when I buy something on Steam it will always be available for me to download, even if a licensing problem means other people can't buy it. With streaming, who knows? Maybe Netflix loses the rights and it disappears. Maybe their encode is garbage and it ruins the dark scenes. So, I still pay for streaming services but anything I actually care about I download and archive.
- kroltan 6y ago> Maybe Netflix loses the rights and it disappears. That is interesting because it happened to me in the most annoying way possible: I was watching Donnie Darko, a rather obscure movie that requires (or at least for me required) a bit of brainpower to watch. So I watched the first half of it and planned to watch the remainder the next day. Come the next day, and where is the movie? Nowhere to be found.
- cableshaft 6y agoThat happened to me with Stargate SG-1. Was going through it on Netflix and suddenly it disappeared. Eventually resurfaced on Amazon Prime but the video quality is garbage on it for some reason.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y ago> For gamers it's just as if the game had a delayed release date. When released, games sell for full price ($70 or whatever it is today), then the price starts going down. Most of the sales happen in a short period after the release. Someone who wouldn't have bought the game even for $10 will not generate revenue no matter whether it's cracked on day 0 or day 60. Someone who's willing to pay $45 may buy a discounted copy if that's available before the crack, and someone who's willing to pay full price and wants the game within 10 days of release is much more likely to pay if a crack isn't available.
- the_af 6y agoGames usually go from DRM to cracked faster than they go from $70 to $10. Plus there's the issue of not buying DRM'ed games out of principle.
- ramraj07 6y agoThis post is literally about a game that never did that so what's your point?
- barumi 6y agoAs far as I could tell the game is still sold at around 40€ so OP's point still stands.
- AniseAbyss 6y agoThe way I see it, considering games are made to make money, the only alternative to DRM is going free to play. They then make their money with microtransactions.
- the_af 6y agoThankfully the people who made the vast collection of GOG and Humble Bundle games I own disagreed.
- Camas 6y ago>For legit customers, the DRM is often intrusive and, because it's so complex and fiddly, often breaks in bizarre ways, giving rise to the paradoxical situation that the legit game is harder to use than the pirated game! This is stuff you only read on certain forums. Most people don't even notice DRM
- chmod775 6y ago> Most people don't even notice DRM Just because they don't know what to blame, doesn't mean they don't notice it. A prominent example is performance degradation with Denuvo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_DD-txK9_Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_DD-txK9_Q
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eggsome 6y agoI can't play games that I've purchased because of DRM. In some cases because I've switched to linux and the security breaching rootkits that they want me to install don't work correctly there. In other cases it's very old games for which the authentication servers no longer exist. It's a real problem.
- deburo 6y ago>Linux I feel sorry for Linux users but you must know game companies don't really care about you guys.
- IntelMiner 6y agoSteam and Proton beg to disagree. The biggest blocker "left" for games right now is the "Easy Anti Cheat" employed by titles such as Rainbow 6: Siege Unfortunately Epic is notoriously Anti-Linux, from their CEO down. So the status of EAC under Linux is a giant question mark
- danielbarla 6y ago> Once cracked, DRM is as good as nothing and it's low effort for an everyday gamer to get and play pirated games. I think you're overstating this quite a bit. It's basically only true for games that are single-player (with a few exceptions), and are not currently receiving frequent updates (or you are categorically not interested in updates). Besides that, e.g. Steam is extremely convenient; installs are rapid and safe, saves are synced across different machines, mods are often well integrated with Steam Workshop, etc. For many, the above list is easily worth the price to pay. It's not like once DRM is cracked, sales drop to zero. DRM exists because the profit-minded companies find that at some level of investment in DRM, they get a good ROI.
- esperent 6y ago> Besides that, e.g. Steam is extremely convenient; For me, Steam is basically spyware that I don't want on my laptop. It's actually a barrier to me playing games because when I (rarely) consider purchasing something then see it's in Steam, my usual reaction is not too bother. It's my computer, I don't want a 3rd party "store" managing my installs. I feel the same way about the windows store fwiw. > installs are rapid and safe Just like normal computer programs then? > saves are synced across different machines Possibly useful but not really important to me. > mods are often well integrated with Steam Workshop, etc. Didn't know about this one, interesting. But I've never found it hard to install mods for games in the past, without Steam. Overall it's something I never needed and now that it's being pushed on me, I don't want it.
- novok 6y agoIn a game like rimworld where it can be typical to run with 30 or 50 mods at a time and swap out different ones, you need a system and steam workshop is that system.
- ThatPlayer 6y agoBut it's not the only system. Factorio, like Rimworld, has a huge mod scene and has it built into the game instead. Which has the advantage of working outside of Steam on a DRM-free (or not-steam) copy, which like another reply says, just makes Steam Workshop another form of lock-in on Steam.
- alkonaut 6y ago> It's definitely anticonsumer. If you assign the value lost to piracy as $0 (i.e pirates wouldn't buy) or you assume any extra money earned by less piracy is never going to benefit consumers in lower prices, then your argument holds. If twice as many paying customers means half the prices, then there is a benefit to consumers. The truth is somewhere between these two extremes of course. But yes - once the DRM is completely cracked, the game should at least be patched to remove the DRM. That would give a window of N days without making the game worse forever.
- Adverblessly 6y ago> Only legitimate buyers lose. The publishers and developers apparently also lose... Previously on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15319476 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15319476 EU commisions a study on the effects of piracy on media sells. The results are not what they expected so they try and hide them. This is "leaked" by a member of parliament. According to that study, specifically for game piracy, every copy of the game that was pirated resulted in 1.24 copies sold, meaning that effective DRM actually reduces sales. So the only ones who don't lose are those making the DRM.
- ChrisRR 6y agoFor gamers, it means that the studio may be able to afford to release a sequel to their favourite games For pirates, it means they either have to wait until it's cracked, or buy a legit copy Don't act like every gamer is automatically a pirate, millions of people are perfectly happy to pay for games and want to see their favourite studios continue
- the_af 6y ago> Don't act like every gamer is automatically a pirate, millions of people are perfectly happy to pay for games and want to see their favourite studios continue I'm not sure where you got the idea I said this. I don't think every gamer is automatically a pirate, though a lot of people do follow the path of least resistance. I pay for my videogames. I support indie devs that don't bundle DRM crap with their games. For AAA DRM-ridden games, I simply don't buy or play them. (To be honest, I don't have a lot of time to play any games these days). DRM is anticonsumer for legal buyers. It gives them a worse experience than the people who play pirated copies.