6 ms·
It is hard to imagine they weren’t aware that their job involved doing nothing (but pay attention to the road). I’d be inclined to give them a pass if they wer
by Aeolun 6y ago
It is hard to imagine they weren’t aware that their job involved doing nothing (but pay attention to the road).
I’d be inclined to give them a pass if they were looking at the road and just inattentive (because that’s expected, like you say), but I find it hard to sympathize with someone watching a show on their phone, explicitly ignoring their one job.
- mindslight 6y agoStepping back, I also find it hard to sympathize with someone watching a show on their phone. But there are two parties to this crime, and only one of them is being charged. Uber is responsible for creating this situation - I doubt this "backup driver" watches videos while driving her own car - yet has managed to escape liability. Hence why it's appropriate to describe her as a "fall gal".
- goodluckchuck 6y agoYeah, the problem isn’t that they weren’t paying attention, or that they weren’t even trying, but that they where intentionally NOT paying attention. That said, I don’t think this gets Uber off the hook. If I were on a jury, I’d likely say Uber was guilty of manslaughter (barring a real look at the evidence).
- akira2501 6y ago> That said, I don’t think this gets Uber off the hook There is exceptional negligence on their part. The fact that vehicle was just blithely travelling the posted speed limit, even at night, even though the speed violated it's assured clear ahead ability, is a damning point. The vehicle will operate unsafely in it's default configuration.
- rdlecler1 6y agoAnd for that reason you have a driver there who should have taken over.
- modo_mario 6y agoDid this person know he should have taken over when the car was respecting the speedlimit but still going faster than it should have been going? I go the speedlimit at night as well. But here in Belgium where there's so much street-lighting it might as well be day How much slower was the car supposed to go for it's sensors and was it all the guys responsibility even if he knew Uber apparently disabled the auto-braking due to issues and didn't pause roadtests?
- goodluckchuck 6y ago> Did this person know he should have taken over when the car was respecting the speedlimit but still going faster than it should have been going? Yeah, and how was the driver even supposed to know how fast the car should have been driving? I know how fast I should driving because I know how far I can see, but the car had LIDAR / Radar / night vision / etc. If the speed limit is 45MPH and the car is going 45MPH, what reason did the driver have to think that the car couldn't see? Either the driver can rely on the car to "see" or they can't.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoHonestly if I’d been given the job of babysitting a self driving car, the same thing could have easily happened to me. I’d get bored out of my mind and unintentionally pull out my phone & start browsing Reddit before I caught myself. It’s a shit, soul sucking job to actively do nothing.
- 60secz 6y agoYou can listen to audiobooks -- if your job is to be a backup driver keep your eyes on the road.
- de_watcher 6y agoI know that cars is the most probable cause of sudden death/injury so I wouldn't do that. How can you 'unintentionally' pull out a phone? I'd probably be looking at the road all the time, but just freeze at that moment where I'd need to take over.
- ardy42 6y ago> How can you 'unintentionally' pull out a phone? Probably more like "absent mindedly" pull out a phone.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoAbsent mindedly is closer. Whatever you call reaching for something out of habit with thinking about it.
- brokenmachine 6y agoHabitually
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoBut you did not work there. There are people who would very easily do this job. If she knew she couldn't concentrate, she shouldn't have taken the job and the risks involved.
- clairity 6y agothat's the fundamental attribution error again, attributing poor judgement/negligence to the driver, who's the visible actor, rather than the inherent systemic flaws designed by other unseen actors who hold greater responsibility.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI think we can all agree that many murderers end up committing their crimes partly because of a system that gives rise to poverty and the knock on effects of poverty on humans. However, I think most folks also agree that incarceration is an important factor in discouraging the commission of more murders. Not everyone does but even the most lenient countries tend not to let the perp off scott free. Which is all to say that "the system made me do it" really doesn't fly as an excuse for felonious behavior.
- clairity 6y agosure, but that extreme isn't helpful just as making the FAE isn't helpful, since, as others have astutely pointed out, the system was designed, whether through negligence, malevolence or other intentions, to put the driver in a (systemic) no-win situation. for instance, in the 737 max crashes, the pilots made errors, but the principal blame lies with boeing and their egregious systemic design flaws.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoIf deterrence didn't work, prison would be pointless cruelty. Paying sustained attention while nothing happens for hours is simply not something people are generally suited for. You can't deterrence them into it.
- baddox 6y agoWould you say the same thing for a chauffeur or truck driver who killed someone because they were using their phone while driving?
- abduhl 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]